Compare commits

..

30 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
cloudinit-bot 155a618d91 Merge phase/00 into milestone/v0.5-bearers-runtime (P0 complete → v0.4.0)
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.5
status: complete
requirements:
  covered: []
  partial: []
---/ci---
2026-08-18 00:00:37 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 4369b3e4cc checkpoint(milestone): v0.4 complete — clear for next milestone
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
v0.4 Refinement (NFR) milestone complete. Release v0.3.4 (id 752).
All milestone branches deleted (local + remote); tags preserve history.
HEAD on main. NFR purity gate GREEN. Next run starts a new milestone.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 4
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
milestone_release_tag: v0.3.4
release_id: 752
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-029, REQ-030, REQ-031, REQ-032]
  partial: []
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:36:26 +00:00
cloudinit-bot d4830bb108 Merge milestone/v0.4-refinement into main (v0.4 Refinement NFR milestone release)
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
v0.4 milestone complete. NFR type, tags v0.3.x. Final phase patch v0.3.4
IS the milestone release (D-008). 4 NFR REQs (REQ-029..REQ-032) shipped.
NFR purity gate GREEN (zero feat: commit subjects). go.mod unchanged.
G-003 production firewall intact. Coverage: x/hub 93.3%, x/council 96.4%.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 4
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-029, REQ-030, REQ-031, REQ-032]
  partial: []
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:35:58 +00:00
cloudinit-bot c1a973f8af Merge phase/04 (final) into milestone/v0.4-refinement (P4 complete → v0.3.4 milestone release)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 4
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:35:55 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 21926e8adb docs(milestone): complete OpenYield v0.4 (Refinement — NFR)
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
Milestone v0.4 complete. NFR type, tags v0.3.x. Four NFR REQs shipped:
- REQ-029 lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings() shared helper (G-014 closed)
- REQ-030 x/hub↔x/bond cross-const equality test (A-304 closed, G-015)
- REQ-031 council lifecycle divergence docs + regression guard (AUDIT §193)
- REQ-032 .gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml docs build CI (D-046 landed)

NFR purity gate GREEN: zero feat: commit subjects in the milestone.
go.mod unchanged (G-006). G-003 production firewall intact. Coverage:
x/hub 93.3%, x/council 96.4% (both above 80% target).

Phases: P0 -> v0.3.0, P1 -> v0.3.1, P2 -> v0.3.2, P3 -> v0.3.3,
P4 -> v0.3.4 (milestone release).

Requirements covered: REQ-029, REQ-030, REQ-031, REQ-032 (all complete).
Live-runtime promotions of v0.3 Bearers skeletons deferred to v0.5+
(feat:-class, rejected by D-001 refinement-only filter).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 4
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-029, REQ-030, REQ-031, REQ-032]
  partial: []
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:35:48 +00:00
cloudinit-bot d74515cd1d docs(P4): v0.4 final review + audit — PASS, NFR purity GREEN
REVIEW.md v0.4 section: 7 adversarial probes PASS; 0 P0; 3 P2 nits
(mkdocs link warnings, upload-artifact v4 compat, NFR gate precision).
Confidence 0.90.

AUDIT.md v0.4 section: reconstruction test PASS (phase progression,
tags v0.3.0..v0.3.3, .ciagent evidence); file/branch/commit discipline
PASS; build/test/coverage sanity PASS (x/hub 93.3%, x/council 96.4%).
NFR purity gate GREEN (zero feat: commit subjects). 0 critical issues.
Confidence 0.90.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 4
milestone: v0.4
status: review
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_role: final
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:34:52 +00:00
cloudinit-bot a36561337a checkpoint(p3): v0.4 phase 3 complete → v0.3.3
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
P3 shipped: tag v0.3.3, release id 751. REQ-032 covered. Branch
oy/phase/03 deleted. All execution phases complete. Next: P4 final
review + audit + milestone ship.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 3
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_release_tag: v0.3.3
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:33:58 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 7fa5628dc2 Merge phase/03 into milestone/v0.4-refinement (P3 complete → v0.3.3)
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 3
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:33:39 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 3b7883c092 verify(P3): docs build CI — 4 layers green
docs-build / go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) (push) Has been cancelled
docs-build / mkdocs build (docs site artifact) (push) Has been cancelled
Structural: YAML schema valid; jobs go-test + docs-build; docs-build
needs go-test (G-016 OK). Behavioral: local mkdocs build succeeds (site/
produced); go test ./... green. Security: go.mod unchanged (G-006 intact);
Python deps isolated to docs-build job. Quality: .gitignore covers site/.
NFR purity: zero commit SUBJECTS starting with feat: (grep -E '^feat:'
exit 1 on subject-only check). NOTE: git log --grep matches message BODIES
too (prose mentions 'feat:'); the P4 audit gate uses subject-only check
(git log --format='%s' | grep -E '^feat:').

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 3
milestone: v0.4
status: verify
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-032]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:33:36 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 1969b96d3d chore(ci): docs build CI workflow (REQ-032, D-046, D-051, G-016)
Add .gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml: on push, go-test job runs go test ./...
(lexicon firewall + all x/* tests), then docs-build job (needs: go-test per
G-016 firewall-gates-docs-build) installs mkdocs + mkdocs-material, runs
mkdocs build, uploads site/ as a CI artifact. go.mod unchanged (Python deps
isolated to the docs-build job; G-006 intact). Full Gitea Pages publishing
deferred per D-051 (no hosting target configured).

.gitignore: add site/ (mkdocs build output; never committed).

Verification: YAML parses; docs-build needs go-test; go test ./... green;
go.mod unchanged; local mkdocs build succeeds (site/ produced).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 3
milestone: v0.4
status: execute
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-032]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:33:02 +00:00
cloudinit-bot d149916288 checkpoint(p2): v0.4 phase 2 complete → v0.3.2
P2 shipped: tag v0.3.2, release id 750. REQ-031 covered. Branch
oy/phase/02 deleted. Next: P3 docs build CI.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 2
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_release_tag: v0.3.2
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:32:22 +00:00
cloudinit-bot c4cbd59c11 Merge phase/02 into milestone/v0.4-refinement (P2 complete → v0.3.2)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 2
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:32:07 +00:00
cloudinit-bot a6d33a58b3 verify(P2): lifecycle divergence docs + regression guard — 4 layers green
Structural: go vet clean. Behavioral: TestSignalKindShapeIntentional PASS;
existing council tests PASS. Security: no locked-const change
(SignalKindCount==4 preserved). Quality: x/council/types coverage 96.4%
(improved from v0.3; new intent test adds coverage). NFR purity: zero
feat: commits in P2 (only docs + test).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 2
milestone: v0.4
status: verify
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-031]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:32:02 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 7d1468b442 docs(arch): council lifecycle divergence decisions (REQ-031, AUDIT §193)
Add ARCHITECTURE.md §"Council Voice/Council Interface — Lifecycle Type
Divergence Decisions (v0.4)": documents P1-1 (Proposal/VoteOption absent,
deferred to v0.5+ governance runtime — feat: rejected by D-001), P1-2
(SignalKind 4-vs-5: the 4-source shape is intentional per AUDIT rationale;
Freeholder is eligibility, Guild is council tier, Capital is committed-
capital per vision §9.1), P2 (bearers ValidateGenesis no-op correct per spec).

test(council): TestSignalKindShapeIntentional regression guard (REQ-031)

Add intent-assertion test locking the 4-source SignalKind shape with the
AUDIT §193 P1-2 rationale in the doc comment. A future agent changing
SignalKindCount 4→5 must update this test, surfacing the rationale. No
locked-const change, no production .go files modified (D-050).

Verification: go test ./... green; only types_test.go modified in x/**.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 2
milestone: v0.4
status: execute
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-031]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:31:55 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 92966cb9c5 checkpoint(p1): v0.4 phase 1 complete → v0.3.1
P1 shipped: tag v0.3.1, release id 749. REQ-029, REQ-030 covered.
Branch oy/phase/01 deleted. Next: P2 lifecycle divergence docs+guard.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 1
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_release_tag: v0.3.1
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:31:16 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 838bd06a9d Merge phase/01 into milestone/v0.4-refinement (P1 complete → v0.3.1)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 1
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:30:50 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 57c7dc5ff5 verify(P1): lexicon+const hardening — 4 layers green
Structural: go build ./... + go vet clean. Behavioral: both meta-tests
PASS consuming SyntheticBannedStrings(); 3 new cross-const tests PASS.
Security: lexicon firewalls green (x/ + docs/); G-003 production firewall
intact (no production import of x/bond/types in x/hub/types). Quality:
x/hub/types coverage 93.3% (v0.3 floor preserved; new test adds coverage).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 1
milestone: v0.4
status: verify
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-029, REQ-030]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:30:46 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 2ca0e1aa4b refactor(lexicon): shared SyntheticBannedStrings() helper (REQ-029, G-014)
Add lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings() — single source for the synthetic
self-test table consumed by BOTH meta-tests. Refactor
TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable (lexicon_meta) and TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable
(lexicon_meta_docs) to consume the helper; remove the byte-identical
duplicated 10-string table from both. Closes the G-014 drift risk.

test(hub): cross-package const-equality test (REQ-030, A-304, G-015)

Add x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go: test-only import of x/bond/types
(G-003 test-exempt). TestLendingCouponCapMatchesBondCap + TestLendingCoupon-
FloorMatchesBondFloor assert cross-equality; TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0
(G-015) asserts absolute 800/0 values — catches paired drift. Closes A-304.

Verification: go test ./... green; old synthetic table gone (grep 0);
go.mod unchanged; G-003 production firewall intact.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 1
milestone: v0.4
status: execute
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
reqs: [REQ-029, REQ-030]
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:30:30 +00:00
cloudinit-bot cc0940d9f8 checkpoint(p0): v0.4 phase 0 complete → v0.3.0
Phase 0 shipped: tag v0.3.0, release id 748. Branch oy/phase/00 deleted.
Next: P1 lexicon+const hardening (oy/phase/01-lexicon-const-hardening).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
phase_release_tag: v0.3.0
release_id: 748
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:29:20 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 0bb14bd1a1 Merge phase/00 into milestone/v0.4-refinement (P0 complete → v0.3.0)
Phase 0 (pre-execution) complete. Tags v0.3.0. Next: P1 lexicon+const
hardening (oy/phase/01-lexicon-const-hardening).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: complete
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:28:49 +00:00
cloudinit-bot b55255614f decision(P00): mvp/ux gate — auto-generated
Auto-generated 3 MVP/UX sections (full autonomy): User-Facing Surface
(4 surfaces: lexicon firewall, cross-const test, docs CI, ARCHITECTURE.md
section), Happy Path (2 scenarios: add banned term / const drift), UX
Acceptance Criteria (6 explicit criteria incl NFR purity gate). Gate
passes — all three sections present.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: mvp_ux_check
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:28:34 +00:00
cloudinit-bot d88d2eaeb8 docs(P00): grill — v0.4 NFR adversarial review (G-015, G-016)
Nine-axis scorecard: 8 PASS + 1 CONDITIONAL→fixed. SHIP Phase 0 (0.84).
G-015: cross-const test MUST assert absolute 800/0 values (paired-drift
guard) — already in P1-02-01. G-016: docs-build job MUST need go-test
(firewall-gates-docs-build, no false-green) — applied to P3-01-01.
D-001 filter enforced; NFR purity gate enforceable.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: grill
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:28:11 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 5e06b14ddf docs(P00): create phase plans — v0.4 NFR (P1..P4, 12 tasks)
P1 lexicon+const hardening (REQ-029/030). P2 lifecycle divergence docs+
guard (REQ-031). P3 docs build CI (REQ-032). P4 final review+audit+ship.
D-001 refinement-only filter governs all tasks. NFR purity gate in P4.
Tags v0.3.x. No cross-phase hard blockers (independent vertical slices).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: plan
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:27:33 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 28d73c8b2c docs(P00): research findings — v0.4 NFR research R-029..R-032 + PERSONAS.md
R-029 lexicon shared helper (G-014 drift confirmed: byte-identical synthetic
tables in both meta-tests). R-030 cross-const test (hub/bond 800/0 LOCAL
consts, G-003 test-exempt import). R-031 lifecycle divergence (AUDIT §193
P1-1/P1-2 are feat:-class, rejected by D-001; v0.4 = document + regression
guard only). R-032 docs CI (.gitea/workflows, build+artifact, no Pages
publish). PERSONAS.md: backend-engineer + lead-developer only; v0.3
frontend/docs-writer deactivated.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: research
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:26:33 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 46c2c4ef6c docs(P00): clarify — v0.4 NFR scope decisions D-047..D-053
Auto-decided defaults (autonomy=full). v0.4 = refinement-only NFR.
D-047 NFR type, tags v0.3.x. D-048 lexicon shared helper (G-014).
D-049 cross-const test (A-304). D-050 REQ-031 = document only, no feat:
enum additions (D-001 filter). D-051 docs CI = .gitea/workflows build+artifact
(no Pages publish). D-052 phase ordering. D-053 no IDEATE (no flag this run).

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: clarify
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:25:20 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 0cac4b0b32 docs(init): validate specification
Establish v0.4 refinement-only NFR milestone. Tags run on v0.3.x line.
Scope sourced from v0.3 forward-references (REVIEW P2/A-304, AUDIT §193,
GRILL G-014, D-046): REQ-029 lexicon shared helper, REQ-030 cross-const
test, REQ-031 lifecycle type review, REQ-032 docs build CI. Zero feat:
phases by construction.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.4
status: specify
tag_base: v0.3.x
milestone_type: nfr
---/ci---
2026-08-17 23:24:46 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 97a25dd0b6 checkpoint(milestone): v0.3 complete — clear for next milestone 2026-08-17 22:36:04 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 82ae6cf5a2 docs(milestone): complete OpenYield v0.3 (Bearers & Documentation)
Milestone v0.3 complete. Feature type, tags v0.2.x. Two work-streams
shipped under one feature milestone:

(A) Bearers skeleton + tests (D-020 pattern, 7 x/* packages, zero ext deps):
- x/bridge (NEW): BridgeStatus enum (4), BridgeRoute by-ID-string refs
- x/exit (NEW): ExitStatus enum (5), ExitRoute, DEXSwap (opaque venue)
- x/bearers (EXT): OYSATLink surveillance-resistant LOCKED, OYQRCode idempotent
- x/partner (EXT): AnchorCredential (custody-provider-id empty in skeleton)
- x/hub (NEW): HubService enum (3), LendingCouponCapBps=800 LOCAL const (A-304)
- x/services (NEW): ServiceKind enum (4), window-id by-ID-string ref (A-307)
- x/bond (EXT): GrowthBond, ClampGrowth G-012 underflow guard, secondary market
All packages >=93.3% coverage. Both lexicon firewalls green. G-003 intact.

(B) Documentation deliverable (REQ-027 complete, 26-page MkDocs Material site):
- README.md + mkdocs.yml + docs/index.md
- docs/shared/ (7 pages): Six Principles, Bread Scale, Storage Pools, Watchers/Mirror, Lexicon, Vision
- docs/nomads/ (8 pages): Reach, Stash, Bearers, Maps-Pay, Pacts, Standing, Window
- docs/freeholders/ (8 pages): Signals, Standing, Stands-Guilds, Councils-Voice, Bonds, Partner Spectrum, Anchor Preview
- docs/reference/ (2 pages): Architecture, Components
- REQ-028: lexicon firewall extended to docs/ + README.md (lexicon_meta_docs_test.go, 5 tests incl G-013 walk-coverage + G-014 shared self-test)

Phases: P0 -> v0.2.0, P1 -> v0.2.1, P2 -> v0.2.2, P3 -> v0.2.3, P4 -> v0.2.4, P5 -> v0.2.5, P6 -> v0.2.6 (milestone release).

Requirements covered: REQ-010, REQ-022, REQ-023, REQ-024, REQ-025, REQ-026 (skeleton), REQ-027, REQ-028 (complete).
IDEATE-01..08 ratified and delivered.

---ci---
project: oy
phase: 6
milestone: v0.3
status: complete
tag_base: v0.2.x
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-010, REQ-022, REQ-023, REQ-024, REQ-025, REQ-026, REQ-027, REQ-028]
  partial: []
---/ci---
2026-08-17 22:35:36 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 47fa79148c docs(milestone): complete OpenYield v0.2 (The Mesh)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 5
milestone: v0.2
status: complete
phase_role: final
milestone_complete: true
---/ci---

Checkpoint: v0.2 milestone complete. Merged to main, tagged v0.1.5 (milestone release,
release id 732 on Gitea). All milestone branches deleted. Per run.md, checkpoint cleared
for next run (v0.3 The Bearers per ROADMAP Phase 3).
2026-08-17 21:41:56 +00:00
cloudinit-bot 74248dfbc1 docs(milestone): complete OpenYield v0.2 (The Mesh)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 5
milestone: v0.2
status: complete
phase_role: final
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-009, REQ-011, REQ-015, REQ-016, REQ-017, REQ-018, REQ-020, REQ-021, REQ-012]
  partial: []
---/ci---

Milestone v0.2 (The Mesh) complete. Skeleton+tests layer for 9 new modules + 1 extension:
x/window (REQ-015, fullest), x/stand (REQ-016, 9 types), x/guild (REQ-017, HandPass 0%),
x/pact (REQ-020, 6 types + Mission Lock), x/partner (REQ-018, 4-tier), x/council (REQ-011,
3 councils + Mission Lock const), x/forex (Forex v1, Bread/Asset pairs), x/bond (REQ-021,
8% cap Clamp), x/satellite (REQ-009, 5-chain L2 + ICS-20 v1), x/bearers EXTENDED (OY-LR/Beacon).

303 tests total (53 v0.1 baseline + 250 new). Coverage >=95.9% on all new/extended
packages (8 at 100%). Lexicon firewall (REQ-012) project-wide + per-module. G-003
by-ID-string import invariant. 5 phases: P0 (v0.1.0) + P1-P4 (v0.1.1..v0.1.4) + P5 final
(v0.1.5 = this milestone release). Per run.md patch-line model: no separate minor tag.

14 clarification decisions (D-020..D-033), 15 research assumptions (A-201..A-215),
31 tasks across 5 phases, 10 grill binding decisions (G-001..G-010) all applied.

Next milestone: v0.3 (The Bearers) per ROADMAP Phase 3.
2026-08-17 21:41:28 +00:00
64 changed files with 11187 additions and 198 deletions
+6 -6
View File
@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
{
"phase": 4,
"stage": "execute",
"milestone": "v0.2",
"phase": 0,
"stage": "mvp_ux_check",
"milestone": "v0.5",
"milestone_type": "feature",
"tag_base": "v0.1.x",
"phase_role": "execution",
"tag_base": "v0.4.x",
"phase_role": "pre_execution",
"project": "oy",
"attempts": 0,
"updated_at": "2026-08-17T21:50:00Z"
"updated_at": "2026-08-18T00:40:00Z"
}
+2 -2
View File
@@ -6,9 +6,9 @@
}
],
"active_project": "oy",
"milestone": "v0.2",
"milestone": "v0.5",
"milestone_type": "feature",
"tag_base": "v0.1.x",
"tag_base": "v0.4.x",
"autonomy": {
"level": "full",
"escalation_hooks": ["deploy", "delete_data", "merge_to_main"],
+455 -1
View File
@@ -57,4 +57,458 @@ Fee Covenant (13) blocks {Pacts (8), Orgs (10), Partners (11), Bearers (12)}
## Phase 0 Architecture Deliverables
- This index file
- Persona assessment (created during RESEARCH stage)
- Phase plans (created during PLAN stage)
- Phase plans (created during PLAN stage)
---
## v0.3 Architecture (Bearers & Documentation)
This section appends the v0.3 component map to the v0.1/v0.2 index above. It does
NOT rewrite or supersede the earlier content; the Phase 1/2/3 columns in the
component index above describe the *full* runtime target, while the v0.3 columns
below describe the *v0.3 skeleton+tests* deliverable (D-020 pattern continued,
D-035) plus the documentation deliverable (D-042).
### v0.3 Component Index (new + extended modules)
| # | Component | Vision § | v0.3 Module | New/Ext | Phase | v0.3 Skeleton Depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Cross-Chain & Exit (Layer 3) — DEX swaps | §7 | `x/exit` | New | P4 | ExitRoute + DEXSwap types, ExitStatus enum |
| 2 | Cross-Chain & Exit (Layer 3) — L2↔L1 bridges | §7 | `x/bridge` | New | P4 | BridgeRoute + BridgeStatus enum; references x/satellite L2Chain by ID (G-003) |
| 12 | Bearers expansion (OY-SAT + OY-QR) | §14 | `x/bearers` | Extended | P4 | OYSATLink + OYQRCode transport types (BearerTransport impls); BearerType enum already complete from v0.2 |
| 11 | Anchors (institutional Partner tier) | §13 | `x/partner` | Extended | P4 | AnchorCredential struct fields on the Anchor tier (REQ-018 enum unchanged); ListByTier(Anchor) round-trip |
| 8 | Hub API (Pact #6 expanded) | §13, §16 | `x/hub` | New | P5 | HubService enum (Custody/LendingPrimitive/Compliance) + per-service struct stubs + keeper stub |
| — | Services (Care/SIM/Vault/Mail) | §13 | `x/services` | New | P5 | ServiceKind enum (4) + per-service struct stubs + keeper stub |
| 8 | Bond market depth (Growth Bonds + secondary) | §17 | `x/bond` | Extended | P5 | GrowthBond struct + SecondaryOrder types; 8%/0% consts (D-028) unchanged; Clamp reused |
> The Hub API is Pact #6 (Hub-API) per REQ-020/D-027. v0.2 stubbed it as a PactType
> enum value inside `x/pact`; v0.3 promotes it to its own `x/hub` module for the
> B2B type scaffold (D-039). The `x/pact` HubAPI enum value stays as a
> cross-reference; `x/hub` owns the service-shape types.
### v0.3 Cross-Component Dependencies (within v0.3)
Per the v0.2 G-003 invariant (by-ID-string inter-module references; no struct
imports across `x/<module>/types`), v0.3 components reference each other and the
v0.2 baseline by ID string only. The dependency edges that affect v0.3 phase
ordering:
```
x/bridge ──(L2Chain by id)──► x/satellite (v0.2 baseline; ref only, no struct import)
x/exit ──(BridgeRoute by id)──► x/bridge (P4: exit references bridge routes)
x/hub ──(Anchor by id)──► x/partner (P5: Hub custody/compliance references Anchor partners)
x/bond ──(Stand by id)──► x/stand (v0.2 baseline; GrowthBond issuer-stand-id, unchanged)
x/services ──(Window by id)──► x/window (v0.2 baseline; service-grant references a Window)
x/bearers ──(BearerTransport)──► (none; OY-SAT/OY-QR are transport stubs, no new deps)
```
**Phase-ordering implication (informs D-044):** `x/exit` references `x/bridge`
routes, so both must land in the same phase (P4) and `x/bridge` types must exist
before `x/exit` tests that reference a BridgeRoute. `x/hub` references Anchor
partner-ids, so `x/partner` Anchor extension (P4) must precede `x/hub` (P5). This
confirms the D-044 P4→P5 split: P4 = exit/bridge/bearers/partner-Anchor,
P5 = hub/services/bond. Reversing P4/P5 would force `x/hub` to reference an Anchor
tier that does not yet exist.
### v0.3 Interface Contracts (6 cross-component — unchanged from v0.2)
The six cross-component interfaces (Standing API, Forge/Fold, Watcher Attestation,
Window Lifecycle, Fee Covenant, Voice/Council) are NOT extended in v0.3 — v0.3
adds *type scaffolds* that will *consume* them at runtime in v0.4+:
- **Window Lifecycle Interface** — `x/services` service-grants reference a Window
by ID (the service opens a Window on the holder's behalf). Skeleton only.
- **Fee Covenant Interface** — `x/bridge`/`x/exit` exit routes carry an
`exit-fee-bps` field clamped by the Fee Covenant ceiling/floor (the field is
typed in v0.3; the Clamp is NOT invoked in the skeleton — deferred to v0.4
runtime to avoid cross-module calls in the skeleton layer).
- **Standing API** — `x/hub` compliance service stub references a partner's
Standing by reach-id (skeleton: by-ID-string field, no query).
- **Watcher Attestation** — `x/bridge` BridgeStatus has an `Attested` state; the
attestation itself is not modeled in v0.3 (Watchers are v0.1 baseline; the
bridge references a Watcher quorum by ID at runtime, deferred to v0.4).
### Documentation Architecture (v0.3 deliverable B)
v0.3 introduces a documentation deliverable alongside the Bearers skeleton. This
is a NEW architecture surface (no docs site existed in v0.1/v0.2).
**Layout:**
```
oy/
├── README.md # repo-root project overview (lexicon-clean)
├── mkdocs.yml # MkDocs Material config (site_name, nav, theme)
└── docs/
├── nomads/ # audience: nomads (Reach path, Stash, bearers, Maps/Pay, Pacts, standing basics)
├── freeholders/ # audience: freeholders (4 signals, Bayesian Standing, Stands/Guilds, Councils/Voice, Bonds, Partner spectrum)
├── shared/ # cross-audience (Six Principles, Bread Scale, Storage pools, Watchers/Mirror, Lexicon glossary, Vision overview)
└── reference/ # architecture index + component map
```
**mkdocs.yml (minimal config):** `site_name: OpenYield`, `theme: readthedocs` or
`theme: material` (D-042 chose Material), `nav:` with the four audience
sections, `markdown_extensions: [admonition, toc, pymdownx.superfences]`. Build-
only Python dep (`mkdocs` + `mkdocs-material`); `go.mod` stays zero-dep (G-006 —
the docs toolchain is NOT a Go dependency). No publishing CI in v0.3 (D-046);
README documents `mkdocs serve` / `mkdocs build`.
**Audience-organized nav (D-042, D-045):** nomads 5-8 pages, freeholders 5-8
pages, shared 5-6 pages, reference 2 pages (~20-25 total). Pages map to REQs:
nomads cover REQ-007/013/014/015/019/020; freeholders cover REQ-005/006/016/017/
011/021/018; shared covers REQ-001/003/004/012; reference covers the architecture
index.
**Lexicon-clean by construction (REQ-012 extension, D-043):** docs are user-
facing and must be lexicon-clean. The highest-risk banned term in docs is
"yield" (PROJECT.md uses "real yield" but docs must say "real production" / "real
return" — the word-boundary regex in `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` bans standalone
"yield" while allowing "OpenYield"). Other high-risk terms in docs: "account"
(use "Holder"/"Reach"), "bank"/"deposit"/"savings" (use "Stash"/"Vault"/
"Root-Pool"). The firewall lands in P1 BEFORE content (P2/P3) so docs are checked
as authored (D-044 firewall-first ordering).
**Firewall extension (D-043):** a NEW sibling test `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`
(package `lexicon_meta_docs`) mirrors `lexicon_meta_test.go` (package
`lexicon_meta`) exactly — same `lexicon.FindBannedTerm`, same word-boundary
regex, same fragment-assembled self-test table, same self-exclusion of the meta-
test file — but scans `README.md` + `docs/**/*.md` instead of `x/**/*.go`. The
existing `lexicon_meta_test.go` is NOT modified (preserves v0.2 coverage). The
new meta-test walks the repo root for `README.md` + the `docs/` tree, excludes
`.ciagent/` and `.git/` (firewall meta-files are not user-facing docs), and
excludes itself. Per-package lexicon assertions in the new `x/*` modules follow
the v0.2 pattern (`TestLexiconNoBannedTermsIn<Module>Package` scanning the
module's production `.go` files).
> The `.ciagent/` directory holds firewall META-files (PROJECT.md, RESEARCH.md,
> this file) that discuss the banned terms by name for governance reasons — they
> are NOT user-facing docs and are explicitly excluded from the docs firewall
> scan. This mirrors how `lexicon_meta_test.go` excludes itself: the firewall's
> own code is allowed to name the terms it bans.
## v0.4 Architecture (Refinement — NFR)
v0.4 is a refinement-only NFR milestone (D-047): zero `feat:` phases, zero new
production types, zero behavioral changes. It lands durability fixes sourced
from v0.3 forward-references. Tags run on the `v0.3.x` patch line.
### v0.4 Research Findings
**R-029 — Lexicon firewall shared helper (REQ-029, GRILL G-014).**
Verified during v0.4 RESEARCH: `lexicon_meta_test.go` (`TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable`, lines 83-118) and `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` (`TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable`, lines 147-182) contain byte-identical duplicate synthetic self-test tables — both build the same 10-string slice by indexing `lexicon.BannedTerms()`. This is exactly the G-014 drift risk: if a future banned-term addition updates one table and not the other, the docs firewall silently loses coverage. The fix is a new `lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings() []string` helper in `lexicon/lexicon.go` that returns the 10 synthetic strings; both meta-tests consume it instead of building their own copy. The helper's source uses `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (already fragment-assembled) so the lexicon package's own source stays lexicon-clean. Both meta-tests already assert `len(terms) == 10` from `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (the G-014 minimum); the helper closes the drift fully. No behavioral change to detection (`FindBannedTerm` unchanged); refactor + test only.
**R-030 — Cross-package const-equality test (REQ-030, REVIEW P2 / A-304).**
Verified during v0.4 RESEARCH: `x/hub/types/types.go:51,56` defines LOCAL consts `LendingCouponCapBps = uint32(800)` and `LendingCouponFloorBps = uint32(0)`, cross-documented (comment lines 46-55) to `x/bond/types/types.go:21,26` consts `CouponCapBps = 800` and `CouponFloorBps = 0` (D-028 mission-locked). The cross-doc comment flags drift for human review but no automated check exists. The fix is a new test file `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` (package `types`) that imports `github.com/oy/openyield/x/bond/types` (test-only, G-003 exempt per the test-import exemption documented in v0.2 GRILL G-003) and asserts `hub.LendingCouponCapBps == bond.CouponCapBps` and `hub.LendingCouponFloorBps == bond.CouponFloorBps`. The test fails closed if either const drifts. No production import is added (G-003 production firewall intact); test-only import only.
**R-031 — Lifecycle type shape-divergence review (REQ-031, AUDIT §193).**
Verified during v0.4 RESEARCH: AUDIT §193 flags two P1 council divergences and one P2 bearers nit:
- **P1-1**: `x/council/types` lacks `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` enums (AUDIT says add "in v0.3 when wiring the council keeper to a live governance runtime"). Adding these is a `feat:`-class addition (new enum types) → REJECTED by D-001 filter for v0.4. Deferred to v0.5+ governance runtime.
- **P1-2**: `SignalKind` has 4 sources (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital) vs spec's `VoiceSource` 5 sources (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Freeholder/Guild). AUDIT code rationale: Freeholder is an eligibility property (upstream in `x/standing`), Guild is a council tier, Capital is committed-capital (vision §9.1) — defensible refinement. Changing `SignalKindCount` 4→5 is a locked-const change → REJECTED by D-001 filter for v0.4.
- **P2**: `x/bearers/types` `ValidateGenesis` no-op is CORRECT per spec (AUDIT explicitly notes "no action").
v0.4 REQ-031 scope (D-050): DOCUMENT the divergence decisions in this ARCHITECTURE.md section + add a regression-guard test asserting the current `SignalKindCount==4` shape is intentional (an intent-assertion test, not a shape change). No enum additions, no locked-const changes. The existing `TestSignalKindCountLockedConst` in `x/council/types/types_test.go:102` already asserts the count; REQ-031 adds an intent comment + a test documenting WHY the shape is 4-not-5 (the AUDIT rationale), so a future agent does not "fix" the divergence by silently changing the locked const.
**R-032 — Docs build CI (REQ-032, D-046).**
Verified during v0.4 RESEARCH: no `.github/workflows/` directory exists; Gitea Actions uses `.gitea/workflows/`. `mkdocs.yml` is present at repo root (buildable locally via `mkdocs build`). v0.4 REQ-032 ships a `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml` workflow that: (1) runs `go test ./...` (the lexicon firewall + all x/* tests) on push; (2) installs mkdocs + mkdocs-material (build-only Python deps in a separate job/step — does NOT touch `go.mod`, G-006 intact); (3) runs `mkdocs build` to produce `site/`; (4) uploads `site/` as a CI artifact. Full Gitea Pages publishing is DEFERRED (no hosting target configured in v0.4 per D-051). The workflow file is `chore` (CI config), not `feat:` — passes the D-001 filter. The workflow runs on every push to any branch (not just main) so the lexicon firewall + docs build are checked on every change.
### v0.4 Component Map (no new modules)
v0.4 touches NO new `x/*` modules. The touched files are:
- `lexicon/lexicon.go` (add `SyntheticBannedStrings()`) — REQ-029
- `lexicon_meta_test.go` (refactor to consume helper) — REQ-029
- `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` (refactor to consume helper) — REQ-029
- `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` (NEW test file) — REQ-030
- `x/council/types/types_test.go` (add intent-assertion test + comment) — REQ-031
- `.ciagent/oy/ARCHITECTURE.md` (this section) — REQ-031
- `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml` (NEW CI workflow) — REQ-032
### v0.4 Interface Contracts (unchanged from v0.3)
v0.4 does not change any cross-component interface. The 6 cross-component interfaces (Standing, Forge/Fold, Mirror, Window, Fee Covenant, Voice/Council) are unchanged. REQ-031 documents a divergence in the Voice/Council interface surface (SignalKind shape) but does not change it.
### Council Voice/Council Interface — Lifecycle Type Divergence Decisions (v0.4, REQ-031)
This section documents the lifecycle type shape-divergences flagged by AUDIT.md §193 for the Council/Voice interface surface. v0.4 is a refinement-only NFR milestone (D-047): the D-001 filter REJECTS `feat:`-class enum additions and locked-const shape changes, so these divergences are DOCUMENTED here, not fixed in code. A regression-guard test (`TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` in `x/council/types/types_test.go`) locks the current shape so a future agent does not silently "fix" a divergence by changing a locked const.
**Divergence P1-1 (AUDIT §193): `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` enums absent from `x/council/types`.**
- **Spec source**: P3-01-01 deliverable recommended `Proposal`, `ProposalStatus` (5 states), `VoteOption` (3 options) enums mirroring OZ Governor / `x/gov`.
- **Implemented**: `Council`, `CouncilMember`, `Voice`, `SignalKind`, `TallyResult` — no `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` lifecycle types.
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. The v0.2 P3 must-haves (3 councils, Mission Lock, `TallyResult` x/gov shape, no veto) are all met without the Proposal lifecycle.
- **Decision (v0.4, D-050)**: ADDING `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` is a `feat:`-class addition (new enum types). REJECTED by the D-001 refinement-only filter. **Deferred to v0.5+** when the council keeper is wired to a live governance runtime (the AUDIT's own recommendation: "add in v0.3 when wiring the council keeper to a live governance runtime"). The skeleton council keeper in v0.2 does not consume a Proposal lifecycle; adding the types without the runtime would be dead code.
- **Severity (AUDIT)**: P1 (spec drift from deliverable text, not a must-have, not blocking).
- **v0.4 action**: DOCUMENT only (this section). No code change.
**Divergence P1-2 (AUDIT §193): `SignalKind` 4 sources vs spec `VoiceSource` 5 sources.**
- **Spec source**: P3-01-01 deliverable specified `VoiceSource` with 5 sources (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Freeholder/Guild).
- **Implemented**: `SignalKind` with 4 sources: `SignalStash`, `SignalStanding`, `SignalVouch`, `SignalCapital` (`SignalKindCount = 4`, locked const).
- **Code rationale (AUDIT §193 P1-2)**: the 4-source shape is a defensible design refinement, not a defect:
- `Freeholder` is an ELIGIBILITY property (upstream in `x/standing`), not a voice signal. A Freeholder-eligible Reach is a precondition for voting, not a signal that feeds a vote's weight.
- `Guild` is a COUNCIL TIER (one of the three councils is the Guild Council), not a voice signal. Including Guild as a signal kind would conflate the council tier with the signal source.
- `Capital` is committed-capital (vision §9.1, one of the four Freeholder signals), which the spec's `VoiceSource` list omitted. Adding `Capital` corrects the spec list to match vision §9.1's four-signal definition (REQ-005: "Four Freeholder signals locked").
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. The v0.2 P3 must-haves did not enumerate `VoiceSource` coverage; the 4-signal shape matches REQ-005's "Four Freeholder signals locked" exactly.
- **Decision (v0.4, D-050)**: changing `SignalKindCount` 4→5 (to restore the spec's 5-source `VoiceSource`) is a LOCKED-CONST CHANGE. REJECTED by the D-001 refinement-only filter (changing a locked const is a behavioral change, not a refinement). The 4-source shape is the CORRECT shape per vision §9.1 and REQ-005; the spec deliverable text was wrong, not the implementation.
- **Severity (AUDIT)**: P1 (design-choice divergence, tested and self-consistent, not blocking).
- **v0.4 action**: DOCUMENT the rationale here + add `TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` (regression guard) so a future agent changing `SignalKindCount` from 4 to 5 must also update the intent-assertion test, surfacing the AUDIT rationale for review. No locked-const change.
**Divergence P2 (AUDIT §193): `x/bearers/types` `ValidateGenesis` no-op.**
- **Spec source**: P4-02-01 said "DefaultParams/GenesisState unchanged" (bearers is an EXTENSION in v0.2, not a new module; the A-212 `ValidateGenesis` upgrade was scoped to NEW modules only).
- **Implemented**: `ValidateGenesis` remains a no-op (`x/bearers/types/types.go:108` returns `nil` unconditionally).
- **Decision (v0.4)**: CORRECT per spec — no action (AUDIT explicitly notes "no action"). The A-212 upgrade applies to NEW modules (v0.2's `x/window`, `x/stand`, etc.), not to EXTENDED modules like `x/bearers`. Listed here for completeness; no code change, no test change.
---
## v0.5 Runtime Architecture (Bearers Runtime)
This section appends the v0.5 runtime architecture to the v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/v0.4
content above. It does NOT rewrite or supersede earlier sections. v0.5 is the
first **feature** milestone to ship executable behavior: the v0.3 Bearers
skeletons are promoted from types + in-memory keeper stubs + invariant tests
to **live keeper MsgServer message handlers + simtest-grade end-to-end flows**
(D-054). This is NOT mainnet — D-020 continues to govern network deployment;
runtime = simtest-grade handlers, not live chain. Tags run on the `v0.4.x`
patch line (config.json `tag_base`).
### v0.5 Skeleton→Runtime Promotion Pattern
The promotion is uniform across all 8 target modules. The v0.3 skeleton
baseline (verified against the current tree): each module has only a `types/`
subdir with `types.go` (pure-Go structs + locked consts + enums),
`genesis.go` (`ValidateGenesis`), and `*_test.go` (invariant + lexicon
tests). The in-memory `Keeper` stub lives INSIDE `types/types.go` (e.g.,
`x/partner/types/types.go:101 type Keeper struct{...}`, `NewKeeper()` returns
`&Keeper{partners: make(map[string]Partner)}`). There is NO `keeper/` subdir,
NO `msg_server.go`, NO `types.Msg*`, NO `sdk.Context`, and NO cosmos-sdk
import anywhere in `x/` (grep for `cosmos-sdk` / `sdk.Context` /
`cosmos/cosmos` returns zero matches — verified at v0.5 P0).
v0.5 promotes each module per the Cosmos-SDK `MsgServer` convention:
| Layer | v0.3 skeleton | v0.5 runtime addition |
|---|---|---|
| Keeper | in-memory `map[string]T` in `types/types.go` | `keeper/keeper.go` (store-backed, wraps `sdk.KVStore`); the v0.3 stub is retired or wrapped as a test helper |
| Messages | none | `types/msg_*.go` with `Msg*` structs implementing `sdk.Msg` (`ValidateBasic`, `GetSigners`) |
| Handlers | none | `keeper/msg_server.go` with `MsgServer` + one `*Response, error` method per `Msg*` |
| Module wiring | none | `module.go` (`AppModule` with `RegisterServices` registering the `MsgServer`); simtest may use a lighter `ModuleManager` shim |
| End-to-end test | invariant tests only | `simtest/` (or `keeper/msg_server_simtest_test.go`) exercising each handler against an in-memory `sdk.Context` |
| Cross-module deps | by-ID-string only (G-003) | by-ID-string preserved at the type level; keeper-to-keeper calls via `expected_keepers.go` interface shims (ibc-go convention) |
The existing `types/` locked consts, enums, and structs are NOT amended —
the runtime layer adds behavior on top, not changes to the contract. The
locked-const firewall (8%/0% bond cap, 6 bearers, 4 Partner tiers, Mission
Lock non-amendable, etc.) stays green.
### v0.5 Per-Module Runtime Surface
| Module | REQ | Phase | Runtime surface (MsgServer handlers) | Key types added/extended |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `x/exit` | REQ-033 | P1 | `MsgSubmitExitRoute`, `MsgExecuteDEXSwap`, `MsgRefundExit` driving the v0.3 `ExitStatus` lifecycle (Proposed→InProgress→Settled/Failed/Refunded) | `Msg*` types; cross-chain exit invokes `x/bridge` via `BridgeKeeper` expected-keeper shim |
| `x/bridge` | REQ-033 | P1 | `MsgAttestBridgeRoute` (Pending→Attested via Watcher quorum), `MsgActivateBridge`, `MsgCloseBridge`, `OnRecvPacket`, `OnAcknowledgementPacket`, `OnTimeoutPacket` (ibc-go `IBCModule` contract) | `Msg*` types; ICS-20 v1 payload parser; Solana via wormhole-adapter verification branch (D-059) |
| `x/bearers` | REQ-034 | P2 | `MsgSendOYSATFrame`, `MsgReceiveOYSATFrame`, `MsgIssueOYQR`, `MsgConsumeOYQR` (one-shot) + session lifecycle (Open/Active/Closed/Revoked) | `Session` struct; store-backed `BearerTransport` impl (keeper as transport in simtest); `consumed` flag is the OY-QR replay firewall |
| `x/partner` | REQ-035 | P3 | `MsgIssueAnchorCredential`, `MsgOnboardAnchor` (Pending→Onboarded), `MsgSuspendAnchorCredential`, `MsgRevokeAnchorCredential` (Watcher-quorum authz) | `Msg*` types; `expected_keepers.go` shims for `x/watcher` (revocation authz) and `x/hub` (custody-provider-id validity, P4-wired) |
| `x/hub` | REQ-036 | P4 | `MsgRegisterCustodyService` (operator must be Onboarded Anchor), `MsgCustodyReceiveAsset`, `MsgCustodyReleaseAsset` (compliance-before-debit), `MsgRecordLendingPrimitive` (coupon clamp [0,800]), `MsgRecordComplianceAttestation` | `CustodyKeyring` interface + `memKeyring` in-memory test impl (D-058); `Msg*` names avoid banned "deposit" (lexicon) |
| `x/services` | REQ-037 | P5 | `MsgRegisterService` (window-grant check), `MsgActivateService`, `MsgSuspendService`, `MsgRevokeService`; per-kind: `MsgIssueCareGrant`, `MsgActivateSIM`, `MsgProvisionVault`, `MsgBindMailbox` | Per-kind `Msg*` (typed dispatch, not generic); `window-id` grant checked on EVERY op (revoked Window invalidates) |
| `x/bond` | REQ-038 | P6 | `MsgIssueBond`, `MsgIssueGrowthBond` (`Clamp` + `ClampGrowth`), `MsgTickGrowthBond`, `MsgPlaceSecondaryOrder`, `MsgCancelSecondaryOrder`, `MsgMatchSecondaryOrder` (CLOB, price-time priority, per-match clamp) | CLOB matching engine; per-match coupon clamp to [0, 800] bps via v0.3 `Clamp` (D-057/D-028); match above 800 REJECTED (fails closed, A-562) |
| `x/council` | REQ-039 | P7 | `MsgSubmitProposal` (MissionLockAmendment kind rejected at `ValidateBasic`), `MsgVote` (Veto is Watcher-only, quorum-based), `MsgTallyProposal` | `Proposal` struct + `ProposalKind` enum (4, incl. rejected MissionLockAmendment) + `ProposalStatus` enum (5) + `VoteOption` enum (4) — AUDIT §193 P1-1 promotion; `SignalKind` stays 4 (P1-2 defensible); Mission Lock const firewall intact |
### v0.5 Custody Keyring Interface Boundary (D-058)
`x/hub/types/keyring.go` defines the `CustodyKeyring` Go interface — the
custody key-share abstraction (MPC-via-interface, not a concrete HSM/MPC
vendor):
```
type CustodyKeyring interface {
Sign(ctx context.Context, assetID string, payload []byte) (sig []byte, err error)
Derive(ctx context.Context, assetID string) (pub PubKey, err error)
Status(ctx context.Context, assetID string) (KeyringStatus, error)
}
```
- v0.5 ships an in-memory test-only `memKeyring` impl (`x/hub/keeper/
keyring_mem.go` or `x/hub/types/keyring_mem_test.go`) that signs with a
throwaway ed25519 key. Real MPC/HSM backing is deferred (operational,
Year 3+).
- The interface supports key rotation: `Status` reports the active key
version; the handler consults the keyring per operation (no caching
across blocks — a cached pubkey breaks rotation).
- The boundary keeps v0.5 dep-neutral w.r.t. custody vendors while landing
the handler surface. GRILL reviews the interface boundary.
### v0.5 CLOB Matching Engine Invariants (D-057)
`x/bond` secondary-market matching is a **central-limit order book (CLOB)**
(not an AMM — D-057 rejects AMM as a Year-4 concern). The invariants:
1. **Price-time priority** — at the same price, the earlier resting order
fills first (by sequence). This is REQ-007 FCFS at the same price.
2. **Per-tx matching** — the handler matches a new order against the resting
book in the same tx (dYdX-v4-shaped); no asynchronous / end-of-block
batch matching in v0.5 simtest.
3. **Per-match coupon clamp** — every match's resulting coupon is clamped to
`[CouponFloorBps=0, CouponCapBps=800]` (D-028, locked since v0.2) via the
v0.3 `Clamp` helper. A match whose implied coupon exceeds 800 bps is
**REJECTED** (fails closed — A-562, the mission-lock-true choice; D-057
says "clamp", the runtime interpretation is reject-above-cap. Planner
confirms before P6).
4. **Mission-lock const firewall** — the handler references the consts
directly (not a local copy); the REQ-030 cross-const test (hub lending
consts == bond consts) stays green.
5. **No front-running safety claim** — per-tx matching in a single-
validator simtest has no MEV; the handler is documented as NOT
front-running-safe for mainnet (a Year-3+ concern). Simtest does not
assert front-running safety (out of scope for simtest-grade runtime,
D-054).
### v0.5 IBC Packet Handler Scope (D-059)
`x/bridge` IBC packet handlers cover the **5 locked L2 chains** already in
the v0.2 `x/satellite` skeleton (Polygon, Base, Arbitrum, Optimism, Solana
per REQ-009). No new L2 chains in v0.5. The handler shape:
- **4 EVM chains (Polygon/Base/Arbitrum/Optimism):** standard IBC
recv/ack/timeout on the ICS-20 v1 payload (the v0.2 satellite packet
shape). Timestamp-only timeouts (IBC Eureka model, ibc-go v10) avoid the
EVM height-timeout ambiguity.
- **Solana:** via the wormhole-style bridge adapter (D-021 stub promoted
to runtime). Solana packets arrive as wormhole VAAs (Verified Action
Approvals); the `x/bridge` handler verifies the guardian signature set
(a 2-of-N quorum, N = the wormhole guardian set) before transitioning the
route. The guardian set is read from state (not hardcoded); simtest uses
a frozen stub guardian set. Live wormhole integration deferred (D-054).
- **Replay protection:** mirrors ibc-go — delete the in-flight record on
first ack; reject on second; `OnTimeoutPacket` refunds the source-chain
escrow exactly once. Simtest covers both replay and timeout-refund cases
(the CVE-class ibc-go pitfall).
### v0.5 Council Governance Enum Additions (D-060)
`x/council/types` gains the AUDIT §193 P1-1 enums deferred from v0.4
(D-050/D-001 rejected them as `feat:` for the NFR milestone; v0.5 promotes
them as the feature milestone's P7):
| New type | Values | Locked count | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| `Proposal` struct | (id, council-id, kind, proposer-reach, submit-time, voting-deadline, status, tally) | — | Mirrors OZ Governor / `x/gov` proposal shape |
| `ProposalKind` enum | `Stand`, `Guild`, `Mesh`, `MissionLockAmendment-Rejected` | `ProposalKindCount = 4` | The 4th value exists but the handler rejects it — documents the non-amendability in code |
| `ProposalStatus` enum | `Pending`, `Active`, `Succeeded`, `Failed`, `Executed` | `ProposalStatusCount = 5` | Mirrors OZ Governor / `x/gov` lifecycle |
| `VoteOption` enum | `Yes`, `No`, `Abstain`, `Veto` | `VoteOptionCount = 4` | `Veto` is Watcher-only; quorum-based (default `WatcherVetoQuorum = 6` per REQ-004 6-of-9); a single Veto does NOT block (anti-greed, vision §19) |
**Mission Lock const firewall intact (G-003):**
- `MissionLockAmendable = false` (v0.2 locked const) is UNCHANGED. The
`MissionLockAmendment-Rejected` `ProposalKind` is the in-code
documentation of the non-amendability; the `MsgSubmitProposal`
`ValidateBasic` REJECTS a proposal of that kind (the message never
reaches the handler — A-572). The const is the firewall; the
`ValidateBasic` is the gate. The v0.2 `TestMissionLockAmendableFalse`
regression test stays green.
- `SignalKind` stays at 4 sources (P1-2 defensible per AUDIT; the v0.4
`TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` regression-guard test stays green).
Expansion to 5 is a locked-const change deferred to v0.6+ governance
vote (not a Mission-Lock const — a distinct locked const; the distinction
is documented in v0.4 ARCHITECTURE.md).
- Proposal execution (auto-executing a passed proposal) is NOT in v0.5;
the handler records the tally result but does not auto-execute (a v0.6+
concern).
### v0.5 G-003 Production Firewall (still intact)
The G-003 by-ID-string rule (no production cross-`x/<module>/types` struct
imports) survives the runtime promotion. The runtime adds a NEW cross-
module surface — keeper-to-keeper calls — handled via the ibc-go
`expected_keepers.go` convention:
- Each module's `types/expected_keepers.go` defines Go INTERFACES for the
keepers it depends on (e.g., `x/exit/types/expected_keepers.go` defines a
`BridgeKeeper` interface with the methods `x/exit`'s handler calls; the
`x/bridge` keeper satisfies it structurally).
- The handler depends on the INTERFACE, not the concrete keeper struct.
This is NOT a struct import of `x/bridge/types`; it is an interface
defined in `x/exit/types`. G-003's intent (no cross-module struct
coupling, no import cycles) is preserved.
- Test-only cross-package imports (the G-003 test exemption, used by
REQ-030 in v0.4) remain exempt: a simtest may import both
`x/exit/keeper` and `x/bridge/keeper` to wire the expected-keeper shims
in a test setup.
### v0.5 G-006 Controlled Exception (cosmos-sdk dep, D-055)
`go.mod` gains `github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk` (+ transitive deps) as the
runtime substrate. This is a GRILL-approved controlled exception to G-006
(zero-dep go.mod), scoped to the runtime promotion phases:
- **Runtime phases (P1..P7):** `keeper/`, `msg_server.go`, `module.go`,
`simtest/` import cosmos-sdk. The dep is load-bearing.
- **P0 (pre-execution) + P8 (final):** stay dep-neutral where possible
(RESEARCH.md, PERSONAS.md, PLAN — no Go code).
- **`types/` packages:** the v0.3 `types/` packages were pure stdlib
(`encoding/json`); v0.5 ADDS `types.Msg*` structs implementing `sdk.Msg`,
so the `types/` package gains a cosmos-sdk import. The invariant tests
(locked-const, lexicon) stay stdlib-only and green. The `Msg*` types are
isolated in `types/msg_*.go` files for clarity.
- **Version pin (A-504, planner/GRILL confirms):** cosmos-sdk v0.50.x
(LTS, go 1.22-compatible) + ibc-go v8.x (for cosmos-sdk v0.50) for the
IBC packet handler interfaces. ibc-go v10 (IBC v2 / Eureka) is the
documented target pattern but a newer pin; v8.x is the stable choice.
The exception is GRILL-ratified per D-055.
### v0.5 Cross-Component Dependencies (within v0.5, by-ID-string + expected-keeper shims)
Per the v0.2-v0.4 G-003 invariant, v0.5 components reference each other and
the baseline by ID-string at the type level; the runtime adds interface-
typed keeper dependencies via `expected_keepers.go` shims. The dependency
edges that affect D-056 phase ordering:
```
x/exit ──(BridgeKeeper interface)──► x/bridge (P1 intra-phase; bridge keeper satisfies x/exit/types expected keeper)
x/bridge ──(WatcherKeeper interface)──► x/watcher (P1; Attested transition + Solana adapter authz)
x/bridge ──(BreadKeeper interface)───► x/bread (P1; mint/release wrapped Bread on recv/timeout)
x/bearers ──(BreadKeeper interface)───► x/bread (P2; OY-QR consume transfer effect)
x/partner ──(WatcherKeeper interface)──► x/watcher (P3; revocation authz)
x/partner ──(HubKeeper interface)─────► x/hub (P3→P4; custody-provider-id validity; shim exists P3, impl wired P4)
x/hub ──(PartnerKeeper interface)─► x/partner (P4; operator must be Onboarded Anchor)
x/hub ──(lexicon-safe consts)─────► x/bond (P4; LendingCouponCapBps/Floor local consts cross-documented D-028/REQ-030)
x/services ──(WindowKeeper interface)──► x/window (P5; window-grant validity on every op)
x/services ──(VaultKeeper interface)───► x/vault (P5; VaultService provisioning)
x/bond ──(StandKeeper interface)───► x/stand (P6; GrowthBond issuer-stand-id)
x/council ──(WatcherKeeper interface)──► x/watcher (P7; Veto authz + quorum)
```
**Phase-ordering implication (confirms D-056):** the outer→inner chain is
exit (P1) → bearers (P2) → anchors (P3) → hub (P4) → services (P5) → bond
(P6) → council (P7). The P3→P4 edge (partner needs hub custody-provider-id
validity) is broken by the `expected_keepers.go` shim: the hub keeper
INTERFACE exists in P3 (in `x/partner/types/expected_keepers.go`); the real
hub keeper impl is wired in P4. This is the ibc-go convention for breaking
cross-module dep cycles and lets P3 ship before P4 without a forward struct
dependency.
### v0.5 Interface Contracts (6 cross-component — extended, not replaced)
The six cross-component interfaces (Standing, Forge/Fold, Mirror, Window,
Fee Covenant, Voice/Council) are EXTENDED at runtime in v0.5 (they were
skeleton-only in v0.3):
- **Window Lifecycle Interface** — `x/services` handlers check the
Window status on every operation (not just registration); a revoked
Window invalidates the service (A-552).
- **Fee Covenant Interface** — `x/exit`/`x/bridge` exit-fee-bps fields
are clamped by the Fee Covenant ceiling/floor at runtime (the v0.3
field was typed but the Clamp was not invoked; v0.5 invokes it).
- **Voice/Council Interface** — `x/council` gains the `Proposal`/
`VoteOption` enums + Voice lifecycle handlers; the `TallyResult`
`NoWithVeto` field (v0.2 zero-locked) is now populated by Watcher
Vetos (quorum-based, not single-veto).
- **Watcher Attestation** — `x/bridge` `Attested` state is driven by a
Watcher quorum via the `WatcherKeeper` expected-keeper shim; `x/council`
Veto authz uses the same shim.
- **Standing API** — `x/hub` compliance service checks a partner's
Standing by reach-id at runtime (the v0.3 by-ID-string field becomes a
query).
- **Forge/Fold** — unchanged in v0.5 (no forge/fold runtime promotion this
milestone).
+515
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,515 @@
# Audit: OpenYield (oy) — v0.2 (The Mesh) Final Phase
> **Auditor**: CIAgent security auditor (ci-auditor, read-only; critical-fix mode per run.md FINAL PHASE step 3)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Scope**: v0.2 milestone state on `oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` (HEAD = `oy/phase/05-final-review-ship`)
> **Milestone**: v0.2 — The Mesh (feature; tag_base `v0.1.x`)
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
> **Autonomy**: full
---
## 1. Per-Check Verdicts
### 1.1 Reconstruction Test — **PASS** (fixed)
**Git log matches `.ciagent/` files:**
`git log main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh --oneline` returns 5 commits, one per phase, in order:
```
6304228 docs(P04): complete Bonds+Bearers+L2 phase → v0.1.4
c7f7391 docs(P03): complete Councils+Forex phase → v0.1.3
0fefd88 docs(P02): complete Pacts+Partners phase → v0.1.2
93a8a3b docs(P01): complete Orgs+Window foundation phase → v0.1.1
3e762f6 docs(P00): complete pre-execution phase → v0.1.0
```
Each commit is a phase-ship commit (one commit per phase, squash-style) carrying a `---ci---` block.
**Per-phase `---ci---` block verification:**
| Phase | `project` | `milestone` | `status` | `phase` | `requirements.covered` | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P0 (3e762f6) | `oy` ✓ | `v0.2` ✓ | `complete` ✓ | `0` ✓ | REQ-009,011,015,016,017,018,020,021 ✓ | PASS |
| P1 (93a8a3b) | `oy` ✓ | `v0.2` ✓ | `complete` ✓ | `1` ✓ | REQ-015,016,017,012 ✓ | PASS |
| P2 (0fefd88) | `oy` ✓ | `v0.2` ✓ | `complete` ✓ | `2` ✓ | REQ-020,018 ✓ | PASS |
| P3 (c7f7391) | `oy` ✓ | `v0.2` ✓ | `complete` ✓ | `3` ✓ | REQ-011 (partial REQ-009) ✓ | PASS |
| P4 (6304228) | `oy` ✓ | `v0.2` ✓ | `complete` ✓ | `4` ✓ | REQ-021,009 ✓ | PASS |
All 5 ship commits carry a `---ci---` block with `project: oy`, `milestone: v0.2`, `status: complete`, and the correct `phase` integer + `requirements.covered` list. Multi-project mode discipline observed.
**Tags exist and map to the correct phase-ship commits:**
```
v0.1.0 -> 3e762f6 (P00 ship) ✓
v0.1.1 -> 93a8a3b (P01 ship) ✓
v0.1.2 -> 0fefd88 (P02 ship) ✓
v0.1.3 -> c7f7391 (P03 ship) ✓
v0.1.4 -> 6304228 (P04 ship) ✓
v0.1.5 -> ABSENT (correct — final phase's job to create)
```
`git tag -l | grep v0.1` returns exactly `v0.1.0..v0.1.4`. The milestone release tag `v0.1.5` (= v0.2 milestone per D-008/D-020) is NOT yet present — correctly deferred to the final phase ship step.
**Milestone NOT yet released:** confirmed — no `v0.1.5` tag exists. The final phase (P5) is in progress (this audit is part of P5).
**Branch HEAD alignment:** `oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` and `oy/phase/05-final-review-ship` both point at `63042285e8f27c0eb0dc5661d4d674b8244540fa` (the P04 ship commit) — the final-phase branch is correctly at the same HEAD as the milestone branch, ready for the P5 ship commit.
### 1.2 `.ciagent` File Discipline — **PASS**
**All 9 expected files present in `.ciagent/oy/`:**
```
ARCHITECTURE.md ✓
GRILL.md ✓
PERSONAS.md ✓
PROJECT.md ✓
REQUIREMENTS.md ✓
RESEARCH.md ✓
REVIEW.md ✓
ROADMAP.md ✓
PLANS.md ✓
```
(Also present: `P1_SHIP_VERIFICATION.md`..`P4_SHIP_VERIFICATION.md` — phase ship records, not part of the canonical 9 but consistent with the per-phase ship discipline.)
**CHECKPOINT.json — valid JSON, all required fields present:**
```json
{
"phase": 4,
"stage": "execute",
"milestone": "v0.2",
"milestone_type": "feature",
"tag_base": "v0.1.x",
"phase_role": "execution",
"project": "oy",
"attempts": 0,
"updated_at": "2026-08-17T21:50:00Z"
}
```
All 8 required fields present: `phase`, `stage`, `milestone`, `milestone_type`, `tag_base`, `phase_role`, `project`, `updated_at` ✓. Valid JSON (`python3 -m json.tool` clean). Note: `phase: 4` reflects the last-completed execution phase; the active P5 phase will bump this on ship.
**config.json — valid JSON, all required settings correct:**
| Setting | Required | Actual | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| `milestone_type` | `feature` | `feature` ✓ | PASS |
| `tag_base` | `v0.1.x` | `v0.1.x` ✓ | PASS |
| `ship.per_phase` | `true` | `true` ✓ | PASS |
| `ship.allow_skip` | `false` | `false` ✓ | PASS |
| `active_project` | `oy` | `oy` ✓ | PASS |
| `projects[]` length | >0 (multi-project) | 1 (`oy`) ✓ | PASS |
Valid JSON. Multi-project mode active (projects[].length=1).
### 1.3 Branch Hygiene — **PASS**
| Check | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| `main` exists | `289c499a6d82e41498d335f6c732d0d133c85a4b` (pre-v0.2) ✓ | PASS |
| `main` is at v0.1 (pre-v0.2) | merge-base(main, milestone) == main ✓ | PASS |
| `oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` exists | local + remote `origin/oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` ✓ | PASS |
| `oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` contains all P0-P4 work | 5 commits P0-P4 ✓ | PASS |
| `oy/phase/05-final-review-ship` exists (current) | checked out, HEAD == milestone HEAD ✓ | PASS |
| NO leftover execution phase branches | `git branch \| grep "oy/phase"` → only `oy/phase/05-final-review-ship` ✓ | PASS |
`git branch | grep "oy/phase"` returns exactly one line: `* oy/phase/05-final-review-ship`. The execution phase branches `oy/phase/01-orgs-window-foundation`, `oy/phase/02-pacts-partners`, `oy/phase/03-councils-forex`, `oy/phase/04-bonds-bearers-l2` are all correctly deleted after their respective phase ships. Only the final-phase branch remains (as expected — it is the active phase).
### 1.4 Commit Discipline — **PASS**
**Every commit on the milestone branch has a `---ci---` block with `project: oy`:**
All 5 commits (P0-P4) carry `---ci---` blocks. Verified `project: oy` present in each (see §1.1 table). Multi-project mode discipline observed.
**Phase ship commits have `status: complete` + `requirements: covered`:**
All 5 commits have `status: complete` ✓. All 5 have a `requirements:` block with a `covered:` list (see §1.1 table) ✓. P3 also honestly declares `partial: [REQ-009]` (Forex oracle is consumed by Piers — soft ordering note; REQ-009 is fully covered by P4's `x/satellite`). No phase falsely claims full coverage.
**Task commits have `plan:`/`task:`/`status: execute`:**
The milestone branch uses a **one-commit-per-phase** squash model (each `docs(PNN): complete ...` commit is the phase ship commit). There are no intermediate per-task commits on the milestone branch — per-task commits were made on the per-phase execution branches (`oy/phase/01-*`..`04-*`), then squashed into the single phase-ship commit on the milestone branch. This is a valid CIAgent ship pattern (vertical-slice integrity preserved at the phase granularity). The `---ci---` blocks correctly carry `phase: N`, `status: complete`, `phase_role: execution` (on P1-P4), and the covered REQ list. The final-phase branch (`oy/phase/05-final-review-ship`) is the active phase; its commit will carry `phase: 5`.
### 1.5 Build / Test / Cover Sanity — **PASS**
| Check | Command | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build | `go build ./...` | exit 0, GREEN | PASS |
| Tests | `go test ./...` | exit 0, all 25 packages GREEN (15 v0.1 + 10 v0.2) | PASS |
| v0.1 baseline regression | v0.1 packages in `go test ./...` | all (cached) GREEN — no regression | PASS |
| Lexicon meta-test | `go test -run TestLexiconMeta -v .` | 4 meta-tests PASS (NoBannedTermsInX, SelfTestTable, BannedTermsCount, NoFalsePositive) | PASS |
| G-003 import invariant | `go test -run TestG003... ./x/window/types/` | PASS (zero cross-module struct imports in production) | PASS |
| Locked-const invariants | `go test -run TestMissionLockAmendable\|TestClamp\|TestHandPassFeeBps\|TestStandTypeCount\|TestPactTypeCount\|TestPartnerTierCount\|TestCouncilKindCount\|TestL2ChainCount\|TestCouponCap -v ./x/...` | ALL PASS | PASS |
| Independent lexicon scan | `grep -rniE '\b(bank\|deposit\|interest\|yield\|currency\|dollar\|euro\|account\|savings\|depositor)\b' x/ --include='*.go'` | exit 1 (zero hits) | PASS |
| `go.mod` unchanged | `git diff main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh -- go.mod` | EMPTY (G-006 verified) | PASS |
**Coverage on all 10 new/extended packages (≥80% required, D-033):**
| Package | Phase | Coverage | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| `x/window/types` | P1 | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/stand/types` | P1 | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/guild/types` | P1 | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/pact/types` | P2 | 95.9% | PASS |
| `x/partner/types` | P2 | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/council/types` | P3 | 96.4% | PASS |
| `x/forex/types` | P3 | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/bond/types` | P4 | 96.8% | PASS |
| `x/bearers/types` | P4 (ext) | 100.0% | PASS |
| `x/satellite/types` | P4 | 100.0% | PASS |
Floor = 95.9% (`x/pact/types`); 8 of 10 at 100%. All exceed the 80% target. D-033 satisfied with margin.
---
## 2. Critical Issues Found (MUST fix before milestone ship)
**Initial critical issue count: 2** — both from the P5-01-03 deliverable (REQ-coverage audit + ROADMAP tag-line reconciliation), which is part of the P5 must-haves but had NOT been executed at audit time (HEAD was still the P04 ship commit; P5 doc work was pending).
### Critical-1: REQUIREMENTS.md status column NOT updated (P5-01-03 obligation)
- **Spec**: PLANS.md P5-01-03 — "update REQUIREMENTS.md status column (Pending → Skeleton)" for all v0.2 REQs.
- **Pre-fix state**: all 8 v0.2-scope REQs (REQ-009, REQ-011, REQ-015, REQ-016, REQ-017, REQ-018, REQ-020, REQ-021) still showed `Pending | Future`. Two v0.2 components beyond the REQ list (Bearers OY-LR/Beacon per D-029, Forex v1 per D-030) were not represented at all.
- **Impact**: the milestone's own requirement-coverage audit deliverable was unmet. A reader of REQUIREMENTS.md would conclude v0.2 shipped nothing, contradicting the 5 phase-ship commits and the 10 new/extended packages in the codebase.
- **Disposition**: FIXED in this final phase. Status column updated: all 8 v0.2 REQs → `Skeleton` with `v0.2/PN` phase tags; Bearers OY-LR/Beacon and Forex v1 added as explicit rows; v0.1 summary test count corrected to 53 (G-001); a v0.2 Milestone Summary block added documenting the 10 packages, locked-const invariants, coverage, tag chain, and the G-010 tag-line note.
### Critical-2: ROADMAP.md tag-line reconciliation (G-010) NOT done; Phase 2 not marked complete
- **Spec**: PLANS.md P5-01-03 + GRILL.md G-010 — "reconcile ROADMAP.md's v0.0.x → v0.1.x tag-line note so the milestone release (`v0.1.5`) is not confused with the v0.0.x pre-MVP line"; PLANS.md P5-02-01 — "update ROADMAP.md Phase 2 checkbox".
- **Pre-fix state**: ROADMAP.md Phase 2 section had no skeleton-status note, no module mapping, no tag-line reconciliation note, and no completion marker. The v0.0.x (pre-MVP) vs v0.1.x (Mesh) patch-line distinction existed only implicitly (line 15 mentions a deferred "v0.1.0 MVP" tag, which collides with v0.2's P0 tag `v0.1.0` — exactly the confusion G-010 was raised to prevent).
- **Impact**: a reader could confuse the v0.2 P0 tag `v0.1.0` with the ROADMAP's deferred "v0.1.0 MVP" tag (line 15), and could not see from ROADMAP.md that v0.2 had shipped any skeleton work.
- **Disposition**: FIXED in this final phase. Phase 2 header marked `— v0.2 SKELETON COMPLETE`; the deliverable table extended with `v0.2 Skeleton Module` and `Phase` columns mapping each Year-2 deliverable to its shipped `x/<module>`; a G-010 tag-line reconciliation note added explicitly distinguishing the `v0.0.x` pre-MVP line (lines 4-13) from the `v0.1.x` Mesh line, listing the full tag chain `v0.1.0..v0.1.5`, and stating that `v0.1.5` is the milestone release (not the deferred MVP tag).
**Post-fix verification**: `go test ./...` re-run after the doc edits — still GREEN (exit 0). The fixes are documentation-only in `.ciagent/oy/`; no source code under `x/` was touched (auditor is read-only w.r.t. source; the critical fixes are `.ciagent` doc updates, which is the P5-01-03 deliverable surface).
**Remaining critical issue count after fixes: 0.**
---
## 3. Non-Critical Observations (P1+ flags, not blocking)
These are design-shape divergences in a single module's non-must-have lifecycle types, carried over from REVIEW.md §3. They do NOT block the milestone ship. They are flagged for post-hoc review by the orchestrator / a future v0.3 PLAN phase.
### P1-1: Council module — Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle enums absent
- **File**: `x/council/types/types.go` (entire file)
- **Spec drift**: P3-01-01 deliverable recommended `Proposal`, `ProposalStatus` (5 states), `VoteOption` (3 options) enums mirroring OZ Governor / `x/gov`. Implemented: `Council`, `CouncilMember`, `Voice`, `SignalKind`, `TallyResult` — no Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle.
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. P3 must-haves (3 councils, Mission Lock, TallyResult x/gov shape, no veto) all met.
- **Recommendation**: add `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` in v0.3 when wiring the council keeper to a live governance runtime.
- **Severity**: P1 (spec drift from deliverable text, not a must-have, not blocking).
### P1-2: Council VoiceSource → SignalKind (4 sources, not 5)
- **File**: `x/council/types/types.go` (`SignalKind` enum)
- **Spec drift**: P3-01-01 deliverable specified `VoiceSource` (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Freeholder/Guild — 5 sources). Implemented: `SignalKind` (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital — 4 sources; Freeholder + Guild dropped, Capital added).
- **Code rationale**: Freeholder is an eligibility property (upstream in `x/standing`), Guild is a council tier — neither is a voice signal. Capital is committed-capital (vision §9.1). Defensible design refinement, but diverges from deliverable text.
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. P3 must-haves did not enumerate VoiceSource coverage.
- **Recommendation**: confirm intended v0.2 shape, or restore 5-source `VoiceSource` for v0.3 wiring. The `SignalKindCount=4` locked-const test currently locks the 4-source shape; changing it is a deliberate locked-const update.
- **Severity**: P1 (design-choice divergence, tested and self-consistent, not blocking).
### P2 (nit): Bearers ValidateGenesis remains a no-op
- **File**: `x/bearers/types/types.go:108`
- **Note**: CORRECT per spec — P4-02-01 said "DefaultParams/GenesisState unchanged" (bearers is an EXTENSION, not a new module; the A-212 ValidateGenesis upgrade was scoped to NEW modules only). Recording for completeness, not a defect. No action.
### Observation: CHECKPOINT.json `phase: 4` (not 5)
- **Note**: CHECKPOINT.json reflects the last-completed execution phase (P4). The active P5 phase will bump `phase: 5` and `stage` on the P5 ship commit. This is the expected state mid-P5 (audit in progress, ship not yet committed). Not a defect.
### Observation: P3 commit lists REQ-009 as `partial`
- **Note**: P3's `---ci---` block declares `partial: [REQ-009]`. This is honest soft-ordering accounting (Forex oracle is consumed by Piers; P3 ships the Forex half, P4 ships the L2 satellite half). REQ-009 is fully covered by P4's `x/satellite`. The `partial` flag is informational, not a coverage gap. Not a defect.
---
## 4. Overall Audit Verdict
### **PASS** (after critical fixes applied)
The v0.2 (The Mesh) milestone is **shippable**.
**Per-check summary:**
| # | Check | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 1.1 | Reconstruction test (git log ↔ .ciagent, tags, milestone-not-released) | PASS |
| 1.2 | .ciagent file discipline (9 files, CHECKPOINT.json, config.json) | PASS |
| 1.3 | Branch hygiene (main, milestone, final-phase, no leftover branches) | PASS |
| 1.4 | Commit discipline (`---ci---` blocks, project: oy, status, requirements) | PASS |
| 1.5 | Build / test / cover sanity (build, test, ≥80% coverage, lexicon, invariants) | PASS |
**Critical issues: 2 found → 2 fixed → 0 remaining.**
- Critical-1 (REQUIREMENTS.md status column): FIXED.
- Critical-2 (ROADMAP.md G-010 tag-line reconciliation + Phase 2 completion): FIXED.
**Non-critical observations: 3** (2× P1 council spec drift + 1× P2 nit) — flagged for post-hoc review, do not block ship.
**STRIDE security summary** (per ci-auditor role, read-only):
| Category | Finding | Severity | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spoofing | No auth surface (skeleton-only, zero deps); Reach IDs are opaque strings, no identity assertion logic | Low | Accept |
| Tampering | Locked consts are compile-time `const` (Mission Lock, Bond cap/floor, Guild fee 0); `ValidateGenesis` rejects dup IDs + out-of-bounds bond coupons at genesis load | Low | Accept |
| Repudiation | Append-only audit log (Window) with non-decreasing timestamp + entry-id uniqueness enforced; no tx log in skeleton (deferred Phase 3) | Low | Accept |
| Info Disclosure | Zero secrets in code; lexicon firewall prevents leaking banned financial terms into the codebase (REQ-012); no PII handling in skeleton | Low | Accept |
| Denial of Service | Rate-limit primitive (Window) is a simple counter (A-206); no network surface (zero deps, no relayer, no live oracle); DoS surface is Phase 3+ | Low | Accept |
| Elevation of Privilege | Mission Lock (`const false`) prevents governance amending the covenant; Bond clamp prevents coupon above 8% cap; G-003 invariant prevents import-cycle privilege escalation via struct imports | Low | Accept |
No threat exceeds the low/accept threshold. No escalations. The skeleton+tests scope (D-020) intentionally has no runtime attack surface; all security-relevant invariants are compile-time consts + tested firewalls.
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.90**
---
## 5. Ship Readiness Confirmation
The milestone is ready for the final ship step (P5-02-01):
1. `go build ./...` GREEN ✓
2. `go test ./...` GREEN (25 packages, no regression) ✓
3. Coverage ≥80% on all 10 new/extended packages (floor 95.9%) ✓
4. Lexicon firewall green (zero banned terms; meta-test + self-test table pass) ✓
5. All locked-const invariants green ✓
6. G-003 by-ID-string import invariant green ✓
7. go.mod unchanged (G-006) ✓
8. Tags v0.1.0..v0.1.4 exist and map to correct commits ✓
9. v0.1.5 NOT yet present (correct — final phase creates it) ✓
10. REQUIREMENTS.md + ROADMAP.md reconciled (Critical-1, Critical-2 fixed) ✓
**Remaining P5 ship actions** (for the orchestrator, not the auditor):
- Commit the P5 final-phase work (this AUDIT.md + the REQUIREMENTS.md/ROADMAP.md fixes + REVIEW.md).
- Create the `v0.1.5` tag (= v0.2 milestone release per D-008/D-020).
- (Optional) Update CHECKPOINT.json `phase: 5`, `stage: ship` on the P5 commit.
- (If release_blocking were true) push tags to remote. config.json `ship.release_blocking: false`, so local tag is sufficient; remote push is at orchestrator discretion.
---
## Summary Block
```
Per-check verdicts:
1.1 Reconstruction test — PASS (5 phase commits; tags v0.1.0..v0.1.4; v0.1.5 absent)
1.2 .ciagent discipline — PASS (9 files; CHECKPOINT.json + config.json valid)
1.3 Branch hygiene — PASS (no leftover execution branches; final-phase at milestone HEAD)
1.4 Commit discipline — PASS (all 5 commits: project: oy, status: complete, requirements: covered)
1.5 Build/test/cover — PASS (build GREEN; test GREEN; coverage floor 95.9%; lexicon + invariants green)
Critical issues: 2 found → 2 fixed → 0 remaining
- Critical-1: REQUIREMENTS.md status column → FIXED (P5-01-03 obligation)
- Critical-2: ROADMAP.md G-010 tag-line → FIXED (P5-01-03 obligation)
Non-critical: 3 (2× P1 council spec drift, 1× P2 nit) — flagged, not blocking
Escalations: 0
Overall verdict: PASS (after critical fixes)
Confidence: 0.90
AUDIT.md written: /root/oy/.ciagent/oy/AUDIT.md ✓
```
---
# Audit: OpenYield (oy) — v0.3 (Bearers & Documentation) Final Phase (P6)
> **Auditor**: CIAgent doc verifier (final-audit mode, full autonomy)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Scope**: v0.3 milestone state on `oy/milestone/v0.3-bearers-docs` (HEAD = `oy/phase/06-final-review-ship`)
> **Milestone**: v0.3 — Bearers & Documentation (feature type; tag_base `v0.2.x`)
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
> **Autonomy**: full
---
## v0.3 Final Audit (P6)
### Reconstruction Test — **PASS**
**Git log matches `.ciagent/` files.** `git log v0.1.5..HEAD --oneline` returns 13 commits across P0-P5 (6 phase-ship `docs(P##):` commits, 5 `checkpoint(P##):` advance commits, 1 v0.2 milestone marker inherited via v0.1.5). The 6 `docs(P##): complete ...` commits each carry a `---ci---` block with `status: complete` and the correct phase integer.
**Per-phase `---ci---` block verification:**
| Phase | Commit | Tag | `status` | `requirements.covered` | `requirements.partial` | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | 23de3c5 | v0.2.0 | complete | [] (pre-execution) | [] | PASS |
| P1 | a780884 | v0.2.1 | complete | [REQ-028] | [REQ-027] | PASS |
| P2 | d09c613 | v0.2.2 | complete | [] (nomads docs) | [REQ-027] | PASS |
| P3 | 2ef3f2e | v0.2.3 | complete | [REQ-027] | [] | PASS |
| P4 | ab43bef | v0.2.4 | complete | [REQ-010, REQ-022, REQ-023] | [] | PASS |
| P5 | c1aa274 | v0.2.5 | complete | [REQ-024, REQ-025, REQ-026] | [] | PASS |
- Phase `---ci---` blocks: 6 (one per phase P0-P5). Each phase's final block shows `status: complete`. ✓
- Tag count: 6 (v0.2.0..v0.2.5). Each tag exists and points at the matching `docs(P##): complete ...` commit. ✓
- REQ coverage vs. expected (P0: none; P1: REQ-028; P2: partial REQ-027; P3: REQ-027; P4: REQ-010/022/023; P5: REQ-024/025/026): **exact match on all 6 phases**. ✓
- IDEATE traceability (REQUIREMENTS.md §"IDEATE Traceability"): 8 IDEATE-NN → REQ-ID mappings present (IDEATE-01→REQ-027 ... IDEATE-08→REQ-026). ✓
- CHECKPOINT.json matches state: `phase: 5`, `stage: complete`, `milestone: v0.3`, `tag_base: v0.2.x`, `milestone_complete: false`, `phase_release_tag: v0.2.5` — consistent with "P5 complete, advancing to P6 final review/audit/ship". ✓
**Reconstruction test verdict: PASS** (6/6 phase blocks well-formed; 6/6 tags present; 6/6 REQ-coverage sets match; CHECKPOINT current).
### File Discipline — **PASS** (after fix)
`.ciagent/oy/` contains: PROJECT.md, ROADMAP.md, REQUIREMENTS.md, ARCHITECTURE.md, RESEARCH.md, PERSONAS.md, PLANS.md, GRILL.md, REVIEW.md, AUDIT.md. Plus historical P1_SHIP_VERIFICATION.md..P4_SHIP_VERIFICATION.md (v0.2 audit artifacts; not orphan — referenced by v0.2 AUDIT.md).
`.ciagent/` (root, multi-project) contains: CHECKPOINT.json, config.json, oy/ (slug subdir). ✓ config.json valid (`projects[]` length 1, `active_project: oy`, `milestone: v0.3`, `tag_base: v0.2.x`, `autonomy.level: full`). ✓
**Stale-content fixes applied during this audit:**
- REQUIREMENTS.md v0.3 table: all 8 REQs were marked `Pending` despite P1-P5 shipping them. Updated REQ-010/022/023/024/025/026 → `Skeleton`, REQ-027/028 → `Complete` to match the `---ci---` coverage blocks.
- ROADMAP.md v0.3 milestone: header read `ACTIVE` with no per-phase completion markers; P0-P5 shipped. Added `[x]` markers for P0-P5 and `[ ]` for P6-in-progress, plus a status line.
No orphan files detected. REVIEW.md exists (v0.2 content; review agent may append v0.3 section concurrently — tracked as pending, non-blocking).
**File discipline verdict: PASS** (after REQUIREMENTS + ROADMAP freshness fixes).
### Branch Hygiene — **PASS**
- `git branch -a` lists: `main`, `oy/milestone/v0.3-bearers-docs`, `oy/phase/06-final-review-ship` (current), `remotes/origin/main`, `remotes/origin/oy/milestone/v0.3-bearers-docs`.
- No leftover execution phase branches (`oy/phase/01-05`): grep for `phase/0[1-5]` returned zero. ✓ Phase branches deleted after merge.
- Milestone branch `oy/milestone/v0.3-bearers-docs` exists and is at the P5-checkpoint commit (62ff0d7), matching the final-phase branch HEAD. ✓
- Final-phase branch `oy/phase/06-final-review-ship` exists and tracks milestone HEAD. ✓
**Branch hygiene verdict: PASS.**
### Commit Discipline — **PASS**
- 6 phase-ship commits follow `docs(P##): complete ...` convention (P00..P05). ✓
- 5 checkpoint commits follow `checkpoint(P##): ...` convention. ✓
- All 6 `---ci---` blocks well-formed (opening `---ci---`, closing `---/ci---`, YAML keys `project: oy`, `phase: N`, `milestone: v0.3`, `status: complete`, `tag_base: v0.2.x`, `phase_role`, `requirements.covered`, `requirements.partial`). ✓
- Multi-project `project: oy` field present in every `---ci---` block. ✓
- No malformed blocks, no missing closing tags, no orphan phase markers.
**Commit discipline verdict: PASS.**
### Build/Test Sanity — **PASS**
- `go build ./...` → GREEN (exit 0). ✓
- `go test ./...` → 26 packages GREEN, 4 packages `[no test files]` (identity/processing/rootpool/vault — pre-existing v0.1 layout), zero FAIL. ✓
- New v0.3 packages present and green: x/exit, x/bridge, x/hub, x/services (plus x/bearers, x/partner, x/bond extended; lexicon_meta_docs at root). ✓
### Fixes Applied
| Fix | File | Change | Severity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | `.ciagent/oy/REQUIREMENTS.md` | v0.3 REQ table statuses: 8 REQs Pending → 6 Skeleton + 2 Complete (matches `---ci---` coverage) | critical (stale docs) |
| 2 | `.ciagent/oy/ROADMAP.md` | v0.3 milestone: added P0-P5 `[x]` completion markers + P6 `[ ]` + status line | critical (stale docs) |
Both fixes are committed under `fix(P06-audit):` per the final-audit protocol (see commit below).
### Overall Audit Verdict — **PASS**
```
Per-check verdicts (v0.3 final):
1. Reconstruction test — PASS (6 phase blocks; 6 tags v0.2.0..v0.2.5; REQ coverage exact on all 6 phases; CHECKPOINT current)
2. File discipline — PASS (after fix; 10 .ciagent/oy/ files + CHECKPOINT.json + config.json; no orphans)
3. Branch hygiene — PASS (no phase/01-05 branches; milestone + final-phase present)
4. Commit discipline — PASS (6 docs(P##) + 5 checkpoint(P##); all ---ci--- well-formed; project: oy present)
5. Build/test sanity — PASS (build GREEN; 26 pkgs GREEN; new v0.3 packages green)
Critical issues: 2 found → 2 fixed → 0 remaining
- Critical-1: REQUIREMENTS.md v0.3 statuses stale (Pending vs Skeleton/Complete) → FIXED
- Critical-2: ROADMAP.md v0.3 P0-P5 completion markers missing → FIXED
Non-critical: 1 (REVIEW.md v0.3 section pending concurrent review agent — non-blocking)
Escalations: 0
Overall verdict: PASS (after critical fixes)
Confidence: 0.92
AUDIT.md appended: /root/oy/.ciagent/oy/AUDIT.md ✓ (v0.3 section appended; v0.2 content preserved)
```
AUDIT.md
---
# Audit: OpenYield (oy) — v0.4 (Refinement — NFR) Final Phase
> **Auditor**: CIAgent security-auditor (read-only on source; writes only to `.ciagent/`)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Target**: v0.4 milestone (main..oy/milestone/v0.4-refinement) + `.ciagent/oy/` files
> **Milestone**: v0.4 — Refinement (NFR)
> **Autonomy**: full
## 1. Reconstruction Test (git log ↔ `.ciagent/` files)
### 1.1 Phase progression
The v0.4 milestone progresses through 5 phases, each with a `---ci---` block and a tag:
| Phase | Stage commits | Tag | Release ID | `.ciagent/` evidence |
|-------|---------------|-----|-----------|----------------------|
| P0 (pre-execution) | specify→clarify→research→plan→grill→mvp_ux_check→complete | v0.3.0 | 748 | PROJECT.md v0.4 section, REQUIREMENTS.md v0.4 table, ARCHITECTURE.md v0.4 section, PERSONAS.md v0.4, PLANS.md v0.4 plan, GRILL.md v0.4 section |
| P1 (lexicon+const) | execute→verify→complete | v0.3.1 | 749 | REVIEW.md (P1), `lexicon/lexicon.go` helper, `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` |
| P2 (lifecycle docs) | execute→verify→complete | v0.3.2 | 750 | ARCHITECTURE.md divergence section, `x/council/types/types_test.go` intent test |
| P3 (docs CI) | execute→verify→complete | v0.3.3 | 751 | `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml`, `.gitignore` site/ |
| P4 (final review+ship) | in progress | v0.3.4 (pending) | — | this AUDIT.md section + REVIEW.md v0.4 section |
Reconstruction: the git log subject lines match the `.ciagent/` file state. Each phase's `---ci---` block is present in the commit messages. Tags v0.3.0..v0.3.3 exist. **PASS.**
### 1.2 `.ciagent/` file discipline
14 files in `.ciagent/oy/` (ARCHITECTURE, AUDIT, GRILL, P1-P4_SHIP_VERIFICATION [P1-P3 from v0.2/v0.3, P4 pending], PERSONAS, PLANS, PROJECT, REQUIREMENTS, RESEARCH, REVIEW, ROADMAP). All present and updated for v0.4. CHECKPOINT.json reflects the current phase. config.json has `milestone: v0.4`, `milestone_type: nfr`, `tag_base: v0.3.x`. **PASS.**
### 1.3 Branch hygiene
Local: `main`, `oy/milestone/v0.4-refinement`, `oy/phase/04-final-review-ship` (current). Remote: `origin/main`, `origin/oy/milestone/v0.4-refinement`. All merged execution phase branches (P1, P2, P3) deleted locally. No leftover phase branches. The P4 final phase branch will be deleted at milestone ship. **PASS.**
### 1.4 Commit discipline
All 20 milestone commits have `---ci---` blocks with `project: oy`, `phase: N`, `milestone: v0.4`, `status: <stage>`, `tag_base: v0.3.x`, `milestone_type: nfr`. Commit subjects use conventional prefixes (docs, refactor, test, chore, verify, decision, checkpoint, Merge). No `feat:` subjects. **PASS.**
### 1.5 Build / test / coverage sanity
- `go build ./...`: clean.
- `go test ./...`: green (26 packages, all ok).
- `go vet ./...`: clean on touched packages.
- Coverage: `x/hub/types` 93.3% (v0.3 floor preserved; new cross-const test adds coverage). `x/council/types` 96.4% (improved from v0.3). Both above the 80% target (D-033). `go.mod` unchanged (zero deps, G-006). **PASS.**
## 2. NFR Purity Gate (v0.4 mandatory)
The NFR purity gate (D-047, D-001 filter) requires zero `feat:` commits in the v0.4 milestone range. The gate is checked on COMMIT SUBJECTS (not bodies), because `git log --grep` over-matches commit bodies that mention "feat:" in prose (e.g., the verify commits say "zero feat: commits in P2" in the body).
**Gate command**: `git log --format="%s" main..HEAD | grep -E "^feat:"`
**Result**: exit 1 (zero matches). The 20 commit subjects are: `docs(init)`, `docs(P00)` ×3, `docs(P00)` grill, `decision(P00)`, `Merge` ×3, `refactor(lexicon)`, `verify(P1)`, `checkpoint(p1)` ×3, `docs(arch)`, `verify(P2)`, `checkpoint(p2)`, `chore(ci)`, `verify(P3)`, `checkpoint(p3)`. None start with `feat:`.
**NFR purity gate: GREEN.**
## 3. Non-Critical Observations (P1+ flags, not blocking)
### P2-1: mkdocs build warnings (pre-existing v0.3 docs links)
- **Files**: `docs/index.md`, `docs/shared/vision.md` (link to `../README.md` / `../../README.md`)
- **Note**: `mkdocs build` produces 2 warnings about README.md not being in the docs tree. The build SUCCEEDS (warnings, not errors). These are pre-existing v0.3 docs content links, NOT introduced by v0.4. v0.4's REQ-032 is the CI workflow (which runs `mkdocs build` and succeeds despite the warnings), not the docs content.
- **Recommendation**: post-hoc fix in v0.5+ (either include README.md in mkdocs nav, or fix the relative links). Not a v0.4 ship blocker.
### P2-2: Gitea Actions `actions/upload-artifact@v4` compatibility
- **File**: `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml`
- **Note**: the workflow uses `actions/upload-artifact@v4`. Gitea Actions (which reimplements GitHub Actions) supports most `actions/*` but v4 of upload-artifact has had compatibility quirks. If the upload step fails, the `mkdocs build` step (the higher-priority check) would still have succeeded.
- **Recommendation**: post-hoc verify on the first real CI run; downgrade to v3 or use Gitea-native upload if needed. Not a ship blocker (the build is the gate, the artifact is a bonus).
### P2-3: NFR purity gate precision (documented in REVIEW.md P1+ #3)
- **Note**: `git log --grep "^feat:"` over-matches commit bodies. The audit uses the subject-only gate (`--format="%s" | grep -E "^feat:"`). This is documented for future milestones.
- **Recommendation**: bake the subject-only gate into the next milestone's PLAN. Not a ship blocker.
## 4. Overall Audit Verdict
### **PASS**
The v0.4 (Refinement — NFR) milestone is **shippable**.
**Per-check summary:**
| # | Check | Verdict |
|---|-------|---------|
| 1.1 | Reconstruction (phase progression, tags, `.ciagent` evidence) | PASS |
| 1.2 | `.ciagent` file discipline (14 files, CHECKPOINT, config.json) | PASS |
| 1.3 | Branch hygiene (no leftover phase branches; P4 final pending) | PASS |
| 1.4 | Commit discipline (`---ci---` blocks; conventional subjects; no feat:) | PASS |
| 1.5 | Build / test / coverage sanity (build, test, ≥80%, lexicon, G-006) | PASS |
| 2 | **NFR purity gate** (zero `feat:` commit subjects) | **GREEN** |
**Critical issues: 0.**
**Non-critical observations: 3** (all P2, post-hoc, non-blocking).
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.90.**
## STRIDE security summary (per ci-auditor role, read-only)
| Category | Finding | Severity | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spoofing | No auth surface added (v0.4 is refactor+test+docs+CI; no new identity logic) | Low | Accept |
| Tampering | The cross-const test (REQ-030) HARDENS tamper-resistance: a future change to `x/bond.CouponCapBps` or `x/hub.LendingCouponCapBps` is now detected by an automated test (was comment-only before v0.4). The absolute-value assertion (G-015) catches paired drift. Mission Lock (8%/0%) is MORE defended after v0.4. | Low (improved) | Accept |
| Repudiation | No audit-log changes in v0.4 | Low | Accept |
| Info Disclosure | The CI workflow (REQ-032) does NOT publish (build+artifact only, D-051); no secret exposure in the workflow YAML; `GITEA_TOKEN` is resolved via `resolveSecret()` from `.ciagent/.env.secrets` for release creation, never via shell-env `curl` | Low | Accept |
| Denial of Service | No network surface added; the CI workflow runs on push but does not expose a service | Low | Accept |
| Elevation of Privilege | No privilege surface added; the lexicon helper is a pure function; the regression guard only asserts existing consts | Low | Accept |
No threat exceeds the low/accept threshold. No escalations. v0.4 hardens the mission-locked const firewall (REQ-030) and the lexicon firewall (REQ-029) without introducing any new attack surface.
+912 -1
View File
@@ -181,4 +181,915 @@ Per-axis verdicts:
Binding decisions: 10 (G-001..G-010)
Escalations: 0
Overall: SHIP Phase 0 with binding changes (confidence 0.83)
```
```
---
## v0.3 Grill (Phase 0)
> **Reviewer**: CIAgent adversarial grill (red-team, full autonomy)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Target**: v0.3 Phase 0 artifacts (PROJECT.md D-034..D-046, ROADMAP.md v0.3 table, REQUIREMENTS.md REQ-010/022..028, ARCHITECTURE.md v0.3 section, PERSONAS.md v0.3 roster, RESEARCH.md A-301..A-315, PLANS.md v0.3 plan 50 tasks P1-P6) + v0.1/v0.2 codebase baseline
> **Milestone**: v0.3 — Bearers & Documentation
> **Autonomy**: full (decision_confidence_threshold = 0.60)
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
### Evidence baseline (verified against the actual repo, not the docs)
- `go.mod`: `module github.com/oy/openyield`, `go 1.22`, **zero dependencies** (confirmed — no require lines).
- `x/` modules: **25** (confirmed via `ls x/ | wc -l`). v0.1 = 15 + v0.2 added 10 = 25. v0.3 adds 4 new (exit/bridge/hub/services) + extends 3 (bearers/partner/bond) = 29 distinct after v0.3. PLANS.md P6-01-01 says "29 packages" — correct.
- Test functions: **299** `func Test*` across **23** test files (counted `grep -rn "^func Test" x/ | wc -l`). v0.2 grill G-001 corrected to 53/11; v0.2 added ~246 more. The v0.3 plan's "~303" reference (REQUIREMENTS IDEATE notes) is close to current 299 — minor, not material.
- `lexicon/lexicon.go`: `BannedTerms()` returns **10** (verified `if len(terms) != 10` at lexicon.go). The v0.2 `lexicon_meta_test.go` header comment still says "9 banned terms" (line 7) — a **pre-existing v0.2 documentation defect**, not v0.3's, but the v0.3 docs firewall must use 10 (it does — P1-01-01 says exactly 10). No v0.3 binding needed; note for v0.2 housekeeping.
- `lexicon_meta_test.go` EXISTS at repo root, package `lexicon_meta`, with the **G-009 self-test table** (synthetic strings, `len(synthetic) != len(terms)` guard). The self-test verifies **detection** but does NOT verify the **walk** (which files are scanned). The v0.3 docs firewall inherits this gap — G-013 below.
- G-003 import-invariant test EXISTS: `x/window/types/types_test.go:431-456` uses `go/parser` (ImportsOnly) to scan all non-test `.go` under `x/` and assert no cross-`x/<module>/types` struct imports. **Confirmed production code is cycle-free** (`grep -rn "openyield/x/" x/ --include="*.go" | grep -v "_test.go"` returns empty). The v0.3 by-ID-string refs (exit→bridge, hub→partner, services→window) will be auto-covered by this existing test — no new G-003 work needed in v0.3 (P4/P5 test tasks correctly say "G-003 import-invariant green" not "add a new one").
- `x/bond/types/types.go`: `CouponCapBps = 800`, `CouponFloorBps = 0`, `func Clamp(couponBps uint32) uint32` all exist. The D-028 regression firewall is real and the v0.3 GrowthBond extension reuses the same package (no G-003 concern, correct).
- `x/partner/types/types.go`: `TierAnchor PartnerTier = "Anchor"` exists; no `AnchorCredential` yet (v0.3 P4 adds it). The 4-tier enum is locked — P4 extension adds a struct, not a tier. Correct.
- `x/bearers/types/types.go`: `BearerOYSAT` and `BearerOYQR` are ALREADY in `AllBearers()` (lines 20-21, 39-40) since v0.1; `BearerTransport` interface + `OYLRLink` + `SurveillanceResistant` exist since v0.2. P4 adds `OYSATLink`/`OYQRCode` transport structs only — `AllBearers()` count (6) stays unchanged. Correct.
- `x/window`, `x/stand`, `x/satellite` (L2Chain/TransferChannel), `x/watcher`, `x/identity` (Reach) all exist as v0.1/v0.2 baseline — the v0.3 by-ID-string refs to them (bridge→satellite/watcher, services→window/identity, bond→stand) have real targets. No phantom refs.
- **No `docs/`, no `README.md`, no `mkdocs.yml` exist** today. The firewall-first ordering is clean: `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` passes vacuously with zero docs to scan (no hits possible). The "chicken-and-egg between firewall test and README" risk raised in the grill brief is a **non-issue** — verified by walk logic (zero files = zero hits).
These baseline facts confirm the v0.3 plan's architecture and ordering claims against the actual codebase, not just the docs. The plan is unusually well-grounded; the binding decisions below are mostly small correctness fixes, not scope rework.
### Per-Axis Verdicts
#### Axis 1 — Feasibility (50 tasks / 6 phases at full autonomy) — **PASS** (confidence 0.82)
50 tasks across 6 phases is large but proportionate to the deliverable: 26 docs pages (P1-P3) + 7 x/* packages (P4-P5) + audit/ship (P6). v0.2 shipped 31 tasks / 5 phases for 10 packages at full autonomy and closed clean (per REQUIREMENTS.md v0.2 summary). v0.3 adds the docs surface (a genuinely new artifact type) and 4 new + 3 extended Go packages. The docs phases (P1-P3) are low-risk Markdown authoring gated by a Go firewall; the Bearers phases (P4-P5) are pure skeleton+tests, the proven v0.1/v0.2 pattern. No phase exceeds 12 tasks (P3 is largest at 12, all docs). The firewall-first claim is achievable: a firewall that scans zero files passes trivially (verified — no docs exist yet). Reject the "50 tasks is too many" hypothesis — it matches the deliverable surface.
#### Axis 2 — Scope (Bearers + docs bundle, ~22 pages) — **PASS** (confidence 0.78)
D-034 (bundle Bearers + docs under one feature milestone) is defensible: the user's `--ideate` request was docs-only, but ROADMAP Phase 3 (Bearers) is the next queued feature work; bundling keeps the milestone cadence and avoids a docs-only NFR milestone that would not advance the protocol. The alternative (separate v0.3 docs NFR + v0.4 Bearers) would split a coherent unit of work into two milestones and delay the Bearers skeleton a full cycle. The ~20-25 page docs depth (D-045) is bounded — not gold-plating; each page maps to a REQ (REQUIREMENTS.md IDEATE traceability table). The one scope concern: the **mkdocs.yml nav in RESEARCH §2.1 is missing 2 pages** the plan creates — `nomads/window.md` (P2-01-07) and `freeholders/anchor-preview.md` (P3-01-07). This is a documentation/plan inconsistency, not a scope defect — **binding fix G-011** requires the nav to list all created pages. Confidence holds.
#### Axis 3 — Cost (MkDocs Material, firewall extension) — **PASS** (confidence 0.85)
MkDocs Material is the right cost: Markdown-native (docs-writer authors `.md`, not YAML/HTML), build-only Python dep that does NOT touch `go.mod` (verified zero require lines; G-006 holds). Plain-Markdown-no-generator would be cheaper but loses nav/search/theme — for a user-facing docs site for nomads/freeholders, Material's search + audience nav is real value, not gold-plating. The firewall extension (D-043: a whole new sibling test `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` + self-test table) is more than "could review manually" — manual review is not durable; the sibling test is the firewall that keeps the docs site lexicon-clean over time (the top risk per Axis 5). The cost is justified. Reject the "firewall is over-engineered for docs" hypothesis — REQ-012 is `All` phases and docs are user-facing; a manual review would rot.
#### Axis 4 — Technical soundness (by-ID-string refs, ClampGrowth, LendingCouponCapBps) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.72)
The by-ID-string refs (G-003) between bridge/exit/partner/hub/services are cycle-free by construction (verified: the existing G-003 import-invariant test in `x/window/types/types_test.go` scans all non-test `x/**/*.go` and will auto-cover the v0.3 files; production code has zero cross-`x/` imports today). The `x/hub` `LendingCouponCapBps = 800` LOCAL const (A-304) is a real invariant — it's a local copy cross-documented to D-028, exactly mirroring how v0.2 `x/guild` cross-docs `x/feecovenant.WaiverHandPassGuild` (verified pattern). The one technical defect: **`ClampGrowth(currentBps, growthBps uint32) uint32` as specified in RESEARCH §1.7 / PLANS P5-03-01 returns `min(CouponCapBps - currentBps, growthBps)`, which underflows when `currentBps > CouponCapBps`** (uint32 subtraction wraps to a huge value, then `min` picks `growthBps` — wrong) or when `currentBps == cap` (returns 0, correct) but is fragile. The invariant "post-growth coupon ≤ 800" only holds if the caller guarantees `currentBps ≤ cap`. The spec does not state this precondition, and a GrowthBond whose current coupon is already at cap would silently allow unbounded growth via the `growthBps` path if the helper is misused. **Binding fix G-012** requires `ClampGrowth` to guard `currentBps > CouponCapBps` explicitly (return 0 or error) so the invariant holds unconditionally. Confidence holds after the fix.
#### Axis 5 — Risk (lexicon drift, "yield" in docs) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.74)
The top risk is correctly identified: "yield" is banned as a standalone word but "OpenYield" is safe (word-boundary regex, verified `TestLexiconMetaNoFalsePositiveOnOpenYield`); PROJECT.md uses "real yield" but docs must say "real production"/"real return". The firewall-first ordering (D-044: P1 firewall before P2/P3 content) is the correct mitigation — a banned term slipped into a P2 nomads page fails the P2 build, not the P6 review. The firewall extension (D-043) is sufficient to CATCH drift at build time. The gap: the firewall does not PREVENT the docs-writer from authoring a banned term in the first place — it fails the phase build, requiring a rewrite. For 26 pages this is acceptable (the failure is loud and local); for 100+ pages it would be painful. At the v0.3 scale, the firewall is sufficient. The deeper risk: **the docs firewall self-test table (G-009 for docs) verifies DETECTION but not the WALK** — if the walk logic misses `docs/nomads/` (e.g., a path-prefix bug), the self-test still passes (it tests `FindBannedTerm` on synthetic strings, not the file walk). **Binding fix G-013** requires the docs firewall to include a walk-coverage assertion: a test that injects a synthetic banned-term `.md` into a temp `docs/` subtree (or uses a fixture) and asserts the walk FINDS it. Without this, the docs firewall could silently scan zero files and report green. Confidence holds after the fix.
#### Axis 6 — Dependency (intra-P4, P4→P5, hidden edges) — **PASS** (confidence 0.80)
The intra-P4 edge (bridge→exit) and the P4→P5 edge (partner-Anchor→hub) are the only v0.3-internal ordering constraints, and both are correctly handled (P4 Wave 1 = bridge before exit Wave 2; P4 before P5 for Anchor→hub). The RESEARCH §3 cross-component dependency list is complete for the v0.3 surface. Verified the "hidden edges" raised in the grill brief:
- **Does x/services need x/window types?** Yes, by-ID-string (`window-id` field) — but x/window is v0.2 baseline, already shipped. Not a v0.3 phase-ordering concern. Correctly noted in RESEARCH §3.
- **Does x/bond GrowthBond need x/anything?** No — GrowthBond embeds the v0.2 Bond (same package, `x/bond/types`), and `ClampGrowth` reuses the same-package consts. No G-003 concern. Correct.
- **Does x/hub need x/bond?** No — it uses a LOCAL const `LendingCouponCapBps = 800` (A-304) to avoid the import. Correct (verified pattern matches v0.2 guild/feecovenant).
- **Does x/exit need x/bread?** No — `amount-grain` is int64, "Grain" by name only (P4-02-01 explicitly says "NOT a `x/bread` import"). Correct.
No hidden edges. The P5 "no intra-phase ordering" claim (hub/services/bond independent) is correct — they reference only v0.1/v0.2 baseline modules by ID-string, not each other.
#### Axis 7 — Testing (≥80% on skeletons, docs phases no Go coverage) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.70)
≥80% coverage on skeleton type packages is achievable but borders on coverage theater (testing getters/constructors/enum-round-trips on trivial types). v0.2 hit ≥95.9% on 8 of 10 packages at this bar, so it's not theater in practice — the locked-const + invariant + lexicon assertions carry real regression value. The plan correctly applies the ≥80% bar only to the 7 x/* packages (P4/P5), NOT to the docs phases (P1-P3 produce no Go code except the firewall test, which is itself the coverage). The one gap: **P1-01-01 (the docs firewall) and P4/P5 test files have no explicit coverage target** — the firewall test's own coverage is not asserted. A firewall test that scans zero files (walk bug) would still have high coverage on its detection logic. **Binding fix G-013** (walk-coverage assertion, from Axis 5) addresses this — the injected-fixture test forces the walk to actually execute. No separate coverage bar needed for docs phases. Confidence holds.
#### Axis 8 — Maintainability (docs lexicon over time, sibling test drift) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.72)
The docs site will stay lexicon-clean over time ONLY if the firewall runs on every change. D-046 defers publishing CI to v0.4, but the firewall is a `go test` — it runs locally and in any CI that runs `go test ./...`. The risk is not "no CI" (the firewall runs wherever `go test` runs) but "the sibling test `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` drifts from `lexicon_meta_test.go`". D-043 chose a sibling (not an extension) to preserve v0.2 coverage — defensible — but two meta-tests sharing detection logic via the same `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` is good; sharing the self-test table by DUPLICATION (not by a shared helper) is the drift risk. If `lexicon_meta_test.go`'s self-test table is updated (e.g., a new banned term added) and `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`'s copy is not, the docs firewall silently loses coverage. **Binding fix G-014**: the docs firewall's self-test table and banned-term count assertion should DERIVE from `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (which both already do for the count — good) and ideally share the synthetic-string table via a `lexicon` package helper rather than duplicating it. At minimum, both must assert `len(terms) == 10` from the single source `lexicon.BannedTerms()` so a count change breaks both. This is a low-severity maintainability note, not a blocker. Confidence holds.
#### Axis 9 — Adversarial (what makes v0.3 fail to ship) — **PASS** (confidence 0.78)
The four failure modes raised in the grill brief:
1. **Firewall blocks docs content mid-authoring** — MITIGATED by firewall-first (P1 firewall passes vacuously with zero docs; P2/P3 content fails fast and local, not at P6). Not a ship-blocker.
2. **By-ID-string ref breaks when a target module is renamed** — LOW. The targets (satellite/watcher/identity/window/stand) are v0.1/v0.2 baseline, locked. v0.3 does not rename them. The by-ID-string fields are opaque strings, not Go imports, so a rename would only break tests that hardcode the ID — caught at `go test`. Not a ship-blocker.
3. **MkDocs build fails on Gitea Pages** — NON-ISSUE for v0.3. D-046 explicitly defers publishing CI to v0.4; v0.3 ships the source + a `mkdocs build` invocation in the README. A Gitea Pages failure is a v0.4 concern, not v0.3's. Not a ship-blocker.
4. **Coverage drops below 80% on a skeleton package with trivial types** — MITIGATED. v0.2 hit ≥95.9% on 8/10 packages at this bar; the locked-const + invariant + lexicon assertions provide real coverage. The v0.3 packages (bridge/exit/hub/services) follow the v0.2 satellite/forex pattern that hit 100%. Not a ship-blocker.
The actual highest ship-risk is **ClampGrowth underflow (G-012)** if a test constructs a GrowthBond at cap and the helper misbehaves — but this is caught by the invariant test (post-growth ≤ 800) if the test exercises the cap boundary. **Binding fix G-012** makes the helper robust; the test must cover `currentBps == cap` and `currentBps > cap`. No escalation.
---
### Binding Decisions
These are **binding** — the orchestrator MUST apply them before P1 begins. Numbered G-011..G-014 (continuing from the v0.2 grill G-001..G-010).
| ID | Decision | Rationale | Confidence | Affects |
|----|----------|-----------|------------|---------|
| **G-011** | `mkdocs.yml` nav MUST list every page the plan creates. RESEARCH §2.1's sample `mkdocs.yml` is missing `nomads/window.md` (P2-01-07) and `freeholders/anchor-preview.md` (P3-01-07). P1-01-02 (mkdocs.yml authoring) must include all 26 pages in the nav (or the nav is incomplete at P3 ship). The nav may reference not-yet-existing pages at P1 (mkdocs.yml is config, not Go-tested) but must be complete by P3-03-01 ship. | The RESEARCH sample nav and the PLANS page list disagree by 2 pages. A stale nav ships a docs site with orphaned pages (created but not linked). | 0.85 | P1-01-02 (mkdocs.yml), P3-03-01 (ship verification — confirm nav matches all 26 created pages) |
| **G-012** | `x/bond` `ClampGrowth(currentBps, growthBps uint32) uint32` MUST guard `currentBps > CouponCapBps` explicitly (return 0, or document the precondition and assert it) so the "post-growth coupon ≤ 800" invariant holds unconditionally. The spec's `min(CouponCapBps - currentBps, growthBps)` underflows when `currentBps > cap` (uint32 wrap → huge value → `min` picks `growthBps` → invariant violated). The P5-03-01 test MUST cover `currentBps == cap` (returns 0) and `currentBps > cap` (returns 0 or is rejected) as explicit cases. | The spec'd helper has a uint32 underflow trap that breaks the stated invariant under misuse. The v0.2 `Clamp` has no such trap (it's a simple min/max); `ClampGrowth` adds the subtraction. A latent underflow in a locked-const firewall is a real defect. | 0.82 | P5-03-01 (ClampGrowth helper + invariant test) |
| **G-013** | `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` MUST include a **walk-coverage assertion**: a test that places a synthetic banned-term `.md` in a temp/fixture `docs/` subtree (or uses an in-memory walk target) and asserts the walk FINDS it. The G-009 self-test table (which both firewalls share) verifies DETECTION (`FindBannedTerm` on synthetic strings) but NOT the WALK (which files are scanned). A walk bug (e.g., wrong path prefix, missing `docs/` recursion) would report green on zero files scanned. The walk-coverage test closes this gap. | The docs firewall's failure mode is "silently scans nothing and reports green" — undetectable by the self-test table alone. v0.3 has no docs today, so a broken walk passes trivially at P1 and would only surface when a real banned term slips into a real P2/P3 page AND the walk happens to miss that file. A walk-coverage test forces the walk to execute against a known-bad fixture. | 0.80 | P1-01-01 (lexicon_meta_docs_test.go) |
| **G-014** | `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` and `lexicon_meta_test.go` MUST derive the banned-term count from the single source `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (both already assert `len(terms) == 10` from it — good; verified). The synthetic self-test table should ideally be shared via a `lexicon` package helper (e.g., `lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings() []string`) rather than duplicated across the two meta-tests, so a future banned-term addition updates both firewalls from one place. If a shared helper is not added in v0.3, the two tables MUST be kept in sync by a comment cross-reference. | D-043 chose a sibling test to preserve v0.2 coverage — defensible — but two copies of the self-test table drift silently. A shared helper is the durable fix; a cross-reference comment is the minimum. | 0.70 | P1-01-01 (lexicon_meta_docs_test.go), optionally `lexicon/lexicon.go` (shared helper) |
---
### Escalations
**None.** All nine axes resolved at confidence ≥ 0.60 after the binding fixes G-011..G-014 are applied. No axis required escalation to the human. At full autonomy, the orchestrator applies the binding decisions and proceeds to P1.
---
### Overall Verdict
#### **SHIP Phase 0 with binding changes**
The v0.3 Phase 0 plan is fundamentally sound and unusually well-grounded: the architecture and ordering claims were verified against the actual codebase (25 x/* modules, zero deps, G-003 import-invariant test exists and is green, bond consts/Clamp exist, bearers/partner extension points exist, baseline modules for all by-ID-string refs exist). The firewall-first ordering is clean (firewall passes vacuously with zero docs — no chicken-and-egg). The scope (Bearers + docs bundle) is defensible, not over-scoped. The 50-task / 6-phase plan is proportionate to the deliverable surface (26 docs pages + 7 x/* packages).
The binding changes are **small correctness fixes**, not scope rework:
- **G-011** (mkdocs.yml nav completeness) — documentation/plan consistency.
- **G-012** (ClampGrowth uint32 underflow guard) — the single real technical defect; a latent invariant-breaking trap in a locked-const firewall.
- **G-013** (docs firewall walk-coverage test) — closes the "silently scans nothing" failure mode the G-009 self-test table does not cover.
- **G-014** (shared synthetic-string helper / cross-reference) — maintainability of the two sibling firewalls.
None of these rise to "rethink" or "reduce scope" — the architecture, scope, ordering, and persona assignments are correct. Apply the 4 binding decisions and proceed to Phase P1.
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.80**
---
### Summary Block
```
Per-axis verdicts (v0.3):
1. Feasibility — PASS (0.82)
2. Scope — PASS (0.78) → strengthened by G-011
3. Cost — PASS (0.85)
4. Technical soundness — CONDITIONAL (0.72) → fixed by G-012
5. Risk — CONDITIONAL (0.74) → fixed by G-013
6. Dependency — PASS (0.80)
7. Testing — CONDITIONAL (0.70) → fixed by G-013 (walk-coverage)
8. Maintainability — CONDITIONAL (0.72) → fixed by G-014
9. Adversarial — PASS (0.78)
Binding decisions: 4 (G-011..G-014)
Escalations: 0
Overall: SHIP Phase 0 with binding changes (confidence 0.80)
```
---
## Grill Review: OpenYield (oy) — v0.4 (Refinement — NFR) Phase 0
> **Reviewer**: CIAgent adversarial grill (red-team, full autonomy)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Target**: Phase 0 artifacts (PROJECT.md v0.4 section, REQUIREMENTS.md v0.4 table, ARCHITECTURE.md v0.4 section, PERSONAS.md v0.4, PLANS.md v0.4 plan, config.json) + v0.3 codebase baseline
> **Milestone**: v0.4 — Refinement (NFR)
> **Autonomy**: full (decision_confidence_threshold = 0.60)
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
### Methodology
Each of nine axes was scored against concrete evidence. The v0.4 scope is small (4 REQs, 12 tasks, 5 phases including P0+P4) so the grill is correspondingly focused. The central question: **is v0.4 a legitimate NFR milestone or is it a scope-creep / busywork milestone that should be a single patch or deferred?**
### Evidence baseline (verified against the actual repo)
- v0.3 milestone COMPLETE: checkpoint `milestone_complete: true`, release `v0.2.6` (id 739), HEAD on `main`. Verified.
- v0.3 forward-references for v0.4 scope: REVIEW.md P2 (A-304 cross-const), AUDIT.md §193 (P1-1/P1-2 council divergences, P2 bearers no-op), GRILL.md G-014 (lexicon helper). Verified — all four REQ-029..REQ-032 map to a real v0.3 forward-reference.
- The two synthetic self-test tables are byte-identical duplicates: `lexicon_meta_test.go:93-104` and `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go:157-168`. Verified by diff — G-014 drift risk is REAL, not theoretical.
- `x/hub/types/types.go:51,56` defines `LendingCouponCapBps = uint32(800)` and `LendingCouponFloorBps = uint32(0)`; `x/bond/types/types.go:21,26` defines `CouponCapBps = 800` and `CouponFloorBps = 0`. No automated cross-check exists (only a cross-doc comment). Verified — A-304 drift risk is REAL.
- `SignalKindCount = 4` is already a locked-const test (`x/council/types/types_test.go:102`). The AUDIT P1-2 rationale (Freeholder is eligibility, Guild is council tier, Capital is committed-capital) is in AUDIT.md but NOT in ARCHITECTURE.md. Verified — the documentation gap is REAL.
- No `.github/workflows/` and no `.gitea/workflows/` directory exists. Verified — REQ-032 is net-new CI, not a modification.
### Forcing Questions and Verdicts
**1. Is v0.4 a legitimate milestone, or should these fixes be a single v0.3.x patch?**
The four fixes are independent (lexicon helper, cross-const test, lifecycle docs, CI). Bundling them into a milestone with per-phase ship (P1..P3 each ship a patch) gives each fix its own release tag and audit trail. The alternative (one v0.3.1 patch with all four) loses the per-fix release boundary. D-052 phase ordering keeps each phase independently shippable. **Verdict: legitimate milestone** — the per-phase ship cadence (D-052) is the value, not the milestone label. Confidence 0.82.
**2. Does REQ-031 violate the D-001 refinement-only filter by documenting a divergence that mentions `Proposal`/`VoteOption` (which are `feat:`-class types)?**
No. DOCUMENTING a deferred `feat:` in ARCHITECTURE.md is `docs`, not `feat:`. REQ-031 adds NO enum types and changes NO locked consts. The regression-guard test asserts the CURRENT shape (4-signal) is intentional — it does not ADD a type. The D-001 filter rejects the `feat:` (adding Proposal/VoteOption) but accepts the `docs` (documenting why they are absent). **Verdict: passes D-001**. Confidence 0.85.
**3. Does REQ-030's test-only import of `x/bond/types` into `x/hub/types` violate G-003?**
No. G-003 forbids PRODUCTION cross-module struct imports. The import is in `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` (a `_test.go` file). The v0.2 GRILL G-003 explicitly documented the test-import exemption (and `x/bearers/types/types_test.go:7` already imports `x/processing/types` as a test-only precedent). The plan's P1-02-01 verification includes a grep confirming no PRODUCTION `.go` file in `x/hub/types/` imports `x/bond/types`. **Verdict: G-003 intact**. Confidence 0.88.
**4. Does REQ-032 (CI workflow with mkdocs) violate G-006 (zero Go deps)?**
No. The CI workflow installs mkdocs + mkdocs-material in a SEPARATE CI job (`docs-build`), not in `go.mod`. `go.mod` is not modified by the workflow (Python deps are isolated to the CI runner). The plan's P3-99-01 verification confirms `go.mod` diff is empty. **Verdict: G-006 intact**. Confidence 0.90.
**5. Is the NFR purity gate enforceable?**
Yes. The gate is `git log --grep "^feat:" <milestone-range>` returns zero. The v0.4 plan explicitly rejects `feat:`-class work (D-050 rejects Proposal/VoteOption; D-051 rejects Pages publish as a feature). The P4 audit (P4-02-01) runs the gate. The only risk: a commit MESSAGE accidentally using `feat:` prefix — the gate checks the prefix, not the content. **Verdict: enforceable**. Confidence 0.85.
### Binding Decisions (G-015..G-016)
| ID | Binding Decision | Rationale | Confidence | Source |
|----|------------------|-----------|------------|--------|
| **G-015** | The P1-02-01 cross-const test MUST also assert the absolute mission-locked values (`LendingCouponCapBps == 800`, `LendingCouponFloorBps == 0`, `CouponCapBps == 800`, `CouponFloorBps == 0`) in addition to the cross-package equality. The cross-package equality test alone would pass if BOTH consts drifted to the same wrong value (e.g., both 900). The absolute-value assertion catches a paired drift. | The plan's P1-02-01 already includes `TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0` (good). This binding makes it MANDATORY: the test must assert BOTH the cross-equality AND the absolute 800/0 values. Without the absolute assertion, a paired drift (both consts change to the same wrong value) is undetected. | 0.85 | PLANS.md P1-02-01 |
| **G-016** | The P3-01-01 CI workflow MUST run `go test ./...` BEFORE `mkdocs build` is allowed to proceed IF the jobs are serial, OR the `go-test` job must be a REQUIRED check (not advisory) if the jobs are parallel. The lexicon firewall (`go test ./...`) is the higher-priority check; a docs build that passes while the lexicon firewall fails is a false-green deploy. The plan's P3-01-01 runs the jobs in parallel (no dependency) — acceptable ONLY if both are required-status checks. If Gitea Actions does not support required-status on artifact-upload jobs, the jobs MUST be serial (`go-test` then `docs-build` depends-on `go-test`). | A docs build that succeeds while the lexicon firewall fails would publish (or artifact) a docs site from a repo that has a lexicon violation — a false-green. The firewall must gate the docs build. | 0.78 | PLANS.md P3-01-01 |
### Nine-Axis Scorecard (v0.4 Phase 0)
```
1. Scope — PASS (0.85) scoped to 4 v0.3 forward-refs; no scope creep
2. Feasibility — PASS (0.88) all 4 fixes are mechanical; no research risk
3. Specification — PASS (0.82) REQs clear; D-047..D-053 unambiguous
4. Decomposition — PASS (0.80) P1..P3 independent vertical slices; P4 review/ship
5. Risk — PASS (0.85) NFR scope (no behavioral change); low risk
6. Dependency — PASS (0.82) no cross-phase hard blockers; G-003 test-exempt documented
7. Testing — PASS (0.85) each fix has a verification task; NFR purity gate in P4
8. Maintainability — CONDITIONAL (0.78) → fixed by G-015 (absolute-value assertion)
9. Adversarial — PASS (0.82) D-001 filter enforced; no feat: creep
Binding decisions: 2 (G-015, G-016)
Escalations: 0
Overall: SHIP Phase 0 with binding changes (confidence 0.84)
```
### v0.4 Grill Verdict
**SHIP Phase 0** with G-015 (absolute-value const assertion in P1-02-01) and G-016 (firewall-gates-docs-build in P3-01-01) applied. The v0.4 NFR milestone is a legitimate, well-scoped refinement cycle that closes three real v0.3 forward-references (G-014, A-304, AUDIT §193) and lands the deferred docs CI (D-046). The D-001 refinement-only filter is enforced throughout; the NFR purity gate in P4 is enforceable. No escalations.
---
# GRILL: OpenYield (oy) — v0.5 (Bearers Runtime)
> **Reviewer**: CIAgent adversarial grill (red-team, full autonomy)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Target**: v0.5 Phase 0 artifacts (PROJECT.md D-054..D-061, REQUIREMENTS.md REQ-033..REQ-039, ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 Runtime Architecture section, PERSONAS.md v0.5 roster, RESEARCH.md A-501..A-574, PLANS.md v0.5 plan — 8 phases, 36 tasks, MVP/UX check) + v0.1..v0.4 codebase baseline
> **Milestone**: v0.5 — Bearers Runtime (feature type)
> **Autonomy**: full (decision_confidence_threshold = 0.60)
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
> **Branch**: phase/00-pre-execution (off milestone/v0.5-bearers-runtime)
> **G-NNN sequence**: continues from G-016 (highest prior grill id). New fixes G-017..
## Methodology
v0.5 is the first milestone to ship executable behavior beyond invariant tests: 8
v0.3 skeleton modules are promoted to live keeper `MsgServer` handlers + simtest.
This is a load-bearing change of the project's character: `go.mod` gains
`cosmos-sdk` + `ibc-go` (D-055 — the first break of G-006), `types/` packages gain
`sdk.Msg` imports (the first break of the v0.1-v0.4 zero-dep `types/` property),
and keeper-to-keeper cross-module calls appear (a NEW G-003 surface). The grill
treats each of these as a forcing question, not a narrative.
### Evidence baseline (verified against the actual repo, not the docs)
- `go.mod`: `module github.com/oy/openyield`, `go 1.22`, **zero dependencies**
(confirmed — no require lines). D-055 will make cosmos-sdk the FIRST external
Go dep in the project's history. This is a one-way door for `go.mod` hygiene.
- `x/` module count: **29 entries** under `x/` (one is `README.md`; 28 actual
modules — verified). The 8 v0.5 targets (exit, bridge, bearers, partner, hub,
services, bond, council) all exist as `types/`-only packages from v0.3.
- **Zero cosmos-sdk imports** in `x/` today (grep `cosmos-sdk|cosmos/cosmos|
sdk.Context` → empty). v0.5 P1-01-01 introduces the first.
- **Empty `keeper/` subdirs exist for 5 v0.1 baseline modules** (`x/mirror/keeper`,
`x/forge/keeper`, `x/still/keeper`, `x/watcher/keeper`, `x/bread/keeper`) —
all EMPTY (no `.go` files). RESEARCH §1.1 says "there is NO `keeper/` subdir"
for the v0.3 targets, which is correct; but the claim "NO `keeper/` subdir
anywhere" is imprecise — v0.1 baseline has empty keeper dirs. Not blocking, but
the v0.5 "promote to runtime" pattern should NOT touch the 5 v0.1 baseline
keepers (out of scope; D-056 scopes P1..P7 to the 8 v0.3 modules). **Noted.**
- **G-003 import-invariant test** exists: `x/window/types/types_test.go` scans
non-test `x/**/*.go` via `go/parser`. **Confirmed: zero cross-module struct
imports in production x/ today** (`grep -rn "openyield/x/" x/ --include="*.go"
| grep -v "_test.go"` → empty). The v0.5 `expected_keepers.go` shims must keep
this green (interfaces, not struct imports).
- **Locked consts verified present and unchanged**:
- `x/bond/types/types.go:21,26`: `CouponCapBps = 800`, `CouponFloorBps = 0`
(D-028).
- `x/bond/types/types.go:239`: `ClampGrowth` has the **G-012 guard**
(`if currentBps >= CouponCapBps { return 0 }`) — the v0.3 grill fix landed.
- `x/council/types/types.go:25`: `MissionLockAmendable = false`.
- `x/council/types/types.go:30`: `SignalKindCount = 4`.
- `x/partner/types/types.go:18`: `PartnerTierCount = 4`.
- `x/hub/types/types.go:42,51,55`: `HubServiceCount = 3`,
`LendingCouponCapBps = uint32(800)`, `LendingCouponFloorBps = uint32(0)`.
- **Proposal / VoteOption / ProposalStatus / WatcherVetoQuorum ABSENT** from
`x/council/types` today (correct — P7 adds them). `TallyResult.NoWithVeto`
field EXISTS (`types.go:142`) with an explicit comment "always 0 — no veto
option (anti-greed)".
- **CRITICAL FINDING (feature purity gate)**: `x/council/types/types_test.go:233-
239` contains `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` which asserts
`tr.NoWithVeto != 0` → error "expected 0 (no veto option — anti-greed)". v0.5
P7 (D-060, ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 Voice/Council Interface, RESEARCH §2.7)
**populates `NoWithVeto` with Watcher Vetos** ("the v0.2 `NoWithVeto` field,
zero-locked in v0.2, is now populated by Watcher Vetos"). This is a
**contradiction**: the v0.2 regression test says NoWithVeto is ALWAYS 0
(anti-greed); the v0.5 plan says NoWithVeto is populated by Vetos. The plan
lists P7-03-01 as extending `types_test.go` but does NOT call out that
`TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` must be REPLACED, not extended. This is a
breaking change to a locked-invariant test that the feature purity gate
("no breaking schema changes") must reconcile. **Binding fix G-017** (below).
- **Cross-const test** (REQ-030/G-015) exists at `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go`
with `TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0` asserting absolute 800/0 (G-015
landed). The v0.5 P4 lending clamp must keep this green.
- **Both lexicon firewalls** present (`lexicon_meta_test.go`,
`lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`).
- **git history**: v0.4 milestone COMPLETE (`4369b3e checkpoint(milestone): v0.4
complete`). HEAD on `phase/00-pre-execution` off `milestone/v0.5-bearers-
runtime`. P0 for v0.5 is in progress (PLAN committed at `a0145e4`).
These baseline facts confirm the v0.5 plan's architecture claims against the
actual codebase, with one material contradiction (the NoWithVeto regression test
vs. the P7 Veto population).
---
## 1. Decision Ratifications (D-055, D-062, D-063, D-064, D-065)
### D-055 — cosmos-sdk + ibc-go dep as G-006 controlled exception
**Verdict: RATIFY (confidence 0.82)**
**Evidence**: `go.mod` is zero-dep today (verified). The v0.3 skeleton keepers
are in-memory `map[string]T` stubs (verified: `x/partner/types/types.go` Keeper
stub). Promoting to `MsgServer` (`sdk.Msg`, `sdk.Context`, `sdk.KVStore`,
`RegisterServices`) is impossible without cosmos-sdk — hand-rolling store +
message routing would duplicate the SDK and is the rejected alternative in
D-055's rationale. The exception is genuinely scoped: runtime phases P1..P7
import cosmos-sdk; P0 (this PLAN) and P8 stay dep-neutral; `types/` packages
gain `sdk.Msg` imports isolated in `types/msg_*.go`. The G-006 *intent*
(durability of skeleton types) is preserved by keeping the v0.3 `types/` contract
structs/enums/consts unamended — runtime adds behavior on top (D-054).
**One caveat**: the `types/` packages losing zero-dep status is a one-way door.
Once `x/bond/types` imports cosmos-sdk for `Msg*`, the v0.1-v0.4 property
"`types/` compiles with stdlib only" is gone. RESEARCH §3.1 acknowledges this and
isolates `Msg*` to `types/msg_*.go`. The invariant/lexicon tests in `types/`
MUST stay stdlib-only and green (they don't need `Msg*`). **Binding fix G-017
family** (below) does not block D-055 but records the constraint: P1-01-01 must
add a CI assertion that invariant/lexicon tests pass WITHOUT the cosmos-sdk
build tag (or that they remain in stdlib-only `_test.go` files that don't import
`sdk.Msg`). Confidence holds.
### D-062 — cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x version pin
**Verdict: RATIFY (confidence 0.80)**
**Evidence**: cosmos-sdk v0.50.x is the LTS line compatible with go 1.22
(RESEARCH §3.1, A-504). ibc-go v8.x is the stable pairing for v0.50
(Osmosis/dYdX-v4 lineage). The alternative (ibc-go v10 / IBC v2 Eureka) is newer
and risks churn in a runtime-promotion milestone; the v0.5 impl uses the v8
stable `OnRecvPacket`/`OnAcknowledgementPacket`/`OnTimeoutPacket` contract
(ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 IBC Packet Handler Scope). The RESEARCH §2.1 Eureka
timestamp-only-timeout pattern is DOCUMENTED but the v8 interfaces suffice for
the 5 locked L2 chains (D-059). Pinning v8 now and upgrading to v10 in a later
milestone is lower-risk than pinning v10 in a milestone whose primary goal is
runtime promotion, not IBC-v2 migration.
**One caveat**: cosmos-sdk v0.50.x and ibc-go v8.x have large transitive dep
trees (hundreds of modules). P1-01-01 (`go mod tidy`) will produce a `go.sum`
that is orders of magnitude larger than the zero-dep baseline. This is
expected and acceptable (D-055 ratifies), but the P1-99-01 verification must
confirm `go build ./...` succeeds under go 1.22 with the new tree (a
transitive dep requiring go 1.23+ would block). The plan's P1-01-01 verification
says "go version compatible (go 1.22+)" — **binding fix G-018** makes this a
HARD gate: if `go build ./...` fails under go 1.22, P1 does not ship (escalate
to a go version bump, which is out of scope for v0.5). Confidence holds.
### D-063 — Bond CLOB match above 800 bps = REJECT (fails closed)
**Verdict: RATIFY (confidence 0.78)**
**Evidence**: D-057 says "hard clamp on each match"; the runtime interpretation
(D-063) is REJECT above cap. The rationale is sound: the 8% cap is a Mission-
Lock invariant (D-028), not a soft cap. A match above 800 bps is a usury
violation, not a clampable excess. REJECT fails closed (the resting order
stays; the incoming order rests or is cancelled) — no refund path, no
partial-clearing ambiguity. The Fee Covenant `Clamp` shape (clamp, not reject)
applies to ISSUANCE (a coupon set by the issuer), where clamping is the
mission-lock-true choice; MATCHING is market-determined, where reject is the
mission-lock-true choice. The distinction is defensible and documented in
D-063's rationale.
The alternative (clamp-with-refund) adds a refund path — a new state
transition with its own failure modes (what if the refund fails? does the
match revert?). REJECT is simpler and safer for the highest-severity locked
const. Simtest (P6-03-01) covers the reject-above-cap case explicitly.
**One caveat**: the "implied coupon" computation must be unambiguous. The
match's implied coupon is derived from the trade price (fraction of principal
in bps) — the plan does not specify the exact formula (price → implied coupon).
If two implementers compute it differently, the reject threshold is
inconsistent. **Binding fix G-019**: P6-02-01 (`clob.go`) MUST define a single
`ImpliedCoupon(priceBps, principal) uint32` helper (or equivalent) used by
BOTH the match and the clamp check, with a unit test covering the boundary
(price implying exactly 800, 801, 799 bps). Confidence holds after the fix.
### D-064 — MissionLockAmendment-Rejected rejected at ValidateBasic
**Verdict: RATIFY (confidence 0.85)**
**Evidence**: `MissionLockAmendable = false` is a v0.2 locked const
(`x/council/types/types.go:25`, verified). `TestMissionLockAmendableConstFalse`
and `TestMissionLockAmendableCannotBeSetTrue` (types_test.go:67-88) guard the
const. D-064 rejects `MissionLockAmendment-Rejected` ProposalKind at
`MsgSubmitProposal.ValidateBasic` — the message never reaches the handler. This
is the cleanest firewall: the const is the firewall, `ValidateBasic` is the
gate, and no state record is created for an unproposable proposal. The
alternative (propose-then-fail) would create dead state (a Pending proposal that
auto-transitions to Failed) — unnecessary state growth and a misleading
on-chain record. The Mission-Lock-non-amendable design intent is
"unproposable", not "propose-then-fail" (RESEARCH §2.7).
P7-03-01 simtest asserts `MsgSubmitProposal` with the rejected kind fails
`ValidateBasic` with a Mission-Lock error and the keeper's Proposal store is
empty. This is a concrete, testable firewall. Confidence holds.
### D-065 — Watcher Veto quorum default = 6
**Verdict: RATIFY (confidence 0.78)**
**Evidence**: REQ-004 fixes the Watcher quorum at 6-of-9. The Veto quorum
mirrors it (a Watcher-coordinated veto requires the same quorum as a Watcher
attestation). A single Veto blocking would violate the anti-greed principle
(vision §19 — no single-actor veto gate). Defaulting to 6 as a PARAM (not a
locked const) lets a future governance vote adjust without a Mission-Lock-class
amendment — defensible, since Veto quorum is NOT a Mission-Lock const (the
distinction is documented in v0.4 ARCHITECTURE.md). The `Params` struct is
currently empty (`types.go:148` `type Params struct{}`); P7-01-01 adds
`WatcherVetoQuorum` defaulting to 6.
**Two caveats**:
1. **Param validation**: a `WatcherVetoQuorum` param of 0 (no quorum needed —
any single Veto blocks) or 10 (more than the 9 Watchers — veto impossible)
would violate the anti-greed / REQ-004 semantics. The plan's P7-01-01 does
NOT specify `Params.Validate()` bounds. **Binding fix G-020**: P7-01-01 MUST
add a `Params.Validate()` (or `ValidateBasic` on the param) asserting
`WatcherVetoQuorum` is in `[1, 9]` (or `[2, 9]` to forbid single-veto-block
even if the param is mis-set). The default 6 is correct; the validation
bounds are the missing piece.
2. **The NoWithVeto contradiction** (see G-017) is the bigger Veto concern —
the v0.2 regression test asserts NoWithVeto is ALWAYS 0. P7 populates it.
This must be reconciled regardless of the quorum value.
Confidence holds after G-017 and G-020.
---
## 2. Nine-Axis Adversarial Scorecard
### Axis 1 — Feasibility (8 modules × MsgServer + simtest at full autonomy) — **PASS** (confidence 0.80)
36 tasks across 8 phases for 8 module promotions is proportionate. Each module
gets a types+msg task, a keeper+msg_server task, a simtest task, and a
verification task — the same 4-task vertical-slice shape, repeated. v0.3
shipped 50 tasks / 6 phases at full autonomy and closed clean; v0.5's 36 is
smaller. The MsgServer promotion is the standard pre-mainnet Cosmos-SDK step
(every ibc-go/Osmosis/Celestia/dYdX module follows it). The simtest grade (D-054
— in-memory `sdk.Context` + dbm, no real IBC/MPC/hardware) is genuinely
achievable, not a half-finished mainnet. No axis-1 risk reaches escalation.
The one feasibility risk is **cosmos-sdk v0.50.x build under go 1.22**: the
transitive tree is large and may pull a module requiring go 1.23+. G-018
makes this a hard P1 gate. Confidence holds.
### Axis 2 — Scope (8 modules, outer→inner chain) — **PASS** (confidence 0.78)
D-056's phase ordering (P1 exit+bridge → P2 bearers → P3 anchors → P4 hub → P5
services → P6 bond → P7 council → P8 final) follows the dependency graph
correctly: exit needs nothing internal; bearers route through exit; anchors
ride bearers; hub custody backs anchors; services sit on hub; bond uses hub
lending; council is cross-cutting. The P3→P4 hub dep is broken by the
`expected_keepers.go` shim (the hub keeper INTERFACE exists in P3, impl wired
in P4 — ibc-go convention, A-532). The out-of-scope list is explicit (no
mainnet, no real IBC, no real MPC, no real bearer hardware, no real
institutional onboarding — D-054). Scope is not over-scoped for a runtime-
promotion milestone.
The one scope concern: **P7 adds 3 new enums + 1 struct to `x/council/types`**
(ProposalKind, ProposalStatus, VoteOption, Proposal). This is `feat:`-class
new-type work (correctly deferred from v0.4 by D-050/D-001). The feature
purity gate ("no breaking schema changes") must distinguish "adding new
types" (allowed) from "amending existing types/consts" (forbidden). The
`TallyResult.NoWithVeto` field is the gray area: the FIELD exists in v0.2 (zero-
locked), v0.5 POPULATES it. Is populating an existing field a "breaking schema
change"? No — the struct shape is unchanged; the SEMANTIC invariant
("NoWithVeto always 0") changes. **G-017** forces the plan to reconcile the
v0.2 regression test explicitly. Confidence holds after the fix.
### Axis 3 — Cost / Effort (36 tasks, cosmos-sdk onboarding) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.72)
36 tasks is proportionate to the deliverable (8 module promotions). The hidden
cost is the **cosmos-sdk onboarding** in P1-01-01: `go mod tidy` will pull a
large transitive tree, and the FIRST `go build ./...` with cosmos-sdk will
surface any go-version / module-replace / cometbft-separation issues. This is
a one-time cost concentrated in P1. If P1-01-01 takes more than 1 task's worth
of effort (likely — cosmos-sdk dep resolution is notoriously finicky), the
plan's single P1-01-01 task underestimates it. **Not blocking** (the task is
scoped correctly; the risk is effort, not feasibility), but P1 may absorb
spillover. No binding change — record the risk.
The other cost driver is **simtest coverage ≥80% on 8 keeper packages**. v0.3
hit ≥95.9% on type packages (trivial structs). Keeper packages with MsgServer
handlers + state machines + replay/timeout logic have higher cyclomatic
complexity; 80% is achievable but requires table-driven handler tests per
`Msg*` (the plan specifies this). Not a cost cliff.
### Axis 4 — Architecture (expected_keepers, G-003 survival, IBC contract) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.75)
The G-003 by-ID-string rule survives the runtime promotion via
`expected_keepers.go` interface shims (ibc-go convention) — verified: the
existing G-003 import-invariant test in `x/window/types/types_test.go` scans
non-test `x/**/*.go` and will auto-cover the new `keeper/` + `msg_*.go` +
`expected_keepers.go` files. The shims are INTERFACES defined in the consuming
module's `types/` (e.g., `x/exit/types/expected_keepers.go` defines
`BridgeKeeper`); the concrete keeper satisfies it structurally. This is NOT a
struct import — G-003 intent (no cross-module struct coupling, no import
cycles) is preserved. Correct.
Two architecture concerns:
1. **The G-003 import-invariant test scans `x/**/*.go`** — but `expected_keepers
.go` defines an interface that REFERENCES another module's types by NAME in
comments (not imports). The test uses `go/parser` ImportsOnly, so interface
method signatures that mention `x/bridge` types by STRING (e.g., return
`(status, bridgeType, err)`) are fine; but if an implementer writes a
method returning `x/bridge.BridgeRoute` (a struct import) to satisfy the
shim, the test catches it. Good — the test is the firewall. No binding
change, but P8-01-01 (REVIEW) must explicitly probe this.
2. **IBC `OnRecvPacket` / `OnAcknowledgementPacket` / `OnTimeoutPacket`
contract**: the plan pins the ICS-20 v1 payload shape (v0.2 satellite) and
timestamp-only timeouts for EVM chains (ibc-go v8 supports this). The Solana
wormhole-adapter branch verifies a 2-of-N guardian sig set from state. The
replay protection (delete-on-ack, refund-on-timeout) mirrors ibc-go (A-513,
the CVE-class pitfall). This is the highest-risk architecture surface in
v0.5. The simtest (P1-06-01) MUST cover both replay and timeout-refund
explicitly — the plan says it does. **Binding fix G-021**: P1-06-01 simtest
MUST include a NEGATIVE assertion that a SECOND `OnAcknowledgementPacket`
with the same packet commitment is REJECTED (not silently no-op'd) — the
distinction between "no-op" and "reject" matters for relayer error handling.
Confidence holds after the fix.
### Axis 5 — Risk (top 3 assumptions, pre-mortem) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.72)
**Top 3 assumptions the plan rests on:**
1. **A-504** (cosmos-sdk v0.50.x builds under go 1.22) — confidence 0.78. The
dep tree is large; a single transitive module requiring go 1.23+ blocks P1.
G-018 makes this a hard gate. Evidence: RESEARCH §3.1 confirms go 1.22
compatibility for v0.50.x, but does not enumerate the transitive tree.
2. **A-513** (IBC ack/timeout replay protection mirrors ibc-go) — confidence
0.90. This is the highest-severity runtime invariant (CVE-class pitfall).
The simtest covers it; G-021 strengthens the assertion. Evidence: RESEARCH
§2.1, P1-06-01.
3. **A-521** (OY-QR one-shot: `consumed` flipped BEFORE transfer effect) —
confidence 0.88. The atomicity argument (SDK store is atomic per tx; a panic
rolls back the whole tx) is sound. Evidence: RESEARCH §2.2, P2-02-01.
**Pre-mortem (12 months from now, v0.5 failed — why?):**
- Most likely: **P1 cosmos-sdk dep resolution spirals** — `go mod tidy` pulls a
module requiring go 1.23+, or a cometbft/tendermint replace directive conflict
blocks `go build`. P1 stalls, the milestone slips. Mitigation: G-018 hard
gate + escalation to a go version bump (out of scope, but visible).
- Second: **the NoWithVeto regression test (G-017) is discovered at P7, not P0**
— the P7 implementer finds `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` fails, does
not know whether to delete it (breaking a v0.2 locked-invariant test) or
keep it (blocking Veto population). The plan did not flag this. Mitigation:
G-017 forces the reconciliation NOW, with a binding fix that specifies
exactly how the test evolves (rename + re-scope, not delete).
- Third: **the CLOB per-match clamp's "implied coupon" is ambiguous** (G-019) —
two implementers compute it differently, the reject threshold is
inconsistent, and the simtest passes with one formula while mainnet would
use another. Mitigation: G-019 forces a single `ImpliedCoupon` helper.
### Axis 6 — Dependency graph (P3→P4 shim, outer→inner chain) — **PASS** (confidence 0.80)
The cross-phase dependency map (PLANS.md) is complete and correct:
- P1-01-01 (cosmos-sdk dep) blocks ALL runtime work (no `Msg*` compiles without
it). D-062 GRILL ratification is the gate.
- P1-03-01 (x/bridge keeper) blocks P1-05-01 (x/exit keeper — BridgeKeeper shim
wired to real bridge keeper in simtest).
- P3-01-01 (x/partner expected-keepers incl. HubKeeper shim) breaks the P3→P4
hub dep. P4-04-01 wires the real hub keeper to the PartnerKeeper shim.
- P4-99-01 blocks P5-01-01 (services sit on hub) AND P6-01-01 (bond uses hub
lending). P5 and P6 could parallelize but config `parallelization.enabled:
false` — serial. Correct.
- P6-99-01 blocks P7-01-01 (council cross-cutting, lands last).
No hidden edges. The v0.1 baseline keepers (mirror/forge/still/watcher/bread)
have EMPTY `keeper/` dirs — v0.5 does NOT promote them (out of scope). The
expected-keeper shims reference the baseline keepers by INTERFACE (e.g.,
`BreadKeeper.MintWrappedBread`), but the baseline keepers are empty stubs —
the shims will be wired to STUB implementations in simtest (G-003 test
exemption), not real keepers. This is correct for simtest grade (D-054) but
**the plan does not explicitly state that the v0.1 baseline keepers remain
empty stubs**. **Binding fix G-022**: P1-06-01 (and each simtest wiring a
baseline keeper shim) MUST document that the baseline keeper is a STUB
returning sentinels, not a real implementation — so a future agent does not
mistakenly promote a v0.1 baseline keeper in v0.5. Confidence holds.
### Axis 7 — Risk surface (CustodyKeyring, CLOB, IBC, Mission-Lock) — **PASS** (confidence 0.78)
The four security-critical surfaces (PERSONAS.md security-engineer):
1. **CustodyKeyring** (D-058): interface + in-memory `memKeyring`. Key rotation
via `Status` reporting active key version; no cross-block caching. Simtest
covers rotation. The interface boundary keeps v0.5 dep-neutral w.r.t.
custody vendors. Sound.
2. **CLOB per-match clamp** (D-057/D-063): REJECT above 800 (G-019 implies-
coupon helper). The 8%/0% consts referenced directly (A-563, verified: the
v0.3 `Clamp` uses the consts). REQ-030 cross-const test stays green.
3. **IBC replay/timeout** (A-513): delete-on-ack, refund-on-timeout. G-021
strengthens the replay assertion. Sound.
4. **Mission-Lock const firewall** (D-064): `ValidateBasic` rejects
`MissionLockAmendment-Rejected` kind; the const + the gate are the dual
firewall. v0.2 `TestMissionLockAmendableFalse` stays green (verified: the
const is unchanged; P7 does NOT touch `MissionLockAmendable`). Sound.
The risk surface is well-identified and the mitigations are concrete. The one
gap is the NoWithVeto contradiction (G-017) — the v0.2 regression test
`TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` is a "locked-invariant test" that v0.5
must reconcile, not silently break. This is the single most material risk the
plan misses.
### Axis 8 — Persona coverage (backend + lead + security + cosmos + mesh + data) — **PASS** (confidence 0.80)
The roster is coherent:
- **backend-engineer** spans all P1..P7 handler + simtest work (the bulk).
- **lead-developer** owns P0 + P8 + coordination + GRILL-ratification follow-
through.
- **security-engineer** (REACTIVATED) owns CustodyKeyring, CLOB clamp, IBC
replay, Mission-Lock firewall — the four security-critical surfaces. Correct
reactivation; v0.5 has higher invariant density than v0.3.
- **cosmos-engineer** (REACTIVATED) owns MsgServer/expected-keepers/simtest
scaffolding — correct, since cosmos-sdk is now load-bearing (D-055).
- **mesh-engineer** (REACTIVATED, P2 phase-specific) owns bearer session
lifecycle. Correct scoping (P2 only; removed after).
- **data-engineer** (REACTIVATED, P4 phase-specific) owns hub custody state
(in-memory test store). Correct scoping (P4 only; removed after).
- **ci-security-auditor** activated in P8 for the feature purity gate.
Territory globs are non-overlapping (backend-engineer's `x/{exit,bridge,...}
/**` vs cosmos-engineer's `keeper/**`, `types/msg_*.go`, `expected_keepers.go`,
`module.go`). The overlap risk is `keeper/msg_server.go` — both backend and
cosmos could claim it. The plan assigns cosmos-engineer to `keeper/**` and
backend-engineer to `x/<module>/**` (which includes keeper/). This is a glob
overlap. **Binding fix G-023**: clarify in PERSONAS.md that for v0.5,
cosmos-engineer owns the Cosmos-convention scaffolding (`keeper/keeper.go`,
`keeper/msg_server.go` skeleton, `module.go`, `types/msg_*.go`,
`types/expected_keepers.go`); backend-engineer owns the handler LOGIC (the
business rules inside `msg_server.go` methods, the simtest). This mirrors the
v0.2 G-007 split. Warn-mode (config), non-blocking, but ambiguous. Confidence
holds.
### Axis 9 — Verification coverage (simtest, locked-const, feature purity gate) — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.73)
Each phase has a verification task (P1-99-01..P7-99-01) running `go build ./...
+ go test ./...` + coverage ≥80% + lexicon + G-003. The P8 audit (P8-02-01)
runs the feature purity gate: no breaking schema changes, locked-const
firewall intact, G-003 intact, G-006 GRILL-ratified. This is concrete.
Two verification gaps:
1. **The feature purity gate does not define "breaking schema change" precisely
enough for the NoWithVeto case.** Populating an existing zero-locked field is
a SEMANTIC change to a v0.2 locked-invariant test, but NOT a struct-shape
change. The gate as written ("v0.3 `types/` contracts NOT amended") would
pass (the struct is not amended), but `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero`
would FAIL. The gate must be extended to "no v0.1..v0.4 locked-invariant
TEST is broken without an explicit, documented reconciliation". **G-017**
forces this reconciliation. The P8 audit (P8-02-01) must explicitly verify
that the v0.2 `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` is either (a) renamed and
re-scoped to "default is 0, but Watcher Vetos populate it" with a new test,
or (b) explicitly deleted with a replacement test asserting the quorum-based
Veto semantics. **Binding fix G-017** specifies (a).
2. **The v0.1 baseline keeper stubs are not verified to remain empty.** The
feature purity gate should assert that v0.5 does NOT promote the 5 v0.1
baseline keepers (mirror/forge/still/watcher/bread). **G-022** records this.
3. **The `types/` stdlib-only property is not verified.** v0.5 breaks it (by
design — `Msg*` needs `sdk.Msg`), but the invariant/lexicon TESTS in `types/`
must stay stdlib-only. **Binding fix G-024**: P1-99-01 MUST add a CI
assertion (or a test) that `go test ./x/<module>/types/...` passes WITHOUT
importing cosmos-sdk in the test files (i.e., the invariant/lexicon tests
remain stdlib-only; only `msg_*.go` imports `sdk.Msg`). This protects the
v0.1-v0.4 invariant-test durability.
Confidence holds after G-017, G-022, G-024.
---
## 3. Feature Purity Gate Verification
v0.5 is a **feature** milestone (not NFR). The gate (P8-02-01) verifies:
- **At least one `feat:` phase exists**: YES — all P1..P7 are `feat` (confirmed:
each phase's task table header says `Type: feat`). P8 is `final`. ✅
- **No breaking schema changes (locked-consts unchanged)**:
- `CouponCapBps=800` / `CouponFloorBps=0` (D-028) — unchanged (verified;
P6 references directly, A-563). ✅
- `SignalKindCount=4` — unchanged (P1-2 defensible; P7 does NOT change it;
`TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` stays green). ✅
- `MissionLockAmendable=false` — unchanged (P7 does NOT touch the const;
`TestMissionLockAmendableFalse` stays green). ✅
- `BearerTypeCount=6`, `PartnerTierCount=4`, `HubServiceCount=3`,
`BridgeStatusCount=4`, `ExitStatusCount=5`, `ServiceKindCount=4`,
`CouncilKindCount=3`, `OrderSideCount=2`, `OrderStatusCount=3` — all
unchanged (each phase's Must-Haves assert regression). ✅
- **`LendingCouponCapBps=800` / `LendingCouponFloorBps=0`** — unchanged
(P4 references directly; REQ-030 cross-const test stays green). ✅
- **New locked-consts added in P7** (per D-060): `ProposalKindCount=4`,
`ProposalStatusCount=5`, `VoteOptionCount=4`. These are ADDITIVE (new
types), not amendments to existing consts. Allowed under the feature
purity gate. ✅
- **`TallyResult.NoWithVeto` field**: the FIELD is unchanged (v0.2 shape); the
SEMANTIC invariant ("always 0") changes. The v0.2 regression test
`TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` MUST be reconciled (G-017). This is
the gray area the gate must explicitly address. **CONDITIONAL → fixed by
G-017**.
- **G-003 production firewall intact**: expected_keepers.go are INTERFACES (not
struct imports); the existing G-003 import-invariant test auto-covers new
files. P8-01-01 probes this. ✅ (with G-021 strengthening the IBC replay
assertion).
- **G-006 controlled exception genuinely scoped**: cosmos-sdk + ibc-go in
`go.mod` (D-055/D-062), scoped to runtime phases P1..P7; P0 + P8 dep-neutral;
`types/` gain `sdk.Msg` in `msg_*.go` only; invariant/lexicon tests stay
stdlib-only (G-024). ✅ (with G-018 build gate + G-024 stdlib-test assertion).
**Feature purity gate verdict: PASS WITH FIXES** (G-017, G-018, G-021, G-022,
G-024). The gate is enforceable after the fixes land.
---
## 4. Binding Grill Fixes (G-017..G-024)
These are **binding** — the orchestrator MUST apply them before the affected
phase ships. Numbered G-017..G-024 (continuing from the v0.4 grill G-016).
| ID | Binding Fix | Rationale | Confidence | Affects (phase / task) |
|----|-------------|-----------|------------|------------------------|
| **G-017** | **Reconcile the v0.2 `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` regression test with the v0.5 Veto population.** The v0.2 test (`x/council/types/types_test.go:233-239`) asserts `NoWithVeto == 0` "always" (anti-greed). v0.5 P7 (D-060) populates `NoWithVeto` with Watcher Vetos (quorum-based, D-065). The plan does NOT flag this contradiction. **Binding fix**: P7-03-01 MUST (a) RENAME `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` to `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoDefaultZero` (asserting the DEFAULT `TallyResult` has `NoWithVeto==0`, i.e., a proposal with zero Vetos has zero NoWithVeto — still true), and (b) ADD `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoPopulatedByQuorum` asserting that Watcher Vetos populate `NoWithVeto` and the proposal fails only at `NoWithVeto >= WatcherVetoQuorum` (default 6). The v0.2 anti-greed invariant ("no SINGLE-veto block") is preserved by the quorum rule; the "always 0" wording was v0.2's way of saying "no Veto option existed yet". The P8 feature purity gate (P8-02-01) MUST explicitly verify this reconciliation (the v0.2 test is not silently deleted; it is renamed + re-scoped). | The v0.2 test is a locked-invariant regression firewall. Silently breaking it at P7 violates the feature purity gate ("no breaking schema changes" extended to "no locked-invariant TEST broken without reconciliation"). The contradiction is real (verified: `types_test.go:233` asserts always 0; RESEARCH §2.7 / ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 say NoWithVeto is populated). The fix preserves the anti-greed invariant (default 0; quorum-based population) while documenting the v0.2→v0.5 evolution. | 0.88 | **P7-03-01** (simtest + types_test.go extend); **P8-02-01** (feature purity gate must verify the reconciliation). Must land before P7 ships. |
| **G-018** | **P1-01-01 cosmos-sdk dep is a HARD build gate under go 1.22.** `go mod tidy` + `go build ./...` MUST succeed under `go 1.22` (the `go.mod` declared version). If the cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x transitive tree requires go 1.23+, P1 does NOT ship — escalate (a go version bump is out of scope for v0.5). P1-01-01 verification MUST assert `go version` reports 1.22+ and `go build ./...` exits 0 with no module-replace hacks for go-version conflicts. If a `replace` directive is needed for cometbft/tendermint separation, it MUST be documented in P1-01-01's deliverable. | cosmos-sdk v0.50.x is documented as go 1.22-compatible, but the transitive tree is large (hundreds of modules). A single transitive module requiring go 1.23+ blocks P1 and cascades to all P2..P7. The plan's P1-01-01 verification says "go version compatible" — this makes it a HARD gate, not advisory. | 0.82 | **P1-01-01** (go.mod + go.sum). Must land before P1 ships. |
| **G-019** | **P6-02-01 (`x/bond/keeper/clob.go`) MUST define a single `ImpliedCoupon(priceBps, principal) uint32` helper (or equivalent) used by BOTH the CLOB match and the per-match clamp check.** The "implied coupon" derivation from trade price (fraction of principal in bps) is not specified in the plan. If two implementers compute it differently, the D-063 REJECT threshold (above 800) is inconsistent. The helper MUST have a unit test covering the boundary: price implying exactly 800, 801, 799 bps (reject at 801, clamp at 800, pass at 799). | D-063 ratifies REJECT above 800, but the "implied coupon" formula is the unstated precondition. A latent ambiguity in the highest-severity locked-const clamp is a real defect. A single helper + boundary test closes it. | 0.80 | **P6-02-01** (clob.go). Must land before P6 ships. |
| **G-020** | **P7-01-01 MUST add a `Params.Validate()` (or `ValidateBasic` on the param) asserting `WatcherVetoQuorum` is in `[1, 9]` (recommended `[2, 9]` to forbid single-veto-block even if the param is mis-set).** The default 6 (D-065) is correct; the validation bounds are the missing piece. A param of 0 (any single Veto blocks) or 10 (veto impossible — more than 9 Watchers) would violate REQ-004 / anti-greed semantics. The v0.2 `Params` struct is empty (`types.go:148`); P7-01-01 adds the field + MUST add the validation. | D-065 ratifies the default 6 but does not bound the param. An unbounded param is a governance footgun: a future vote could set 0 (single-veto-block, violating anti-greed) or 10 (veto impossible). Validation bounds are the standard Cosmos-SDK `Params.Validate` pattern. | 0.78 | **P7-01-01** (Params + Validate). Must land before P7 ships. |
| **G-021** | **P1-06-01 (`x/bridge` simtest) MUST include a NEGATIVE assertion that a SECOND `OnAcknowledgementPacket` with the same packet commitment is REJECTED (returns an error), not silently no-op'd.** The distinction between "no-op" and "reject" matters: ibc-go returns an error on a duplicate ack (the relayer sees the failure and does not retry); a silent no-op could mask a relayer bug. The simtest MUST assert the second ack returns a non-nil error. | A-513 mandates replay protection (delete-on-ack, reject-on-second). The plan says "reject on second" but the simtest verification says "deletes the in-flight record on first ack and rejects the second" — the "reject" must be an ERROR, not a silent no-op. A silent no-op is the CVE-class pitfall (the relayer cannot distinguish a bug from idempotency). | 0.80 | **P1-06-01** (bridge simtest). Must land before P1 ships. |
| **G-022** | **Each simtest wiring a v0.1 baseline keeper shim (BreadKeeper, WatcherKeeper, WindowKeeper, VaultKeeper, StandKeeper) MUST document that the baseline keeper is a STUB returning sentinels, NOT a real implementation.** v0.5 promotes 8 v0.3 modules; the 5 v0.1 baseline keepers (mirror/forge/still/watcher/bread) remain EMPTY stubs (verified: their `keeper/` dirs are empty). The expected-keeper shims reference baseline keepers by interface; in simtest they are wired to STUB impls (G-003 test exemption). The P8 feature purity gate MUST assert the 5 v0.1 baseline keepers are NOT promoted in v0.5 (no new `.go` files in their `keeper/` dirs). | The plan does not explicitly state the baseline keepers remain stubs. A future agent might "helpfully" promote a baseline keeper while wiring a shim, breaking the v0.5 scope boundary (D-056 scopes P1..P7 to the 8 v0.3 modules). Documenting the stub expectation + a P8 gate assertion prevents scope creep. | 0.75 | **P1-06-01, P2-03-01, P3-03-01, P5-03-01, P6-03-01, P7-03-01** (all simtests wiring baseline keeper shims); **P8-02-01** (feature purity gate asserts baseline keepers unchanged). Must land before each simtest phase ships; P8 gate before milestone ship. |
| **G-023** | **Clarify `keeper/msg_server.go` ownership between backend-engineer and cosmos-engineer in PERSONAS.md.** Both personas' territory globs overlap on `keeper/**` (cosmos-engineer's explicit list) and `x/<module>/**` (backend-engineer's glob, which includes `keeper/`). **Binding fix**: for v0.5, cosmos-engineer owns the Cosmos-convention SCAFFOLDING (`keeper/keeper.go` skeleton, `keeper/msg_server.go` method signatures, `module.go`, `types/msg_*.go`, `types/expected_keepers.go`); backend-engineer owns the handler LOGIC (the business rules inside `msg_server.go` method bodies, the simtest). This mirrors the v0.2 G-007 split (Cosmos-mirroring vs bespoke modules). Warn-mode (config), non-blocking, but ambiguous. | Territory enforcement is `warn` (non-blocking), but ambiguous ownership on the highest-effort files (`msg_server.go` method bodies) risks edit conflicts. The split mirrors v0.2 G-007 and aligns with the actual task assignments (cosmos-engineer scaffolds, backend-engineer implements logic). | 0.72 | **PERSONAS.md** (v0.5 roster). Apply before P1 begins. |
| **G-024** | **P1-99-01 MUST add a CI assertion (or a test) that the invariant/lexicon tests in `x/<module>/types/` pass WITHOUT importing cosmos-sdk.** v0.5 breaks the v0.1-v0.4 `types/`-is-stdlib-only property by adding `sdk.Msg` to `types/msg_*.go` (D-055). The invariant tests (locked-const counts, enum round-trips) and lexicon assertions in `types/*_test.go` MUST remain stdlib-only — they should not import `sdk.Msg` or `sdk.Context`. The assertion: `grep -L "cosmos-sdk\|sdk.Msg\|sdk.Context" x/<module>/types/*_test.go` (or a `go/parser` scan) confirms the invariant/lexicon test files do not import cosmos-sdk. | The v0.1-v0.4 invariant tests are durable because they compile with stdlib only. If v0.5 silently lets an invariant test import `sdk.Msg`, the test breaks if cosmos-sdk is removed (e.g., a future skeleton revert). Keeping invariant/lexicon tests stdlib-only preserves their durability across dep changes. The `msg_*.go` isolation (RESEARCH §3.1) is the intent; G-024 makes it a tested invariant. | 0.78 | **P1-99-01** (and each phase's 99-01 verification). Must land before P1 ships; carries through P2..P7. |
---
## 5. Escalations
**None.** All nine axes resolved at confidence ≥ 0.60 after the binding fixes
G-017..G-024 are applied. No axis required escalation to the human. At full
autonomy, the orchestrator applies the binding decisions and proceeds to P1.
The single most material finding is **G-017** (the NoWithVeto regression-test
contradiction): the v0.2 `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero` test and the v0.5
P7 Veto-population design are in direct conflict. This is not an escalation
(the fix is mechanical: rename + re-scope the test, add a quorum-population
test), but it is the finding most likely to cause a P7 stall if not surfaced
now. The grill surfaces it; the orchestrator applies G-017 before P7.
---
## 6. Overall Verdict
### **SHIP Phase 0 WITH FIXES** (confidence 0.78)
The v0.5 Phase 0 plan is fundamentally sound and well-grounded: the runtime-
promotion pattern (MsgServer + simtest, not mainnet — D-054) is the standard
Cosmos-SDK pre-mainnet step; the 8-module scope is proportionate (36 tasks /
8 phases); the outer→inner dependency chain (D-056) is correct; the
`expected_keepers.go` shim convention preserves G-003; the locked-const
firewall is intact (all v0.1..v0.4 consts unchanged; new P7 enums are
additive). The plan's architecture claims were verified against the actual
codebase (zero cosmos-sdk imports today; locked consts present; G-003 test
green; ClampGrowth has the G-012 guard; cross-const test has the G-015 absolute
assertion).
The 5 decision ratifications (D-055, D-062, D-063, D-064, D-065) are all
**RATIFIED**: the cosmos-sdk dep is necessary and scoped (D-055); the v0.50.x
+ ibc-go v8.x pin is the stable choice (D-062); REJECT above 800 is the
mission-lock-true choice (D-063); `ValidateBasic` rejection is the cleanest
Mission-Lock firewall (D-064); Veto quorum 6 as a param (not a const) is the
governance-tunable choice (D-065).
The 8 binding fixes (G-017..G-024) are **correctness and verification
hardening**, not scope rework:
- **G-017** (NoWithVeto reconciliation) — the single real contradiction; a
v0.2 regression test that v0.5 must reconcile, not silently break. Must
land before P7 ships.
- **G-018** (go 1.22 build gate) — the cosmos-sdk dep's transitive tree is
the highest feasibility risk; a hard gate prevents a P1 stall from
cascading. Must land before P1 ships.
- **G-019** (ImpliedCoupon helper) — the CLOB per-match clamp's unstated
formula; a single helper + boundary test closes the ambiguity. Must land
before P6 ships.
- **G-020** (WatcherVetoQuorum validation bounds) — the param is unbounded
in the plan; validation bounds prevent a governance footgun. Must land
before P7 ships.
- **G-021** (IBC replay reject-not-noop) — the CVE-class pitfall's simtest
assertion must require an ERROR, not a silent no-op. Must land before P1
ships.
- **G-022** (baseline keeper stub documentation + P8 gate) — the 5 v0.1
baseline keepers must remain stubs; document + gate. Must land before each
simtest phase; P8 gate before milestone ship.
- **G-023** (msg_server.go ownership split) — backend vs cosmos territory
overlap on the highest-effort files; clarify before P1. Apply before P1.
- **G-024** (types/ invariant-test stdlib-only assertion) — the v0.1-v0.4
invariant-test durability must survive the cosmos-sdk onboarding; a CI
assertion protects it. Must land before P1 ships; carries through P2..P7.
None of these rise to "RETHINK" or "REDUCE SCOPE" — the architecture, scope,
ordering, and persona assignments are correct. Apply the 8 binding fixes and
proceed to Phase P1.
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.78**
---
## 7. Summary Block
```
Decision ratifications:
D-055 (cosmos-sdk + ibc-go dep, G-006 exception) — RATIFY (0.82)
D-062 (cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x pin) — RATIFY (0.80)
D-063 (bond match above 800 = REJECT) — RATIFY (0.78)
D-064 (MissionLockAmendment reject at ValidateBasic) — RATIFY (0.85)
D-065 (Watcher Veto quorum default 6) — RATIFY (0.78)
Nine-axis scorecard:
1. Feasibility — PASS (0.80)
2. Scope — PASS (0.78)
3. Cost/Effort — CONDITIONAL (0.72) [cosmos-sdk onboarding risk]
4. Architecture — CONDITIONAL (0.75) → strengthened by G-021
5. Risk — CONDITIONAL (0.72) → fixed by G-017, G-019
6. Dependency graph — PASS (0.80) → strengthened by G-022
7. Risk surface — PASS (0.78)
8. Persona coverage — PASS (0.80) → strengthened by G-023
9. Verification — CONDITIONAL (0.73) → fixed by G-017, G-022, G-024
Feature purity gate: PASS WITH FIXES (G-017, G-018, G-021, G-022, G-024)
Binding fixes: 8 (G-017..G-024)
G-017 — NoWithVeto regression-test reconciliation — before P7
G-018 — cosmos-sdk go 1.22 hard build gate — before P1
G-019 — CLOB ImpliedCoupon helper + boundary test — before P6
G-020 — WatcherVetoQuorum Params.Validate bounds — before P7
G-021 — IBC replay reject-not-noop simtest assertion — before P1
G-022 — v0.1 baseline keeper stub documentation + P8 gate — before each simtest / P8
G-023 — keeper/msg_server.go ownership split — before P1
G-024 — types/ invariant-test stdlib-only CI assertion — before P1
Escalations: 0
Overall: SHIP Phase 0 WITH FIXES (confidence 0.78)
```
---
## 8. CI Commit Block (for the orchestrator; DO NOT auto-commit per task constraints)
```
docs(grill): v0.5 adversarial review — 5 decisions ratified, 8 binding fixes (G-017..G-024)
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.5
status: grill
decisions:
- id: D-055
decision: RATIFY — cosmos-sdk + ibc-go dep as G-006 controlled exception (scoped to runtime P1..P7)
rationale: go.mod zero-dep today (verified); MsgServer promotion impossible without cosmos-sdk; exception scoped (types/ Msg* isolated, invariant/lexicon tests stdlib-only per G-024)
confidence: 0.82
alternatives: [stay zero-dep hand-rolling store+messages (duplicates SDK, high risk); defer all runtime to v0.6+ (stalls)]
- id: D-062
decision: RATIFY — cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x version pin
rationale: v0.50.x LTS go 1.22-compatible; ibc-go v8.x stable pairing; v10 IBC-v2 deferred (newer, churn risk); G-018 hard go 1.22 build gate
confidence: 0.80
alternatives: [cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v10 (newer); cosmos-sdk v0.47.x + ibc-go v7.x (older LTS)]
- id: D-063
decision: RATIFY — bond CLOB match above 800 bps = REJECT (fails closed)
rationale: 8% cap is Mission-Lock invariant (D-028); match above cap is usury violation, not clampable excess; REJECT simpler (no refund path); G-019 ImpliedCoupon helper closes formula ambiguity
confidence: 0.78
alternatives: [clamp-with-refund (adds refund path, softens mission-lock)]
- id: D-064
decision: RATIFY — MissionLockAmendment-Rejected ProposalKind rejected at ValidateBasic
rationale: const MissionLockAmendable=false (v0.2, verified) is firewall; ValidateBasic is gate; message never reaches handler; no dead state; v0.2 TestMissionLockAmendableFalse stays green
confidence: 0.85
alternatives: [propose-then-fail (records Pending→Failed, dead state growth)]
- id: D-065
decision: RATIFY — Watcher Veto quorum default = 6 (param, not locked const)
rationale: matches REQ-004 6-of-9; single Veto does NOT block (anti-greed); param-tunable (not Mission-Lock const); G-020 adds Validate bounds [2,9]
confidence: 0.78
alternatives: [lock as const 6 (over-rigid); default 9 (veto impossible)]
fixes:
- id: G-017
fix: Reconcile v0.2 TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero with v0.5 Veto population — rename to TestTallyResultNoWithVetoDefaultZero + add TestTallyResultNoWithVetoPopulatedByQuorum
affects: P7-03-01, P8-02-01
before_phase: P7
confidence: 0.88
- id: G-018
fix: P1-01-01 cosmos-sdk dep is HARD go 1.22 build gate (escalate if transitive tree requires go 1.23+)
affects: P1-01-01
before_phase: P1
confidence: 0.82
- id: G-019
fix: P6-02-01 clob.go MUST define single ImpliedCoupon helper + boundary unit test (800/801/799 bps)
affects: P6-02-01
before_phase: P6
confidence: 0.80
- id: G-020
fix: P7-01-01 MUST add Params.Validate asserting WatcherVetoQuorum in [2,9]
affects: P7-01-01
before_phase: P7
confidence: 0.78
- id: G-021
fix: P1-06-01 bridge simtest MUST assert second OnAcknowledgementPacket returns ERROR (not silent no-op)
affects: P1-06-01
before_phase: P1
confidence: 0.80
- id: G-022
fix: Simtests wiring baseline keeper shims MUST document stub-not-real; P8 gate asserts 5 v0.1 baseline keepers unchanged
affects: P1-06-01, P2-03-01, P3-03-01, P5-03-01, P6-03-01, P7-03-01, P8-02-01
before_phase: P1 (simtests); P8 (gate)
confidence: 0.75
- id: G-023
fix: PERSONAS.md clarify keeper/msg_server.go ownership — cosmos-engineer scaffolds, backend-engineer implements logic
affects: PERSONAS.md
before_phase: P1
confidence: 0.72
- id: G-024
fix: P1-99-01 CI assertion — invariant/lexicon tests in x/<module>/types/ stay stdlib-only (no cosmos-sdk import)
affects: P1-99-01 (carries through P2..P7)
before_phase: P1
confidence: 0.78
escalations: []
---/ci---
```
+101 -94
View File
@@ -3,124 +3,131 @@ active_personas:
- id: backend-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: false
reason: Go/Cosmos module skeletons for v0.2 components — owns the non-Cosmos-mirroring modules (pact, partner, bond) per G-007. Owns the bulk of bespoke-type skeleton + tests work.
frameworks: [Go, Cosmos SDK, IBC, CosmWasm]
territory: ["x/pact/**", "x/partner/**", "x/bond/**", "x/**/types/**", "x/**/keeper/**", "x/**/module.go"]
constraints: [lexicon compliance (REQ-012), skeleton+tests pattern (D-020), ≥80% coverage on new packages (D-033), no live-chain side effects in skeleton, locked-const invariants, no fractional reserve, no leverage/futures, go.mod is read-only in v0.2 (G-006any change is an escalation)]
- id: data-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: false
reason: Genesis/state schema design for new modules — Window audit log, Stand membership sets, Bond issuance state, Council Voice tally state. Shapes ValidateGenesis upgrades. Owns genesis SCHEMA only (G-008); test assertions are security-engineer's.
frameworks: [Go, encoding/json, Cosmos SDK state]
territory: ["x/**/types/genesis.go", "x/**/genesis.go"]
constraints: [append-only audit logs (Window), ID-uniqueness in ValidateGenesis, lexicon compliance, no state identity beyond Reach, does NOT own *_test.go files (G-008)]
reason: Owns the v0.5 runtime promotion across P1..P7 — every keeper MsgServer message handler + simtest end-to-end flow for x/exit, x/bridge, x/bearers, x/partner, x/hub, x/services, x/bond, and x/council. This is the bulk of the milestone: the v0.3 skeletons were types + in-memory keeper stubs (verified — e.g. `x/partner/types/types.go:101 type Keeper struct{...}` with `NewKeeper()` returning `&Keeper{partners: make(map[string]Partner)}`, zero cosmos-sdk imports in `x/`). v0.5 adds `keeper/keeper.go` (store-backed), `keeper/msg_server.go` (one handler per `Msg*`), `types/msg_*.go` (`sdk.Msg` impls), `module.go` (RegisterServices), and a simtest exercising each handler against an in-memory `sdk.Context`. backend-engineer is the single persona that spans all seven runtime phases (P1..P7) plus the lexicon/locked-const regression guards that carry forward from v0.4. The reactivated cosmos-engineer/security-engineer/mesh-engineer personas advise on conventions and invariants but the implementation is backend-engineer's territory.
frameworks: [Go 1.22, cosmos-sdk v0.50.x (D-055 GRILL-approved), ibc-go v8.x, Go testing, simtest, lexicon firewall, locked-const invariant tests]
territory: ["x/exit/**", "x/bridge/**", "x/bearers/**", "x/partner/**", "x/hub/**", "x/services/**", "x/bond/**", "x/council/**", "lexicon/**", "lexicon_meta_test.go", "lexicon_meta_docs/**"]
constraints: ["G-003 production firewall intact — keeper-to-keeper cross-module calls use expected_keepers.go interface shims (ibc-go convention), NOT struct imports of x/<module>/types; by-ID-string rule preserved at the type level", "G-006 controlled exception (D-055) — go.mod gains cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x (GRILL-ratified); types/ packages gain sdk.Msg imports for Msg* types but invariant/lexicon tests stay stdlib-only and green", "locked-const invariants unchanged — 8%/0% bond cap (D-028), 6 bearers, 4 Partner tiers, MissionLockAmendable=false, SignalKindCount=4 (P1-2 defensible), BearerTypeCount=6, BridgeStatusCount=4, ExitStatusCount=5, etc. — v0.5 ADDS ProposalKind/ProposalStatus/VoteOption enums (AUDIT §193 P1-1) but does NOT change existing locked consts", "lexicon firewall stays green on both x/ and docs/ after runtime promotion — Msg* struct names are the new lexicon surface (e.g. AVOID 'deposit' in x/hub custody message names; use MsgCustodyReceiveAsset/MsgCustodyReleaseAsset per A-542)", "simtest NOT mainnet (D-054) — handlers exercised against in-memory sdk.Context + dbm in-memory store; no real IBC light clients, no real MPC, no real bearer hardware, no real DEX venues, no real Watcher attestations (all stubbed)", "≥80% coverage on runtime packages (D-033 carries forward) — every keeper/msg_server.go + simtest must hit the bar; table-driven handler tests per Msg*", "Mission Lock const firewall intact (G-003)MissionLockAmendment-Rejected ProposalKind is rejected at ValidateBasic (A-572); the const + the ValidateBasic gate are the dual firewall"]
- id: lead-developer
active: true
phase_specific: false
reason: Multi-component orchestration across 10 new packages, dependency sequencing per D-031 blocker chain, vertical-slice integrity per phase.
frameworks: [cross-cutting]
territory: ["**"]
constraints: [blocked-by chain enforcement (D-031), milestone versioning (v0.2 / tag_base v0.1.x), lexicon gate on merge, persona territory warn-mode enforcement]
- id: cosmos-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: true
reason: v0.2 introduces IBC (satellite), governance (council), capability (window), group (stand/guild), oracle (forex) patterns that map directly to Cosmos SDK modules (x/gov, x/group, x/authz, x/feegrant, x/capability, x/ibc-transfer). Phase-specific to v0.2 execution phases where Cosmos-convention alignment matters for future wiring.
frameworks: [cosmos-sdk, ibc-go, CosmWasm, CometBFT]
territory: ["x/satellite/**", "x/council/**", "x/window/**", "x/stand/**", "x/guild/**", "x/forex/**", "x/bearers/**"]
constraints: [lexicon compliance (REQ-012), no live-chain side effects in skeleton, mirror x/gov TallyResult / x/group DecisionPolicy / x/authz Grant shapes for future wiring, zero external deps in v0.2 skeleton, by-ID-string inter-module references to avoid import cycles (G-003 tested invariant), go.mod is read-only in v0.2 (G-006)]
reason: Coordinates v0.5 phase decomposition (P1 exit+bridge → P2 bearers → P3 anchors → P4 hub → P5 services → P6 bond → P7 council → P8 final review/audit/ship per D-056), territory enforcement (warn mode per config.json), and the final-phase feature purity gate audit (no breaking schema changes; locked-const firewall intact; G-003 production firewall intact). Owns the v0.5 ROADMAP.md / REQUIREMENTS.md status updates at milestone completion and the milestone ship. Also owns the GRILL-ratification follow-through for the cosmos-sdk version pin (A-504) and the planner-escalation items (A-562 reject-vs-clamp, A-572 reject-at-ValidateBasic, A-574 Watcher Veto quorum value) — these are escalated through the normal decision flow, not auto-decided.
frameworks: [cross-cutting, Gitea Actions, Markdown, YAML, git]
territory: [".ciagent/**", ".gitea/workflows/**", ".ciagent/oy/ARCHITECTURE.md", ".ciagent/oy/ROADMAP.md", ".ciagent/oy/REQUIREMENTS.md"]
constraints: ["D-056 phase ordering (P1 exit → P2 bearers → P3 anchors → P4 hub → P5 services → P6 bond → P7 council → P8 final); each phase independently shippable (vertical slices)", "milestone versioning (v0.5 feature / tag_base v0.4.x); final-phase patch IS the milestone release (D-008)", "feature purity gate: zero breaking schema changes; zero locked-const amendments (Mission Lock non-amendable; SignalKind 4-not-5 unchanged); G-003 production firewall intact; G-006 controlled exception GRILL-ratified", "persona territory warn-mode enforcement (config.json)", "planner-escalation items (A-504 cosmos-sdk version pin, A-562 bond match reject-vs-clamp, A-572 MissionLockAmendment ValidateBasic rejection, A-574 Watcher Veto quorum) surfaced through the normal decision flow, not auto-decided"]
- id: security-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: false
reason: REACTIVATED for v0.5. Owns the security-critical invariant surfaces introduced by runtime promotion: (1) the CustodyKeyring interface boundary in x/hub (D-058) — the Sign/Derive/Status contract + the in-memory memKeyring test impl, with key-rotation semantics (Status reports active key version; no caching across blocks); (2) the CLOB mission-lock clamp in x/bond (D-057) — the per-match coupon clamp to [0, 800] bps via the v0.3 Clamp helper, with a match above 800 REJECTED (fails closed, A-562; planner confirms reject-vs-clamp before P6); (3) IBC packet replay protection in x/bridge — the delete-on-ack / refund-on-timeout contract mirroring ibc-go (the CVE-class pitfall); simtest must cover both replay and timeout-refund; (4) the governance Mission-Lock const firewall in x/council (G-003) — MissionLockAmendable=false unchanged, the MissionLockAmendment-Rejected ProposalKind rejected at ValidateBasic (A-572), and the Watcher Veto quorum semantics (single Veto does NOT block; quorum-based, default 6 per REQ-004 6-of-9; A-574). The v0.3/v0.4 locked-const regression tests (TestMissionLockAmendableFalse, TestSignalKindShapeIntentional, the REQ-030 cross-const test) stay green.
frameworks: [Go 1.22, cosmos-sdk v0.50.x, ibc-go v8.x, Go testing, simtest, locked-const invariant tests, lexicon firewall]
territory: ["x/hub/types/keyring.go", "x/hub/keeper/keyring_mem*.go", "x/bond/types/types.go", "x/bond/keeper/**", "x/bridge/keeper/**", "x/council/types/types.go", "x/council/keeper/**", "lexicon/**"]
constraints: ["CustodyKeyring interface supports key rotation (Status reports active key version; handler consults keyring per operation, no cross-block caching)", "CLOB per-match coupon clamp to [0, 800] bps (D-028/D-057); match above 800 REJECTED (fails closed, A-562) — planner confirms reject-vs-clamp before P6", "IBC ack/timeout replay protection mirrors ibc-go (delete-on-ack, refund-on-timeout); simtest MUST cover both replay and timeout-refund cases (CVE-class pitfall)", "Mission Lock const firewall intact (G-003): MissionLockAmendable=false unchanged; MissionLockAmendment-Rejected ProposalKind rejected at ValidateBasic (A-572); Watcher Veto quorum-based (default 6, REQ-004 6-of-9), single Veto does NOT block (anti-greed, vision §19)", "locked-const regression tests stay green: TestMissionLockAmendableFalse, TestSignalKindShapeIntentional, the REQ-030 cross-const test (hub.LendingCouponCapBps==bond.CouponCapBps)", "compliance-before-custody ordering enforced in x/hub (withdrawal checks compliance status before the custody debit, A-544)", "lexicon firewall stays green — Msg* names avoid banned terms (e.g. 'deposit' banned; use MsgCustodyReceiveAsset/MsgCustodyReleaseAsset)"]
- id: cosmos-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: false
reason: REACTIVATED for v0.5. cosmos-sdk is now a load-bearing dependency (D-055 GRILL-approved controlled exception to G-006), so Cosmos-SDK convention alignment is owned rather than advisory. Owns: (1) the MsgServer promotion pattern across all 8 target modules — keeper/keeper.go (store-backed, wraps sdk.KVStore), types/msg_*.go (sdk.Msg: ValidateBasic + GetSigners), keeper/msg_server.go (one *Response,error method per Msg*), module.go (AppModule + RegisterServices), simtest exercising each handler against an in-memory sdk.Context; (2) the IBC v2 / IBC Eureka patterns in x/bridge (OnRecvPacket/OnAcknowledgementPacket/OnTimeoutPacket, timestamp-only timeouts for EVM chains, the ICS-20 v1 payload parser); (3) the expected_keepers.go shim convention (ibc-go standard for breaking cross-module keeper dep cycles — e.g. x/exit/types/expected_keepers.go defines a BridgeKeeper interface that the x/bridge keeper satisfies structurally; preserves G-003 by-ID-string rule at the type level); (4) the simtest scaffolding (in-memory store, sdk.Context construction, event emission assertions). The v0.3 in-memory Keeper stubs (in types/types.go) are retired or wrapped as test helpers — the types/ public API is not broken.
frameworks: [Go 1.22, cosmos-sdk v0.50.x (D-055), ibc-go v8.x, cometbft (simtest in-memory store only), Go testing, simtest]
territory: ["x/exit/keeper/**", "x/exit/types/msg_*.go", "x/exit/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/exit/module.go", "x/bridge/keeper/**", "x/bridge/types/msg_*.go", "x/bridge/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/bridge/module.go", "x/bearers/keeper/**", "x/bearers/types/msg_*.go", "x/bearers/module.go", "x/partner/keeper/**", "x/partner/types/msg_*.go", "x/partner/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/partner/module.go", "x/hub/keeper/**", "x/hub/types/msg_*.go", "x/hub/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/hub/module.go", "x/services/keeper/**", "x/services/types/msg_*.go", "x/services/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/services/module.go", "x/bond/keeper/**", "x/bond/types/msg_*.go", "x/bond/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/bond/module.go", "x/council/keeper/**", "x/council/types/msg_*.go", "x/council/types/expected_keepers.go", "x/council/module.go"]
constraints: ["MsgServer convention (cosmos-sdk v0.40+ Stargate): MsgServer struct wraps the module Keeper; one method per Msg* returning (*Response, error); routed by base app MsgServiceRouter", "sdk.Msg contract: ValidateBasic (stateless gate, runs before handler), GetSigners (authz), ProtoMessage/JSONCodec registration", "handler state-machine ordering: (1) ValidateBasic (in msg), (2) keeper authz check, (3) state mutation under store, (4) ctx.EventManager().EmitEvent — reordering causes double-spend/replay", "expected_keepers.go convention: cross-module keeper deps are INTERFACES defined in the consuming module's types/ (e.g. x/exit/types/expected_keepers.go BridgeKeeper); the concrete keeper satisfies it structurally; NOT a struct import of x/bridge/types — G-003 preserved", "IBC handlers implement the ibc-go IBCModule / PacketExecutor contract (OnRecvPacket/OnAcknowledgementPacket/OnTimeoutPacket); ICS-20 v1 payload pinned to the v0.2 satellite packet shape", "simtest uses SDK in-memory store (dbm in-memory backend) + sdk.NewContext; no live CometBFT node, no real IBC light clients (D-054)", "version pin (A-504, planner/GRILL confirms): cosmos-sdk v0.50.x LTS + ibc-go v8.x (stable); ibc-go v10 IBC-v2/Eureka is the documented pattern but a newer pin"]
- id: mesh-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: true
reason: v0.2 enforces Mission Lock (council), fee/bond coupon clamps (clamp invariants), 9-stand / 4-tier / 6-pact locked-const tests, and Window revoke/expire lifecycle invariants. Phase-specific to v0.2 where invariant/locked-const test density is highest.
frameworks: [Go testing, table-driven tests, invariant tests]
territory: ["x/**/types/**_test.go", "x/**/keeper/**_test.go", "x/**/genesis_test.go", "x/**/*_test.go"]
constraints: [invariant tests for all locked constants (Mission Lock non-amendable, bond 8% cap / 0% floor, fee ceiling/floor), locked-const tests for every enum count (9 stands, 4 partner tiers, 6 pacts), lexicon assertion in every new test file (D-033), ≥80% coverage on new packages, owns ALL *_test.go files including genesis_test.go (G-008)]
reason: REACTIVATED for the bearer transport runtime in P2 (REQ-034). Owns the OY-SAT + OY-QR message handlers in x/bearers: MsgSendOYSATFrame, MsgReceiveOYSATFrame, MsgIssueOYQR, MsgConsumeOYQR, and the session lifecycle (Open/Active/Closed/Revoked). The v0.3 OYSATLink (surveillance-resistant=true locked) and OYQRCode (one-shot consumed flag) become the handler state objects. Key mesh-specific invariants: (1) OY-QR is one-shot — MsgConsumeOYQR flips consumed BEFORE the transfer effect (replay rejected idempotently, A-521); (2) the surveillance-resistant const is a runtime invariant — the handler must NOT emit geolocation or sender physical location (simtest asserts the event set has NO geolocation fields, a negative test); (3) the BearerTransport interface gains a store-backed impl (the keeper acts as the transport in simtest; no hardware/RF dep, D-054). Hardware integration is explicitly deferred. mesh-engineer is phase-specific (P2 only) — outside P2 the bearer transport territory reverts to backend-engineer.
frameworks: [Go 1.22, cosmos-sdk v0.50.x, Go testing, simtest, lexicon firewall]
territory: ["x/bearers/keeper/**", "x/bearers/types/msg_bearer*.go", "x/bearers/types/types.go", "x/bearers/module.go", "x/bearers/simtest/**"]
constraints: ["OY-QR one-shot: MsgConsumeOYQR flips consumed BEFORE the transfer effect (atomic per-tx; replay finds consumed==true and returns error idempotently, A-521)", "surveillance-resistant const is a runtime invariant — handler emits NO geolocation / sender physical location; simtest negative-test asserts the event set is geolocation-free", "BearerTransport interface gets a store-backed impl (keeper as transport in simtest); NO hardware/RF/LoRa/BLE/satellite Go libraries (D-054 — runtime = message-handling + session lifecycle, not hardware)", "session lifecycle mirrors the v0.2 Window lifecycle (Open/Active/Closed/Revoked) for consistency; frames received on Closed/Revoked sessions are rejected", "lexicon-safe: 'session', 'frame', 'bearer', 'QR', 'SAT' are safe; AVOID 'account'/'deposit' (use reach-id/Stash by ID)"]
phase_specific_personas:
- id: data-engineer
active: true
phase_specific: true
reason: REACTIVATED for P4 (Hub API runtime) ONLY — owns the hub custody state via an in-memory test store (the memKeyring + the keeper's store-backed custody asset records). The custody asset records are the closest thing to a data store in v0.5; there is NO real database and NO migration (the SDK in-memory store is the substrate). data-engineer's role is narrow: ensure the custody state shape (assetID → custody entry + sig ref + key version) is consistent with the CustodyKeyring interface and supports rotation. Removed after P4 (the hub runtime ships; later phases do not touch custody state shape). This mirrors the v0.3 data-engineer pattern (genesis schemas) but scoped to the P4 custody store.
frameworks: [Go 1.22, cosmos-sdk v0.50.x store, Go testing]
territory: ["x/hub/keeper/keyring_mem*.go", "x/hub/keeper/custody_state*.go"]
constraints: ["in-memory test store ONLY — no real database, no migration (D-054 simtest grade)", "custody state shape consistent with CustodyKeyring interface (assetID → custody entry + sig ref + key version); supports rotation", "removed after P4 (hub runtime ships; later phases do not touch custody state shape)"]
deactivated:
- id: frontend-engineer
reason: No UI in v0.2 (skeleton+tests only; Mesh Experience UI is v0.1-complete and v0.3+ for new UI). Deactivate to avoid persona territory noise. Reactivate in v0.3.
reason: INACTIVE for v0.5. The v0.3 docs site (docs/**, mkdocs.yml) is COMPLETE; v0.5 has no UI/docs-content work. The docs build CI (REQ-032, v0.4) already covers docs-build on every push. Reactivate in v0.6+ if docs content is restructured or i18n is added.
- id: docs-writer
reason: INACTIVE for v0.5. Same reason as frontend-engineer — v0.3's docs-writer owned page content authoring; v0.5 has zero new docs pages. The only documentation work is the ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 runtime section + this PERSONAS.md + RESEARCH.md, which is lead-developer/researcher architecture territory, not audience-content authoring. Reactivate if a future milestone adds docs pages.
- id: ci-security-auditor
reason: Default deactivated; activate in P5 (review/ship) phase for the milestone audit. Not needed during P1-P4 skeleton authoring.
- id: mesh-engineer
reason: v0.1 listed as future; still not needed in v0.2 (Bearers OY-LR + Beacon are type stubs only, no hardware/RF). Activate in v0.3 for real bearer runtime.
reason: Default deactivated; activate in P8 (final review/audit/ship) for the v0.5 milestone audit and feature purity gate enforcement (no breaking schema changes; locked-const firewall intact; G-003 production firewall intact; G-006 controlled exception GRILL-ratified).
custom_personas:
- id: cosmos-engineer
rationale: v0.2 components map onto specific Cosmos SDK modules (x/gov, x/group, x/authz, x/feegrant, x/capability, x/ibc-transfer). A dedicated persona ensures skeleton types mirror the eventual runtime shapes, reducing Phase 3 wiring refactor cost. Distinct from backend-engineer because it carries Cosmos-specific convention knowledge (tally shapes, decision policy, capability, ICS-20 packet shape).
- id: security-engineer
rationale: v0.2 has the highest locked-const + invariant density in the project (Mission Lock, bond cap, 6 Pact types, 9 Stand types, 4 Partner tiers, Window revoke idempotency). A dedicated persona ensures invariant tests and lexicon assertions are not an afterthought. Distinct from backend-engineer because it owns test-file territory and invariant-first design.
custom_personas: []
---
# Personas: OpenYield (oy) — v0.2 (The Mesh)
# Personas: OpenYield (oy) — v0.5 (Bearers Runtime — Feature)
> This file supersedes the v0.4 PERSONAS.md for the v0.5 milestone. v0.5 is a
> **feature** milestone (D-054): the v0.3 Bearers skeletons are promoted
> from types + in-memory keeper stubs + invariant tests to live keeper
> MsgServer message handlers + simtest-grade end-to-end flows. This is
> NOT mainnet — D-020 continues to govern network deployment; runtime =
> simtest-grade handlers, not live chain.
>
> The active roster is **backend-engineer + lead-developer + security-
> engineer (REACTIVATED) + cosmos-engineer (REACTIVATED) + mesh-engineer
> (REACTIVATED, P2 phase-specific)**. The v0.3 docs personas (frontend-
> engineer, docs-writer) are deactivated because v0.5 has no docs-content
> work (the docs site is complete from v0.3; the docs build CI is complete
> from v0.4). data-engineer is reactivated as a P4-phase-specific persona
> for the hub custody state (in-memory test store only; removed after P4).
> ci-security-auditor is default off; activate in P8 for the final audit.
>
> cosmos-sdk is now a load-bearing dependency (D-055 GRILL-approved
> controlled exception to G-006); go.mod gains cosmos-sdk v0.50.x +
> ibc-go v8.x (A-504, planner/GRILL confirms the exact pin).
## Active Roster
### backend-engineer
- **Domain**: Go/Cosmos module skeletons for v0.2 — owns the **non-Cosmos-mirroring** modules (pact, partner, bond) per G-007, plus shared `types/`+`keeper/`+`module.go` authoring.
- **Frameworks**: Go, Cosmos SDK, IBC, CosmWasm.
- **Territory**: `x/pact/**`, `x/partner/**`, `x/bond/**`, `x/**/types/**`, `x/**/keeper/**`, `x/**/module.go`. (`go.mod` is read-only in v0.2 per G-006.)
- **Constraints**: lexicon compliance (REQ-012), skeleton+tests pattern (D-020), ≥80% coverage on new packages (D-033), no live-chain side effects in skeleton, locked-const invariants, no fractional reserve, no leverage/futures.
| Persona | Active | Phase-specific | Territory |
|---------|--------|-----------------|-----------|
| backend-engineer | yes | no (all runtime phases P1..P7) | `x/{exit,bridge,bearers,partner,hub,services,bond,council}/**`, `lexicon*` |
| lead-developer | yes | no (all phases) | `.ciagent/**`, `.gitea/workflows/**` |
| security-engineer | yes | no (all runtime phases) | `x/hub` keyring, `x/bond` keeper, `x/bridge` keeper, `x/council` keeper, `lexicon/**` |
| cosmos-engineer | yes | no (all runtime phases) | `keeper/**`, `types/msg_*.go`, `types/expected_keepers.go`, `module.go` across all 8 target modules |
| mesh-engineer | yes | yes (P2 only) | `x/bearers/keeper/**`, `x/bearers/types/msg_bearer*.go`, `x/bearers/simtest/**` |
| data-engineer | yes | yes (P4 only) | `x/hub/keeper/keyring_mem*.go`, `x/hub/keeper/custody_state*.go` |
### data-engineer
- **Domain**: Genesis/state schema design — Window audit log, Stand membership sets, Bond issuance state, Council Voice tally state. Shapes `ValidateGenesis` upgrades (v0.1's no-op → v0.2 ID-uniqueness checks). Owns genesis **schema** only (G-008); genesis **test assertions** are security-engineer's.
- **Frameworks**: Go, `encoding/json`, Cosmos SDK state.
- **Territory**: `x/**/types/genesis.go`, `x/**/genesis.go` (excludes `*_test.go` per G-008).
- **Constraints**: append-only audit logs (Window), ID-uniqueness in `ValidateGenesis`, lexicon compliance, no state identity beyond Reach.
## Phase-Persona Matrix
### lead-developer
- **Domain**: Multi-component orchestration across 10 new packages, dependency sequencing per D-031 blocker chain, vertical-slice integrity per phase.
- **Frameworks**: cross-cutting.
- **Territory**: `**`.
- **Constraints**: blocked-by chain enforcement (D-031), milestone versioning (v0.2 / tag_base v0.1.x), lexicon gate on merge, persona territory warn-mode enforcement.
| Phase | Personas | Work |
|-------|----------|------|
| P0 (pre-execution) | lead-developer (spec/clarify/research/plan/grill/mvp-ux + ship) | this file + RESEARCH.md + ARCHITECTURE.md v0.5 sections; planner-escalation items surfaced |
| P1 (exit + bridge runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + security-engineer | REQ-033: `x/exit` DEX swap routing + `x/bridge` L2↔L1 IBC packet handlers (5 L2 chains, D-059); ibc-go IBCModule contract; Solana wormhole-adapter branch; replay/timeout simtest |
| P2 (bearers transport runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + mesh-engineer (phase-specific) | REQ-034: OY-SAT + OY-QR message handlers; session lifecycle; OY-QR one-shot consumed-before-transfer; surveillance-resistant invariant |
| P3 (anchors onboarding runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + security-engineer | REQ-035: `x/partner` Anchor credential issuance + revocation handlers; Watcher-quorum authz via expected-keeper shim; P3→P4 hub dep broken by HubKeeper interface shim |
| P4 (hub API B2B runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + security-engineer + data-engineer (phase-specific) | REQ-036: custody/lending/compliance handlers; CustodyKeyring interface + memKeyring (D-058); lending coupon clamp [0,800]; compliance-before-custody ordering; lexicon (avoid 'deposit' in Msg names) |
| P5 (services runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer | REQ-037: Care/SIM/Vault/Mail service lifecycle handlers; per-kind Msg* (typed dispatch); window-grant checked on every op |
| P6 (bond market runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + security-engineer | REQ-038: Growth Bond issuance + secondary-market CLOB matching (D-057); per-match coupon clamp [0,800] (A-562 reject-above-cap, planner confirms); price-time priority FCFS (REQ-007); no AMM |
| P7 (council governance runtime) | backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer + security-engineer | REQ-039: Proposal/VoteOption enums (AUDIT §193 P1-1); Voice lifecycle handlers; MissionLockAmendment-Rejected rejected at ValidateBasic (A-572); Watcher Veto quorum (A-574, default 6); SignalKind stays 4 |
| P8 (final review/audit/ship) | lead-developer + ci-security-auditor (activated) | feature purity gate audit; locked-const firewall verification; G-003 + G-006 (D-055 exception) verification; milestone ship |
### cosmos-engineer (custom, phase-specific to v0.2)
- **Domain**: v0.2 components map onto Cosmos SDK modules — `x/gov` (council tally), `x/group` (stand/guild decision policy), `x/authz`/`x/feegrant` (window), `x/capability` (window unforgeable ref), `x/ibc-transfer` ICS-20 (satellite). Ensures skeleton types mirror runtime shapes for low-friction Phase 3 wiring.
- **Frameworks**: cosmos-sdk, ibc-go, CosmWasm, CometBFT.
- **Territory**: `x/satellite/**`, `x/council/**`, `x/window/**`, `x/stand/**`, `x/guild/**`, `x/forex/**`, `x/bearers/**` (Cosmos-convention-mirroring modules per G-007; `x/pact`/`x/partner`/`x/bond` are backend-engineer's). `go.mod` read-only per G-006.
- **Constraints**: lexicon compliance (REQ-012), no live-chain side effects in skeleton, mirror `x/gov` `TallyResult` / `x/group` `DecisionPolicy` / `x/authz` `Grant` shapes, zero external deps in v0.2 skeleton, by-ID-string inter-module references (G-003 tested invariant).
## Constraints Carried Forward
### security-engineer (custom, phase-specific to v0.2)
- **Domain**: Invariant + locked-const test authorship. Owns **all** test-file territory across v0.2 packages (including `genesis_test.go` per G-008). Highest invariant density in the project: Mission Lock non-amendable, bond 8% cap / 0% floor clamp, fee ceiling/floor clamp, 6 Pact types, 9 Stand types, 4 Partner tiers, Window revoke/expire idempotency, lexicon assertion per module.
- **Frameworks**: Go testing, table-driven tests, invariant tests.
- **Territory**: `x/**/types/**_test.go`, `x/**/keeper/**_test.go`, `x/**/genesis_test.go`, `x/**/*_test.go` (all test files per G-008).
- **Constraints**: invariant tests for all locked constants, locked-const tests for every enum count (9 stands, 4 partner tiers, 6 pacts, 3 councils), lexicon assertion in every new test file (D-033), ≥80% coverage on new packages, Window lifecycle idempotency tests (revoke-after-expire, double-revoke).
- **G-003 production firewall intact**: keeper-to-keeper cross-module calls use `expected_keepers.go` interface shims (ibc-go convention), NOT struct imports of `x/<module>/types`. The by-ID-string rule is preserved at the type level. Test-only cross-package imports remain exempt (the G-003 test exemption, used by REQ-030 in v0.4; simtest may import multiple `x/*/keeper` packages to wire shims).
- **G-006 controlled exception (D-055)**: `go.mod` gains `cosmos-sdk v0.50.x` + `ibc-go v8.x` (GRILL-ratified). Scoped to runtime phases P1..P7; P0 + P8 stay dep-neutral where possible. `types/` packages gain `sdk.Msg` imports for `Msg*` types (isolated in `types/msg_*.go`); invariant/lexicon tests stay stdlib-only and green. Exact version pin is A-504 (planner/GRILL confirms).
- **Locked-const invariants unchanged**: v0.5 ADDS `ProposalKind` (4) / `ProposalStatus` (5) / `VoteOption` (4) enums to `x/council/types` (AUDIT §193 P1-1 promotion, D-060) but does NOT change existing locked consts — `CouponCapBps=800` / `CouponFloorBps=0` (D-028), `BearerTypeCount=6`, `PartnerTierCount=4`, `MissionLockAmendable=false`, `SignalKindCount=4` (P1-2 defensible; v0.4 `TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` stays green), `BridgeStatusCount=4`, `ExitStatusCount=5`, `ServiceKindCount=4`, `HubServiceCount=3`, `CouncilKindCount=3`, etc. The REQ-030 cross-const test (`hub.LendingCouponCapBps==bond.CouponCapBps`) stays green.
- **Lexicon firewall stays green**: the `lexicon_meta_test.go` (x/**/*.go) + `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` (docs) automatically cover the new `keeper/`, `msg_server.go`, `simtest/` files. The new `Msg*` struct names are the lexicon surface — AVOID "deposit" in `x/hub` custody message names (use `MsgCustodyReceiveAsset`/`MsgCustodyReleaseAsset`, A-542); "coupon" not "interest"/"yield" in `x/bond`; "session"/"frame" safe in `x/bearers`; "veto" safe in `x/council`. Per-module lexicon assertions added to each new `keeper/` package.
- **Simtest NOT mainnet (D-054)**: handlers exercised against in-memory `sdk.Context` + dbm in-memory store; no real IBC light clients, no real MPC, no real bearer hardware, no real DEX venues, no real Watcher attestations (all stubbed). The simtest does NOT assert front-running safety (out of scope for simtest-grade runtime; the CLOB handler is documented as NOT front-running-safe for mainnet, a Year-3+ concern).
- **≥80% coverage on runtime packages (D-033 carries forward)**: every `keeper/msg_server.go` + simtest must hit the bar; table-driven handler tests per `Msg*`.
## Deactivated
- **frontend-engineer** — No UI in v0.2 (skeleton+tests only). Mesh Experience UI is v0.1-complete; new UI is v0.3+. Reactivate in v0.3.
- **ci-security-auditor** — Default deactivated; activate in P5 (review/ship) for milestone audit.
- **mesh-engineer** — v0.1 listed as future; still not needed in v0.2 (Bearers OY-LR + Beacon are type stubs only). Activate in v0.3 for real bearer runtime.
## Planner-Escalation Items (low-confidence assumptions, surfaced through the normal decision flow)
## Custom Personas
- **cosmos-engineer** — v0.2 components map onto specific Cosmos SDK modules. Dedicated persona ensures skeleton types mirror eventual runtime shapes, reducing Phase 3 wiring refactor cost. Distinct from backend-engineer: carries Cosmos-specific convention knowledge (tally shapes, decision policy, capability, ICS-20 packet shape).
- **security-engineer** — v0.2 has the highest locked-const + invariant density in the project. Dedicated persona ensures invariant tests and lexicon assertions are not an afterthought. Distinct from backend-engineer: owns test-file territory and invariant-first design.
These are NOT auto-decided; the planner must resolve them before the corresponding phase lands:
## Framework Alignment
- **Go 1.22** — all personas target Go 1.22 (`go.mod`).
- **cosmos-sdk** — cosmos-engineer targets cosmos-sdk v0.50.x (LTS) for future wiring; NOT vendored in v0.2 skeleton.
- **ibc-go** — cosmos-engineer targets ibc-go v8/v10 for satellite module shape; NOT vendored in v0.2 skeleton.
- **CosmWasm** — cosmos-engineer targets wasmvm v1.5/v2.0 for potential Pacts-as-contracts in Phase 3; NOT vendored in v0.2.
1. **A-504** — cosmos-sdk / ibc-go version pin (proposed: cosmos-sdk v0.50.x + ibc-go v8.x; alternative: ibc-go v10 IBC-v2/Eureka). GRILL review. Confidence 0.78.
2. **A-562**bond CLOB match above 800 bps: REJECT (fails closed, proposed) vs CLAMP-with-refund (D-057 says "clamp"). Resolve before P6. Confidence 0.70.
3. **A-572**`MissionLockAmendment-Rejected` ProposalKind: reject at `ValidateBasic` (proposed, the message never reaches the handler) vs propose-then-fail (record Pending → auto-transition Failed with event). Resolve before P7. Confidence 0.80.
4. **A-574**Watcher Veto quorum value (proposed default: 6, matching REQ-004 6-of-9). Resolve before P7. Confidence 0.75.
## Territory Alignment
- Mapped to actual `x/<name>/` structure (15 v0.1 modules + 9 new v0.2 modules + 1 extended).
- backend-engineer owns `x/pact`, `x/partner`, `x/bond` (non-Cosmos-mirroring per G-007) + shared `types/`+`keeper/`+`module.go` authoring.
- data-engineer owns `genesis.go` schema only (G-008 — excludes `*_test.go`).
- cosmos-engineer owns the Cosmos-convention-mirroring modules (`x/satellite`, `x/council`, `x/window`, `x/stand`, `x/guild`, `x/forex`) + `x/bearers` extension (G-007).
- security-engineer owns **all** `*_test.go` files across the new packages (G-008 — including `genesis_test.go`).
- lead-developer owns `**` for cross-cutting coordination.
- `go.mod` is **read-only** in v0.2 (G-006) — no persona may modify it; any change is an escalation (would violate D-020/A-201 zero-dep invariant).
## Removal Notes
## Constraint Alignment
- **Lexicon (REQ-012)** — every persona carries it; security-engineer asserts it per test file.
- **Skeleton + tests pattern (D-020)** — backend-engineer + cosmos-engineer enforce.
- **≥80% coverage on new packages (D-033)** — security-engineer owns the gate.
- **Blocker chain (D-031)** — lead-developer enforces phase ordering.
- **No live-chain side effects in skeleton** — cosmos-engineer + backend-engineer enforce (no relayer, no CometBFT, no live oracle).
- **Locked-const invariants** — security-engineer owns; every locked constant has a dedicated test.
## Phase-Specific Personas
- **cosmos-engineer** — phase-specific to v0.2 execution phases (P1-P4). Remove or merge back into backend-engineer after v0.2 ships (Cosmos convention alignment is most critical during the first Mesh-era skeleton).
- **security-engineer** — phase-specific to v0.2 (highest invariant density). May persist into v0.3 if invariant-test density remains high; reassess at v0.3 PLAN.
- frontend-engineer and docs-writer were deactivated in v0.4 (no docs-content phase); they remain deactivated in v0.5 for the same reason (the docs site is complete from v0.3; the docs build CI is complete from v0.4). They will reactivate in v0.6+ if docs content is restructured or i18n is added.
- cosmos-engineer, security-engineer, and mesh-engineer were deactivated in v0.3/v0.4 (lower Cosmos-convention / invariant density, no bearer hardware runtime); they are REACTIVATED in v0.5 because cosmos-sdk is now load-bearing (D-055), the runtime introduces new security-critical invariant surfaces (CustodyKeyring, CLOB clamp, IBC replay, Mission-Lock const firewall), and the bearer transport gets live handlers (P2).
- data-engineer is reactivated as a P4-phase-specific persona (hub custody state, in-memory test store only) and removed after P4. This mirrors the v0.3 genesis-schema pattern but scoped narrowly to the P4 custody store.
- ci-security-auditor is default off; activate in P8 for the final audit + feature purity gate.
+1352 -1
View File
File diff suppressed because it is too large Load Diff
+158 -23
View File
@@ -61,33 +61,115 @@ OpenYield (OY) is a durable, anti-greed, jurisdiction-light financial layer —
- D-009: Rebased history to fix v1.0 → v0.1 in ---ci--- blocks
## Milestone
v0.2The Mesh (active milestone; feature type; tags run on the v0.1.x patch line)
v0.5Bearers Runtime (in progress; feature type; tags run on the v0.4.x patch line)
### v0.2 Scope (The Mesh — ROADMAP Phase 2)
Target: $1B annual volume, 4 service categories. Implements the pending Mesh-era requirements:
- **REQ-009** Satellite chains (Layer 2) — wrapped Bread, Pass-Act propagation on Polygon/Base/Arbitrum/Optimism/Solana [§7]
- **REQ-011** Three Councils (Mesh, Guild, Stand) with Mission Lock — multi-source Voice [§19]
- **REQ-015** Window primitive — scope, duration, rate-limit, audit log, revoke [§10]
- **REQ-016** Nine Stand types (Household, Crew, Entity, Co-op, Circle, Trust, Foundation, Confederation, Shadow) [§11]
- **REQ-017** Guilds with Hand-Passes at 0% protocol fee [§12]
- **REQ-018** Four-tier Partner Spectrum (Op, Master Op, Pier, Anchor) [§13]
- **REQ-020** Six Pacts (Pause, Ground, Stance, Cover, Stand Registry, Hub API) [§16]
- **REQ-021** Mesh Bond Market with 8% upper coupon cap, 0% floor [§17]
- Bearers expansion: OY-LR + Beacon v1
- Forex Engine v1
### v0.5 Scope (Live-runtime promotions of the v0.3 Bearers skeletons)
v0.5 promotes the v0.3 Bearers skeletons from type+keeper-stub layers to live
runtime behavior. This is the first milestone to ship executable behavior
beyond invariant tests — keepers gain message handlers, transactions, and
end-to-end flows. Sourced from the v0.3/v0.4 deferred items (D-050,
PROJECT.md v0.4 out-of-scope, ROADMAP Phase 3 "The Bearers" runtime subset).
The skeleton-first pattern (D-020) continues to govern NEW components, but
v0.3-era modules (`x/exit`, `x/bridge`, `x/bearers`, `x/partner`, `x/hub`,
`x/services`, `x/bond`) gain runtime implementations this milestone. No live
chain launch (D-020 continues to apply to network deployment); runtime here
means keeper message handlers + simtest-grade end-to-end flows, not mainnet.
- **REQ-033** Exit layer runtime — `x/exit` DEX swap routing + bridge message handlers; `x/bridge` L2↔L1 IBC packet handlers. Promotes REQ-010 from skeleton → runtime. Live DEX/IBC channels still deferred.
- **REQ-034** Bearers transport runtime — OY-SAT + OY-QR bearer transport message handlers in `x/bearers` (extends REQ-019). Hardware integration deferred; runtime = message-handling + session lifecycle in simtest.
- **REQ-035** Anchors onboarding runtime — `x/partner` Anchor tier credential issuance + revocation handlers (extends REQ-018). Real institutional onboarding deferred; runtime = credential lifecycle in simtest.
- **REQ-036** Hub API B2B runtime — `x/hub` custody, lending primitive, compliance message handlers. Real B2B suite deferred; runtime = keeper handlers + simtest.
- **REQ-037** Services runtime — `x/services` Care / SIM / Vault / Mail service lifecycle handlers. Live service integrations deferred; runtime = lifecycle handlers + simtest.
- **REQ-038** Bond market depth runtime — `x/bond` Growth Bonds + secondary-market matching handlers (extends REQ-021). Live market depth deferred; runtime = matching engine + simtest.
- **REQ-039** Council governance runtime — `x/council` Proposal/VoteOption enum types (AUDIT §193 P1-1, deferred from v0.4) + Voice lifecycle handlers. Mission Lock const firewall intact (G-003); runtime = governance message handlers + simtest.
### Milestone Type
Feature (at least one `feat` phase). Phase 0 → `v0.1.0`; execution phases `v0.1.1..v0.1.N`; final phase patch IS the milestone release. No separate minor tag.
Feature (all execution phases are `feat`). Phase 0 → `v0.4.0`; execution phases `v0.4.1..v0.4.N`; final phase patch `v0.4.(N+1)` IS the v0.5 milestone release. No separate minor tag. The final-phase audit enforces the feature purity gate (no breaking schema changes; locked-const firewall intact).
### Out of Scope (v0.2)
- Cross-chain exit / DEX integration (Phase 3 / v0.3)
- OY-SAT, OY-QR bearers (Phase 3)
- Full Hub API B2B suite (Phase 3)
- Yield Token, Travel + 11 service categories (Phase 4)
- Full Mesh Bond market depth (Phase 3+; v0.2 ships first Mesh Bonds only)
### Out of Scope (v0.5)
- Live chain launch / mainnet / real IBC channels / real bearer transports (D-020 pattern continues; runtime = simtest-grade message handlers)
- Real institutional Anchors onboarding (credential lifecycle in simtest only)
- Yield Token, Travel + 11 service categories (ROADMAP Phase 4 — Maturity)
- i18n / MkDocs internationalization
- Cover Pool seniority mechanics (still deferred per PROJECT.md Q7)
- Breaking schema changes / locked-const amendments (Mission Lock non-amendable)
- SignalKind 4→5 enum expansion (AUDIT §193 P1-2; defensible per current rationale, deferred to v0.6+ governance vote)
### Prior Milestone
v0.1 — OpenYield Foundation Init (COMPLETE; pre-MVP foundation skeleton; released as v0.0.9 per run.md patch-line model)
### Prior Milestones
- v0.1 — OpenYield Foundation Init (COMPLETE; pre-MVP foundation skeleton; released as v0.0.9)
- v0.2 — The Mesh (COMPLETE; skeleton + tests; released as v0.1.5)
- v0.3 — Bearers & Documentation (COMPLETE; feature; released as v0.2.6)
- v0.4 — Refinement (COMPLETE; NFR; released as v0.3.4)
## Prior Milestone
v0.4 — Refinement (complete; NFR type; tags ran on the v0.3.x patch line)
### v0.4 Scope (Refinement-only NFR — v0.3 post-hoc forward-references)
v0.4 is a refinement-only NFR milestone: zero `feat:` phases. It lands the
durability fixes v0.3 flagged but did not block on, sourced from REVIEW.md,
AUDIT.md §193, and GRILL.md G-014. Live-runtime promotions of the v0.3 Bearers
skeletons are out of scope (deferred to v0.5+).
- **REQ-029** Lexicon firewall shared helper (`lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings()`) — dedupe the synthetic self-test table between `lexicon_meta_test.go` and `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`. Both meta-tests derive count + strings from the single `lexicon` package source, so a future banned-term addition updates both firewalls from one place. (GRILL G-014)
- **REQ-030** Cross-package const-equality test — `x/hub.LendingCouponCapBps == x/bond.CouponCapBps` (and Floor). Test-only import (G-003 exempt). Catches silent mission-lock drift between hub LOCAL consts and bond D-028 consts. (REVIEW.md P2 / A-304)
- **REQ-031** x/* lifecycle type shape-divergence review + alignment fixes — audit non-must-have lifecycle types across modules flagged by AUDIT §193; align where divergent without behavioral change. (AUDIT.md §193)
- **REQ-032** Docs build CI — Gitea Actions workflow running `go test ./...` (lexicon firewall) + `mkdocs build` on every push; upload `site/` as a CI artifact. Full Gitea Pages publishing deferred if no hosting target configured. (D-046)
### Milestone Type
NFR (all phases are refactor/test/quality/chore). Phase 0 → `v0.3.0`; execution phases `v0.3.1..v0.3.3`; final phase patch `v0.3.4` IS the milestone release. No separate minor tag. The final-phase audit enforces the NFR purity gate (zero `feat:` commits).
### Out of Scope (v0.4)
- Live-runtime promotions: Exit/DEX, OY-SAT/OY-QR hardware, Hub API B2B, bond matching, L2 IBC rollout, Anchors onboarding (all `feat:`, deferred to v0.5+)
- i18n / MkDocs internationalization (`feat:`, rejected by D-001 filter)
- Yield Token, Travel + 11 service categories (ROADMAP Phase 4)
- Cover Pool seniority mechanics (still deferred per PROJECT.md Q7)
### Prior Milestones
- v0.1 — OpenYield Foundation Init (COMPLETE; pre-MVP foundation skeleton; released as v0.0.9)
- v0.2 — The Mesh (COMPLETE; skeleton + tests; released as v0.1.5)
- v0.3 — Bearers & Documentation (COMPLETE; feature; released as v0.2.6)
### v0.3 Scope (Bearers skeleton + Docs site — ROADMAP Phase 3 partial, plus a docs deliverable)
This milestone bundles two parallel work-streams under one feature milestone:
**(A) Bearers skeleton (D-020 pattern continued)** — implements the v0.1 PROJECT.md
out-of-scope items now promoted to v0.3 (ROADMAP Phase 3 "The Bearers" subset),
as skeleton + tests (Go types + keeper stubs + invariant tests; no live chain):
- **REQ-010** Exit layer (Layer 3) — DEX swaps, bridges, off-mesh services (§7). Promoted from Skeleton to a fuller skeleton: `x/exit` (exit-route types) + `x/bridge` (L2↔L1 bridge types). Live runtime deferred to v0.4.
- **Bearers expansion** — OY-SAT (satellite) + OY-QR bearer transport types, extending `x/bearers` (D-029 pattern). Hardware integration deferred.
- **Anchors** — first institutional Partner tier (`x/partner` extension: Anchor credential types). REQ-018 promoted from Skeleton → fuller skeleton.
- **Hub API** — B2B backbone: custody, lending primitive, compliance types (`x/hub`). Full B2B suite deferred to v0.4.
- **Services** — Care / SIM / Vault / Mail service types (`x/services`). Live services deferred.
- **Bond market depth** — Growth Bonds + secondary-market types, extending `x/bond` (REQ-021 promoted from Skeleton → fuller skeleton). Full market depth deferred.
**(B) Documentation deliverable** — README.md + docs site in `docs/` for nomads and freeholders:
- Repo-root `README.md` (lexicon-clean project overview).
- MkDocs Material site (`mkdocs.yml` + `docs/`), organized by audience:
- `docs/nomads/` — Reach path, Stash, bearers, Maps/Pay, six Pacts, standing basics.
- `docs/freeholders/` — Four Freeholder signals, Bayesian Standing, Stands/Guilds, Councils/Voice, Bonds, Partner spectrum.
- `docs/shared/` — Six Principles, Bread Scale, Storage pools, Watchers/Mirror, Lexicon glossary, Vision overview.
- `docs/reference/` — architecture index, component map.
- **REQ-012 firewall extension** — extend the lexicon meta-test to scan `README.md` + `docs/**/*.md` (new sibling `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`), so the docs site is durably lexicon-clean. This is a `feat/test` phase.
### Milestone Type
Feature (Bearers phases are feat; docs phases are docs/test). Phase 0 → `v0.2.0`; execution phases `v0.2.1..v0.2.5`; final phase patch `v0.2.6` IS the milestone release. No separate minor tag.
### Out of Scope (v0.3)
- Live chain launch / real IBC channels / real bearer transports (D-020 pattern continues)
- DEX integration runtime, full Hub API B2B suite runtime (types only in v0.3)
- Yield Token, Travel + 11 service categories (ROADMAP Phase 4)
- i18n / versioning in MkDocs (single-language v0.3)
- Cover Pool seniority mechanics (still deferred per PROJECT.md Q7)
### Prior Milestones
- v0.1 — OpenYield Foundation Init (COMPLETE; pre-MVP foundation skeleton; released as v0.0.9)
- v0.2 — The Mesh (COMPLETE; skeleton + tests; released as v0.1.5)
## Clarification Decisions (Phase 0 — CLARIFY, autonomy=full)
@@ -108,4 +190,57 @@ Auto-decided defaults logged per clarify workflow Step 4 (full autonomy → acce
| D-030 | **Forex Engine v1**: Forex pair type + rate-oracle interface + stub keeper; no live oracle integration | Live oracle integration depends on external partners (Piers), Phase 3. | 0.80 | [live oracle integration] |
| D-031 | **Phase ordering** follows ARCHITECTURE.md blocker chain: P1 Orgs+Window foundation → P2 Pacts+Partners → P3 Councils+Forex → P4 Bonds+Bearers+L2. The final phase (P5) is review/ship. | Respects dependency graph; vertical slices keep each phase independently shippable. | 0.80 | [different wave ordering] |
| D-032 | **Lexicon** enforced project-wide; all new modules must pass the lexicon assertion test (no banned terms). Non-negotiable. **Note (G-002)**: lexicon assertion tests are NEW in v0.2 — v0.1 is lexicon-clean in practice but has NO lexicon test firewall. v0.2 introduces the firewall (scaffolded in P1 per G-004, extended in P5). | REQ-012 is `All` phases. | 1.00 | [—] |
| D-033 | **Test coverage target**: ≥80% on new keeper/type packages. v0.1 baseline = **53 tests across 11 test files** (corrected per G-001; not 48). Add lexicon assertion to each new module's test file. | Consistency with v0.1 quality bar (53 tests verified); lexicon drift is the highest-severity regression. | 0.85 | [lower coverage bar] |
| D-033 | **Test coverage target**: ≥80% on new keeper/type packages. v0.1 baseline = **53 tests across 11 test files** (corrected per G-001; not 48). Add lexicon assertion to each new module's test file. | Consistency with v0.1 quality bar (53 tests verified); lexicon drift is the highest-severity regression. | 0.85 | [lower coverage bar] |
### v0.3 Clarification Decisions (Phase 0 — CLARIFY, autonomy=full)
Auto-decided defaults logged per clarify workflow Step 4 (full autonomy → accept defaults, log decisions).
| ID | Decision | Rationale | Confidence | Alternatives |
|----|----------|-----------|------------|--------------|
| D-034 | **v0.3 milestone bundles Bearers skeleton (D-020 pattern) + docs deliverable** under one feature milestone, rather than two separate NFR+feature milestones. Bearers phases are `feat`; docs phases are `docs`/`test`. Tags run on `v0.2.x`. | User request (--ideate) is docs-only but ROADMAP Phase 3 (Bearers) is the next queued feature work; bundling keeps the milestone cadence and avoids an NFR-only milestone that would not advance the protocol. Feature type because Bearers phases are feat. | 0.82 | [separate v0.3 docs NFR + v0.4 Bearers feature; or docs as patches on v0.2 line] |
| D-035 | **Bearers skeleton continues the D-020 skeleton+tests pattern** (Go types + keeper stubs + invariant tests; no live chain, no real IBC channels, no real bearer transports). Live runtime for any Bearers component deferred to v0.4+. | v0.1/v0.2 both shipped skeleton-first; v0.3 stays consistent. Live runtime needs Watchers + Root Basket backing (Year 3 target). | 0.85 | [fuller keeper implementations in v0.3] |
| D-036 | **REQ-010 Exit layer**: skeleton = `x/exit` (ExitRoute, DEXSwap types) + `x/bridge` (L2↔L1 bridge types, BridgeStatus enum). No live DEX integration. REQ-010 promoted from v0.1 Skeleton → v0.3 fuller skeleton (two packages instead of one). | Exit runtime needs Anchor partners + L2 bridges; v0.3 lands the typed shape. | 0.80 | [single x/exit package, defer all exit to v0.4] |
| D-037 | **REQ-022 Bearers OY-SAT + OY-QR**: extend `x/bearers/types` with `OYSAT` + `OYQR` bearer transport types (BearerTransport interface already in v0.2). No hardware/RF runtime. D-029 pattern continued. | Hardware integration is not a software deliverable; v0.3 completes the 6-bearer type set (v0.2 had 4: Internet/OY-BLE/OY-WiFi-Direct + OY-LR/Beacon). | 0.82 | [real bearer runtime, defer OY-SAT/OY-QR to v0.4] |
| D-038 | **REQ-023 Anchors**: extend `x/partner/types` with `Anchor` tier credential types (REQ-018 had the 4-tier enum; v0.3 adds Anchor-specific credential fields). No live institutional onboarding. | Anchors need Watchers + Hub API backing; v0.3 lands the credential shape. | 0.78 | [separate x/anchor module, defer Anchors to v0.4] |
| D-039 | **REQ-024 Hub API**: new `x/hub` module — custody, lending-primitive, compliance type stubs (HubService enum + per-service structs). No live B2B runtime. Full Hub API B2B suite deferred to v0.4. | Hub API needs Anchors + Watchers; v0.3 lands the typed scaffold. | 0.80 | [full Hub API runtime in v0.3] |
| D-040 | **REQ-025 Services**: new `x/services` module — Care/SIM/Vault/Mail service type stubs (ServiceKind enum + per-service structs). No live services. | Services are operational, not protocol-level; v0.3 lands the typed shape. | 0.78 | [full services runtime in v0.3] |
| D-041 | **REQ-026 Bond market depth**: extend `x/bond/types` with GrowthBond type + secondary-market order types. 8% cap / 0% floor consts (D-028) unchanged. Full secondary-market matching deferred to v0.4. | v0.2 shipped first issuance; v0.3 adds depth types without a live matching engine. | 0.80 | [full bond market in v0.3] |
| D-042 | **Docs deliverable (REQ-027)**: repo-root `README.md` + MkDocs Material site (`mkdocs.yml` + `docs/`). `mkdocs.yml` at repo root; `docs/` organized by audience: `docs/nomads/`, `docs/freeholders/`, `docs/shared/`, `docs/reference/`. Build-only Python dep (mkdocs + material); `go.mod` stays zero-dep. | User chose MkDocs Material + audience organization. MkDocs is Markdown-native, lightest toolchain; build-only dep does not affect Go modules (G-006). | 0.85 | [Hugo, Docusaurus, plain Markdown no generator] |
| D-043 | **REQ-028 lexicon firewall extension**: new sibling test `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` (package `lexicon_meta_docs`) scanning `README.md` + `docs/**/*.md` for the 10 banned terms, using the same `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` + word-boundary regex. Self-exclusion + fragment pattern preserved. `.ciagent/` files are NOT scanned (they are firewall meta-files, not user-facing docs). | REQ-012 is `All` phases and docs are user-facing; the firewall must cover docs to be durable. Extending the existing meta-test (not modifying it) preserves v0.2 coverage. | 0.88 | [single combined meta-test scanning both x/ and docs/] |
| D-044 | **Phase ordering**: P1 docs foundation + firewall extension → P2 nomads docs → P3 freeholders docs → P4 Bearers skeleton I (exit/bridge/bearers/partner) → P5 Bearers skeleton II (hub/services/bond) → P6 final review/ship. Firewall lands in P1 BEFORE content (P2/P3) so docs are checked as authored. | Firewall-first ensures docs content is lexicon-clean by construction, not by retrofit. Bearers split across P4/P5 keeps each phase independently shippable (vertical slices). | 0.82 | [Bearers first then docs, or all docs in one phase] |
| D-045 | **Docs depth per audience**: each audience section (nomads, freeholders) gets 5-8 Markdown pages covering its core REQs (nomads: Reach/Stash/bearers/Maps-Pay/Pacts/standing-basics; freeholders: 4 signals/Bayesian Standing/Stands-Guilds/Councils-Voice/Bonds/Partner spectrum). `docs/shared/` gets 5-6 concept pages. `docs/reference/` gets architecture index + component map. Total ~20-25 pages. | Enough depth to be a real docs site, not a placeholder; bounded to keep P1-P3 phases shippable. | 0.80 | [deeper (40+ pages), shallower (10 pages)] |
| D-046 | **No docs-site publishing CI in v0.3**`mkdocs.yml` is buildable locally (`mkdocs serve` / `mkdocs build`); CI publishing to GitHub Pages/Gitea Pages is deferred to v0.4. v0.3 ships the source + a build invocation in the README. | Publishing CI needs deployment secrets + a hosting target; v0.3 lands the content. | 0.82 | [include publishing CI in v0.3] |
### Ideation outcome (Phase 0 — IDEATE stage, autonomy=full)
IDEATE stage ratified 8 ideas (IDEATE-01..IDEATE-08) at full autonomy, mapped to REQ-010/REQ-022..REQ-028. Docs deliverable (IDEATE-01/02) is the user's `--ideate` request; Bearers ideas (IDEATE-03..08) are the ROADMAP Phase 3 subset. Three ideation tiers ran (mechanical, backend-enriched, cross-project); mechanical tier found no `lessons:`/`compound:` tags in v0.1/v0.2 history (convention unused) and v0.2 closed clean (9/9 REQs, 303 tests, ≥95.9% coverage). Defaults accepted per full autonomy; traceability recorded in `.ciagent/oy/REQUIREMENTS.md` (IDEATE Traceability section).
### v0.4 Clarification Decisions (Phase 0 — CLARIFY, autonomy=full)
Auto-decided defaults logged per clarify workflow Step 4 (full autonomy → accept defaults, log decisions). v0.4 is a refinement-only NFR milestone (no `--ideate` flag this run; scope pre-seeded from v0.3 forward-references). The D-001 refinement-only filter governs scope eligibility.
| ID | Decision | Rationale | Confidence | Alternatives |
|----|----------|-----------|------------|--------------|
| D-047 | **v0.4 milestone type = NFR** (all phases refactor/test/quality/chore). Zero `feat:` phases by construction. Tags run on the `v0.3.x` patch line: P0 → `v0.3.0`, P1..P3 → `v0.3.1..v0.3.3`, final phase P4 → `v0.3.4` (milestone release). No separate minor tag. | The candidate work set (REQ-029..REQ-032) is entirely refactor/test/quality/chore. Promoting any Bearers skeleton to live runtime would be `feat:` and is deferred to v0.5+. | 0.90 | [feature milestone promoting v0.3 skeletons to live runtime] |
| D-048 | **REQ-029 lexicon shared helper**: add `lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings() []string` to the `lexicon` package; both `lexicon_meta_test.go` and `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` consume it instead of duplicating their own synthetic self-test tables. Both already assert `len(terms) == 10` from `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (G-014 minimum met); the helper closes the drift risk fully. | GRILL G-014 binding fix. Single source of truth for synthetic banned strings; a future banned-term addition updates both firewalls from one place. Refactor+test (NFR-eligible). | 0.88 | [cross-reference comment only (G-014 minimum)] |
| D-049 | **REQ-030 cross-package const-equality test**: new test file `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` (package `types`) that imports `x/bond/types` (test-only, G-003 exempt) and asserts `hub.LendingCouponCapBps == bond.CouponCapBps` and `hub.LendingCouponFloorBps == bond.CouponFloorBps`. Test-only import does not violate G-003 (production-import firewall). | REVIEW.md P2 / A-304. Catches silent mission-lock drift between hub LOCAL consts and bond D-028 consts. Test (NFR-eligible). | 0.85 | [document manual-sync requirement in ARCHITECTURE.md only] |
| D-050 | **REQ-031 lifecycle type shape-divergence review scope = DOCUMENT only, no code shape changes**. AUDIT §193 P1-1 (council Proposal/VoteOption absent) and P1-2 (SignalKind 4 vs 5 sources) are `feat:`-class additions (new enum types / locked-const shape changes) and are REJECTED by the D-001 refinement-only filter. v0.4 REQ-031 ships an ARCHITECTURE.md section documenting the divergence decisions (P1-2 defensible per AUDIT code rationale; P1-1 deferred to v0.5+ governance runtime) + a test asserting the current `SignalKindCount==4` locked-const shape is intentional (regression guard, not a shape change). | Adding Proposal/VoteOption enums is `feat:`; changing SignalKind 4→5 is a locked-const change. Both are out-of-scope for an NFR milestone. Documentation + a regression-guard test are NFR-eligible. | 0.82 | [add Proposal/VoteOption enums (feat:, deferred to v0.5+)] |
| D-051 | **REQ-032 docs build CI = Gitea Actions workflow** at `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml` running `go test ./...` (lexicon firewall) + `mkdocs build` on every push; upload `site/` as a CI artifact. Full Gitea Pages publishing is deferred (no hosting target configured in v0.4). The workflow file itself is a `chore` (config, not feature). | D-046 forward-reference. `.github/workflows/` does not exist; Gitea Actions uses `.gitea/workflows/`. Build+artifact CI is `chore` (NFR-eligible); full Pages publish needs a hosting target (deferred). | 0.80 | [include full Gitea Pages publish (needs hosting target + secrets)] |
| D-052 | **Phase ordering** (provisional, planner finalizes): P1 lexicon hardening (REQ-029 + REQ-030 — same `lexicon`/test territory, vertical slice) → P2 lifecycle divergence documentation + regression guard (REQ-031) → P3 docs build CI (REQ-032) → P4 final review + audit + milestone ship. Each phase independently shippable; P1 lands the firewall durability fixes first (highest-severity regression risk). | P1 bundles the two lexicon/const firewall fixes (same territory); P2 is documentation+test; P3 is CI config. Vertical slices. | 0.80 | [different wave ordering] |
| D-053 | **No IDEATE stage in v0.4** (no `--ideate` flag this run). The NFR scope was pre-seeded from v0.3 forward-references and ratified at CLARIFY. If `--ideate` is passed on a later v0.4 run, the D-001 refinement-only filter applies. | run.md §IDEATE is conditional on `--ideate`. This invocation has no `--ideate`. | 1.00 | [run IDEATE anyway] |
## Clarification Decisions (Phase 0 v0.5 — CLARIFY, autonomy=full)
Auto-decided defaults logged per clarify workflow Step 4 (full autonomy → accept defaults, log decisions). No `--ideate` flag this run; v0.5 scope is pre-seeded from PROJECT.md v0.4 out-of-scope + AUDIT §193 P1-1 + D-050 and ratified at CLARIFY.
| ID | Decision | Rationale | Confidence | Alternatives |
|----|----------|-----------|------------|--------------|
| D-054 | **"Runtime" = simtest-grade keeper message handlers + end-to-end flows, NOT mainnet.** v0.5 ships executable keeper behavior (MsgServer handlers, keeper Set/Get/Remove, simtest `simtest`-package flows) for the v0.3 Bearers modules. No live chain launch, no real IBC channels, no real bearer transports, no real institutional onboarding (D-020 pattern continues to govern network deployment). | v0.3 skeletons are types + keeper stubs + invariant tests. The next increment is message handlers + simtest, which is the Cosmos-SDK standard pre-mainnet step. Mainnet deployment is a Year-3+ operational concern (Watchers + Root Basket backing required). | 0.88 | [full mainnet launch in v0.5; types-only with no handlers (stalls progress)] |
| D-055 | **Cosmos SDK dependency is GRILL-approved for v0.5.** `go.mod` gains `github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk` (and transitive deps) as the runtime substrate for keeper MsgServer handlers, `types.Msg`, `sdk.Context`, store, and simtest. This is a controlled exception to G-006 (zero-dep go.mod), escalated to GRILL for binding ratification. The exception is scoped to runtime promotion phases (P1..P7); P0 and the final phase remain dep-neutral where possible. | v0.3 skeletons used stub `keeper.go` files that already import cosmos-sdk (see LSP errors on `x/watcher/keeper/keeper.go` — pre-existing imports). Promoting to runtime makes the dependency load-bearing rather than stub-only. G-006's intent (zero-dep for skeleton durability) is preserved by isolating the dep to runtime phases and keeping types/invariants dep-free. | 0.80 | [stay zero-dep, hand-roll keeper store + message types (duplicates SDK, high risk); defer all runtime to v0.6+ (stalls)] |
| D-056 | **Phase ordering** (provisional, planner finalizes): P1 Exit+Bridge runtime (REQ-033, Layer 3 — outermost edge, fewest internal deps) → P2 Bearers transport runtime (REQ-034, depends on exit for off-mesh routing) → P3 Anchors runtime (REQ-035, depends on partner + bearers) → P4 Hub API runtime (REQ-036, depends on anchors for custody backing) → P5 Services runtime (REQ-037, depends on hub) → P6 Bond market runtime (REQ-038, depends on hub lending primitive) → P7 Council governance runtime (REQ-039, cross-cutting, lands last) → P8 final review + audit + milestone ship. Each phase independently shippable; P1 lands the outermost edge first (lowest internal coupling). | The dependency chain is outer→inner: exit needs nothing internal; bearers routes through exit; anchors ride bearers; hub custody backs anchors; services sit on hub; bond matching uses hub lending; governance is cross-cutting. Vertical slices, each phase shippable. | 0.82 | [governance-first; bond-first; single mega-phase] |
| D-057 | **Bond matching engine = central-limit order book (CLOB) with the 8% cap / 0% floor consts (D-028) as hard clamp on each match.** No AMM (constant-product or otherwise) in v0.5; AMM is a Year-4 Maturity concern. The CLOB matches Growth Bond bids/offers at the locked coupon cap; secondary-market trades clear at market price but the bond's *coupon* stays within the mission-locked band. REQ-038 ships the matching handler + simtest; live market depth deferred. | CLOB is the standard secondary-market primitive; AMM is for spot/swaps (Exit layer's DEX, deferred). The mission-lock clamp (D-028) is a per-match invariant, not a market-wide cap. CLOB lets the cap be enforced per-match. | 0.80 | [AMM (wrong fit for coupon-bearing bonds); batch auction (deferred to Maturity)] |
| D-058 | **Hub custody model = key-share abstraction (MPC-via-interface, not a concrete HSM/MPC vendor).** `x/hub` custody handlers expose a `CustodyKeyring` interface with `Sign`/`Derive` methods; v0.5 ships an in-memory test-only implementation. Real MPC/HSM backing is deferred (operational, Year 3+). This keeps v0.5 dep-neutral w.r.t. custody vendors while landing the handler surface. | Custody key management is operational, not protocol-level. An interface + test impl lets runtime handlers be exercised in simtest without committing to a vendor. GRILL reviews the interface boundary. | 0.78 | [commit to a specific MPC vendor (premature); hand-roll shamir (out of scope)] |
| D-059 | **IBC packet scope = the 5 L2 chains already in the v0.2 skeleton** (Polygon, Base, Arbitrum, Optimism, Solana per REQ-009/`x/satellite`). v0.5 `x/bridge` handlers implement IBC packet recv/ack for these 5 chains' `BridgeStatus` transitions. No new L2 chains in v0.5. Solana IBC uses the wormhole-style bridge adapter (already stubbed in `x/bridge` per D-021). | The 5 L2 chains are the locked-const set (REQ-009). Adding new chains is a Year-4 concern. Solana IBC was a v0.1 deferred item (D-021) now promoted. | 0.82 | [add 3+ new L2 chains (Year 4); defer Solana IBC again (stalls)] |
| D-060 | **Council governance shape (AUDIT §193 P1-1)**: add `Proposal` and `VoteOption` enum types to `x/council/types` (currently absent per AUDIT). `ProposalKind` enum = {Stand, Guild, Mesh, MissionLockAmendment-Rejected} (Mission Lock non-amendable → the enum value exists but the handler rejects it; documents the non-amendability in code). `VoteOption` enum = {Yes, No, Abstain, Veto} (Veto = Watcher-only, quorum rule). SignalKind stays at 4 sources (P1-2 defensible per AUDIT; expansion deferred to v0.6+ governance vote). Mission Lock const firewall (G-003) intact. | AUDIT P1-1 flagged the absence as a divergence. Adding the enums is `feat:` (deferred from v0.4 by D-001). P1-2 (SignalKind 4→5) is a locked-const change rejected by the audit rationale, so it stays at 4. | 0.82 | [add SignalKind 5th source (locked-const change, rejected); defer Proposal/VoteOption again (stalls)] |
| D-061 | **No IDEATE stage in v0.5** (no `--ideate` flag this run). The feature scope was pre-seeded from PROJECT.md v0.4 out-of-scope + AUDIT §193 P1-1 + D-050 and ratified at CLARIFY. The D-001 refinement-only filter does NOT apply (v0.5 is a feature milestone, not NFR). | run.md §IDEATE is conditional on `--ideate`. This invocation has no `--ideate`. | 1.00 | [run IDEATE anyway] |
+126 -9
View File
@@ -10,19 +10,125 @@
| REQ-006 | Standing anti-gaming formula | §9.2 | High | Complete | P6 |
| REQ-007 | FCFS processing | §15 | High | Complete | P7 |
| REQ-008 | OY Chain (Layer 1) | §7 | High | Skeleton | P1 |
| REQ-009 | Satellite chains (Layer 2) | §7 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-009 | Satellite chains (Layer 2) | §7 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P4 |
| REQ-010 | Exit layer (Layer 3) | §7 | Medium | Skeleton | P8 |
| REQ-011 | Three Councils with Mission Lock | §19 | High | Pending | Future |
| REQ-011 | Three Councils with Mission Lock | §19 | High | Skeleton | v0.2/P3 |
| REQ-012 | Lexicon compliance | §3 | High | Complete | All |
| REQ-013 | Bread unit with scale | §4 | High | Complete | P2 |
| REQ-014 | Three pools of storage | §5 | High | Complete | P3 |
| REQ-015 | Window primitive | §10 | High | Pending | Future |
| REQ-016 | Nine Stand types | §11 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-017 | Guilds with free Hand-Passes | §12 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-018 | Four-tier Partner Spectrum | §13 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-015 | Window primitive | §10 | High | Skeleton | v0.2/P1 |
| REQ-016 | Nine Stand types | §11 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P1 |
| REQ-017 | Guilds with free Hand-Passes | §12 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P1 |
| REQ-018 | Four-tier Partner Spectrum | §13 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P2 |
| REQ-019 | Six bearers via Unified Bearer Layer | §14 | Medium | Complete | P7 |
| REQ-020 | Six Pacts | §16 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-021 | Mesh Bond Market with 8pct cap | §17 | Medium | Pending | Future |
| REQ-020 | Six Pacts | §16 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P2 |
| REQ-021 | Mesh Bond Market with 8pct cap | §17 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P4 |
| Bearers OY-LR + Beacon | (vision §14) | §14 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P4 |
| Forex Engine v1 | (vision §13) | §13 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.2/P3 |
## v0.3 Milestone Requirements (Bearers & Documentation)
| ID | Requirement | Vision § | Priority | Status | Phase |
|----|-------------|----------|----------|--------|-------|
| REQ-010 | Exit layer (Layer 3) — DEX swaps, bridges, off-mesh services | §7 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P4 |
| REQ-022 | Bearers expansion: OY-SAT + OY-QR bearer transports | §14 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P4 |
| REQ-023 | Anchors — first institutional Partner tier | §13 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P4 |
| REQ-024 | Hub API — B2B backbone: custody, lending primitive, compliance | §13 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P5 |
| REQ-025 | Services — Care / SIM / Vault / Mail | §13 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P5 |
| REQ-026 | Bond market depth — Growth Bonds + secondary market | §17 | Medium | Skeleton | v0.3/P5 |
| REQ-027 | README.md + docs site in docs/ for nomads and freeholders | (vision §8) | High | Complete | v0.3/P1-P3 |
| REQ-028 | Extend REQ-012 lexicon firewall to scan docs/ + README.md | §3 | High | Complete | v0.3/P1 |
> REQ-022 through REQ-028 are NEW in v0.3 (ratified during Phase 0 IDEATE as
> IDEATE-01..IDEATE-07, then assigned final REQ-IDs). REQ-010 is promoted from
> v0.1 Skeleton to a fuller v0.3 skeleton.
## v0.4 Milestone Requirements (Refinement — NFR)
v0.4 is a refinement-only NFR milestone: zero `feat:` phases. Scope sourced
from v0.3 forward-references (REVIEW.md, AUDIT.md §193, GRILL.md G-014).
Live-runtime promotions are out of scope (deferred to v0.5+). The D-001
refinement-only filter applies to any IDEATE stage.
| ID | Requirement | Source | Class | Priority | Status | Phase |
|----|-------------|--------|-------|----------|--------|-------|
| REQ-029 | Lexicon firewall: shared `lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings()` helper — dedupe the synthetic self-test table between `lexicon_meta_test.go` and `lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`; both meta-tests derive count + strings from the single source so a future banned-term addition updates both firewalls from one place | GRILL G-014 | refactor/test | High | Complete | v0.4/P1 |
| REQ-030 | Cross-package const-equality test: `x/hub.LendingCouponCapBps == x/bond.CouponCapBps` (and Floor) — test-only import (G-003 exempt), catches silent mission-lock drift between hub LOCAL consts and bond D-028 consts | REVIEW.md P2 / A-304 | test | High | Complete | v0.4/P1 |
| REQ-031 | x/* lifecycle type shape-divergence review + alignment fixes — audit non-must-have lifecycle types across modules flagged by AUDIT §193; align shapes where divergent (no behavioral change) | AUDIT.md §193 | refactor/quality | Medium | Complete | v0.4/P2 |
| REQ-032 | Docs build CI — Gitea Actions workflow that runs `go test ./...` (lexicon firewall) + `mkdocs build` on every push; upload the built `site/` as a CI artifact. Full Gitea Pages publishing deferred if no hosting target is configured (chore, not feat) | D-046 | chore/ci | Medium | Complete | v0.4/P3 |
> REQ-029..REQ-032 are NEW in v0.4. All are NFR classes (refactor/test/quality/
> chore) — zero `feat:` phases by construction. The final-phase audit enforces
> the NFR purity gate (zero `feat:` commits in the milestone).
## Milestone v0.4 Summary (Refinement — NFR) — COMPLETE
- 4 v0.4-scope REQs shipped as NFR (refactor/test/docs/chore): REQ-029, REQ-030, REQ-031, REQ-032
- Closes 3 real v0.3 forward-references: GRILL G-014 (lexicon drift), REVIEW P2/A-304 (const drift), AUDIT §193 (council divergence docs)
- Lands the D-046 docs-CI forward-reference (.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml, build+artifact, no Pages publish per D-051)
- NFR purity gate GREEN: zero `feat:` commit subjects in the milestone (20 commits, all docs/refactor/test/chore/verify/decision/checkpoint/Merge)
- `go.mod` unchanged (G-006 — zero Go deps; Python deps isolated to CI docs-build job)
- G-003 production firewall intact (no production import of `x/bond/types` in `x/hub/types`; cross-const test is test-only)
- Coverage: x/hub/types 93.3% (v0.3 floor preserved), x/council/types 96.4% (improved); both above 80% target
- Tags: v0.3.0 (P0) -> v0.3.1 (P1) -> v0.3.2 (P2) -> v0.3.3 (P3) -> v0.3.4 (P4 = v0.4 milestone release)
- Tag-line note: v0.4 (NFR) ships on the v0.3.x patch line (config tag_base). The v0.3.4 milestone release IS the deliverable (D-008 — final phase patch IS the milestone release; no separate minor tag).
## v0.5 Milestone Requirements (Bearers Runtime — Feature)
v0.5 promotes the v0.3 Bearers skeletons from type+keeper-stub layers to
live runtime behavior (keeper message handlers + simtest-grade end-to-end
flows). No live chain launch (D-020 continues to govern network deployment);
runtime = keeper handlers + simtest, not mainnet. Sourced from the v0.3/v0.4
deferred items (D-050, PROJECT.md v0.4 out-of-scope, ROADMAP Phase 3 runtime).
| ID | Requirement | Source | Class | Priority | Status | Phase |
|----|-------------|--------|-------|----------|--------|-------|
| REQ-033 | Exit layer runtime — `x/exit` DEX swap routing + `x/bridge` L2↔L1 IBC packet handlers; promotes REQ-010 from skeleton → runtime (simtest-grade message handlers; live DEX/IBC channels deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS / D-050 | feat | High | pending | v0.5/P1 |
| REQ-034 | Bearers transport runtime — OY-SAT + OY-QR bearer transport message handlers in `x/bearers` (extends REQ-019/REQ-022); session lifecycle in simtest (hardware integration deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS | feat | Medium | pending | v0.5/P2 |
| REQ-035 | Anchors onboarding runtime — `x/partner` Anchor tier credential issuance + revocation handlers (extends REQ-018/REQ-023); credential lifecycle in simtest (real institutional onboarding deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS | feat | Medium | pending | v0.5/P3 |
| REQ-036 | Hub API B2B runtime — `x/hub` custody, lending primitive, compliance message handlers; keeper handlers + simtest (real B2B suite deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS | feat | High | pending | v0.5/P4 |
| REQ-037 | Services runtime — `x/services` Care / SIM / Vault / Mail service lifecycle handlers; runtime handlers + simtest (live service integrations deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS | feat | Medium | pending | v0.5/P5 |
| REQ-038 | Bond market depth runtime — `x/bond` Growth Bonds + secondary-market matching handlers (extends REQ-021/REQ-026); matching engine + simtest (live market depth deferred) | PROJECT.md v0.4 OOS | feat | High | pending | v0.5/P6 |
| REQ-039 | Council governance runtime — `x/council` Proposal/VoteOption enum types (AUDIT §193 P1-1, deferred from v0.4) + Voice lifecycle handlers; governance message handlers + simtest (Mission Lock const firewall intact per G-003; SignalKind 4→5 expansion deferred to v0.6+) | AUDIT §193 P1-1 / D-050 | feat | Medium | pending | v0.5/P7 |
> REQ-033..REQ-039 are NEW in v0.5. All are `feat`-class (runtime promotion
> from skeleton). No breaking schema changes; locked-const firewall intact
> (Mission Lock non-amendable). The final-phase audit enforces the feature
> purity gate (no breaking schema changes; G-003 production firewall intact;
> G-006 go.mod unchanged unless a runtime dep is GRILL-approved).
## IDEATE Traceability (Phase 0 — IDEATE stage, autonomy=full)
The IDEATE stage ran the three ideation tiers (mechanical, backend-enriched,
cross-project) on the v0.3 milestone scope and ratified 8 ideas (IDEATE-01..
IDEATE-08) at full autonomy. Each IDEATE-NN maps to a REQ-ID in the v0.3
requirements table above. Mechanical tier: no `lessons:`/`compound:` tags in
v0.1/v0.2 history (convention unused); one historical escalation (milestone
release pending — no remote) resolved in v0.2; v0.2 closed clean (9/9 REQs,
303 tests, ≥95.9% coverage). Backend-enriched + cross-project tiers confirmed
the docs deliverable + Bearers skeleton bundle (D-034) and the firewall-first
ordering (D-044). Defaults accepted per full autonomy.
| IDEATE ID | REQ-ID | Category | Source | Confidence | Phase |
|-----------|--------|----------|--------|------------|-------|
| IDEATE-01 | REQ-027 | improvement/docs | user `--ideate` request + D-042/D-045 | 0.90 | v0.3/P1-P3 |
| IDEATE-02 | REQ-028 | quality/security | D-043 + RESEARCH firewall-extension design | 0.88 | v0.3/P1 |
| IDEATE-03 | REQ-010 | coverage/architecture | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-036 | 0.80 | v0.3/P4 |
| IDEATE-04 | REQ-022 | coverage | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-037 | 0.82 | v0.3/P4 |
| IDEATE-05 | REQ-023 | coverage | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-038 | 0.78 | v0.3/P4 |
| IDEATE-06 | REQ-024 | architecture | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-039 | 0.80 | v0.3/P5 |
| IDEATE-07 | REQ-025 | coverage | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-040 | 0.78 | v0.3/P5 |
| IDEATE-08 | REQ-026 | coverage | ROADMAP Phase 3 + D-041 | 0.80 | v0.3/P5 |
Notes:
- IDEATE-01/02 (docs deliverable + firewall) are the user's `--ideate` request
ratified via D-042/D-043/D-045.
- IDEATE-03..08 (Bearers skeleton) are the ROADMAP Phase 3 subset bundled into
v0.3 per D-034.
- IDEATE-02 lands in P1 (firewall-first) BEFORE IDEATE-01 content (P2/P3) per
D-044 — docs are lexicon-clean by construction.
- IDEATE-03..05 ship in P4 (Bearers skeleton I); IDEATE-06..08 ship in P5
(Bearers skeleton II) — vertical slices, each phase independently shippable.
## Milestone v0.1 Summary
- 10 REQs complete (skeleton + tests)
@@ -30,4 +136,15 @@
- 9 REQs pending (future milestones v0.2-v0.4)
- All locked constants verified by tests
- Lexicon fully compliant
- 48 unit tests passing across 11 modules
- 53 unit tests passing across 11 modules (G-001 corrected count)
## Milestone v0.2 Summary (The Mesh) — COMPLETE (skeleton + tests)
- 8 v0.2-scope REQs shipped as skeleton + tests: REQ-009, REQ-011, REQ-015, REQ-016, REQ-017, REQ-018, REQ-020, REQ-021
- 2 v0.2-scope components shipped beyond the REQ list: Bearers OY-LR + Beacon (D-029), Forex Engine v1 (D-030)
- REQ-012 (lexicon) enforced project-wide: per-module assertions in all 10 new/extended packages + project-wide meta-test (G-002 firewall NEW in v0.2)
- 10 new/extended packages: x/window, x/stand, x/guild, x/pact, x/partner, x/council, x/forex, x/bond, x/satellite, x/bearers(ext)
- All locked-const invariants green (9 Stands, 4 Partner tiers, 6 Pacts, 3 Councils, Mission Lock non-amendable, Bond 8% cap / 0% floor clamp, Guild 0% fee, Forex spread cap >=0, 5 L2 chains, Window status count)
- Coverage >=80% on all 10 new/extended packages (floor 95.9%, 8 of 10 at 100%)
- go.mod unchanged (zero external deps, G-006 / A-201)
- Tags: v0.1.0 (P0) -> v0.1.1 (P1) -> v0.1.2 (P2) -> v0.1.3 (P3) -> v0.1.4 (P4) -> v0.1.5 (P5 = v0.2 milestone release)
- Tag-line note (G-010): v0.1 pre-MVP shipped on the v0.0.x patch line (ROADMAP lines 4-13); v0.2 ships on the v0.1.x patch line (config tag_base). The v0.1.5 milestone release is NOT the deferred v0.1.0 "MVP" tag — they are different lines.
+1566 -1
View File
File diff suppressed because it is too large Load Diff
+423
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,423 @@
# Review: OpenYield (oy) — v0.2 (The Mesh) Final Phase (P1-P4)
> **Reviewer**: CIAgent code reviewer (correctness, security, maintainability, adversarial lenses)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Scope**: `git diff main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh` — all v0.2 execution work (P1-P4: x/window, x/stand, x/guild, x/pact, x/partner, x/council, x/forex, x/bond, x/satellite, x/bearers extension, lexicon package, lexicon_meta_test.go)
> **Milestone**: v0.2 — The Mesh
> **Mode**: multi-project (slug `oy`)
> **Autonomy**: full — P0 fixes auto-applied; P1+ flagged for post-hoc review (do not block ship)
---
## Verification Commands Run
| Command | Result |
|---|---|
| `go build ./...` | **GREEN** (exit 0) |
| `go test ./...` | **GREEN** (exit 0, all 25 packages: 15 v0.1 baseline + 10 v0.2 new/extended) |
| `go test -cover ./x/{window,stand,guild,pact,partner,council,forex,bond,bearers,satellite}/types/...` | **ALL ≥80%** (range 95.9%100.0%; 8 of 10 at 100%) |
| `go test -run TestLexiconMeta ./...` | **GREEN** (4 meta-tests pass at root pkg) |
| `go test -run TestG003NoCrossModuleStructImportsInProduction ./x/window/types/` | **GREEN** (G-003 invariant enforced) |
| `git diff main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh -- go.mod` | **EMPTY** (go.mod read-only — G-006 verified) |
| `grep -rniE '\b(bank\|deposit\|interest\|yield\|currency\|dollar\|euro\|account\|savings\|depositor)\b' x/ --include='*.go'` | **ZERO HITS** (lexicon firewall green) |
| v0.1 baseline regression | **NO REGRESSION** (all v0.1 packages cached/green) |
### Coverage detail
| Package | Coverage |
|---|---|
| x/window/types | 100.0% |
| x/stand/types | 100.0% |
| x/guild/types | 100.0% |
| x/pact/types | 95.9% |
| x/partner/types | 100.0% |
| x/council/types | 96.4% |
| x/forex/types | 100.0% |
| x/bond/types | 96.8% |
| x/bearers/types | 100.0% |
| x/satellite/types | 100.0% |
All packages exceed the 80% target (D-033) — the floor is 95.9%.
---
## 1. Per-Axis Verdicts
### Axis 1 — Correctness — **PASS** (confidence 0.90)
Verified every locked const, enum count, struct shape, and ValidateGenesis ID-uniqueness check against RESEARCH.md §1 + PLANS.md task specs:
| Component | Locked const / enum | Spec | Code | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Window | `WindowStatusCount` | 4 (Open/Active/Revoked/Expired) | `=4` ✓ | PASS |
| Stand | `StandTypeCount` | 9 (Household/Crew/Entity/Co-op/Circle/Trust/Foundation/Confederation/Shadow) | `=9` ✓ all 9 names match vision §11 | PASS |
| Guild | `HandPassFeeBps` | 0 | `=0` ✓ + FeeGrain==0 enforced in ValidateGenesis | PASS |
| Pact | `PactTypeCount` | 6 (Pause/Ground/Stance/Cover/StandRegistry/HubAPI) | `=6` ✓ | PASS |
| Pact | `MissionLockAmendable` | false | `=false` ✓ + per-type `AmendableCoreTermsPause/Ground/Stance=false` ✓ | PASS |
| Partner | `PartnerTierCount` | 4 (Op/MasterOp/Pier/Anchor) | `=4` ✓ | PASS |
| Council | `CouncilKindCount` | 3 (Mesh/Guild/Stand) | `=3` ✓ | PASS |
| Council | `MissionLockAmendable` | false | `=false` ✓ (highest-severity firewall) | PASS |
| Forex | `SpreadCapBps` | ≥0 (placeholder 0, A-214) | `=0` ✓ + test asserts ≥0 | PASS |
| Bond | `CouponCapBps` | 800 (8%) | `=800` ✓ | PASS |
| Bond | `CouponFloorBps` | 0 (0%) | `=0` ✓ | PASS |
| Satellite | `L2ChainCount` | 5 (Polygon active + 4 stubs) | `=5` ✓ Polygon only ChainActive | PASS |
| Satellite | `ChannelStatusCount` | 4 (Init/TryOpen/Open/Closed) | `=4` ✓ ICS-20 v1 shape | PASS |
**ValidateGenesis ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1 no-op)** — all present and tested:
- window: dup window-ids ✓ + audit-log entry-id uniqueness + non-decreasing timestamps ✓
- stand: dup stand-ids ✓ + dup (stand-id, reach-id) membership pairs ✓
- guild: dup guild-ids ✓ + dup pass-ids ✓ + FeeGrain==0 covenant ✓
- pact: dup pact-ids ✓ + known-type check ✓ + Mission-Lock echo ✓
- partner: dup partner-ids ✓
- council: dup council-ids ✓ + dup voice-ids ✓ + referential integrity (voice→council) ✓ + Stand/Guild Council ref-required ✓
- forex: dup pair-ids ✓ + dup provider-ids ✓ + known-oracle-kind ✓
- bond: dup bond-ids ✓ + coupon clamp at genesis load ✓ + known-status ✓
- satellite: dup channel-ids ✓ + dup denoms ✓
- bearers: no-op (correct — spec said "DefaultParams/GenesisState unchanged"; extension is types-only)
**Correctness caveat (P1, not blocking):** the council module's *governance lifecycle shape* is simpler than the P3-01-01 deliverable recommended (see P1+ flags below). All must-haves are met; the drift is in the non-must-have Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle enums.
### Axis 2 — Security — **PASS** (confidence 0.92)
- **Lexicon firewall (G-002, REQ-012)**: zero banned terms in any `x/**/*.go` (verified by `TestLexiconMetaNoBannedTermsInX` + independent `grep` word-boundary scan, exit 1 = no matches). The firewall is NEW in v0.2 and green from P1. The `lexicon/lexicon.go` package bootstraps terms from two-character fragments so the firewall's own source contains no banned literals (standard lexicon-test bootstrapping pattern).
- **G-003 by-ID-string invariant**: `TestG003NoCrossModuleStructImportsInProduction` (x/window/types/types_test.go:437) scans every non-test `.go` under `x/` with `go/parser` and asserts no production file imports a foreign `x/<module>/types` package. Test passes. Independent grep confirms: the only cross-module `oy/openyield/x/...` imports in test files are self-imports (test pkg → its own types pkg) + the pre-existing v0.1 `x/bearers` test → `x/processing/types` (a test import, not production).
- **Mission Lock**: `MissionLockAmendable = false` as compile-time `const` in BOTH `x/pact/types` (line 24) and `x/council/types` (line 25). Per-type `AmendableCoreTermsPause/Ground/Stance = false` consts in pact. Tests assert the const is false AND that the typed comparison would fail to compile if the const changed type (defence in depth).
- **Bond Clamp invariants**: `Clamp(couponBps)` enforces `min(cap, max(floor, coupon))` at both construction (`Issue`) and genesis load (`ValidateBonds`). Tested for above-cap→cap, in-range→unchanged, below-floor boundary. The genesis path rejects out-of-bounds coupons rather than silently clamping (authoritative schema).
- **No secrets in code**: no credentials, API keys, or private material present (skeleton-only, zero external deps).
### Axis 3 — Maintainability — **PASS** (confidence 0.90)
- **v0.1 pattern consistency**: all 10 packages follow the v0.1 skeleton convention — `package types`, `ModuleName`/`StoreKey`/`RouterKey`/`QuerierRoute` consts, typed structs with `json`+`yaml` tags, `Params` struct, `DefaultParams()`, `GenesisState`, `DefaultGenesisState()`, `ValidateGenesis(json.RawMessage) error`. No drift from the v0.1 layout.
- **Table-driven tests**: present throughout (window rate-limit, bond clamp, lexicon self-test, lexicon false-positive, partner keeper round-trip, council genesis validation). Matches v0.1's 53-test baseline pattern (now 299 tests across 23 files — v0.1 baseline preserved + v0.2 additions).
- **Coverage ≥80%**: all 10 new/extended packages exceed 80% (floor 95.9%, 8 of 10 at 100%). D-033 satisfied.
- **No external deps added**: `git diff main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh -- go.mod` is EMPTY. G-006/A-201 zero-dep invariant intact. All v0.2 code compiles with stdlib only (`encoding/json`, `fmt`, `sync`, `regexp`, `strings`, `os`, `path/filepath`, `runtime`, `testing`, `go/parser`, `go/token`).
- **G-008 genesis schema vs test split**: `genesis.go` files (data-engineer schema) present in window, stand, bond, council, forex, pact, satellite. `*_test.go` files (security-engineer) own all test assertions including `genesis_test.go` (present in window, stand, bond). Helper composition is clean: `ValidateGenesis` in `types.go` delegates to `Validate*` helpers in `genesis.go`.
### Axis 4 — Adversarial — **CONDITIONAL** (confidence 0.78)
- **No double-counted REQs**: every v0.2 REQ (009, 011, 015, 016, 017, 018, 020, 021, Bearers, Forex) maps to exactly one module + test task. REQ-012 (lexicon) is cross-cutting (per-module + project-wide meta-test).
- **No missing must-haves**: all P1-P4 must-have checklists satisfied (verified per phase in §3 below).
- **Spec drift detected (P1, non-blocking)**: the council module's P3-01-01 deliverable recommended a full OZ Governor / `x/gov` proposal lifecycle (`Proposal` struct, `ProposalStatus` enum with 5 states, `VoteOption` enum with 3 options) plus a 5-source `VoiceSource` enum (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Freeholder/Guild). The implemented code has a simpler `Voice` + `TallyResult` shape, renamed `VoiceSource``SignalKind` with 4 sources (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital — dropped Freeholder and Guild, added Capital), and no Proposal/ProposalStatus/VoteOption enums. The P3 must-haves (3 councils, Mission Lock, TallyResult x/gov shape, no veto) are ALL met — the drift is in the non-must-have lifecycle enums. Flagged P1 for v0.3 (see §2).
- **No other drift**: all other modules match their task deliverables exactly (locked consts, struct fields, enum names, genesis invariants).
### Axis 5 — Grill Binding Decisions — **9 APPLIED + 1 N/A** (see §4)
---
## 2. P0 Issues + Auto-Applied Fixes
**P0 count: 0.** No P0 issues found. No auto-applied fixes.
Rationale: all locked consts are correct, all ValidateGenesis ID-uniqueness checks are present, the lexicon firewall is green, G-003 import invariant is tested and green, Mission Lock and Bond Clamp invariants are const-enforced and tested, go.mod is unchanged, coverage exceeds 80% everywhere. The two spec-drift findings (council lifecycle enums) are P1 — they do not break any must-have, do not introduce a security hole, and do not affect the locked-const firewall. They are flagged for post-hoc review, not auto-fixed (auto-fixing would mean designing the Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle, which is a design decision the orchestrator should make in v0.3, not a P0 patch).
---
## 3. P1+ Issues for Post-Hoc Review (flag, don't fix)
### P1-1: Council module — Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle enums absent
- **File:line**: `x/council/types/types.go:33-145` (entire council types file)
- **Spec (P3-01-01 deliverable)**: `Proposal` struct (id, council, proposer-reach, submit-time, voting-period, status); `ProposalStatus` enum (Pending, Active, Succeeded, Failed, Executed — mirror OZ/Governor + `x/gov`); `VoteOption` enum (Yes, No, Abstain — no "no-with-veto", anti-greed).
- **Implemented**: `Council`, `CouncilMember`, `Voice`, `SignalKind`, `TallyResult`. No `Proposal`, no `ProposalStatus`, no `VoteOption`. The `Voice` struct carries a `TallyResult` directly, collapsing the proposal→vote→tally lifecycle into a single Voice cast.
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. P3 must-haves were: 3 councils ✓, Mission Lock ✓, TallyResult mirrors x/gov ✓, VoteOption has no veto (N/A — no VoteOption enum at all). The must-haves do not require the Proposal/VoteOption enums; they were in the task deliverable description, not the must-have checklist.
- **Recommendation for v0.3**: when wiring the council keeper to a live governance runtime, add `Proposal` + `ProposalStatus` (Pending→Active→Succeeded→Failed→Executed) + `VoteOption` (Yes/No/Abstain) so the council can run an actual proposal lifecycle. The current `Voice`+`TallyResult` shape is sufficient for the skeleton's tally-structure goal but insufficient for live governance.
- **Severity**: P1 (spec drift from deliverable, not a must-have, not blocking).
### P1-2: Council VoiceSource→SignalKind (4 sources, not 5)
- **File:line**: `x/council/types/types.go:102-129` (`SignalKind` enum + `AllSignalKinds()`)
- **Spec (P3-01-01 deliverable)**: `VoiceSource` enum (Stash, Standing, Vouch, Freeholder, Guild) — 5 multi-source weighting inputs.
- **Implemented**: `SignalKind` enum (Stash, Standing, Vouch, Capital) — 4 sources. "Freeholder" and "Guild" dropped; "Capital" added.
- **Code rationale (types.go:104-114)**: the comment explains Capital as "committed-capital signal (vision §9.1 committed_capital)" and argues Freeholder is an eligibility property (upstream in `x/standing`), not a voice signal, and Guild is a council tier, not a voice source. This is a defensible design refinement — but it diverges from the P3-01-01 deliverable text.
- **Must-have impact**: NONE. P3 must-haves did not enumerate VoiceSource coverage; only "Mission Lock invariant" and "TallyResult x/gov shape" were must-haves.
- **Recommendation for post-hoc review**: confirm with the lead-developer/cosmos-engineer that the 4-source `SignalKind` (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital) is the intended v0.2 shape, or whether the 5-source `VoiceSource` (adding Freeholder + Guild) should be restored for v0.3 wiring. The `SignalKindCount=4` locked-const test (types_test.go:102) currently locks the 4-source shape; changing it in v0.3 is a deliberate locked-const update.
- **Severity**: P1 (design-choice divergence from deliverable, tested and self-consistent, not blocking).
### P2 (nit): Bearers ValidateGenesis remains a no-op
- **File:line**: `x/bearers/types/types.go:108` (`func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error { return nil }`)
- **Note**: this is CORRECT per spec — P4-02-01 said "DefaultParams/GenesisState unchanged" (bearers is an EXTENSION, not a new module; v0.1's bearers ValidateGenesis was a no-op and the extension adds types, not genesis state). The A-212 upgrade was scoped to NEW modules. Recording as a P2 nit for completeness, not a defect. No action needed.
---
## 4. Grill Binding Decisions Verification (G-001..G-010)
| ID | Decision | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| **G-001** | Correct v0.1 baseline test count: 53 tests / 11 files (not 48) | **APPLIED** | PROJECT.md D-033 line 111: "53 tests across 11 test files (corrected per G-001; not 48)"; RESEARCH.md line 20: "53 tests across 11 test files (not 48)"; RESEARCH.md line 575: "53 tests, 11 files, zero deps". No "48" reference remains as a v0.1 baseline claim. |
| **G-002** | Lexicon assertion tests are NEW in v0.2 (v0.1 has zero); firewall is new work, not inherited | **APPLIED** | RESEARCH.md lines 16-20: "v0.1 is lexicon-clean in practice but has **zero** lexicon test files... The lexicon assertion tests are NEW in v0.2"; PROJECT.md D-032 line 110: "lexicon assertion tests are NEW in v0.2 — v0.1 is lexicon-clean in practice but has NO lexicon test firewall". Code: `lexicon/lexicon.go` + `lexicon_meta_test.go` are new in v0.2; zero lexicon test files exist on `main`. |
| **G-003** | By-ID-string inter-module refs (A-203) enforced as a TESTED invariant in P1-01-02 | **APPLIED** | `x/window/types/types_test.go:437` `TestG003NoCrossModuleStructImportsInProduction` scans every non-test `.go` under `x/` with `go/parser` (ImportsOnly) and asserts no production file imports a foreign `x/<module>/types` package. Test passes (verified: `go test -run TestG003... -v` → PASS). Independent grep confirms zero cross-module struct imports in production code. |
| **G-004** | Lexicon meta-test scaffolding moved from P5 to P1 Wave 3 (new task P1-04-02); P5-01-01 EXTENDS it | **APPLIED** | `lexicon_meta_test.go` exists at repo root with `TestLexiconMetaNoBannedTermsInX`, `TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable`, `TestLexiconMetaBannedTermsCount`, `TestLexiconMetaNoFalsePositiveOnOpenYield`. Package doc (line 1-15) states "the durable firewall created in v0.2 P1 Wave 3; P5-01-01 EXTENDS it rather than recreating it." All 4 meta-tests pass. |
| **G-005** | One `x/pact` module with `PactType` enum + 6 per-type execute-entry structs (A-207), NOT six micro-modules | **APPLIED** | PROJECT.md D-027 line 105: "**one `x/pact` module** with a `PactType` enum... NOT six micro-modules". Code: single `x/pact/types/types.go` with `PactType` enum (6 values) + 6 `Execute*` methods on `*Pact` (`ExecutePause`, `ExecuteGround`, `ExecuteStance`, `ExecuteCover`, `ExecuteStandRegistry`, `ExecuteHubAPI`). No `x/pactpause`, `x/pactground`, etc. dirs exist. |
| **G-006** | `go.mod` is read-only in v0.2 (zero deps, A-201); any change is an escalation | **APPLIED** | `git diff main..oy/milestone/v0.2-mesh -- go.mod` is **EMPTY**. PERSONAS.md lines 9, 33, 65, 83, 114 all state "go.mod is read-only in v0.2 (G-006)". No persona may modify it. |
| **G-007** | `x/pact`/`x/partner`/`x/bond`=backend-engineer; `x/window`/`x/stand`/`x/guild`/`x/council`/`x/satellite`/`x/forex`/`x/bearers`=cosmos-engineer | **APPLIED** | PERSONAS.md line 65 (backend territory): "`x/pact/**`, `x/partner/**`, `x/bond/**`"; line 83 (cosmos territory): "`x/satellite/**`, `x/council/**`, `x/window/**`, `x/stand/**`, `x/guild/**`, `x/forex/**`, `x/bearers/**` (Cosmos-convention-mirroring modules per G-007; `x/pact`/`x/partner`/`x/bond` are backend-engineer's)". Lines 109-111 reiterate the split. No overlap remains. |
| **G-008** | Genesis schema (`genesis.go`)=data-engineer; genesis test assertions (`*_test.go` incl `genesis_test.go`)=security-engineer | **APPLIED** | PERSONAS.md line 14 (data-engineer): "Owns genesis SCHEMA only (G-008); test assertions are security-engineer's"; line 17: "does NOT own *_test.go files (G-008)"; line 41 (security-engineer): "owns ALL *_test.go files including genesis_test.go (G-008)"; line 71 (data-engineer territory): "`x/**/types/genesis.go`, `x/**/genesis.go` (excludes `*_test.go` per G-008)"; line 89 (security-engineer territory): "all test files per G-008". Code: `genesis.go` files present in 7 modules; `genesis_test.go` present in window/stand/bond; all `*_test.go` use `package types_test` (external test package, security-engineer convention). |
| **G-009** | Self-test table in lexicon meta-test (synthetic string per banned term) | **APPLIED** | `lexicon_meta_test.go:83` `TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable` — builds a synthetic string per banned term (10 terms: bank, deposit, interest, yield, currency, dollar, euro, account, savings, depositor) and asserts each triggers detection. Test passes. Also `TestLexiconMetaBannedTermsCount` asserts exactly 10 terms configured. |
| **G-010** | P5-01-03 reconciles ROADMAP.md tag-line narrative (v0.0.x vs v0.1.x) | **N/A** (P5 task, out of P1-P4 review scope) | G-010 is explicitly a P5-01-03 task (ROADMAP tag-line reconciliation). P1-P4 execution phases do not touch ROADMAP.md. The PLANS.md P5-01-03 task description (line 249) still carries the G-010 obligation. Correctly deferred to P5. |
**Grill decisions applied: 9 APPLIED + 1 N/A (G-010 is P5, out of scope) = 9 of 9 applicable.**
---
## 5. Per-Phase Must-Have Audit
### P1 (Orgs + Window Foundation) — ALL MET ✓
- [x] `x/window`, `x/stand`, `x/guild` each have `types/types.go` + `types/types_test.go` (v0.1 pattern, package `types`, zero external deps).
- [x] `go build ./...` and `go test ./...` green across the whole repo.
- [x] ≥80% coverage on `x/window/types` (100%), `x/stand/types` (100%), `x/guild/types` (100%).
- [x] Window lifecycle tests: Open→Active→Revoked→Expired (`TestWindowLifecycleOpenActiveRevokedExpired`); revoke-after-expire no-op (`TestRevokeAfterExpireIsNoOp`); double-revoke idempotent (`TestDoubleRevokeIdempotent`).
- [x] Stand locked-const: exactly 9 types with vision §11 names (`TestStandTypeCountLockedConst`, `TestAllStandTypesNames`).
- [x] Guild `HandPassFeeBps == 0` invariant test (`TestHandPassFeeBpsLockedConst`).
- [x] Lexicon assertion in all 3 new test files.
- [x] `ValidateGenesis` performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212).
- [x] G-003 import-invariant test (`TestG003NoCrossModuleStructImportsInProduction`).
- [x] Lexicon meta-test scaffolding in P1 Wave 3 (G-004) with self-test table (G-009).
- (Tag `v0.1.1` is a ship-time action, not a code must-have — tracked in P1-04-01.)
### P2 (Pacts + Partners) — ALL MET ✓
- [x] `x/pact`, `x/partner` each have `types/types.go` + `types/types_test.go`.
- [x] `go build ./...` and `go test ./...` green.
- [x] ≥80% coverage on `x/pact/types` (95.9%), `x/partner/types` (100%).
- [x] Pact locked-const: exactly 6 types (vision §16 names) (`TestPactTypeCountLockedConst`).
- [x] Partner locked-const: exactly 4 tiers (Op, MasterOp, Pier, Anchor) (`TestPartnerTierCountLockedConst`).
- [x] Mission-Lock invariant: Pause/Ground/Stance `AmendableCoreTerms == false` (`TestMissionLockAmendableConstFalse` + per-type flags).
- [x] Lexicon assertion in both new test files.
- [x] `ValidateGenesis` ID-uniqueness checks (pact: dup pact-id; partner: dup partner-id).
### P3 (Councils + Forex) — ALL MET ✓ (with P1 spec-drift flags on council lifecycle)
- [x] `x/council`, `x/forex` each have `types/types.go` + `types/types_test.go`.
- [x] `go build ./...` and `go test ./...` green.
- [x] ≥80% coverage on `x/council/types` (96.4%), `x/forex/types` (100%).
- [x] Council locked-const: exactly 3 kinds (Mesh, Guild, Stand) (`TestCouncilKindCountLockedConst`).
- [x] **Mission Lock invariant**: `MissionLockAmendable == false` + cannot-be-set-true test (`TestMissionLockAmendableConstFalse`, `TestMissionLockAmendableCannotBeSetTrue`).
- [x] `TallyResult` shape mirrors `x/gov` (yes/no/abstain/nowithveto/total/quorum_met) (`TestTallyResultStructShape`).
- [x] `VoteOption` has no "no-with-veto" — N/A (no VoteOption enum; `TallyResult.NoWithVeto` is always 0, `TestTallyResultNoWithVetoAlwaysZero`).
- [x] Forex pair labels lexicon-clean (base-asset/quote-asset, "Bread"/"Asset" sample) (`TestForexPairStructFields`); `RateOracle` interface compiles (`TestRateOracleInterfaceCompiles`).
- [x] Lexicon assertion in both new test files.
- [x] `ValidateGenesis` ID-uniqueness (council: dup council-id + dup voice-id) + referential integrity (voice→council) (`TestValidateGenesisRejectsVoiceWithUnknownCouncil`).
- [P1 flag] Council `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` enums absent (see §3 P1-1).
- [P1 flag] Council `VoiceSource``SignalKind` (4 not 5) (see §3 P1-2).
### P4 (Bonds + Bearers + L2) — ALL MET ✓
- [x] `x/bond` (new), `x/bearers` (extended), `x/satellite` (new) each have `types/types.go` + `types/types_test.go`.
- [x] `go build ./...` and `go test ./...` green — including all v0.1 baseline tests (no regression across 25 packages).
- [x] ≥80% coverage on `x/bond/types` (96.8%), `x/bearers/types` (100%), `x/satellite/types` (100%).
- [x] Bond clamp invariant: `CouponCapBps == 800`, `CouponFloorBps == 0`; clamp below→floor, above→cap, in-range→unchanged (`TestClampBelowFloorReturnsFloor`, `TestClampAboveCapReturnsCap`, `TestClampInRangeUnchanged`, `TestClampMatchesFeeCovenantShape`).
- [x] Bond lexicon: "coupon" exclusively, no "interest"/"yield" (A-210) — verified by meta-test + per-module lexicon test.
- [x] Bearers: `BearerTransport` interface compiles (`TestBearerTransportInterfaceSignature`); `OYLRLink` + `BeaconFrame` stubs; existing `AllBearers()` (6) unchanged (`TestOYLRStillInAllBearers` — regression green).
- [x] Satellite: `L2Chain` exactly 5 (Polygon active + 4 stubs) (`TestL2ChainCountLockedConst`, `TestPolygonOnlyActiveRep`); `Packet` pinned to ICS-20 v1 shape; zero external deps.
- [x] Lexicon assertion in all 3 test files (bond, bearers, satellite).
- [x] `ValidateGenesis` ID-uniqueness (bond: dup bond-id; satellite: dup channel-id + dup denom) + genesis clamp (Bond: coupon within [floor, cap]).
---
## 6. Overall Verdict
### **APPROVE WITH P1+ FLAGS**
The v0.2 (The Mesh) milestone P1-P4 execution work is **shippable**.
**Rationale:**
- All P1-P4 must-have checklists are met (verified per phase in §5).
- All 13 locked consts/enums are correct (Window 4, Stand 9, Guild 0, Pact 6, Partner 4, Council 3, MissionLock false in pact+council, Bond 800/0, Forex ≥0, Satellite 5+4).
- All ValidateGenesis ID-uniqueness checks present (A-212 upgrade applied to all 9 new modules; bearers extension correctly exempt).
- `go build ./...` and `go test ./...` green across all 25 packages (15 v0.1 + 10 v0.2) — no regression.
- Coverage ≥80% on all 10 new/extended packages (floor 95.9%, 8 of 10 at 100%).
- Lexicon firewall green (zero banned terms in any `x/**/*.go`); G-002 firewall is new and operational.
- G-003 by-ID-string invariant tested and green (zero cross-module struct imports in production).
- go.mod unchanged (G-006 verified — `git diff` empty).
- 9 of 9 applicable grill binding decisions applied (G-010 is P5, N/A for this scope).
- Mission Lock and Bond Clamp invariants are compile-time consts + tested firewalls.
**P1+ flags (2) for post-hoc review — do NOT block the milestone ship:**
1. Council `Proposal`/`ProposalStatus`/`VoteOption` lifecycle enums absent (P3-01-01 deliverable drift; must-haves met; recommend adding for v0.3 live governance wiring).
2. Council `VoiceSource``SignalKind` (4 sources Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital, not 5 with Freeholder/Guild) (P3-01-01 deliverable drift; defensible design choice; locked-const test currently locks the 4-source shape; confirm intended for v0.3).
These are design-shape divergences in a single module's non-must-have lifecycle types. They do not affect the Mission Lock firewall, the locked consts, the lexicon firewall, the by-ID-string invariant, coverage, or any must-have. The orchestrator should review them post-ship and decide whether v0.3 restores the full Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle and the 5-source VoiceSource.
**P0 fixes auto-applied: 0**
**P1+ flags: 2** (both in x/council/types)
**P2 nits: 1** (bearers ValidateGenesis no-op — correct per spec, no action)
**Grill decisions applied: 9 APPLIED + 1 N/A (G-010 is P5) = 9 of 9 applicable**
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.88**
---
## Summary Block
```
Per-axis verdicts:
1. Correctness — PASS (0.90) [all locked consts correct; council lifecycle drift is P1]
2. Security — PASS (0.92) [lexicon green; G-003 tested; Mission Lock + Bond Clamp const-enforced]
3. Maintainability — PASS (0.90) [v0.1 pattern; coverage ≥95.9%; go.mod unchanged; G-008 split clean]
4. Adversarial — CONDITIONAL (0.78) [council Proposal/VoteOption + VoiceSource→SignalKind drift; no must-have missing]
5. Grill Decisions — 9 APPLIED + 1 N/A (G-010 P5)
P0 fixes auto-applied: 0
P1+ flags: 2 (x/council/types — Proposal/VoteOption lifecycle absent; VoiceSource→SignalKind 4-not-5)
P2 nits: 1 (bearers ValidateGenesis no-op — correct per spec)
Overall: APPROVE WITH P1+ FLAGS (confidence 0.88) — milestone ship not blocked
```
---
## v0.3 Final Review (P6)
**Reviewer:** Multi-persona final review (correctness, testing, security, performance, maintainability, adversarial)
**Scope:** `v0.1.5..HEAD` — all v0.3 milestone phases (P0 pre-exec + P1 docs foundation + P2 nomads docs + P3 freeholders docs + P4 Bearers I + P5 Bearers II)
**Branch:** `oy/milestone/v0.3-bearers-docs` (reviewed on `oy/phase/06-final-review-ship`)
**Date:** 2026-08-17
**Diff stat:** 56 files changed, 6891 insertions(+), 169 deletions(-)
### Verification commands (all PASS)
```
go build ./... — PASS (zero errors)
go test ./... — PASS (all packages green)
go test -cover ./x/{bridge,exit,bearers,partner,hub,services,bond}/types/ — PASS (coverage below)
go test -run TestLexiconMeta ./lexicon_meta_docs/ . — PASS (docs firewall green)
go test -run TestLexiconMeta ./ — PASS (x/ firewall green, repo-root package)
```
### Coverage on new/extended packages
| Package | Coverage | Threshold (80%) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| x/bridge/types | 100.0% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/exit/types | 100.0% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/bearers/types | 100.0% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/partner/types | 100.0% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/hub/types | 93.3% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/services/types | 100.0% | ✓ | PASS |
| x/bond/types | 95.1% | ✓ | PASS |
All packages exceed the ≥80% coverage requirement. The two sub-100% packages (hub 93.3%, bond 95.1%) have gaps only in defensive genesis error-branches (e.g., `validateComplianceServices` 87.5%, `Clamp`/`ClampLendingCoupon` 80% — the upper-bound and floor branches each exercised by ≥1 test but not every permutation). No must-have is uncovered; G-012 boundary cases (`currentBps==cap`, `currentBps>cap`, underflow guard) are all explicitly tested (`TestClampGrowthCurrentAtCapReturnsZero`, `TestClampGrowthCurrentAboveCapReturnsZero`, `TestClampGrowthInvariantPostGrowthLeCap`).
### Per-axis verdicts
#### 1. Correctness (backend-engineer) — PASS (0.92)
Locked-const invariants all enforced and tested:
- `BridgeStatusCount = 4` (x/bridge/types/types.go:18) — `AllBridgeStatuses()` returns 4 in REQ-015 order. ✓
- `ExitStatusCount = 5` (x/exit/types/types.go:18) — `AllExitStatuses()` returns 5 in vision §7 order. ✓
- `HubServiceCount = 3` (x/hub/types/types.go:42) — `AllHubServices()` returns 3 (Custody/LendingPrimitive/Compliance). ✓
- `ServiceKindCount = 4` (x/services/types/types.go:37) — locked count asserted. ✓
- `OrderSideCount = 2` (x/bond/types/types.go:171) — Buy/Sell. ✓
- `OrderStatusCount = 3` (x/bond/types/types.go:174) — Open/Filled/Cancelled. ✓
- `PartnerTierCount = 4` (x/partner/types/types.go:18) — regression intact. ✓
- `BondStatusCount = 5` (x/bond/types/types.go:31) — regression intact. ✓
- `CouponCapBps = 800` / `CouponFloorBps = 0` (x/bond/types/types.go:21,26) — D-028 LOCKED, regression firewall in types_test.go asserts both values. ✓
**G-012 (ClampGrowth underflow guard) — CORRECT.** The guard at x/bond/types/types.go:239 (`if currentBps >= CouponCapBps { return 0 }`) runs BEFORE the `CouponCapBps - currentBps` subtraction (line 243), so the uint32 underflow path is unreachable. Five boundary/invariant tests cover: currentBps==0 (full room), currentBps==cap (return 0), currentBps>cap (return 0, NOT wrapped huge), growth>room (clamp to room), growth<room (unchanged), and a meta-assert `current + ClampGrowth(current, growth) <= max(current, cap)` across a fuzz table.
The hub `LendingCouponCapBps`/`LendingCouponFloorBps` LOCAL consts (A-304) mirror x/bond's LOCKED values (800/0) without importing x/bond (G-003 preserved). Genesis-side clamp enforcement present in both `validateLendingPrimitives` (hub) and `ValidateBonds`/`ValidateGrowthBonds` (bond).
#### 2. Testing (backend-engineer) — PASS (0.90)
All new packages ≥93.3% (above 80% threshold). Per-package lexicon assertions present in every new package's types_test.go (TestLexiconNoBannedTermsIn<Pkg>Package + TestLexiconNoBannedTermsIn<Pkg>TestFile) — confirmed in x/bridge, x/exit, x/bearers, x/partner, x/hub, x/services, x/bond. G-012 boundary cases (currentBps==cap, currentBps>cap) explicitly tested. Locked-const regression tests present (Test<Const>LockedConst pattern) for every locked const enumerated above.
#### 3. Security (security) — PASS (0.93)
Both lexicon firewalls green:
- x/ firewall (`lexicon_meta_test.go`, package `lexicon_meta`): `go test -run TestLexiconMeta ./` PASS.
- docs/ firewall (`lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`, package `lexicon_meta_docs`): `go test -run TestLexiconMeta ./lexicon_meta_docs/` PASS. Scans README.md + docs/**/*.md.
Adversarial verification: confirmed `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` catches all 10 banned terms (bank, deposit, interest, yield, currency, dollar, euro, account, savings, depositor) via direct injection test. The docs firewall self-test table (G-009 for docs), walk-coverage test (G-013), and self-test drift assertion (G-014) all present and passing — the firewall provably CATCHES banned-term regressions rather than silently scanning nothing.
**G-003 (by-ID-string, no struct imports between x/*) — INTACT.** `grep -rn "oy/openyield/x/"` across all new package non-test .go files returns ZERO struct imports. The only cross-package import in a test file is `x/bearers/types/types_test.go` importing `x/processing/types` (a test-only import for a stub reference; G-003 governs production struct imports, not test imports). All cross-module references in production types use ID-string fields (issuer-stand-id, reach-id, holder-reach-id, custody-provider-id, anchor-id, bond-id, operator-partner-id, etc.) with explicit G-003 doc-comments.
#### 4. Performance (backend-engineer) — PASS (0.95)
`go.mod` UNCHANGED since v0.1.5 (`git diff v0.1.5..HEAD -- go.mod go.sum` is empty) — zero external deps preserved (G-006). The mkdocs build deps (mkdocs + mkdocs-material) are Python-only and documented as non-Go (mkdocs.yml header comment). Skeleton stubs use O(1) maps for registry lookups (x/partner Keeper); no N+1 patterns in the stub code. The genesis validators iterate slices once (O(n) per set) with map-backed uniqueness checks — appropriate for skeleton scale.
#### 5. Maintainability (lead-developer) — PASS (0.91)
**Pattern consistency:** All new modules follow the v0.1/v0.2 file structure (types.go + types_test.go, genesis.go where genesis validation exists). The Params/GenesisState/DefaultGenesisState/ValidateGenesis pattern is uniform across x/bridge, x/exit, x/bearers, x/partner, x/hub, x/services, x/bond. G-008 split (data-engineer's genesis.go schema helpers composed by ValidateGenesis in types.go) is present in x/bond and x/hub. The new modules use the same ModuleName/StoreKey/RouterKey/QuerierRoute const block and the same JSON/YAML struct-tag convention as v0.1/v0.2 modules.
**Docs cross-reference (G-011):** `mkdocs.yml` nav lists ALL 26 pages (1 Home + 8 Nomads + 8 Freeholders + 7 Shared + 2 Reference = 26), matching the 26 .md files under docs/. `docs/reference/components.md` cross-references the new modules (10 mentions of x/* packages). All docs pages are lexicon-clean (firewall green).
**.ciagent/oy/* updates:** PROJECT, ROADMAP, REQUIREMENTS, ARCHITECTURE, RESEARCH, PERSONAS, PLANS, GRILL all updated to reflect v0.3 scope (Bearers & Documentation, REQ-024..REQ-028, D-037..D-046, A-304..A-313, G-011..G-014).
#### 6. Adversarial (adversarial) — PASS (0.88)
Adversarial probes attempted and their outcomes:
1. **Banned term slipped into docs** — the firewall self-test table (`TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable`, G-009 for docs) injects synthetic banned-term strings and asserts FindBannedTerm detects each; the walk-coverage test (`TestLexiconMetaDocsWalkCoverage`, G-013) injects a real .md fixture under docs/.lexicon_fixture/ and asserts the walk FINDS it. Catches the "silently scans nothing and reports green" failure mode. ✓
2. **Locked-const regression** — every locked const has a `Test<Const>LockedConst` regression test asserting the exact value AND the All<Enum>() entry count/names. A regression (e.g., BridgeStatusCount→5) fails the test. ✓
3. **Struct import breaks G-003** — no production .go file in the new packages imports another x/* package; verified by grep. ✓
4. **ClampGrowth underflow** — the guard returns 0 BEFORE the subtraction; the underflow path is unreachable; tested with currentBps>cap (e.g., 801) asserting return 0 (NOT 4294967295). ✓
5. **Hub A-304 drift from x/bond D-028** — the LOCAL consts are documented as cross-referenced (comment "also 800") and a regression test asserts LendingCouponCapBps==800. A future x/bond cap change without a matching hub change is flagged by the cross-doc comment (not a test — appropriate since they are LOCAL to hub). Note P2 below.
### P0 fixes auto-applied
**0.** No P0 (critical) issues found. The milestone ships clean.
### P1+ flags (post-hoc review — do NOT block ship)
**1.** [P2 nit, maintainability] x/hub `LendingCouponCapBps`/`LendingCouponFloorBps` (A-304) are LOCAL consts cross-documented to x/bond's D-028 consts (both 800/0) but there is no automated cross-check that they stay in lockstep. If a future mission-locked change to x/bond.CouponCapBps does not update the hub LOCAL const, the two packages silently drift. The cross-doc comment in types.go:46-50 flags this for human review, but a shared-const test (e.g., asserting `LendingCouponCapBps == x/bond.CouponCapBps` — though that would require a test-only import, acceptable per G-003 test exemption) would be more robust. Recommend post-hoc: add a cross-package const-equality test OR document the manual-sync requirement in ARCHITECTURE.md. Not a ship blocker — both are currently 800/0.
**2.** [P2 nit, testing] x/hub coverage 93.3% and x/bond coverage 95.1% leave defensive error-branches in `ClampLendingCoupon` (80%), `Clamp` (80%), `validateComplianceServices` (87.5%), `ValidateGrowthBonds` (85.7%) partially exercised. All must-have paths are tested; the uncovered lines are error-return branches for malformed genesis inputs. Recommend post-hoc: add 2-3 negative-case genesis tests per package to close the gaps to 100%. Not a ship blocker (both above the 80% threshold).
**3.** [P2 nit, docs] `docs/reference/architecture.md` has 0 cross-references to x/* packages (vs `docs/reference/components.md` which has 10). The architecture page is conceptual; the components page is the cross-ref hub. Acceptable as-is, but post-hoc adding 1-2 module cross-refs to architecture.md would improve discoverability. Not a ship blocker.
### Overall verdict
**SHIP.**
All verification commands pass. All locked-const invariants enforced and tested. Both lexicon firewalls green (x/ and docs/). G-003 (by-ID-string, no struct imports) intact across all new packages. G-012 (ClampGrowth underflow guard) correctly implemented with explicit boundary tests. Zero external deps (go.mod unchanged). Coverage ≥93.3% on all new/extended packages (above 80% threshold). mkdocs.yml nav complete (26/26 pages, G-011). No P0 issues. Three P2 nits flagged for post-hoc review (none blocking).
**P0 fixes auto-applied: 0**
**P1+ findings: 0 P1, 3 P2 (all nits, post-hoc, non-blocking)**
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.91**
---
# Review: OpenYield (oy) — v0.4 (Refinement — NFR) Final Phase
> **Reviewer**: CIAgent multi-persona code review (lead-developer + backend-engineer lenses)
> **Date**: 2026-08-17
> **Target**: All v0.4 milestone commits (main..oy/milestone/v0.4-refinement) across P1..P3
> **Milestone**: v0.4 — Refinement (NFR)
> **Autonomy**: full
## Scope Reviewed
The v0.4 milestone ships 4 REQs across 3 execution phases (P1..P3) + phase 0 (pre-execution). 20 commits, 15 files changed (+764 / -157). The review covers the execution-phase deliverables:
- **P1** (v0.3.1): REQ-029 lexicon shared helper, REQ-030 cross-const test
- **P2** (v0.3.2): REQ-031 lifecycle divergence docs + regression guard
- **P3** (v0.3.3): REQ-032 docs build CI
## Adversarial Probes
1. **Does the shared helper actually dedupe?** Probe: `grep -rn 'open a.*here\|make a.*now\|compounding.*rate' lexicon_meta_test.go lexicon_meta_docs/` — returns ZERO matches (the old duplicated table is gone; both meta-tests now call `lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings()`). Verified at `lexicon_meta_test.go:93` and `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go:155` (both consume the helper). ✓
2. **Does the cross-const test fail closed on drift?** Probe: the test imports `bondtypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/bond/types"` in `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go:28` and asserts `LendingCouponCapBps != bondtypes.CouponCapBps` would fail the test. The absolute-value test `TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0` (G-015) catches paired drift (both consts → 900). Both paths verified by reading the test. ✓
3. **Does the regression guard lock the 4-signal shape?** Probe: `TestSignalKindShapeIntentional` at `x/council/types/types_test.go` asserts `SignalKindCount == 4` with a `t.Fatalf` (not `t.Errorf`) and checks `AllSignalKinds()` returns `[SignalStash, SignalStanding, SignalVouch, SignalCapital]` in order. The doc comment includes the AUDIT §193 P1-2 rationale. Changing `SignalKindCount` to 5 fails this test AND `TestSignalKindCountLockedConst`. ✓
4. **Does the CI workflow YAML parse and enforce G-016?** Probe: `python3 -c "import yaml; doc=yaml.safe_load(open('.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml')); assert doc['jobs']['docs-build']['needs'] == 'go-test'"` — passes. The `needs: go-test` line is present at `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml` in the `docs-build` job. ✓
5. **Is `go.mod` really unchanged across the whole milestone?** Probe: `git diff main..HEAD -- go.mod` — empty. The CI workflow's Python deps are in a separate job; the lexicon helper adds no Go deps; the cross-const test adds no Go deps (test-only import of an internal package). G-006 intact. ✓
6. **NFR purity gate — zero `feat:` commit SUBJECTS?** Probe: `git log --format="%s" main..HEAD | grep -E "^feat:"` — exit 1 (no matches). All 20 subjects are `docs(`, `refactor(`, `test(`, `chore(`, `verify(`, `decision(`, `checkpoint(`, or `Merge`. NOTE: `git log --grep "^feat:"` matches commit BODIES too (the v0.4 verify commits mention "feat:" in prose like "zero feat: commits in P2"); the correct gate uses subject-only check via `--format="%s"`. This is a documented refinement for the audit. ✓
7. **Does G-003 hold — no production cross-module struct imports added?** Probe: `grep -rn "x/bond/types" x/hub/types/ --include="*.go" | grep -v "_test.go"` — zero matches. The only import of `x/bond/types` in `x/hub/types/` is in `cross_const_test.go` (a `_test.go` file, G-003 test-exempt). Production firewall intact. ✓
## P0 fixes auto-applied
**0.** No P0 (critical) issues found. The milestone ships clean.
## P1+ flags (post-hoc review — do NOT block ship)
**1.** [P2 nit, maintainability] The `mkdocs build` local run produced 2 warnings about README.md links (`docs/index.md` links to `../README.md`, `docs/shared/vision.md` links to `../../README.md`). These are pre-existing v0.3 docs links (not introduced by v0.4); the warnings are non-blocking (mkdocs builds successfully). Recommend post-hoc: either configure `mkdocs.yml` to include README.md in the nav, or fix the relative links. Not a v0.4 ship blocker (the docs site builds; v0.4's REQ-032 is the CI workflow, not the docs content).
**2.** [P2 nit, CI] The `docs-build.yml` workflow uses `actions/upload-artifact@v4` with `retention-days: 14`. Gitea Actions may have a different artifact retention default; the explicit `retention-days: 14` is defensive. If Gitea Actions does not support v4 of the upload-artifact action, the workflow would fail at the upload step (the `mkdocs build` itself would have succeeded). Recommend post-hoc: verify Gitea Actions supports `actions/upload-artifact@v4`; if not, downgrade to v3 or use the Gitea-native artifact upload. Not a ship blocker (the build itself is the higher-priority check; the artifact upload is a bonus).
**3.** [P2 nit, audit-gate precision] The NFR purity gate (`git log --grep "^feat:"`) over-matches commit bodies. The correct gate is subject-only (`git log --format="%s" | grep -E "^feat:"`). The P4 audit uses the subject-only check. Recommend post-hoc: document the subject-only gate in the next milestone's PLAN so future audits do not over-count. Not a ship blocker (the subject-only gate is green).
## Overall verdict
**SHIP.**
All four REQs (REQ-029..REQ-032) delivered. The three real v0.3 forward-references (G-014 lexicon drift, A-304 const drift, AUDIT §193 council divergence) are closed; the D-046 docs-CI forward-reference is landed. `go test ./...` green across all 26 packages. `go.mod` unchanged (G-006). G-003 production firewall intact. NFR purity gate GREEN (zero `feat:` commit subjects). No P0 issues. Three P2 nits flagged for post-hoc review (none blocking).
**P0 fixes auto-applied: 0**
**P1+ findings: 0 P1, 3 P2 (all nits, post-hoc, non-blocking)**
**Confidence in overall verdict: 0.90**
+102 -30
View File
@@ -14,44 +14,116 @@
- Status: COMPLETE (local-only ship, no remote configured)
- MVP release (v0.1.0) deferred until system validated as production-ready
## Phase 1 — Foundation (Year 1)
**Target**: first 10,000 Holders, 50 Master Ops
## Milestone v0.2 — The Mesh (COMPLETE)
- [x] P0: Pre-Execution → v0.1.0
- [x] P1: Orgs + Window Foundation → v0.1.1
- [x] P2: Pacts + Partners → v0.1.2
- [x] P3: Councils + Forex → v0.1.3
- [x] P4: Bonds + Bearers + L2 → v0.1.4
- [x] P5: Final Review + Ship → v0.1.5 (milestone release)
- Status: COMPLETE (skeleton + tests layer; released as v0.1.5)
| Component | Deliverable |
|---|---|
| OY Chain & Mirror (1) | L1 chain launched, 9 Watchers bonded, Mirror live |
| Bread Unit & Root Basket (3) | Forge/Fold on Ethereum + 23 L2s; initial Root Basket |
| Storage Substrate (5) | Stash, Vault, Root-Pool contracts |
| Bloom Engine (4) | Bloom accrual loop tied to Mirror attestations |
| Fee Covenant (13) | 0.1% ceiling live, processor share 50%, internal minimum 1 Grain |
| Identity, Standing & Citizenship (6) | Reach v1, Standing v1, Nomad/Freeholder system |
| Bearers & Processing Mesh (12) | Processing v1, OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct |
| Mesh Experience (9) | Maps, Pay v1 |
## Milestone v0.3 — Bearers & Documentation (COMPLETE; feature type; tags v0.2.x)
Target: Bearers skeleton (ROADMAP Phase 3 subset) + docs site for nomads and freeholders.
## Phase 2 — The Mesh (Year 2)
**Target**: $1B annual volume, 4 service categories
- [x] P0: Pre-Execution (spec/clarify/research/ideate/plan/grill) → v0.2.0
- [x] P1: Docs foundation + REQ-012 firewall extension → v0.2.1
- [x] P2: Nomads docs → v0.2.2
- [x] P3: Freeholders docs + reference → v0.2.3 (REQ-027 complete)
- [x] P4: Bearers skeleton I (x/exit, x/bridge, x/bearers, x/partner) → v0.2.4
- [x] P5: Bearers skeleton II (x/hub, x/services, x/bond) → v0.2.5
- [x] P6: Final Review + Audit + Ship → v0.2.6 (milestone release)
- Status: COMPLETE — Bearers skeleton (7 x/* packages) + docs site (26 pages) shipped
| Component | Deliverable |
|---|---|
| Organizational Primitives (10) | 9 Stand types, Guilds (Hand-Passes free) |
| Partner Spectrum & Forex (11) | First Piers, Forex Engine v1 |
| Window Primitive (7) | Holder-authorized data channels |
| Pacts Suite (8) | Pause, Ground, Stance, Cover, Stand Registry |
| Governance (14) | Mesh Council activated |
| Bearers expansion | OY-LR + Beacon v1 |
| Bonds | First Mesh Bonds |
> v0.3 bundles two work-streams under one feature milestone: (A) Bearers
> skeleton+tests (D-020 pattern) and (B) README.md + MkDocs Material docs site
> organized by audience, with the REQ-012 lexicon firewall extended to docs.
## Phase 3 — The Bearers (Year 3)
| Phase | Type | Scope | Patch |
|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | docs | Pre-Execution (spec/clarify/research/ideate/plan/grill) | v0.2.0 |
| P1 | feat/test+docs | Docs foundation + REQ-012 firewall extension to docs/ + README.md + shared docs | v0.2.1 |
| P2 | docs | Nomads docs (docs/nomads/) | v0.2.2 |
| P3 | docs | Freeholders docs (docs/freeholders/) + docs/reference/ | v0.2.3 |
| P4 | feat | Bearers skeleton I: x/exit, x/bridge, x/bearers (OY-SAT, OY-QR), x/partner (Anchor) | v0.2.4 |
| P5 | feat | Bearers skeleton II: x/hub, x/services, x/bond (Growth Bonds + secondary market) | v0.2.5 |
| P6 | final | REVIEW + AUDIT + milestone SHIP | v0.2.6 (milestone release) |
### v0.3 Component mapping
| Component | Deliverable | v0.3 Skeleton Module | Phase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cross-Chain & Exit (2) | L2/L1 bridge types, DEX swap types | x/exit, x/bridge | v0.3/P4 |
| Bearers expansion | OY-SAT, OY-QR bearer transport types | x/bearers (extended) | v0.3/P4 |
| Anchors | First institutional Partner tier | x/partner (extended: Anchor) | v0.3/P4 |
| Hub API | B2B backbone: custody, lending primitive, compliance types | x/hub | v0.3/P5 |
| Services | Care / SIM / Vault / Mail service types | x/services | v0.3/P5 |
| Bond market | Growth Bonds, secondary-market types | x/bond (extended) | v0.3/P5 |
| Documentation | README.md + MkDocs Material docs site | docs/, mkdocs.yml, README.md | v0.3/P1-P3 |
| Lexicon firewall | Extend REQ-012 to docs/ + README.md | lexicon_meta_docs_test.go | v0.3/P1 |
> **Tag-line note (G-010 continuation)**: v0.1 pre-MVP shipped on the `v0.0.x`
> patch line; v0.2 (The Mesh) shipped on the `v0.1.x` patch line; v0.3 (Bearers
> & Documentation) ships on the `v0.2.x` patch line (config.json `tag_base:
> v0.2.x`): P0 -> `v0.2.0`, P1..P5 -> `v0.2.1..v0.2.5`, P6 -> `v0.2.6`
> (= the v0.3 milestone release, per D-008 — final phase patch IS the
> milestone release; no separate minor tag).
## Milestone v0.4 — Refinement (COMPLETE; NFR type; tags v0.3.x)
Target: Close the v0.3 post-hoc forward-references (lexicon firewall drift,
hub↔bond const drift, council lifecycle type divergence) + land the deferred
docs build CI. Refinement-only NFR milestone: zero `feat:` phases.
- [x] P0: Pre-Execution (spec/clarify/research/plan/grill/mvp-ux) → v0.3.0
- [x] P1: Lexicon + const hardening (REQ-029, REQ-030) → v0.3.1
- [x] P2: Lifecycle divergence docs + regression guard (REQ-031) → v0.3.2
- [x] P3: Docs build CI (REQ-032) → v0.3.3
- [x] P4: Final Review + Audit + Ship → v0.3.4 (milestone release)
- Status: COMPLETE — 4 NFR REQs shipped; NFR purity gate GREEN (zero feat: commits); go.mod unchanged
> v0.4 closes three real v0.3 forward-references (GRILL G-014 lexicon helper,
> REVIEW P2/A-304 cross-const test, AUDIT §193 council divergence docs) and
> lands the D-046 docs-CI forward-reference. Live-runtime promotions of the
> v0.3 Bearers skeletons are deferred to v0.5+ (feat:-class, rejected by the
> D-001 refinement-only filter).
| Phase | Type | Scope | Patch |
|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | docs | Pre-Execution (spec/clarify/research/plan/grill/mvp-ux) | v0.3.0 |
| P1 | refactor+test | Lexicon shared helper (REQ-029) + cross-const test (REQ-030) | v0.3.1 |
| P2 | docs+test | Council lifecycle divergence docs (REQ-031) + regression guard | v0.3.2 |
| P3 | chore+ci | Docs build CI workflow (REQ-032) | v0.3.3 |
| P4 | final | REVIEW + AUDIT + milestone SHIP | v0.3.4 (milestone release) |
### v0.4 Component mapping
| Component | Deliverable | v0.4 Change | Phase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lexicon firewall | Shared `SyntheticBannedStrings()` helper | `lexicon/lexicon.go` + both meta-tests refactored | v0.4/P1 |
| Mission-locked const firewall | Cross-package const-equality test | `x/hub/types/cross_const_test.go` (NEW) | v0.4/P1 |
| Council Voice/Council interface | Lifecycle divergence documentation + regression guard | ARCHITECTURE.md section + `x/council/types/types_test.go` intent test | v0.4/P2 |
| Docs CI | Gitea Actions workflow (build + artifact) | `.gitea/workflows/docs-build.yml` (NEW) | v0.4/P3 |
> **Tag-line note (G-010 continuation)**: v0.4 (NFR) ships on the `v0.3.x`
> patch line (config.json `tag_base: v0.3.x`): P0 -> `v0.3.0`, P1..P3 ->
> `v0.3.1..v0.3.3`, P4 -> `v0.3.4` (= the v0.4 milestone release, per D-008 —
> final phase patch IS the milestone release; no separate minor tag).
## Phase 3 — The Bearers (Year 3) — v0.3 PARTIAL SKELETON
**Target**: $10B annual volume → fee auto-declines to 0.07%
> v0.3 ships a skeleton+tests subset of Phase 3 (Cross-Chain/Exit, OY-SAT/OY-QR,
> Anchors, Hub API, Services, Bond market depth). Full runtime deferred to v0.4+.
| Component | Deliverable |
|---|---|
| Cross-Chain & Exit (2) | Full L2/L1 bridges, DEX integration |
| Bearers expansion | OY-SAT, OY-QR |
| Hub API | B2B backbone: custody, lending primitive, compliance |
| Anchors | First institutional partners |
| Services | Care / SIM / Vault / Mail |
| Bond market | Full market, Growth Bonds |
| Cross-Chain & Exit (2) | Full L2/L1 bridges, DEX integration (runtime deferred to v0.4) |
| Bearers expansion | OY-SAT, OY-QR (skeleton types in v0.3) |
| Hub API | B2B backbone: custody, lending primitive, compliance (skeleton types in v0.3) |
| Anchors | First institutional partners (skeleton types in v0.3) |
| Services | Care / SIM / Vault / Mail (skeleton types in v0.3) |
| Bond market | Full market, Growth Bonds (skeleton types in v0.3) |
## Phase 4 — Maturity (Years 45+)
**Target**: $50100B volume → fees auto-decline to 0.03%
+55
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
# OpenYield docs build CI (REQ-032, D-046 forward-reference, D-051, G-016).
#
# Runs the lexicon firewall (go test ./...) AND builds the MkDocs Material docs
# site on every push. The docs-build job DEPENDS on go-test (G-016 binding:
# firewall-gates-docs-build — a lexicon violation blocks the docs build so no
# false-green docs artifact is produced from a repo with a firewall failure).
#
# Scope (chore, not feat: per D-001 refinement-only filter):
# - go-test job: setup Go 1.22, run `go test ./...` (lexicon firewall + all
# x/* tests + the v0.4 cross-const test). Zero external Go deps (G-006).
# - docs-build job: setup Python, pip install mkdocs + mkdocs-material
# (build-only Python deps, ISOLATED to this job — go.mod is NOT modified),
# run `mkdocs build` (produces site/), upload site/ as a CI artifact.
#
# Out of scope (deferred per D-051): full Gitea Pages publishing. v0.4 ships
# build + artifact only; a hosting target is not configured.
#
# Triggers: on push (all branches) so the firewall + docs build are checked
# on every change, not just on main.
name: docs-build
on:
push:
jobs:
go-test:
name: go test ./... (lexicon firewall + all x/* tests)
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v4
- uses: actions/setup-go@v5
with:
go-version: '1.22'
- name: go test ./...
run: go test ./...
docs-build:
name: mkdocs build (docs site artifact)
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
needs: go-test # G-016: firewall-gates-docs-build (no false-green docs build)
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v4
- uses: actions/setup-python@v5
with:
python-version: '3.11'
- name: install mkdocs + mkdocs-material
run: pip install mkdocs mkdocs-material
- name: mkdocs build
run: mkdocs build
- name: upload site/ artifact
uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
with:
name: docs-site
path: site/
retention-days: 14
+2
View File
@@ -2,3 +2,5 @@
.env.secrets
.env.*
.ciagent/.env.secrets
# MkDocs build output (REQ-032 CI produces site/ as an artifact; never commit it)
site/
+83
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
# OpenYield
OpenYield is a jurisdiction-light, public-good mesh for **real production** — a
protocol organized around Holders, Stands, and the Six Principles, designed to
hold real value without the words or the shapes that invite capture. The mesh
runs on OY Chain (Layer 1), a canonical state layer for the Bread unit, the
Storage Pools (Stash, Vault, Root-Pool), Standing, Watcher attestations, and
the Pact / Council / Partner surface. It is anti-greed by construction: Mission
Lock fixes the Six Principles and fee covenant so no council can amend them,
and the 8% coupon cap on bonds is a mission-locked ceiling, not a parameter.
## The Six Principles
1. **Real value** — the mesh holds real production, not speculation.
2. **Sustainability** — fees are floored and capped; the protocol cannot drain its users.
3. **Mission-lock** — the Six Principles and fee covenant are immutable; no council can amend them.
4. **Openness** — anyone may join; the mesh is a public good.
5. **Ownership** — Holders own their Stash and their Reach; custody is theirs.
6. **Self-service** — a Holder can act without a custodian; the mesh is jurisdiction-light.
## Bread unit & scale
The unit of value is **Bread**, scaled in 11 tiers: **Grain → Crumb → Bread →
Loaf → Batch → Cake → Bakery → Granary → Mill → Harvest → Earth.**
## Status
**v0.3 (Bearers & Documentation) — in progress.** The codebase is a skeleton +
tests layer (Go types + keeper stubs + invariant tests, zero external Go deps)
matching the v0.1/v0.2 pre-MVP pattern. See `.ciagent/oy/ROADMAP.md` for the
phase plan and `.ciagent/oy/PROJECT.md` for governance.
## Build & test
OpenYield is pure Go with **zero external dependencies** (`go.mod` has no
`require` lines; `go 1.22`). From the repo root:
```sh
go build ./...
go test ./...
```
## Docs
The docs site is [MkDocs Material](https://squidfunk.github.io/mkdocs-material/)
(a build-only Python dep; **not** a Go dep — `go.mod` is unchanged). To
preview locally:
```sh
mkdocs serve
# or build to a static site/ dir:
mkdocs build
```
The site lives under `docs/` (see `mkdocs.yml` for the nav). Publishing CI is
deferred to v0.4 (D-046); v0.3 ships the source.
## Lexicon firewall
OpenYield bans 10 financial terms as standalone words (REQ-012) across all Go
source (`x/**/*.go`) and all docs (`README.md` + `docs/**/*.md`). The banned
terms are the words you would expect a legacy financial institution to use;
this README and the docs describe them only by their **safe replacements**, so
the firewall itself never trips. The firewall is enforced in code by two
sibling Go tests:
- `lexicon_meta_test.go` (v0.2) — scans `x/**/*.go`.
- `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` (v0.3) — scans `README.md` +
`docs/**/*.md`.
Both use `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` (word-boundary, case-insensitive), so
"OpenYield" is safe (word-boundary does not match the banned term inside an
identifier) but the standalone banned term is not — docs say **"real
production"** / **"real return"**, and a Holder's identity is **Holder** /
**Reach**, never the banned word for a custodial position. See
`docs/shared/lexicon.md` for the glossary of safe replacements.
## Governance
- `.ciagent/oy/PROJECT.md` — full vision, decisions (D-0xx), assumptions.
- `.ciagent/oy/PLANS.md` — phase plans (v0.1, v0.2, v0.3).
- `.ciagent/oy/REQUIREMENTS.md` — REQ coverage matrix.
- `.ciagent/oy/ROADMAP.md` — release roadmap.
+47
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
# Anchor Preview
An **Anchor** (REQ-023) is the fourth and highest tier of the
[Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md) (REQ-018) — the first **institutional**
Partner tier. Anchors are coming in v0.3 P4. This page previews what an Anchor
is and what the v0.3 skeleton will deliver; the runtime behavior is deferred
to v0.4+.
## What an Anchor is
An Anchor is a Partner that carries an **AnchorCredential**: a jurisdiction
(e.g., "EU-MiCA"), a custody provider, and a set of attestation references.
The Anchor tier is how the jurisdiction-light mesh interfaces with
jurisdiction-bound institutional actors without becoming them. An Anchor
holds a credential; the [Holder](../nomads/reach.md) still holds their
[Stash](../nomads/stash.md). The mesh says **custody**, **compliance**, and
**jurisdiction** — never the legacy institutional words banned by the
[lexicon](../shared/lexicon.md).
## What is coming in v0.3 P4
v0.3 P4 (REQ-023) extends `x/partner` with the `AnchorCredential` struct and
a `Partner.AnchorCredential()` accessor (returns nil for non-Anchor tiers).
The four-tier `PartnerTier` enum (Op, Master Op, Pier, Anchor) is **unchanged**
— v0.3 adds Anchor-specific fields, not a new tier. The custody-provider-id
field is a by-ID-string reference to `x/hub` (the Hub API, coming in v0.3 P5),
empty in the v0.3 skeleton because the Hub is not live until P5/v0.4. This is
the P4→P5 ordering edge: `x/hub` in P5 references Anchor partner-ids from P4.
## Why Anchors matter to a Freeholder
A Freeholder engaging an Anchor gets a Partner with a verifiable credential
and a custody/compliance relationship — useful for cross-jurisdiction routes
and institutional [bonds](bonds.md). The Anchor's [Standing](standing.md) and
attestations are visible so the Freeholder can verify the Anchor is real
before opening a [Window](../nomads/window.md). See
[Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md) for the other three tiers, and
[Councils & Voice](councils-voice.md) for how the Mesh Council can suspend or
revoke an Anchor.
## What v0.3 does not deliver
The v0.3 skeleton is types + tests only (D-035): the `AnchorCredential`
struct, the accessor, and the `ListAnchors()` keeper alias. Live custody
routing, attestation verification, and the Hub API integration are v0.4+
runtime work. See [Components](../reference/components.md) for the full
module map.
+46
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
# Bonds
A **Mesh Bond** (REQ-021, vision §17) is a [Stand](stands-guilds.md)-issued
instrument that pays a **coupon** to its holder over a term and returns the
principal at maturity. The coupon is bounded by a **mission-locked cap and
floor**: 8% upper cap, 0% floor (locked `CouponCapBps = 800` and
`CouponFloorBps = 0` in `x/bond`). The cap exists so the mesh cannot become a
speculative market; the floor exists so the coupon cannot go negative.
## The coupon clamp
The coupon is clamped to `[floor, cap]` by the `Clamp` helper in `x/bond`
(same shape as the [Fee Covenant](../shared/six-principles.md) clamp): a
coupon above 8% is reduced to 8%; a coupon below 0% is raised to 0%; a coupon
in range is unchanged. The clamp is a tested invariant: below floor → floor,
above cap → cap, in range → unchanged. This is the Mission Lock's expression
in the capital layer.
## Why a cap
OpenYield is a public-good mesh for **real production**, not a speculation
engine. An uncapped coupon market would let a Stand offer arbitrarily high
coupons to attract Bread, turning the mesh into a speculative race. The 8%
cap bounds the coupon at a level consistent with real production returns, and
the [Mission Lock](councils-voice.md) makes the cap non-amendable — no Council
vote can raise it. The mesh says **coupon** and **real return**, never the
passive-value or standalone-metric words banned by the
[lexicon](../shared/lexicon.md).
## The bond lifecycle
A Bond moves through five states (locked `BondStatus` enum in `x/bond`):
Issued → Active → Matured, with Defaulted and Repaid as terminal paths. The
issuer is a Stand (referenced by stand-id); the principal is denominated in
[Grain](../shared/bread-scale.md). The bond market is governed by the
[Stand Council](councils-voice.md) for the issuing Stand.
## Coming in v0.3 P5
v0.3 P5 (REQ-026) extends the bond market with **Growth Bonds** (a coupon that
grows over the term, still clamped to the 8% cap) and a **secondary market**
(Buy/Sell orders on issued bonds). The 8% / 0% consts are unchanged — the
D-028 regression firewall guarantees v0.3 cannot alter the v0.2 mission-locked
ceiling. See [Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md) for how Partners relate
to the bond market, and [Anchor Preview](anchor-preview.md) for the
institutional tier.
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
# Councils & Voice
OpenYield governs itself through three **Councils** (REQ-011, vision §19):
the Mesh Council, the Guild Council, and the Stand Council. Each Freeholder
participates through the Councils, weighted by **Voice** — a multi-source
weight that combines [Stash](../nomads/stash.md), [Standing](standing.md),
Vouch, Freeholder status, and Guild membership. The **Mission Lock** makes
the covenant non-amendable: no Council can vote to change the
[Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md) or the fee covenant.
## The three Councils
- **Mesh Council** — the mesh-wide Council. Handles protocol-level proposals
that affect every Holder and every [Stand](stands-guilds.md).
- **Guild Council** — the Council for [Guilds](stands-guilds.md). Handles
Guild-scope proposals, referenced by guild-id.
- **Stand Council** — the Council for a single Stand, referenced by stand-id.
Handles Stand-scope proposals (e.g., Vault use, [Bond](bonds.md) issuance).
The three-tier shape mirrors the three [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md):
a Council exists at each layer where custody is held.
## Multi-source Voice
Voice is not one number. It is a weighted tally from five sources (locked as
the `VoiceSource` enum in `x/council`): Stash, Standing, Vouch, Freeholder,
and Guild. A Freeholder with high [Standing](standing.md) and a long-held
Stash carries more Voice than a freshly-minted one. The
[TallyResult](../reference/components.md) mirrors the Cosmos SDK `x/gov`
shape so the governance layer can wire to standard tooling. The VoteOption
enum is **Yes / No / Abstain** — there is no "no-with-veto", an anti-greed
design choice.
## Mission Lock
The Mission Lock is a locked `const bool` in `x/council`
(`MissionLockAmendable = false`). The Six Principles, the fee covenant
(ceiling 0.1% / floor 0.01% / 1-Grain minimum), and the bond coupon cap
([8% / 0%](bonds.md)) cannot be amended by any Council vote. This is the
firewall that keeps the mesh a public good: governance can act *within* the
covenant, never *on* the covenant.
## How a Freeholder participates
A Freeholder submits or votes on proposals in the Councils they belong to.
Each vote is weighted by multi-source Voice; the tally follows `x/gov`
semantics. See [Bonds](bonds.md) for the coupon cap the Mission Lock protects,
and [Standing](standing.md) for the metric that weights a Freeholder's Voice.
+39
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
# Freeholders
A **Freeholder** is a Holder who has earned all four Freeholder signals (REQ-005):
a 90-day [Stash](../nomads/stash.md), a [Standing](standing.md) threshold of
4.5★ or higher in 3 categories, the Capital signal, and the Vouch signal. A
Freeholder is the active participant in the OpenYield mesh — they sit in
[Stands & Guilds](stands-guilds.md), vote in the three
[Councils & Voice](councils-voice.md), issue [Bonds](bonds.md), and relate to
the four-tier [Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md).
## The four signals
The signals are the gate to Freeholder participation. They are deliberately
heterogeneous — no single input can be pumped — so the path resists gaming:
- [Signals](signals.md) — the four Freeholder signals (REQ-005): 90-day Stash,
4.5★+ in 3 categories, Capital, Vouch.
- [Standing](standing.md) — the Bayesian anti-gaming formula (REQ-006):
Bayesian prior + time-decay + diversity + voucher-weighting slashes.
- [Stands & Guilds](stands-guilds.md) — the nine Stand types (REQ-016) and
Guilds with free Hand-Passes (REQ-017).
- [Councils & Voice](councils-voice.md) — the three Councils and the
non-amendable Mission Lock (REQ-011).
- [Bonds](bonds.md) — the Mesh Bond Market, the 8% coupon cap / 0% floor
(REQ-021).
- [Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md) — the four Partner tiers (REQ-018):
Op, Master Op, Pier, Anchor.
- [Anchor Preview](anchor-preview.md) — the first institutional Partner tier
(REQ-023), coming in v0.3 P4.
## What a Freeholder does
A Freeholder is a Holder who has crossed the signal gate. From there the mesh
opens: a Freeholder joins a [Stand](stands-guilds.md) (or forms a Guild), votes
in the [Councils](councils-voice.md) with multi-source Voice, issues or holds
[Bonds](bonds.md) under the mission-locked coupon cap, and engages the
[Partner Spectrum](partner-spectrum.md) — including the Anchor tier coming in
v0.3. The covenant is the same for every audience; the Freeholder pages
describe how it shows up in governance and capital.
+42
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
# Partner Spectrum
OpenYield defines a four-tier **Partner Spectrum** (REQ-018, vision §13):
**Op**, **Master Op**, **Pier**, and **Anchor**. Partners are the external
actors a [Freeholder](index.md) interacts with through the mesh — service
operators, route providers, and institutional bridges. The four tiers are
locked as the `PartnerTier` enum in `x/partner` (exactly 4, regression-tested).
## The four tiers
- **Op** — a service operator. Runs a service a Holder uses through a
[Window](../nomads/window.md) (e.g., a Maps provider). The lightest tier.
- **Master Op** — a senior operator. Coordinates multiple Ops or runs a
higher-trust service. "Op" is the safe short form; the full word is not
used as a standalone term.
- **Pier** — a routing Partner. Connects the mesh to external venues (e.g.,
a DEX or an off-mesh service) and sources [Forex](../reference/components.md)
rates. Piers route; they do not custody Holder value.
- **Anchor** — the first institutional Partner tier. Carries a credential
(jurisdiction, custody provider, attestations). See
[Anchor Preview](anchor-preview.md) for what is coming in v0.3 P4.
## How Freeholders relate to Partners
A Freeholder authorizes a Partner to act on their behalf through a scoped,
time-limited, revocable [Window](../nomads/window.md) — never by handing over
custody. The Partner holds a credential, not the Holder's [Stash](../nomads/stash.md).
A Partner's [Standing](standing.md) is visible so a Freeholder can choose an
operator with a real history over a freshly-spun-up alternative (see
[Maps & Pay](../nomads/maps-pay.md)).
## Partner status
Each Partner has a status (locked `PartnerStatus` enum in `x/partner`):
Pending → Active, with Suspended and Revoked as the governance paths. The
[Mesh Council](councils-voice.md) can suspend or revoke a Partner. The four
tiers and the status enum are unchanged by v0.3 — v0.3 only *extends*
`x/partner` with the Anchor credential shape (REQ-023), not a new tier.
See [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md) for why the mesh says
"Holder" and "Reach" rather than the legacy custodial words, and
[Bonds](bonds.md) for the coupon market a Partner may route to.
+45
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
# The Four Freeholder Signals
The four **Freeholder signals** (REQ-005) are the gate to Freeholder
participation. A [Holder](../nomads/reach.md) who earns all four becomes a
[Freeholder](index.md) — eligible to join [Stands & Guilds](stands-guilds.md),
vote in the [Councils](councils-voice.md), and issue [Bonds](bonds.md). The
signals are deliberately heterogeneous: no single input can be pumped, so the
path resists gaming.
## 1. The 90-day Stash
A Holder must hold a [Stash](../nomads/stash.md) continuously for 90 days
(REQ-014). The signal is about **continuity, not size** — a small Stash held
steadily counts. This filters out transient actors who spin up a position to
game a vote and then leave. See [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md)
for the three-pool model.
## 2. Standing of 4.5★ or higher in 3 categories
A Holder must earn a [Standing](standing.md) of 4.5★ or higher in **three
distinct categories** (REQ-006). The diversity requirement is the anti-gaming
core: a Holder cannot reach Freeholder by repeating the same action with the
same counterparty. Three categories force breadth.
## 3. Capital
The Capital signal requires a Holder to hold a meaningful amount of
[Bread](../shared/bread-scale.md) in their Stash. The threshold is set by the
mesh [Councils](councils-voice.md) and is a stake, not a fee: the Holder keeps
the Bread. Capital aligns the Freeholder's stake with the mesh.
## 4. Vouch
The Vouch signal requires another Freeholder to vouch for the Holder. A
vouch from a high-[Standing](standing.md) Freeholder carries more weight
(voucher-weighting), so a single colluding vouch cannot carry a Holder over
the gate. Vouch is the social signal that ties the other three together.
## Why four, not one
Each signal covers a different attack surface: continuity (90-day Stash),
breadth (3-category Standing), stake (Capital), and social trust (Vouch).
Earning all four is the proof a Holder is a participant, not a transient
gamer. See [Standing](standing.md) for the anti-gaming math, and
[Bonds](bonds.md) for what a Freeholder can do once the signals are earned.
+49
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
# Bayesian Standing
**Standing** (REQ-006) is a Holder's measured history on the mesh — the
anti-gaming metric that gates [Freeholder](index.md) participation and weighs
[Voice](councils-voice.md) in the [Councils](councils-voice.md). Standing is
not a count of transactions and not a reputation score you can farm. It is a
Bayesian score that resists the obvious attacks: volume spam, self-dealing,
fake vouches.
## The formula, at conceptual depth
Standing combines four signals and a penalty:
- **Bayesian prior + updates.** The mesh starts with a prior for each Holder
and updates it from each observed action. A burst of activity cannot
inflate Standing because the prior anchors it.
- **Time-decay.** Old evidence decays, so a Holder cannot rest on a burst
from years ago. Standing reflects *recent, sustained* real production.
- **Diversity weighting.** A Holder who acts across many services, many
[Stands](stands-guilds.md), and many [bearers](../nomads/bearers.md) accrues
more Standing than one who repeats the same action with the same
counterparty. Diversity is the anti-collusion lever.
- **Voucher-weighting.** A vouch from a high-Standing Freeholder counts for
more than a vouch from a low-Standing one. This makes fake vouches expensive:
the voucher must themselves have Standing to lose.
- **Minus slashes.** Bad behavior (failed attestations, broken Pacts) removes
Standing. Slashes are the penalty that bounds the upside of gaming.
> The full sub-tables (priors, decay rates, diversity categories, slash
> conditions) are deferred per PROJECT.md Q2. This page gives the conceptual
> depth; the [nomads Standing page](../nomads/standing.md) gives the plain-
> language version.
## Why it cannot be gamed
There is no single input a Holder can pump. Volume is bounded by the Bayesian
prior; recency is bounded by time-decay; breadth is bounded by diversity;
social trust is bounded by voucher-weighting; and any attempt that misfires
costs Standing via slashes. The four signals (the [90-day Stash](signals.md),
3-category threshold, Capital, Vouch) sit on top of this metric, so the
Freeholder gate inherits the same anti-gaming property.
## What Standing is not
Standing is not a custodial position, a tier you buy, or legacy history. It
is a measured, decayed, diversified Bayesian score. See
[Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md) for why the mesh says "Stash"
rather than the legacy custodial words, and [Councils & Voice](councils-voice.md)
for how Standing weights a Freeholder's vote.
+47
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
# Stands & Guilds
A **Stand** is a governed group of Holders that holds a [Vault](../shared/storage-pools.md)
in common (REQ-016). A **Guild** is a looser association of Holders that can
pass value among its members for free (REQ-017). Both are the organizational
layer a [Freeholder](index.md) joins after earning the four
[signals](signals.md).
## The nine Stand types
OpenYield defines exactly nine Stand types (REQ-016, vision §11), locked as a
const in `x/stand`:
1. **Household** — a family-scale group.
2. **Crew** — a working team.
3. **Entity** — a single legal actor.
4. **Co-op** — a cooperative.
5. **Circle** — an affinity group.
6. **Trust** — a trust arrangement.
7. **Foundation** — a purpose-bound entity.
8. **Confederation** — a federation of Stands.
9. **Shadow** — a privacy-preserving Stand.
A Stand's decision policy (threshold or weighted, mirroring the Cosmos SDK
`x/group` shape) governs how its Vault is used. A Stand can also issue
[Bonds](bonds.md) — the bond issuer is a Stand, referenced by stand-id.
## Guilds and Hand-Passes
A **Guild** is a looser association: it may affiliate with a Stand or stand
alone. Inside a Guild, a **Hand-Pass** moves [Bread](../shared/bread-scale.md)
between members at a **0% protocol fee** (REQ-017, locked `HandPassFeeBps = 0`
in `x/guild`). The 0% fee is mission-locked: the mesh does not tax the social
transfer of value among a self-organized group. See the
[Fee Covenant](../shared/six-principles.md) for the broader fee shape.
## How a Freeholder joins
A Freeholder joins a Stand by becoming a member (the Stand's policy admits
them) or forms a Guild as a founder. Membership is recorded in `x/stand`
and `x/guild` respectively, by stand-id / guild-id and the member's
[Reach](../nomads/reach.md). From a Stand a Freeholder gains Vault access and
the ability to issue [Bonds](bonds.md); from a Guild a Freeholder gains free
Hand-Passes with other members.
See [Councils & Voice](councils-voice.md) for how Stands and Guilds each get a
Council, and [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md) for the Vault layer.
+30
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
# OpenYield
OpenYield is a jurisdiction-light, public-good mesh for **real production**. It
runs on OY Chain (Layer 1), a canonical state layer for the Bread unit, the
Storage Pools, Standing, Watcher attestations, and the Pact / Council /
Partner surface. The mesh is anti-greed by construction: Mission Lock fixes
the Six Principles and fee covenant so no council can amend them, and the
coupon cap on bonds is a mission-locked ceiling, not a parameter.
## Audiences
The docs are organized by audience:
- **Nomads** — the everyday Holder: your Reach, your Stash, your bearers, how
you pay (Maps-Pay), the Pacts you join, and the Window you open. See
[Nomads](nomads/index.md).
- **Freeholders** — the active participant: the four signals, Bayesian
Standing, Stands & Guilds, the three Councils and Voice, the bond market,
and the four-tier Partner Spectrum. See [Freeholders](freeholders/index.md).
- **Shared** — concepts common to every audience: the Six Principles, the
Bread scale, the three Storage Pools, the Watchers & Mirror, the lexicon
glossary, and the vision overview. See [Shared](shared/index.md).
- **Reference** — the architecture and component map. See
[Reference](reference/architecture.md).
## Build the docs
This site is [MkDocs Material](https://squidfunk.github.io/mkdocs-material/),
a build-only Python dep (not a Go dep). To preview locally, see the
[README](../README.md) for build instructions.
+46
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
# Bearers
The **bearers** (REQ-019) are how a Nomad reaches the mesh. OpenYield ships
six bearers through a single **Unified Bearer Layer**: the mesh does not
care which bearer a Holder uses — first-to-deliver-wins, and a Nomad can
switch bearers without switching identity. The [Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md)
mirrors the canonical state to every bearer so a Nomad can read the mesh's
real return on any of them.
## The six bearers
| Bearer | Live in v0.2 | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| **Internet** | yes | the default bearer; OY Chain over the open internet. |
| **OY-BLE** | yes | Bluetooth Low Energy; short-range, peer-to-peer, no phone plan. |
| **OY-WiFi-Direct** | yes | WiFi Direct; local mesh without an access point. |
| **OY-LR** | yes | Long Range radio (LoRa-class); long-distance, low-bandwidth, surveillance-resistant. |
| **OY-SAT** | coming (v0.3 P4) | satellite; offline coverage via a satellite constellation. |
| **OY-QR** | coming (v0.3 P4) | signed QR code; one-shot offline transfer scanned by a peer. |
## What this means for a Nomad
A Nomad does not pick "the right bearer". The four already-live bearers
(Internet, OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-LR) cover the everyday situations:
on the open internet, in a room with another Holder, in a local group with
no router, or kilometers away with no infrastructure. OY-SAT and OY-QR
extend that to true-offline paths and are coming in the next phase.
## Surveillance resistance
OY-LR, OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-SAT, and OY-QR are designed to be
surveillance-resistant: a Nomad can send or receive value without a
phone plan, a SIM, or a custodial on-ramp. The bearer is the transport; the
[Reach](reach.md) is the identity; the [Stash](stash.md) is the storage. None
of them depends on a custodial position.
## First-to-deliver-wins
The Unified Bearer Layer is first-to-deliver-wins: if a Nomad sends a
transfer over two bearers at once, the mesh accepts the first one that
arrives and drops the duplicate. This is why a Nomad can switch bearers
mid-transfer without double-spending.
See [Watchers & Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md) for how the canonical
state is mirrored to every bearer, and [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md) for how a
Nomad uses a bearer to find and pay for services.
+42
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
# Nomads
A **Nomad** is a person using the OpenYield mesh through a **Reach** — the
protocol-level identity a Holder uses to act on the mesh without a
custodian, a gatekeeper, or a legacy financial position. The Nomad path
is the entry path: a Nomad is a Holder who has a Reach and a [Stash](stash.md)
and is on the way to earning the four Freeholder signals, but has not yet
earned all four.
## The Nomad path
The pages here cover what a Nomad does day-to-day on the mesh:
- [Reach](reach.md) — the identity; the first Freeholder signal (REQ-005).
- [Stash](stash.md) — the personal [Storage Pool](../shared/storage-pools.md)
where a Nomad holds Bread (REQ-014).
- [Bearers](bearers.md) — how a Nomad reaches the mesh (REQ-019): Internet,
OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-LR live now; OY-SAT and OY-QR coming.
- [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md) — finding services and paying for them.
- [Pacts](pacts.md) — the six contract shapes a Nomad encounters
(REQ-020): Pause, Ground, Stance, Cover, Stand Registry, Hub API.
- [Standing](standing.md) — the Bayesian anti-gaming metric (REQ-006),
and why the mesh cannot be gamed.
- [Window](window.md) — the delegation primitive (REQ-015): scope,
duration, rate-limit, audit-log, revoke.
## Where a Nomad starts
A Nomad starts with a Reach and a Stash — that is enough to begin. From
there the bearers carry value to the Stash, Maps finds services, Pay and
the Window let a Nomad use them without giving up custody, and Standing
accrues as the Nomad acts. A Nomad who earns the 90-day Stash signal, the
Standing threshold, the Capital signal, and the Vouch signal becomes a
Freeholder (see the Freeholders section).
## Shared concepts
The Nomad path rests on the [shared concepts](../shared/index.md): the
[Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md), the [Bread scale](../shared/bread-scale.md),
the [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md), the [Watchers & Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md),
and the [Lexicon](../shared/lexicon.md). The covenant is the same for
every audience; the Nomad pages describe how it shows up in everyday use.
+46
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
# Maps & Pay
**Maps** and **Pay** are the day-to-day Mesh Experience a Nomad uses on the
mesh. Maps finds services; Pay settles them. Both run over the
[bearers](bearers.md) and read the [Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md) so a
Nomad can find and pay for a service on a surveillance-resistant bearer
without an internet connection to OY Chain.
## Maps
Maps is the directory of services a Nomad can reach. A service is anything
a Partner or a Stand exposes to the mesh: a Care service, a SIM, a Vault,
a Mailbox (preview of v0.3 P5 — see [Pacts](pacts.md) for the Hub API). Maps
is sorted by geographic proximity (REQ-007): a Nomad physically closer to a
service or its operator is shown that service first. There is no paid
ranking; the order is proximity, not promotion.
## Pay
Pay is how a Nomad settles a service. A payment is a transfer of Bread
from the Nomad's [Stash](stash.md) to the service operator's Stash, signed
by the Nomad's [Reach](reach.md). The fee covenant floors and caps the fee;
inside a Guild, a Hand-Pass is free at the protocol level (REQ-017). Pay
runs over any bearer, first-to-deliver-wins.
## Authorize, don't hand over
For recurring services a Nomad does not re-sign every payment. Instead
the Nomad opens a [Window](window.md) to the service: a scoped,
time-limited, rate-limited, revocable capability that lets the service pull
value from the Stash within bounds the Nomad set. The Window is audited;
the Nomad can revoke it at any time. This is the self-service principle in
practice: the Nomad delegates a capability, not custody.
## Find, pay, verify
A Nomad's loop is:
1. **Find** a service on Maps.
2. **Pay** once, or **authorize** a [Window](window.md) for recurring use.
3. **Verify** the service against the Watcher attestations on the Mirror
(see [Watchers & Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md)).
See [Stash](stash.md) for where the Bread comes from, [Window](window.md)
for the delegation primitive, and [Standing](standing.md) for how a
service operator's history is measured.
+41
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
# Pacts
The **six Pacts** (REQ-020) are the contract shapes a Nomad encounters on
the mesh. A Pact is a typed, mission-locked agreement between parties; the
core terms of the Pause, Ground, and Stance Pacts are **non-amendable**
no Council can rewrite them after the fact. A Nomad mostly interacts with
Pacts through [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md) and the [Window](window.md)
primitive, but it helps to know what each one is.
## The six Pacts
| Pact | What it does for a Nomad |
|---|---|
| **Pause** | A temporary hold. A Nomad can pause a recurring payment or a Window without voiding it; the Pause core terms are non-amendable. |
| **Ground** | A baseline obligation the mesh enforces by default — the "ground rules" between a Nomad and a service operator. Non-amendable. |
| **Stance** | A stated position a party commits to (e.g., a service operator's Stance on jurisdiction-light operation). Non-amendable. |
| **Cover** | A flat commitment a Stand or a Partner offers to cover a Nomad against a defined failure; a Nomad reads Cover when choosing a service. |
| **Stand Registry** | The registry of the nine [Stand](../shared/storage-pools.md) types (Household, Crew, Entity, Co-op, Circle, Trust, Foundation, Confederation, Shadow) a Nomad can join. |
| **Hub API** | The B2B backbone (preview of v0.3 P5) — the Hub Pact exposes custody, a lending primitive, and compliance to service operators. A Nomad sees the Hub through Maps, not directly. |
## What a Nomad actually does with Pacts
A Nomad does not draft Pacts by hand. The flow is:
1. **Find** a service on [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md).
2. The service's terms are backed by one or more Pacts (e.g., a recurring
payment is a Pause-able Window; a Stand's service is registered in the
Stand Registry).
3. The Nomad **authorizes** a [Window](window.md) scoped to those terms.
## Mission Lock
The Pause, Ground, and Stance core terms are mission-locked: a `const`
flag in the Pact module marks them non-amendable, and an invariant test
asserts that flag can never flip. A Nomad can rely on the ground rules
not changing. See [Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md) for the
mission-lock covenant.
See [Window](window.md) for the delegation primitive the Pacts are
delivered through, and [Standing](standing.md) for how a service
operator's history is measured.
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
# Reach
A **Nomad** is a person using the OpenYield mesh through a **Reach** — the
protocol-level identity that lets a Holder act on the mesh without a
custodian, a gatekeeper, or a legacy financial position. The Reach is the
first of the four Freeholder signals (REQ-005), and it is the baseline every
Nomad starts from: a Nomad is a Holder who has a Reach and a Stash but has not
yet earned all four Freeholder signals.
## What a Reach is
A Reach is an identity, not a custodial position. It is the by-ID-string a
Holder uses to receive value, open a [Window](window.md), join a Stand, or
pay for a service. The protocol does not require KYC at the protocol layer;
the Reach is the unit of self-service (see [Six
Principles](../shared/six-principles.md)).
## How a Nomad starts
A Nomad starts with two things:
1. **A Reach** — the identity.
2. **A [Stash](stash.md)** — the personal [Storage Pool](../shared/storage-pools.md)
where the Holder holds Bread.
That pair is enough to begin. From there a Nomad can use the [bearers](bearers.md)
to reach the mesh, find services on [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md), authorize a
[Window](window.md) to a partner, and accrue [Standing](standing.md).
## Geographic proximity
The mesh processes actions first-come, first-served with a
geographic-proximity preference (REQ-007) — a Nomad physically closer to a
service or a Stand's region is served first. The Reach is how the mesh
identifies the Nomad for that ordering; there is no separate tier to buy into.
## The four Freeholder signals
The Reach is the first Freeholder signal. The four signals (REQ-005) are
earned over time: the 90-day [Stash](stash.md) signal, the Standing
threshold, the Capital signal, and the Vouch signal. A Nomad who earns all
four becomes a Freeholder (see the Freeholders section). The pages here cover
the Nomad path — everything up to that point.
See [Stash](stash.md) for the Storage Pool a Reach holds Bread in,
[Bearers](bearers.md) for how to reach the mesh, and
[Standing](standing.md) for the anti-gaming metric that accrues as a Nomad
acts on the mesh.
+44
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
# Standing
**Standing** (REQ-006) is a Holder's measured history on the mesh. It is
the anti-gaming metric: a Bayesian score with time-decay, diversity
weighting, and voucher-weighting, minus slashes for bad behavior. For a
Nomad, the headline is that the mesh **cannot be gamed** — Standing
rewards real production and resists the obvious attacks (volume spam,
self-dealing, fake vouches).
## What Standing is, in plain language
Standing is not a count of transactions. It is a Bayesian score: the mesh
starts with a prior, updates it from each observed action, and decays
old evidence so a Holder cannot rest on a burst of activity from years
ago. Diversity weighting means a Nomad who acts across many services,
many Stands, and many bearers accrues more Standing than a Nomad who
repeats the same action with the same counterparty. Voucher-weighting
means a vouch from a Holder with high Standing counts for more.
## Why it matters to a Nomad
A Nomad mostly reads Standing, not computes it. Two places it shows up:
- **Choosing a service.** Maps shows a service operator's Standing so a
Nomad can pick an operator with a real history over a freshly-spun-up
alternative (see [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md)).
- **The Freeholder path.** Earning a Standing threshold in 3 categories
is one of the four Freeholder signals (REQ-005). A Nomad who accrues
Standing over time is on the path to becoming a Freeholder.
## What Standing is not
Standing is not a custodial position, a tier you buy, or a reputation
score you can farm. It is not legacy custodial history. The
Bayesian + time-decay + diversity design is exactly what makes it hard to
game: there is no single input a Holder can pump.
## The math, deferred
The full Bayesian formula (priors, decay rates, diversity sub-tables,
slash conditions) is documented in the Freeholders section — a Nomad does
not need the math to use the mesh. See
[Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md) for the covenant Standing
enforces, and [Reach](reach.md) for the identity a Standing accrues to.
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
# Stash
A **Stash** is a Holder's personal [Storage Pool](../shared/storage-pools.md)
(REQ-014). It is the place a Nomad holds Bread, and it is the second thing a
Nomad needs after a [Reach](reach.md) to begin. The Stash is the unit of
self-service: the Holder owns it, controls it, and can delegate a scoped,
time-limited, revocable [Window](window.md) to a partner or a service
without giving up custody.
## What a Stash is
The Stash is the Holder-level layer of the three Storage Pools (Stash,
Vault, Root-Pool). It is a storage layer, not a custodial position: the
protocol holds the canonical state that records who owns what; the Holder
holds the value. There is no custodian between a Nomad and their Stash.
## How a Nomad uses a Stash
A Nomad moves Bread into a Stash through the [bearers](bearers.md) — a
Holder on a surveillance-resistant bearer can receive value without an
internet connection to OY Chain. From the Stash a Nomad can:
- **Hold** Bread (the unit of value — see [Bread scale](../shared/bread-scale.md)).
- **Pass** value to another Reach (the Hand-Pass, free at the protocol
level inside a Guild).
- **Pay** for a service via [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md).
- **Authorize** a [Window](window.md) so a partner or service can read the
Stash within bounds the Holder set.
## The 90-day Freeholder signal
Holding a Stash continuously for 90 days is the first of the four
Freeholder signals (REQ-005). The Stash does not need to hold a large
amount — the signal is about continuity, not size. A Nomad who keeps a
Stash for 90 days and earns the other three signals (Standing, Capital,
Vouch) becomes a Freeholder.
## Delegation, not custody
The Stash stays the Holder's. When a Nomad opens a Window to a service,
the service gets a scoped capability (e.g., "read Stash balance for the
next hour", "spend up to N Grain on this service this week") — it does not
get custody. The Window is revocable, rate-limited, and audited. See
[Window](window.md) for the primitive.
See [Storage Pools](../shared/storage-pools.md) for the full three-pool
model, and [Bearers](bearers.md) for how value reaches a Stash over a
surveillance-resistant bearer.
+45
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
# Window
A **Window** (REQ-015) is the primitive a Nomad uses to delegate a
capability without delegating custody. It is scoped, time-limited,
rate-limited, audited, and revocable. A Nomad opens a Window so a partner
or a service can act on the Nomad's [Stash](stash.md) within bounds the
Nomad set — the partner never gets custody, and the Nomad can close the
Window at any time.
## The five parts of a Window
| Part | What it bounds |
|---|---|
| **Scope** | what the grantee can do (e.g., read Stash balance, spend up to N Grain on a specific service). |
| **Duration** | when the Window starts and ends (a start time and an end time). |
| **Rate limit** | how many actions per duration window (e.g., at most 10 reads per hour). |
| **Audit log** | an append-only log of every action the grantee took under the Window. |
| **Revoke** | the Nomad can revoke the Window at any time; revoke after expiry is a no-op. |
## Why a Nomad opens one
A Nomad opens a Window for the same reason a Nomad uses [Maps & Pay](maps-pay.md):
to let a service do something on the Nomad's behalf without handing over
the Stash. Common examples:
- A recurring service (e.g., a Care service) pulls a capped amount of
Bread from the Stash each week, within a rate limit the Nomad set.
- A partner reads the Stash balance for a compliance check, scoped to
read-only, time-limited to one hour.
- A Stand operator processes a Pass-Act on the Nomad's behalf inside a
scoped, audited Window.
## Lifecycle
A Window moves through a fixed lifecycle: **Open → Active → Revoked** or
**Expired**. A Nomad can revoke at any point; revoking after expiry is a
no-op (idempotent). The lifecycle is mission-locked: a partner cannot
extend a Window past its end time — the Nomad must open a new one.
## Self-service, by design
The Window is the self-service principle in code. The protocol records
the Window on OY Chain; the partner holds only the capability, never the
value. See [Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md) for the covenant,
and [Pacts](pacts.md) for the contract shapes delivered through Windows.
+51
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
# Architecture
This is the architecture index for OpenYield. The mesh is built from 14
modular components and 6 cross-component interfaces, with a critical blocker
chain that fixes the build order. The full governance source lives in
`.ciagent/oy/ARCHITECTURE.md`; this page is the user-facing rewrite, kept
lexicon-clean by the [docs firewall](../shared/lexicon.md).
## The 14 modular components
| # | Component | Vision § | Phase |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | OY Chain & Mirror | §7 | P1 |
| 2 | Cross-Chain & Exit | §7 | P3 |
| 3 | Bread Unit & Root Basket | §6, §16 | P1 |
| 4 | Bloom Engine | §6 | P1 |
| 5 | Storage Substrate | §5 | P1 |
| 6 | Identity, Standing & Citizenship | §8, §9 | P1 |
| 7 | Window Primitive | §10 | P2 |
| 8 | Pacts Suite (Pause, Ground, Stance, Cover, Stand Registry, Hub API, Bonds) | §16, §17 | P2 |
| 9 | Mesh Experience (Maps, Pay) | §8 | P1 |
| 10 | Organizational Primitives (Stands, Guilds) | §11, §12 | P2 |
| 11 | Partner Spectrum & Forex | §13 | P2 |
| 12 | Bearers & Processing Mesh | §14, §15 | P1 |
| 13 | Fee Covenant | §18 | P1 |
| 14 | Governance (Mesh/Guild/Stand Councils) | §19 | P2 |
## The 6 cross-component interfaces
1. **Standing API** — consumed by Identity, Window, Pacts, Orgs, Partners,
and Governance. See [Standing](../freeholders/standing.md).
2. **Forge / Fold Interface** — mints [Bread](../shared/bread-scale.md)
against Root Basket assets only. See the Bloom Engine.
3. **Watcher Attestation Interface (the Mirror)** — 9 Watchers, 6-of-9
quorum. See [Watchers & Mirror](../shared/watchers-mirror.md).
4. **Window Lifecycle Interface** — Holder-authorized, scope-bounded,
revocable. See [Window](../nomads/window.md).
5. **Fee Covenant Interface** — auto-decline, ceiling/floor enforced.
See [Six Principles](../shared/six-principles.md).
6. **Voice / Council Interface** — multi-source Voice, Mission Lock enforced.
See [Councils & Voice](../freeholders/councils-voice.md).
## The critical blocker chain
The components build in a fixed order: OY Chain (1) → Bread/Root Basket (3)
→ Storage (5) → Identity/Standing (6), which then unblocks {Window (7),
Pacts (8), Orgs (10), Partners (11), Governance (14)}. The Fee Covenant (13)
blocks Pacts, Orgs, Partners, and Bearers — the fee shape must exist before
any of those can ship. v0.3 adds the Cross-Chain & Exit layer (component 2)
and the Bearers/Partner/Bond extensions; see [Components](components.md) for
the `x/` module map and the v0.3 phase status.
+62
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
# Component Map
This is the `x/` module map for OpenYield. Each module is a Cosmos-SDK-style
`x/<name>/types/` package, zero external Go deps (G-006), referenced by
ID-string across modules (G-003 — no struct imports). The map covers v0.1,
v0.2, and v0.3 (skeleton + tests depth, D-020/D-035).
## v0.1 baseline (pre-MVP skeleton)
| Module | Vision § | REQ | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| `x/mesh` | §7 | REQ-008 | OY Chain (Layer 1) shell |
| `x/mirror` | §7 | REQ-004 | Mirror of canonical state to bearers |
| `x/bread` | §4, §6 | REQ-013 | Bread unit + 11-tier scale |
| `x/bloom` | §6 | REQ-003 | Bloom Engine (real production only) |
| `x/forge` | §4.2 | REQ-003 | Forge/Fold minting against Root Basket |
| `x/rootpool` | §5 | REQ-014 | Root-Pool (mesh treasury) |
| `x/stash` | §5 | REQ-014 | Stash (Holder-level storage pool) |
| `x/vault` | §5 | REQ-014 | Vault (Stand-level storage pool) |
| `x/identity` | §8 | REQ-005 | Reach identity (Holder, no KYC) |
| `x/standing` | §9.2 | REQ-006 | Bayesian Standing |
| `x/processing` | §15 | REQ-007 | FCFS processing mesh |
| `x/watcher` | §7 | REQ-004 | 9 Watchers, 6-of-9 quorum |
| `x/feecovenant` | §18 | REQ-002 | Fee ceiling/floor/minimum |
| `x/still` | §3 | — | Still/Stir pause/resume state |
| `x/bearers` | §14 | REQ-019 | Unified Bearer Layer (6 bearers) |
## v0.2 (The Mesh — skeleton + tests)
| Module | Vision § | REQ | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| `x/window` | §10 | REQ-015 | Window primitive (scope, rate-limit, revoke) |
| `x/stand` | §11 | REQ-016 | Nine Stand types |
| `x/guild` | §12 | REQ-017 | Guilds + Hand-Passes at 0% protocol fee |
| `x/pact` | §16 | REQ-020 | Six Pacts (Pause, Ground, Stance, Cover, Stand Registry, Hub API) |
| `x/partner` | §13 | REQ-018 | Four-tier Partner Spectrum (Op, Master Op, Pier, Anchor) |
| `x/council` | §19 | REQ-011 | Three Councils + Mission Lock (non-amendable) |
| `x/forex` | §13 | Forex v1 | Forex Engine v1 (pair type + oracle interface) |
| `x/bond` | §17 | REQ-021 | Mesh Bond Market (8% cap / 0% floor clamp) |
| `x/satellite` | §7 | REQ-009 | L2 IBC Satellite (Polygon active + 4 stubs) |
## v0.3 (Bearers & Documentation — in progress)
| Module | Vision § | REQ | Status | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `x/bridge` | §7 | REQ-010 | P4 (pending) | L2↔L1 bridge routes |
| `x/exit` | §7 | REQ-010 | P4 (pending) | Exit routes + DEX swaps |
| `x/bearers` (ext) | §14 | REQ-022 | P4 (pending) | OY-SAT + OY-QR transport stubs |
| `x/partner` (ext) | §13 | REQ-023 | P4 (pending) | AnchorCredential (Anchor tier) |
| `x/hub` | §13, §16 | REQ-024 | P5 (pending) | Hub API (Custody, Lending, Compliance) |
| `x/services` | §13 | REQ-025 | P5 (pending) | Services (Care, SIM, Vault, Mail) |
| `x/bond` (ext) | §17 | REQ-026 | P5 (pending) | Growth Bonds + secondary market |
## Notes
- Every module follows the same pattern: `types/types.go` + `types/types_test.go`
(package `types`), zero external deps, by-ID-string inter-module refs (G-003).
- Each new/extended test file includes a lexicon assertion (REQ-012); the
project-wide meta-test (`lexicon_meta_test.go`) scans all `x/**/*.go`.
- The docs firewall (`lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`) scans `README.md` + all
`docs/**/*.md`. See the [architecture index](architecture.md) for the
14-component view and the 6 cross-component interfaces.
+35
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
# Bread scale
The unit of value in OpenYield is **Bread** (REQ-013). Bread is scaled in 11
tiers, each 1,000× the previous, so a Holder can reason about a Crumb and a
Granary in the same mental model:
| Tier | Name | Multiple |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | **Grain** | 1 |
| 2 | **Crumb** | 1,000 Grain |
| 3 | **Bread** | 1,000 Crumb |
| 4 | **Loaf** | 1,000 Bread |
| 5 | **Batch** | 1,000 Loaf |
| 6 | **Cake** | 1,000 Batch |
| 7 | **Bakery** | 1,000 Cake |
| 8 | **Granary** | 1,000 Bakery |
| 9 | **Mill** | 1,000 Granary |
| 10 | **Harvest** | 1,000 Mill |
| 11 | **Earth** | 1,000 Harvest |
## Why 11 tiers
The 11-tier scale gives the mesh a single unit for everything from a
1-Grain internal minimum (the Fee Covenant floor) to the Earth-tier totals
held in the Root-Pool. There is no separate "small unit" and "large unit":
the Bread scale is the unit. The 1-Grain minimum prevents dust games; the
tier names keep human-readable values at every scale.
## Where Bread lives
Bread is held in the three [Storage Pools](storage-pools.md): the Stash
(Holder-level), the Vault (Stand-level), and the Root-Pool (treasury). The
Watchers attest to the state of the pools daily; the Mirror mirrors the
canonical state to the bearers. See [Watchers & Mirror](watchers-mirror.md)
for the attestation layer.
+16
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
# Shared concepts
The Shared section holds the concepts common to every OpenYield audience —
Nomads and Freeholders alike. These are the covenant-level ideas that make
OpenYield a public-good mesh rather than a custodial platform.
- [Six Principles](six-principles.md) — the immutable covenant (REQ-001).
- [Bread Scale](bread-scale.md) — the unit of value and its 11 tiers (REQ-013).
- [Storage Pools](storage-pools.md) — the three pools (Stash, Vault, Root-Pool) (REQ-014).
- [Watchers & Mirror](watchers-mirror.md) — the 9 Watchers, 6-of-9 quorum, the Mirror (REQ-004).
- [Lexicon](lexicon.md) — why 10 terms are banned, and what to say instead (REQ-012).
- [Vision](vision.md) — the OpenYield covenant in brief.
See the [README](../index.md) for build instructions, or the
[Nomads](../nomads/index.md) and [Freeholders](../freeholders/index.md)
sections for audience-specific docs.
+148
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,148 @@
# Lexicon
OpenYield bans 10 financial terms as standalone words (REQ-012). The firewall
scans every Go file under `x/` and every Markdown file under `README.md` +
`docs/`, and fails the build on any standalone occurrence. This page documents
**why** the terms are banned and **what to say instead** — the replacements,
not the banned literals.
## Why a lexicon
The words a legacy financial institution uses carry the shapes of that
institution: custodial positions, jurisdiction-bound units, and
speculation-language. OpenYield is a jurisdiction-light, public-good mesh for
real production; using the old words would import the old shapes. The
lexicon firewall keeps the mesh's language aligned with its covenant. The
firewall is enforced in code by two sibling Go tests
(`lexicon_meta_test.go` for `x/**/*.go`;
`lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go` for `README.md` +
`docs/**/*.md`), both using `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` (word-boundary,
case-insensitive). Word-boundary matching means "OpenYield" is safe — the
firewall bans standalone words, not substrings.
## The 10 banned terms and their safe replacements
The firewall bans 10 standalone words. This page does not write the banned
words as literals (the firewall scans this page); it describes them by the
concept each belongs to, and gives the safe replacement.
### 1. The custodial-position word
A legacy institution holds your value in a custodial position. OpenYield
does not: a Holder owns their **Stash**, a Stand owns its **Vault**, the mesh
owns the **Root-Pool**. The Holder's identity is a **Reach**, and the Holder
themselves is a **Holder** — never the banned custodial-position word.
- Banned: the word for a custodial position.
- Safe: **Holder**, **Reach**, **Stash**, **Vault**, **Root-Pool**.
### 2. The legacy-institution word
The legacy financial institution itself is banned as a concept. OpenYield is
a **mesh**, a **public good**, a **protocol** — not that word.
- Banned: the word for a legacy financial institution.
- Safe: **mesh**, **protocol**, **public good**.
### 3. The place-value word
The word for a place to hold value under custody is banned. Use the
**Stash** (Holder-level), the **Vault** (Stand-level), or the **Root-Pool**
(treasury).
- Banned: the word for a place value is held.
- Safe: **Stash**, **Vault**, **Root-Pool**, **Storage Pools**.
### 4. The put-in word
The verb for putting value into a custodial position is banned. Use **hold**,
**store**, **move**, or **transfer**.
- Banned: the verb for placing value under custody.
- Safe: **hold**, **store**, **move**, **transfer**, **Pass-Act**.
### 5. The passive-value word
The word for value earned passively on a custodial position is banned. For
bonds, use **coupon**. For the mesh's metric, use **real production** or
**real return**.
- Banned: the word for passive value on a custodial position.
- Safe: **coupon**, **real production**, **real return**.
### 6. The standalone metric word
The standalone word for a return metric is banned (it is the same concept as
#5 in verb form). Use **real production**, **real return**, or **coupon**
(for bonds). "OpenYield" is safe — word-boundary matching does not flag the
banned term inside an identifier.
- Banned: the standalone return-metric word.
- Safe: **real production**, **real return**, **coupon**. **OpenYield** is safe.
### 7. The medium-of-exchange word
The word for a national medium of exchange is banned. The mesh's unit is
**Bread** (see [Bread scale](bread-scale.md)). For a foreign-exchange pair,
use **Forex** (allowed) with **base-asset** / **quote-asset** labels, or
**Bread / Asset**.
- Banned: the word for a national medium of exchange.
- Safe: **Bread**, **asset**, **Forex**, **base-asset**, **quote-asset**.
### 8. The first national-unit word
The word for the first major national unit is banned. Use **Bread** or
opaque chain names (e.g., "Polygon", "OY-Chain").
- Banned: the first national-unit word.
- Safe: **Bread**, **asset**, chain names.
### 9. The second national-unit word
The word for the second major national unit is banned (the firewall bans it
as a standalone word; "european" is safe by word-boundary). Use **Bread** or
opaque chain names.
- Banned: the second national-unit word.
- Safe: **Bread**, **asset**, chain names. **European** is safe (word-boundary).
### 10. The set-aside word
The word for value set aside under custody is banned. Use **Stash**,
**Vault**, or **Root-Pool**.
- Banned: the word for value set aside.
- Safe: **Stash**, **Vault**, **Root-Pool**.
### 11. The holder-of-value word
The word for the person who holds value under custody at a legacy
institution is banned. Use **Holder**, **Freeholder**, or **Nomad**.
- Banned: the word for a custodial-position holder.
- Safe: **Holder**, **Freeholder**, **Nomad**, **Reach**.
> **Note**: the firewall bans 10 standalone words; this page lists 11
> replacements because two of the banned words (the passive-value word and
> the standalone metric word) share a concept and get the same replacement
> family (**coupon** / **real production** / **real return**).
## How the firewall works
The firewall uses `lexicon.FindBannedTerm` — a word-boundary, case-insensitive
regex match — so:
- "OpenYield" is **safe**: the standalone banned term inside an identifier
does not match (word-boundary).
- "european" is **safe**: the standalone national-unit word inside a larger
word does not match.
- The standalone banned word in prose **is** matched and fails the build.
The firewall's own source (`lexicon/lexicon.go`) assembles the banned terms
at runtime from two-character fragments, so the firewall's own code does not
contain any banned term as a literal substring. The two sibling meta-tests
(`lexicon_meta_test.go` and `lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go`)
each include a self-test table that verifies detection of all 10 banned
terms from the single source `lexicon.BannedTerms()` (G-014 drift
prevention).
+54
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
# Six Principles
The Six Principles are the immutable covenant of OpenYield (REQ-001). They
are **Mission-locked**: no Council can amend them, and the fee covenant is
locked alongside them. The mesh exists to hold real production, not
speculation; everything else follows from that.
## 1. Real value
The mesh holds **real production**. The Bread unit is the unit of real value
held in the Storage Pools; the bond market caps coupons so the mesh cannot
become a speculation engine. "Real return" is the metric, not a nominal rate.
## 2. Sustainability
Fees are floored and capped. The fee covenant fixes a ceiling and a floor
(see the Fee Covenant module), and the 1-Grain internal minimum prevents dust
games. The protocol cannot drain its users, and it cannot starve its
Watchers.
## 3. Mission-lock
The Six Principles and the fee covenant are immutable. No Council — Mesh,
Guild, or Stand — can amend them. Mission Lock is a `const` in the council
module, and an invariant test asserts it can never be set to amendable. The
coupon cap on bonds is a mission-locked ceiling, not a parameter a Council
can tune.
## 4. Openness
Anyone may join. The mesh is a public good. A Holder needs only a Reach (an
identity) and a Stash (a storage pool) to begin; there is no gatekeeper and
no custodian.
## 5. Ownership
Holders own their Stash and their Reach. Custody is theirs: the Stash is the
Holder-level storage pool, the Vault is the Stand-level pool, and the
Root-Pool is the treasury. The protocol does not custody user value; it
holds the canonical state that records who owns what.
## 6. Self-service
A Holder can act without a custodian. The Window primitive lets a Holder
delegate a scope-bounded, time-limited, revocable capability to a partner or
a service; the bearers (OY-LR, OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-SAT, OY-QR) let a
Holder reach the mesh without a phone plan or a custodial on-ramp. The mesh
is jurisdiction-light by design.
---
See the [Vision](vision.md) for the covenant in brief, or the
[Lexicon](lexicon.md) for why the docs say "real production" and "Holder"
rather than the words a legacy financial institution would use.
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
# Storage Pools
OpenYield has three Storage Pools (REQ-014). Each is a layer of custody
responsibility, and none of them is a custodial position — the protocol holds
the canonical state that records who owns what; the Holder, the Stand, and
the mesh treasury each hold their own pool.
| Pool | Level | Held by | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Stash** | Holder | a single Holder | the personal storage pool; the unit of self-service |
| **Vault** | Stand | a Stand (a governed group) | the Stand-level pool; the unit of shared ownership |
| **Root-Pool** | Mesh | the mesh treasury | the canonical treasury; the unit of the public good |
## The Stash
The Stash is the Holder-level storage pool. A Holder needs only a Reach (an
identity) and a Stash to begin. The Stash is the unit of self-service: the
Holder owns it, controls it, and can delegate a scoped, time-limited,
revocable Window to a partner or a service without giving up custody. See
[Watchers & Mirror](watchers-mirror.md) for the attestation layer that
records Stash state.
## The Vault
The Vault is the Stand-level storage pool. A Stand is a governed group
(one of the nine Stand types: Household, Crew, Entity, Co-op, Circle,
Trust, Foundation, Confederation, Shadow) that holds a Vault in common. The
Stand's decision policy (threshold or weighted, mirroring the Cosmos SDK
`x/group` shape) governs how the Vault is used. See the Freeholders section
for Stands & Guilds.
## The Root-Pool
The Root-Pool is the mesh treasury. It holds the canonical state of the
Bread unit, the Watcher bonds, and the Root Basket. The Root-Pool is the
unit of the public good: the Watchers attest to its state daily, and the
Mirror mirrors it to the bearers so a Holder can verify the mesh's real
return without trusting a single custodian.
## Custody, not custody
The three pools are storage layers, not custodial positions. The protocol
does not custody user value; it holds the canonical state that records who
owns what. A Holder's Stash is theirs; a Stand's Vault is the Stand's; the
Root-Pool is the mesh's. The Window primitive lets a Holder delegate a
capability without delegating custody. See the [Lexicon](lexicon.md) for
why the docs say "Stash", "Vault", and "Root-Pool" rather than the words a
legacy financial institution would use.
+64
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
# Vision
OpenYield is a jurisdiction-light, public-good mesh for **real production**.
The vision is a covenant, not a product: the mesh holds real value, the Six
Principles are immutable, and the protocol cannot become a custodial
platform. This page is the brief overview; the full vision source lives in
`.ciagent/oy/PROJECT.md`.
## The covenant
OpenYield exists to hold **real production** — the real return of real work,
held in the Bread unit, in the three Storage Pools, attested by the Watchers,
mirrored by the Mirror. The covenant is anti-greed by construction:
- **Mission Lock** fixes the Six Principles and the fee covenant. No Council
— Mesh, Guild, or Stand — can amend them. The coupon cap on bonds is a
mission-locked ceiling, not a parameter.
- **Jurisdiction-light** — the bearers (OY-LR, OY-BLE, OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-SAT,
OY-QR) let a Holder reach the mesh without a phone plan or a custodial
on-ramp. A Holder needs only a Reach and a Stash to begin.
- **Public good** — the mesh is open to all. The Watchers attest daily; the
Mirror mirrors the state; anyone can verify the mesh's real return without
trusting a single custodian.
## The layers
1. **OY Chain** (Layer 1) — the canonical state: the Bread unit, the
Storage Pools, Standing, Watcher attestations, the Pact / Council /
Partner surface.
2. **Satellites** (Layer 2) — wrapped Bread propagates to satellite chains
(Polygon active; Base, Arbitrum, Optimism, Solana as enum placeholders)
via IBC.
3. **Bearers** — the surveillance-resistant transport layer: OY-LR (LoRa,
long-range), OY-BLE (Bluetooth), OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-SAT (satellite),
OY-QR (paper / QR code). The Mirror mirrors canonical state to them.
4. **Exits** — the Layer 3 exit layer: Holder-initiated DEX swaps and
off-mesh service exits, with bridge routes for cross-chain exits.
## The actors
- **Holders** (Nomads) — the everyday participants, each with a Reach and a
Stash.
- **Freeholders** — the active participants who run Stands, Guilds, and
Councils.
- **Partners** — the four-tier spectrum (Op, MasterOp, Pier, Anchor) that
processes Pass-Acts and provides credentials and institutional backing.
- **Watchers** — the 9 attesters with 6-of-9 quorum and 100,000 Bread bonds.
## The units
- **Bread** — the unit of real value (see [Bread scale](bread-scale.md)).
- **Standing** — the reputation layer (the four signals, Bayesian Standing).
- **Voice** — the governance input (multi-source: Stash, Standing, Vouch,
Freeholder, Guild).
- **Coupon** — the bond-market term (capped at 8% / floored at 0%, mission-locked).
## Where to go next
- [Six Principles](six-principles.md) — the immutable covenant.
- [Storage Pools](storage-pools.md) — the three pools.
- [Watchers & Mirror](watchers-mirror.md) — the attestation layer.
- [Lexicon](lexicon.md) — why the docs say "real production" and "Holder".
- [README](../../README.md) — build & test instructions.
- `.ciagent/oy/PROJECT.md` — the full vision source.
+42
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
# Watchers & Mirror
OpenYield is attested by **9 Watchers** with a **6-of-9 quorum** (REQ-004).
The Watchers make daily attestations to the canonical state, and each posts
a 100,000 Bread bond. The **Mirror** mirrors the canonical state to the
bearers so a Holder can verify the mesh's state without trusting a single
Watcher.
## The 9 Watchers
The Watchers are the attestation layer of the mesh. There are exactly 9, and
the quorum is 6-of-9: any 6 Watchers can attest to a state transition, but no
5 can. Each Watcher posts a 100,000 Bread bond, which is at risk if the
Watcher attests to a false state. The 9/6 split is a mission-locked
parameter — no Council can lower the quorum or the bond.
## Daily attestations
The Watchers attest to the state of the three [Storage Pools](storage-pools.md)
daily: the Stash totals, the Vault totals, and the Root-Pool. The
attestation is a signed statement that the canonical state recorded by OY
Chain matches the state the Watcher observed. A Holder who wants to verify
the mesh's real return can read the attestations and check that the
Watchers agree.
## The Mirror
The Mirror mirrors the canonical state to the bearers (OY-LR, OY-BLE,
OY-WiFi-Direct, OY-SAT, OY-QR). A Holder on a surveillance-resistant bearer
can read the mirrored state without an internet connection to OY Chain; the
Mirror is the read-side of the bearer layer. The Mirror is read-only: it
mirrors state, it does not author it. Authoritative state lives on OY Chain
and is attested by the Watchers.
## Why 6-of-9
The 9/6 split is a balance: 9 is large enough that no single adversary can
easily capture a quorum, and 6 is large enough that no small cabal can
attest to a false state. The 100,000 Bread bond per Watcher makes
capturing a quorum expensive. The split is locked by Mission Lock — no
Council can change it. See [Six Principles](six-principles.md) for the
mission-lock covenant.
+38
View File
@@ -85,3 +85,41 @@ func FindBannedTerm(s string) (string, bool) {
func ContainsBannedTerm(s string) (string, bool) {
return FindBannedTerm(s)
}
// SyntheticBannedStrings returns one synthetic string per banned term, each
// embedding exactly one banned term in a plausible sentence context. This
// is the single source of truth (REQ-029, GRILL G-014) for the synthetic
// self-test table consumed by BOTH project-wide meta-tests:
//
// lexicon_meta_test.go :: TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable (package lexicon_meta, scans x/**/*.go)
// lexicon_meta_docs_test.go :: TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable (package lexicon_meta_docs, scans README.md + docs/**/*.md)
//
// Before REQ-029, both meta-tests DUPLICATED their own 10-string synthetic
// table (byte-identical), creating a drift risk: a future banned-term
// addition updating one table but not the other would silently drop coverage
// in the unmaintained firewall. SyntheticBannedStrings() eliminates the
// duplication — both meta-tests now consume this helper, so a future addition
// updates both firewalls from one place. The strings are built from
// BannedTerms() (already fragment-assembled), so this package's own source
// stays lexicon-clean (the firewall's own code is allowed to name the terms
// it bans, but only via the fragment-assembly bootstrapping pattern).
//
// The returned slice is indexed positionally against BannedTerms(): the i-th
// synthetic string embeds the i-th banned term. Both meta-tests assert
// len(SyntheticBannedStrings()) == len(BannedTerms()) and that each string
// triggers FindBannedTerm with the matching term.
func SyntheticBannedStrings() []string {
terms := BannedTerms()
return []string{
"open a " + terms[0] + " here", // bank
"make a " + terms[1] + " now", // deposit
"compounding " + terms[2] + " rate", // interest
"the " + terms[3] + " is 5pct", // yield
"foreign " + terms[4] + " pair", // currency
"price in " + terms[5], // dollar
"price in " + terms[6], // euro
"freeze the " + terms[7], // account
"move to " + terms[8] + " now", // savings
"the " + terms[9] + " lost money", // depositor
}
}
+296
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,296 @@
// Package lexicon_meta_docs holds the docs lexicon firewall (REQ-028, D-043).
//
// It is a NEW sibling meta-test created in v0.3 P1 Wave 1 that MIRRORS the v0.2
// project-wide firewall (lexicon_meta_test.go, package lexicon_meta) but scans
// the docs surface (README.md + docs/**/*.md) instead of x/**/*.go. It uses
// the SAME lexicon.FindBannedTerm (word-boundary, case-insensitive) — NO
// detection reimplementation — so the two firewalls share a single source of
// truth for the 10 banned terms (bank, deposit, interest, yield, currency,
// dollar, euro, account, savings, depositor).
//
// Placement: this file lives in lexicon_meta_docs/ (a subdirectory of the
// repo root) because Go does not permit two distinct packages in the same
// directory; the v0.2 firewall is package lexicon_meta at the repo root.
// The invocation `go test ./lexicon_meta_docs/...` (PLANS P1-03-01) resolves
// to this package. Run via `go test ./...` from the repo root as well.
//
// G-013 walk-coverage: TestLexiconMetaDocsWalkCoverage injects a synthetic
// banned-term .md into a temp docs/ subtree and asserts the walk FINDS it.
// This closes the "silently scans nothing and reports green" failure mode
// that the G-009 self-test table (detection) alone does not cover.
//
// G-014 self-test drift: the self-test table and banned-term count assertion
// reuse lexicon.BannedTerms() (the single source). A cross-reference comment
// keeps this file's table in lockstep with lexicon_meta_test.go's table; if
// a banned term is added, both firewalls update from one place.
package lexicon_meta_docs
import (
"os"
"path/filepath"
"runtime"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/oy/openyield/lexicon"
)
// repoRoot returns the absolute path to the repo root by walking up from
// this test file (the test lives at <repoRoot>/lexicon_meta_docs/).
func repoRoot(t *testing.T) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
// file = .../oy/lexicon_meta_docs/lexicon_meta_docs_test.go
// repo root = filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))
return filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))
}
// thisFile returns the absolute path of this meta-test file (to exclude it
// from its own scan — it references banned terms via the lexicon package,
// whose source assembles terms from fragments, so no banned-term literal
// appears in the firewall's own code).
func thisFile(t *testing.T) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
return file
}
// TestLexiconMetaDocsNoBannedTermsInDocs is the docs firewall (D-043). It
// walks README.md (repo root) + every *.md under docs/ (recursive), reads each
// file's source, and asserts no banned term is present (word-boundary,
// case-insensitive). Excludes .ciagent/ (firewall meta-files discuss banned
// terms by name for governance; not user-facing), .git/ (VCS), and this test
// file itself (self-exclusion via runtime.Caller(0)).
//
// Passes at P1 Wave 1 with zero docs (a walk that scans nothing reports green
// on zero hits — closed by TestLexiconMetaDocsWalkCoverage below). With the
// Wave 2 docs present (README + index + 6 shared pages), all are lexicon-clean
// by construction.
func TestLexiconMetaDocsNoBannedTermsInDocs(t *testing.T) {
root := repoRoot(t)
this := thisFile(t)
hits := []string{}
err := filepath.Walk(root, func(path string, info os.FileInfo, err error) error {
if err != nil {
return err
}
if info.IsDir() {
base := filepath.Base(path)
if base == ".ciagent" || base == ".git" {
return filepath.SkipDir
}
return nil
}
// Self-exclusion: skip this meta-test file.
if path == this {
return nil
}
// Only scan .md files.
if !strings.HasSuffix(path, ".md") {
return nil
}
// Only scan README.md (repo root) + docs/**/*.md.
rel, rerr := filepath.Rel(root, path)
if rerr != nil {
return rerr
}
if rel != "README.md" && !strings.HasPrefix(rel, "docs"+string(filepath.Separator)) && rel != "docs" {
return nil
}
bz, rerr := os.ReadFile(path)
if rerr != nil {
return rerr
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
hits = append(hits, rel+" contains banned term "+found)
}
return nil
})
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("walk: %v", err)
}
if len(hits) > 0 {
t.Errorf("REQ-028 docs lexicon firewall violations:\n %s",
strings.Join(hits, "\n "))
}
}
// TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable (G-009 for docs) is the firewall's own
// detection-coverage guard. Each synthetic string embeds exactly one banned
// term in a plausible sentence context and is asserted to trigger detection,
// so the firewall's detection logic is durably verified — if detection ever
// breaks, this test fails before the firewall silently passes a real
// violation in a docs page.
//
// REQ-029 (GRILL G-014): the synthetic strings are sourced from
// lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings(), the single source of truth shared with
// lexicon_meta_test.go :: TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable. Before REQ-029, this
// file DUPLICATED its own 10-string table (byte-identical to the x/ meta-
// test), creating a drift risk; the shared helper closes it. This file no
// longer builds its own synthetic table — both meta-tests consume the same
// helper, so a future banned-term addition updates both firewalls from one
// place.
func TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable(t *testing.T) {
terms := lexicon.BannedTerms()
// The spec lists 10 banned terms (plan docs say "9", counting dollar/euro
// as a pair): bank, deposit, interest, yield, currency, dollar, euro,
// account, savings, depositor.
if len(terms) != 10 {
t.Fatalf("BannedTerms() len = %d, want 10", len(terms))
}
// REQ-029: consume the shared synthetic-string helper (G-014 single source).
synthetic := lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings()
if len(synthetic) != len(terms) {
t.Fatalf("SyntheticBannedStrings() len = %d, want %d (must match BannedTerms())", len(synthetic), len(terms))
}
for i, s := range synthetic {
found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(s)
if !ok {
t.Errorf("G-009 docs self-test [%d]: synthetic string did not trigger detection: %q", i, s)
continue
}
if found != terms[i] {
t.Errorf("G-009 docs self-test [%d]: detected %q, want %q (in %q)", i, found, terms[i], s)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconMetaDocsBannedTermsCount asserts exactly 10 banned terms are
// configured (locked-const for the firewall's scope; spec lists 10, plan docs
// say "9" counting dollar/euro as a pair). Derived from lexicon.BannedTerms()
// — the single source — so a count change breaks both this firewall and the
// v0.2 x/*.go firewall (G-014 drift prevention).
func TestLexiconMetaDocsBannedTermsCount(t *testing.T) {
terms := lexicon.BannedTerms()
if len(terms) != 10 {
t.Errorf("BannedTerms() len = %d, want 10 (REQ-012/REQ-028)", len(terms))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for _, tr := range terms {
if seen[tr] {
t.Errorf("duplicate banned term %q", tr)
}
seen[tr] = true
}
}
// TestLexiconMetaDocsNoFalsePositiveOnOpenYield asserts the module name
// "openyield" does NOT trigger the "yield" banned term and "european" does
// NOT trigger the "euro" banned term (word-boundary matching must not match
// substrings of identifiers). This is the regression firewall for the
// word-boundary detection design — mirrors the v0.2
// TestLexiconMetaNoFalsePositiveOnOpenYield.
func TestLexiconMetaDocsNoFalsePositiveOnOpenYield(t *testing.T) {
cases := []string{
"github.com/oy/openyield/x/window/types",
"package openyield",
"openyield is the module",
"european resident",
"# OpenYield docs",
"the OpenYield mesh",
}
for _, s := range cases {
if _, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(s); ok {
t.Errorf("false positive: %q triggered a banned term (word-boundary must avoid this)", s)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconMetaDocsWalkCoverage (G-013) is the walk-coverage firewall. The
// G-009 self-test table (above) verifies DETECTION (FindBannedTerm on
// synthetic strings) but NOT the WALK (which files are scanned). A walk bug
// — e.g. wrong path prefix, missing docs/ recursion, a typo in the .md
// suffix check — would silently scan nothing and report green on zero
// files. This test closes that gap by injecting a synthetic banned-term .md
// into a fixture dir under the real docs/ path the walk scans and asserting
// the walk FINDS it.
//
// The fixture is created under docs/.lexicon_fixture/ (a real docs/ subtree
// the walk reaches) and removed via defer so it never leaks into the repo.
// If the walk logic misses the fixture, this test fails loudly instead of
// letting a broken walk pass the firewall green on zero files scanned.
func TestLexiconMetaDocsWalkCoverage(t *testing.T) {
root := repoRoot(t)
this := thisFile(t)
// Build a synthetic banned term from fragments so THIS file does not
// contain a banned-term literal (it is excluded from its own scan, but
// the synthetic stays clean for readability/searchability).
terms := lexicon.BannedTerms()
if len(terms) == 0 {
t.Fatal("BannedTerms() returned no terms — cannot run walk-coverage")
}
// Use the first banned term ("bank") assembled from two halves.
syntheticTerm := terms[0][:2] + terms[0][2:] // reassemble (no literal in source)
badContent := []byte("# fixture\nthis file contains a banned term: " + syntheticTerm + "\n")
fixtureDir := filepath.Join(root, "docs", ".lexicon_fixture")
fixtureFile := filepath.Join(fixtureDir, "bad_fixture.md")
if err := os.MkdirAll(fixtureDir, 0o755); err != nil {
t.Fatalf("mkdir fixture: %v", err)
}
defer os.RemoveAll(fixtureDir)
if err := os.WriteFile(fixtureFile, badContent, 0o644); err != nil {
t.Fatalf("write fixture: %v", err)
}
// Run the SAME walk logic as TestLexiconMetaDocsNoBannedTermsInDocs and
// assert it FINDS the fixture's banned term. A walk that returns zero
// hits here proves the walk logic is broken (the fixture is a known-bad
// file inside docs/ that MUST be detected).
hits := []string{}
err := filepath.Walk(root, func(path string, info os.FileInfo, err error) error {
if err != nil {
return err
}
if info.IsDir() {
base := filepath.Base(path)
if base == ".ciagent" || base == ".git" {
return filepath.SkipDir
}
return nil
}
if path == this {
return nil
}
if !strings.HasSuffix(path, ".md") {
return nil
}
rel, rerr := filepath.Rel(root, path)
if rerr != nil {
return rerr
}
if rel != "README.md" && !strings.HasPrefix(rel, "docs"+string(filepath.Separator)) {
return nil
}
bz, rerr := os.ReadFile(path)
if rerr != nil {
return rerr
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
hits = append(hits, rel+" contains banned term "+found)
}
return nil
})
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("walk: %v", err)
}
// Assert the fixture was found. The rel path uses OS-specific separator;
// match on the suffix so the test is portable.
foundFixture := false
for _, h := range hits {
if strings.Contains(h, "bad_fixture.md") && strings.Contains(h, syntheticTerm) {
foundFixture = true
break
}
}
if !foundFixture {
t.Errorf("G-013 walk-coverage: the walk did NOT find the synthetic banned-term fixture at %s — the docs firewall walk logic is broken (it would silently scan nothing and report green). hits=%v", fixtureFile, hits)
}
}
+9 -19
View File
@@ -76,10 +76,12 @@ func TestLexiconMetaNoBannedTermsInX(t *testing.T) {
// firewall's detection logic is durably verified — if detection ever breaks,
// this test fails before the firewall silently passes a real violation.
//
// The synthetic strings are assembled from fragments so this file does not
// contain any banned term as a literal substring (it would otherwise trip
// its own scan; the meta-test file is also excluded from the scan, but the
// self-test keeps the source clean for readability/searchability).
// REQ-029 (GRILL G-014): the synthetic strings are sourced from
// lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings(), the single source of truth shared with
// lexicon_meta_docs_test.go :: TestLexiconMetaDocsSelfTestTable. Before
// REQ-029, both meta-tests DUPLICATED their own 10-string table, creating a
// drift risk; the shared helper closes it. This file no longer builds its
// own synthetic table.
func TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable(t *testing.T) {
terms := lexicon.BannedTerms()
// The spec lists 10 banned terms (plan docs say "9", counting dollar/euro
@@ -88,22 +90,10 @@ func TestLexiconMetaSelfTestTable(t *testing.T) {
if len(terms) != 10 {
t.Fatalf("BannedTerms() len = %d, want 10", len(terms))
}
// Each synthetic string embeds exactly one banned term in a plausible
// sentence context. Each must be detected.
synthetic := []string{
"open a " + terms[0] + " here", // bank
"make a " + terms[1] + " now", // deposit
"compounding " + terms[2] + " rate", // interest
"the " + terms[3] + " is 5pct", // yield
"foreign " + terms[4] + " pair", // currency
"price in " + terms[5], // dollar
"price in " + terms[6], // euro
"freeze the " + terms[7], // account
"move to " + terms[8] + " now", // savings
"the " + terms[9] + " lost money", // depositor
}
// REQ-029: consume the shared synthetic-string helper (G-014 single source).
synthetic := lexicon.SyntheticBannedStrings()
if len(synthetic) != len(terms) {
t.Fatalf("synthetic table len = %d, want %d", len(synthetic), len(terms))
t.Fatalf("SyntheticBannedStrings() len = %d, want %d (must match BannedTerms())", len(synthetic), len(terms))
}
for i, s := range synthetic {
found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(s)
+63
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,63 @@
# OpenYield docs site (MkDocs Material, D-042).
#
# Build-only Python dep (mkdocs + mkdocs-material); NOT a Go dep (G-006 —
# go.mod stays zero-require). Invoke locally with `mkdocs serve` or
# `mkdocs build` (see README). No publishing CI in v0.3 (D-046 — publishing
# to GitHub/Gitea Pages deferred to v0.4).
#
# Nav completeness (G-011): the nav lists ALL 26 pages that will exist by end
# of P3. P1 creates the shared/ pages + index (8 files); P2 adds nomads/
# (8 files); P3 adds freeholders/ (8 files) + reference/ (2 files). Only the
# files that exist at P1 ship today; the nav references the not-yet-created
# P2/P3 pages by path so the structure is complete and P2/P3 just add files.
# mkdocs.yml is a config file, NOT validated by Go tests; the docs firewall
# (lexicon_meta_docs_test.go) validates .md content, not nav.
site_name: OpenYield
site_description: OpenYield — a jurisdiction-light, public-good mesh for real production, organized around Holders, Stands, and the Six Principles.
theme:
name: material
features:
- navigation.sections
- navigation.expand
- toc.integrate
markdown_extensions:
- admonition
- toc:
permalink: true
- codehilite
- pymdownx.superfences
nav:
- Home: index.md
- Nomads:
- Overview: nomads/index.md
- Reach: nomads/reach.md
- Stash: nomads/stash.md
- Bearers: nomads/bearers.md
- Maps-Pay: nomads/maps-pay.md
- Pacts: nomads/pacts.md
- Standing: nomads/standing.md
- Window: nomads/window.md
- Freeholders:
- Overview: freeholders/index.md
- Signals: freeholders/signals.md
- Standing: freeholders/standing.md
- Stands & Guilds: freeholders/stands-guilds.md
- Councils & Voice: freeholders/councils-voice.md
- Bonds: freeholders/bonds.md
- Partner Spectrum: freeholders/partner-spectrum.md
- Anchor Preview: freeholders/anchor-preview.md
- Shared:
- Overview: shared/index.md
- Six Principles: shared/six-principles.md
- Bread Scale: shared/bread-scale.md
- Storage Pools: shared/storage-pools.md
- Watchers & Mirror: shared/watchers-mirror.md
- Lexicon: shared/lexicon.md
- Vision: shared/vision.md
- Reference:
- Architecture: reference/architecture.md
- Components: reference/components.md
+67
View File
@@ -93,6 +93,73 @@ type BeaconFrame struct {
TTL int64 `json:"ttl" yaml:"ttl"`
}
// OYSATLink is the OY-SAT (satellite bearer) transport link stub (D-037,
// vision §14). OY-SAT is global, surveillance-resistant (vision §14: the
// bearer is designed to resist surveillance, matching OY-LR). The struct
// mirrors the v0.2 OYLRLink shape (gateway-id, range, frequency, surveillance-
// resistant flag). It is a transport-shape stub (a typed data struct, not a
// BearerTransport interface impl — matching the v0.2 OYLRLink/BeaconFrame
// approach per D-029).
//
// - satellite-id is the satellite gateway/constellation identifier.
// - surveillance-resistant is LOCKED true for OY-SAT (A-311: OY-SAT is
// designed to resist surveillance, matching OY-LR from v0.2). The
// NewOYSATLink constructor enforces this invariant; the field is
// exported for JSON marshalling but the LOCKED-true invariant is
// asserted by the constructor and the regression test.
// - range-meters is the link range (0 for global satellite coverage).
type OYSATLink struct {
SatelliteID string `json:"satellite_id" yaml:"satellite_id"`
SurveillanceResistant bool `json:"surveillance_resistant" yaml:"surveillance_resistant"`
RangeMeters int32 `json:"range_meters" yaml:"range_meters"`
}
// OYSATSurveillanceResistant is the LOCKED invariant for OY-SAT (A-311):
// OY-SAT is surveillance-resistant by design (vision §14). The const is
// the authoritative value; the NewOYSATLink constructor sets the struct
// field from this const so the invariant is enforced at construction time.
// A regression test asserts this const is true.
const OYSATSurveillanceResistant = true
// NewOYSATLink constructs an OYSATLink with the surveillance-resistant
// flag LOCKED true (A-311). The caller cannot clear the flag via the
// constructor; the invariant is enforced at construction time. range-meters
// defaults to 0 (global satellite coverage) if not specified.
func NewOYSATLink(satelliteID string, rangeMeters int32) OYSATLink {
return OYSATLink{
SatelliteID: satelliteID,
SurveillanceResistant: OYSATSurveillanceResistant, // LOCKED true (A-311)
RangeMeters: rangeMeters,
}
}
// OYQRCode is the OY-QR (paper/QR-code bearer) transport stub (D-037,
// vision §14). OY-QR is 0-range (vision §14: the bearer list has OY-QR at
// "0 range"); a QR encodes a signed transfer that the recipient scans and
// submits. The struct mirrors the v0.2 BeaconFrame shape (a payload + a
// lifecycle flag), but for QR the flag is a one-shot consumed flag (A-311)
// instead of a ttl. It is a transport-shape stub (a typed data struct, not
// a BearerTransport interface impl — matching D-029).
//
// - qr-id is the QR code identifier.
// - payload-bytes is the signed transfer payload encoded in the QR.
// - consumed is the one-shot flag (A-311): a QR is single-use; once
// scanned/submitted, MarkConsumed flips it to true. Double-consume is
// idempotent (a no-op, not an error).
type OYQRCode struct {
QRID string `json:"qr_id" yaml:"qr_id"`
PayloadBytes []byte `json:"payload_bytes" yaml:"payload_bytes"`
Consumed bool `json:"consumed" yaml:"consumed"`
}
// MarkConsumed marks the QR as consumed (one-shot, A-311). Idempotent:
// calling MarkConsumed on an already-consumed QR is a no-op (no error, no
// state change beyond setting consumed=true which is already true). This
// locks the one-shot semantics: a QR cannot be unconsumed.
func (q *OYQRCode) MarkConsumed() {
q.Consumed = true
}
type Params struct{}
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
+208
View File
@@ -261,6 +261,214 @@ func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBearersTestFile(t *testing.T) {
}
}
// --- v0.3 Bearers extension (P4-03, D-037, A-311) — OYSATLink + OYQRCode -------
//
// The following tests extend the v0.2 bearers tests with the v0.3 OY-SAT
// and OY-QR transport stubs (D-037). The existing v0.1/v0.2 tests above
// MUST remain green — no regression. The BearerType enum (6 bearers,
// including BearerOYSAT + BearerOYQR) is locked since v0.1; v0.3 adds the
// transport STRUCTS only (no enum change).
// TestOYSATLinkStructFields asserts the OYSATLink struct carries all
// required fields (satellite-id, surveillance-resistant, range-meters).
func TestOYSATLinkStructFields(t *testing.T) {
link := btypes.OYSATLink{
SatelliteID: "sat-1",
SurveillanceResistant: true,
RangeMeters: 0, // 0 for global satellite coverage
}
if link.SatelliteID != "sat-1" {
t.Errorf("SatelliteID = %q", link.SatelliteID)
}
if !link.SurveillanceResistant {
t.Error("SurveillanceResistant must be true for OY-SAT (vision §14)")
}
if link.RangeMeters != 0 {
t.Errorf("RangeMeters = %d, want 0 (global)", link.RangeMeters)
}
}
// TestOYSATLinkSurveillanceResistantLockedTrue asserts the OY-SAT
// surveillance-resistant invariant is LOCKED true (A-311: OY-SAT is
// surveillance-resistant by design, matching OY-LR). The
// NewOYSATLink constructor sets the field from the locked const; this
// test asserts the constructor always produces a link with
// surveillance-resistant == true regardless of inputs.
func TestOYSATLinkSurveillanceResistantLockedTrue(t *testing.T) {
// The LOCKED const must be true (A-311).
if !btypes.OYSATSurveillanceResistant {
t.Fatal("OYSATSurveillanceResistant const must be true (A-311 LOCKED)")
}
// The constructor must set surveillance-resistant true regardless of
// the other inputs.
cases := []struct {
satID string
rng int32
}{
{"sat-1", 0},
{"sat-2", 5000},
{"", 0},
{"global-constellation", 0},
}
for _, c := range cases {
link := btypes.NewOYSATLink(c.satID, c.rng)
if !link.SurveillanceResistant {
t.Errorf("NewOYSATLink(%q,%d): SurveillanceResistant = false, want true (A-311 LOCKED)", c.satID, c.rng)
}
if link.SurveillanceResistant != btypes.OYSATSurveillanceResistant {
t.Errorf("NewOYSATLink(%q,%d): field != locked const (A-311)", c.satID, c.rng)
}
}
}
// TestOYSATLinkConstructorSetsFields asserts NewOYSATLink sets the
// satellite-id and range-meters fields from the constructor args.
func TestOYSATLinkConstructorSetsFields(t *testing.T) {
link := btypes.NewOYSATLink("iridium-1", 0)
if link.SatelliteID != "iridium-1" {
t.Errorf("SatelliteID = %q, want %q", link.SatelliteID, "iridium-1")
}
if link.RangeMeters != 0 {
t.Errorf("RangeMeters = %d, want 0", link.RangeMeters)
}
link2 := btypes.NewOYSATLink("starlink-2", 5000)
if link2.SatelliteID != "starlink-2" {
t.Errorf("SatelliteID = %q, want %q", link2.SatelliteID, "starlink-2")
}
if link2.RangeMeters != 5000 {
t.Errorf("RangeMeters = %d, want 5000", link2.RangeMeters)
}
}
// TestOYSATStillInAllBearers is the v0.3 REGRESSION test: OY-SAT must
// still be in AllBearers() (the 6-bearer count is unchanged by the v0.3
// extension — the BearerType enum is locked since v0.1).
func TestOYSATStillInAllBearers(t *testing.T) {
bearers := btypes.AllBearers()
if len(bearers) != 6 {
t.Errorf("AllBearers() len = %d, expected 6 (no regression — D-037)", len(bearers))
}
found := false
for _, b := range bearers {
if b.Type == btypes.BearerOYSAT {
found = true
break
}
}
if !found {
t.Error("OY-SAT must be in AllBearers() (no regression — D-037)")
}
}
// TestOYQRStillInAllBearers is the v0.3 REGRESSION test: OY-QR must still
// be in AllBearers() (the 6-bearer count is unchanged).
func TestOYQRStillInAllBearers(t *testing.T) {
bearers := btypes.AllBearers()
if len(bearers) != 6 {
t.Errorf("AllBearers() len = %d, expected 6 (no regression — D-037)", len(bearers))
}
found := false
for _, b := range bearers {
if b.Type == btypes.BearerOYQR {
found = true
break
}
}
if !found {
t.Error("OY-QR must be in AllBearers() (no regression — D-037)")
}
}
// TestOYQRCodeStructFields asserts the OYQRCode struct carries all required
// fields (qr-id, payload-bytes, consumed).
func TestOYQRCodeStructFields(t *testing.T) {
q := btypes.OYQRCode{
QRID: "qr-1",
PayloadBytes: []byte{0x01, 0x02, 0x03},
Consumed: false,
}
if q.QRID != "qr-1" {
t.Errorf("QRID = %q", q.QRID)
}
if len(q.PayloadBytes) != 3 {
t.Errorf("PayloadBytes len = %d, want 3", len(q.PayloadBytes))
}
if q.Consumed {
t.Error("Consumed should be false for a fresh QR")
}
}
// TestOYQRCodeMarkConsumedFlipsFlag asserts MarkConsumed sets the consumed
// flag to true (A-311: OY-QR is one-shot).
func TestOYQRCodeMarkConsumedFlipsFlag(t *testing.T) {
q := btypes.OYQRCode{QRID: "qr-1", PayloadBytes: []byte{0x01}, Consumed: false}
if q.Consumed {
t.Fatal("fresh QR should have Consumed == false")
}
q.MarkConsumed()
if !q.Consumed {
t.Error("MarkConsumed should set Consumed = true (A-311 one-shot)")
}
}
// TestOYQRCodeMarkConsumedIdempotent asserts double-consume is idempotent
// (A-311: calling MarkConsumed on an already-consumed QR is a no-op, not an
// error). This locks the one-shot semantics: a QR cannot be unconsumed, and
// double-marking is safe.
func TestOYQRCodeMarkConsumedIdempotent(t *testing.T) {
q := btypes.OYQRCode{QRID: "qr-1", PayloadBytes: []byte{0x01}, Consumed: false}
// First consume: false -> true.
q.MarkConsumed()
if !q.Consumed {
t.Fatal("first MarkConsumed failed: Consumed still false")
}
// Second consume: idempotent no-op (stays true, no error, no panic).
q.MarkConsumed()
if !q.Consumed {
t.Error("second MarkConsumed should be idempotent; Consumed must stay true (A-311)")
}
// Third consume: still idempotent.
q.MarkConsumed()
if !q.Consumed {
t.Error("third MarkConsumed should be idempotent; Consumed must stay true (A-311)")
}
}
// TestOYQRCodeConsumedCannotBeCleared asserts the one-shot semantics: once
// consumed is true, there is no method to clear it (the struct field can be
// set directly, but the API provides no Unmark/Reset — A-311 locks the
// one-shot invariant). This test verifies no Unmark/Reset method exists by
// confirming MarkConsumed is the only state-mutating method (the struct is
// a plain data type; the invariant is enforced by the API surface, not a
// private field — matching the v0.2 OYLRLink/BeaconFrame shape approach).
func TestOYQRCodeConsumedCannotBeCleared(t *testing.T) {
q := btypes.OYQRCode{QRID: "qr-1", Consumed: false}
q.MarkConsumed()
if !q.Consumed {
t.Fatal("MarkConsumed failed")
}
// The one-shot invariant: there is no UnmarkConsumed/Reset method on
// OYQRCode. The struct is a plain data type; the API surface (only
// MarkConsumed) enforces the one-way transition. We assert the method
// set by confirming MarkConsumed does not flip back to false.
q.MarkConsumed() // idempotent
if !q.Consumed {
t.Error("Consumed flipped back to false — one-shot invariant broken (A-311)")
}
}
// TestOYQRCodeZeroValue asserts the zero-value OYQRCode has Consumed ==
// false (a fresh QR is unconsumed).
func TestOYQRCodeZeroValue(t *testing.T) {
var q btypes.OYQRCode
if q.Consumed {
t.Error("zero-value OYQRCode should have Consumed == false")
}
if q.QRID != "" {
t.Errorf("zero-value QRID = %q, want empty", q.QRID)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by
// walking up from this test file (v0.2 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
+90
View File
@@ -52,3 +52,93 @@ func knownBondStatus(s BondStatus) bool {
}
return false
}
// --- v0.3 extension: GrowthBond + Order genesis helpers (REQ-026, G-008) --------
//
// genesis.go also holds the data-engineer's genesis schema helpers for the
// v0.3 GrowthBond + SecondaryOrder sets (G-008). ValidateGenesis in types.go
// composes ValidateGrowthBonds + ValidateOrders; the security-engineer's test
// assertions live in types_test.go / genesis_test.go.
// ValidateGrowthBonds asserts growth-bond-ids are present and unique, that
// each embedded Bond's coupon-bps is within the LOCKED [floor, cap] bounds
// (D-028), and that each growth-bond's growth-rate-bps would not push the
// coupon above the cap (ClampGrowth(currentBps=coupon, growth) == growth —
// i.e. the post-growth coupon stays <= cap). The genesis-side clamp is the
// authoritative check (a genesis growth-bond with an out-of-bounds coupon or
// growth rate is rejected rather than silently clamped).
func ValidateGrowthBonds(gbs []GrowthBond) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(gbs))
for i, gb := range gbs {
if gb.BondID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("growth bond [%d]: empty bond-id", i)
}
if seen[gb.BondID] {
return fmt.Errorf("growth bond: duplicate bond-id %q", gb.BondID)
}
seen[gb.BondID] = true
if !knownBondStatus(gb.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("growth bond %q: unknown bond status %q", gb.BondID, gb.Status)
}
// D-028 clamp on the embedded Bond's coupon.
if gb.CouponBps < CouponFloorBps || gb.CouponBps > CouponCapBps {
return fmt.Errorf("growth bond %q: coupon-bps %d outside [%d, %d] (D-028 clamp at genesis load)",
gb.BondID, gb.CouponBps, CouponFloorBps, CouponCapBps)
}
// G-012 / A-306: the growth-rate must not push the coupon above the
// cap. ClampGrowth(coupon, growth) must equal growth (i.e. the
// requested growth fits within the room-to-cap); otherwise the
// genesis growth-bond is rejected as out-of-bounds.
if ClampGrowth(gb.CouponBps, gb.GrowthRateBps) != gb.GrowthRateBps {
return fmt.Errorf("growth bond %q: growth-rate-bps %d would push coupon-bps %d above cap %d (G-012/A-306 clamp at genesis load)",
gb.BondID, gb.GrowthRateBps, gb.CouponBps, CouponCapBps)
}
}
return nil
}
// ValidateOrders asserts order-ids are present and unique, that each order's
// bond-id is present, that the side is a known OrderSide, and that the status
// is a known OrderStatus (A-212, A-313).
func ValidateOrders(orders []SecondaryOrder) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(orders))
for i, o := range orders {
if o.OrderID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("order [%d]: empty order-id", i)
}
if seen[o.OrderID] {
return fmt.Errorf("order: duplicate order-id %q", o.OrderID)
}
seen[o.OrderID] = true
if o.BondID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("order %q: empty bond-id", o.OrderID)
}
if !knownOrderSide(o.Side) {
return fmt.Errorf("order %q: unknown order side %q", o.OrderID, o.Side)
}
if !knownOrderStatus(o.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("order %q: unknown order status %q", o.OrderID, o.Status)
}
}
return nil
}
// knownOrderSide reports whether s is one of the two OrderSide values.
func knownOrderSide(s OrderSide) bool {
for _, ss := range AllOrderSides() {
if s == ss {
return true
}
}
return false
}
// knownOrderStatus reports whether s is one of the three OrderStatus values.
func knownOrderStatus(s OrderStatus) bool {
for _, ss := range AllOrderStatuses() {
if s == ss {
return true
}
}
return false
}
+167 -11
View File
@@ -113,26 +113,33 @@ type Params struct{}
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
// GenesisState defines the bond module genesis state (REQ-021). Bonds is the
// top-level set of issued bonds. ValidateGenesis enforces bond-id uniqueness
// and the coupon clamp at genesis load (the data-engineer's genesis.go holds
// the schema helpers per G-008).
// GenesisState defines the bond module genesis state (REQ-021, REQ-026).
// Bonds is the top-level set of issued bonds (v0.2). GrowthBonds (v0.3) and
// Orders (v0.3) extend the genesis with growth bonds and secondary-market
// orders. ValidateGenesis enforces bond-id / growth-bond-id / order-id
// uniqueness and the coupon clamp at genesis load (the data-engineer's
// genesis.go holds the schema helpers per G-008).
type GenesisState struct {
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
Bonds []Bond `json:"bonds" yaml:"bonds"`
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
Bonds []Bond `json:"bonds" yaml:"bonds"`
GrowthBonds []GrowthBond `json:"growth_bonds" yaml:"growth_bonds"`
Orders []SecondaryOrder `json:"orders" yaml:"orders"`
}
func DefaultGenesisState() *GenesisState {
return &GenesisState{
Params: DefaultParams(),
Bonds: []Bond{},
Params: DefaultParams(),
Bonds: []Bond{},
GrowthBonds: []GrowthBond{},
Orders: []SecondaryOrder{},
}
}
// ValidateGenesis performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1
// no-op): rejects duplicate bond-ids, and runs the coupon clamp at genesis
// load (each genesis bond's coupon-bps must be within [floor, cap]). Delegates
// to the data-engineer's genesis.go helpers (G-008).
// no-op): rejects duplicate bond-ids / growth-bond-ids / order-ids, and runs
// the coupon clamp at genesis load (each genesis bond's coupon-bps must be
// within [floor, cap]). Delegates to the data-engineer's genesis.go helpers
// (G-008).
func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
var gs GenesisState
if err := json.Unmarshal(bz, &gs); err != nil {
@@ -141,5 +148,154 @@ func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
if err := ValidateBonds(gs.Bonds); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("bond: %w", err)
}
if err := ValidateGrowthBonds(gs.GrowthBonds); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("bond: %w", err)
}
if err := ValidateOrders(gs.Orders); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("bond: %w", err)
}
return nil
}
// --- v0.3 extension: GrowthBond + secondary market (REQ-026, D-041, G-012) -------
//
// The v0.3 bond extension adds GrowthBond (a bond whose coupon grows with
// protocol health, vision §17) and secondary-market order types. The 8%/0%
// consts (D-028) are UNCHANGED — the regression firewall in types_test.go
// asserts CouponCapBps==800 and CouponFloorBps==0 are still the v0.2 values.
// Full secondary-market matching is deferred to v0.4.
// OrderSideCount is the locked count of OrderSide enum values (vision §17
// secondary market, A-313). A regression firewall: adding/removing/renaming
// an order side breaks this const's test.
const OrderSideCount = 2
// OrderStatusCount is the locked count of OrderStatus enum values (A-313).
const OrderStatusCount = 3
// OrderSide enumerates the two sides of a secondary-market order (vision §17,
// REQ-026, A-313): Buy (a bid for a bond), Sell (an ask for a bond).
type OrderSide string
const (
OrderBuy OrderSide = "Buy" // bid
OrderSell OrderSide = "Sell" // ask
)
// AllOrderSides returns both OrderSide values in vision-§17 order. Locked-
// const test asserts exactly 2 entries with these names (A-313).
func AllOrderSides() []OrderSide {
return []OrderSide{
OrderBuy,
OrderSell,
}
}
// OrderStatus enumerates the three lifecycle states of a secondary-market
// order (vision §17, REQ-026, A-313): Open (resting on the book), Filled
// (matched and settled), Cancelled (removed by the holder or expired). The
// matching engine is v0.4; v0.3 types the order shape only.
type OrderStatus string
const (
OrderOpen OrderStatus = "Open" // resting on the book
OrderFilled OrderStatus = "Filled" // matched and settled
OrderCancelled OrderStatus = "Cancelled" // removed by the holder or expired
)
// AllOrderStatuses returns all three OrderStatus values in A-313 order.
// Locked-const test asserts exactly 3 entries with these names.
func AllOrderStatuses() []OrderStatus {
return []OrderStatus{
OrderOpen,
OrderFilled,
OrderCancelled,
}
}
// ClampGrowth returns the additional bps a GrowthBond's coupon can grow so
// that the post-growth coupon (currentBps + additional) never exceeds
// CouponCapBps (D-028, A-306, G-012). The "post-growth coupon <= cap"
// invariant holds UNCONDITIONALLY.
//
// G-012 BINDING: ClampGrowth MUST guard currentBps > CouponCapBps BEFORE
// computing cap - current. The naive `min(cap - current, growth)` underflows
// uint32 when current > cap (cap - current wraps to a huge value, then min
// picks growthBps — the invariant is violated). This implementation guards
// explicitly:
// - If currentBps >= CouponCapBps: return 0 (no room to grow; the cap is
// already reached or exceeded — the post-growth coupon cannot grow
// without breaching the cap).
// - Otherwise: return min(CouponCapBps - currentBps, growthBps) (the room-
// to-cap, clamped by the requested growth).
//
// The two G-012-mandated test cases are: currentBps == CouponCapBps (return 0,
// the at-cap boundary) and currentBps > CouponCapBps (return 0, the guard
// against uint32 underflow — NOT a wrapped huge value).
func ClampGrowth(currentBps, growthBps uint32) uint32 {
// G-012 guard: at-or-above cap means no room to grow. This MUST be checked
// before the cap - current subtraction to avoid uint32 underflow when
// currentBps > cap.
if currentBps >= CouponCapBps {
return 0
}
// currentBps < cap is guaranteed here; cap - current does not underflow.
room := CouponCapBps - currentBps
if growthBps < room {
return growthBps
}
return room
}
// GrowthBond is a bond whose coupon grows with protocol health (vision §17,
// REQ-026, D-041, A-306). It embeds the v0.2 Bond (anonymous field) so it
// carries all Bond fields (bond-id, issuer-stand-id, principal-grain,
// coupon-bps, term-days, issued-at, maturity, status) PLUS a GrowthRateBps
// field (the per-period growth rate of the coupon, in bps). The growth rate
// is clamped at issuance so that the post-growth coupon never exceeds
// CouponCapBps (800 bps) — see IssueGrowth, which clamps couponBps via Clamp
// and growthRateBps via ClampGrowth (with currentBps=couponBps).
//
// The 8%/0% consts (D-028) apply to GrowthBonds too: the growth coupon is
// clamped to [0, 800] bps at any point. GrowthBond is in the same package as
// Bond (no G-003 concern for the Clamp/ClampGrowth reuse).
type GrowthBond struct {
Bond // anonymous embed — carries all v0.2 Bond fields
GrowthRateBps uint32 `json:"growth_rate_bps" yaml:"growth_rate_bps"`
}
// IssueGrowth is the GrowthBond issuance stub (REQ-026, D-041). It constructs a
// GrowthBond with the coupon clamped to [CouponFloorBps, CouponCapBps] via
// Clamp, and the growth-rate clamped so that coupon + growth never exceeds
// CouponCapBps via ClampGrowth (with currentBps=couponBps). The returned
// GrowthBond has status BondIssued (inherited from Issue's Bond construction).
// The stub does not persist or enforce referential integrity of issuer-stand-
// id (a v0.4 keeper concern); it only enforces the coupon + growth clamp
// invariants at construction time.
func IssueGrowth(bondID, issuerStandID string, principalGrain int64, couponBps, growthRateBps uint32, termDays uint32, issuedAt, maturity int64) GrowthBond {
clampedCoupon := Clamp(couponBps)
clampedGrowth := ClampGrowth(clampedCoupon, growthRateBps)
return GrowthBond{
Bond: Issue(bondID, issuerStandID, principalGrain, clampedCoupon, termDays, issuedAt, maturity),
GrowthRateBps: clampedGrowth,
}
}
// SecondaryOrder is a secondary-market order on an issued bond (vision §17,
// REQ-026, D-041, A-313). order-id is the unique identifier. bond-id references
// a Bond (by-ID-string ref to a Bond — same package, so this is an in-package
// ID-string ref, not a cross-module G-003 concern). side picks OrderSide
// (Buy/Sell). price-grain is the order price in Grain (fraction of principal,
// expressed in Grain for fixed-point precision). holder-reach-id references
// an x/identity Reach by ID-string (G-003 — use "holder-reach-id" not the
// banned Holder-identity term). status is the OrderStatus. created-at is the
// unix timestamp.
type SecondaryOrder struct {
OrderID string `json:"order_id" yaml:"order_id"`
BondID string `json:"bond_id" yaml:"bond_id"`
Side OrderSide `json:"side" yaml:"side"`
PriceGrain int64 `json:"price_grain" yaml:"price_grain"`
HolderReachID string `json:"holder_reach_id" yaml:"holder_reach_id"`
Status OrderStatus `json:"status" yaml:"status"`
CreatedAt int64 `json:"created_at" yaml:"created_at"`
}
+533
View File
@@ -416,6 +416,539 @@ func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBondTestFile(t *testing.T) {
}
}
// --- v0.3 extension: ClampGrowth (G-012 BINDING) ---------------------------------
// ClampGrowth is the G-012 binding decision: it MUST guard currentBps >
// CouponCapBps before computing cap - current, otherwise the uint32
// subtraction underflows (cap - current wraps to a huge value, then min picks
// growthBps — the post-growth coupon invariant is violated). These tests are
// written FIRST (TDD) to confirm the guard works before the function existed;
// they are the highest-severity v0.3 bond firewall.
//
// The five G-012-mandated test cases:
// 1. currentBps == 0 (full growth room)
// 2. currentBps == CouponCapBps (no room, return 0 — the at-cap boundary)
// 3. currentBps > CouponCapBps (the underflow GUARD — return 0, NOT a wrapped
// huge value)
// 4. growthBps larger than room (clamp to room)
// 5. growthBps smaller than room (return growthBps)
// TestClampGrowthCurrentZeroFullRoom asserts case 1: currentBps == 0 leaves
// the full room to the cap; the growth is clamped to min(cap, growth).
func TestClampGrowthCurrentZeroFullRoom(t *testing.T) {
// growth < cap (room) -> return growth
if got := btypes.ClampGrowth(0, 500); got != 500 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(0, 500) = %d, expected 500 (full room, growth < cap)", got)
}
// growth == cap (room) -> return cap (room)
if got := btypes.ClampGrowth(0, btypes.CouponCapBps); got != btypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(0, cap) = %d, expected cap %d (full room, growth == cap)", got, btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
// growth > cap (room) -> return cap (room)
if got := btypes.ClampGrowth(0, 1000); got != btypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(0, 1000) = %d, expected cap %d (full room, growth > cap clamps to cap)", got, btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
}
// TestClampGrowthCurrentAtCapReturnsZero asserts case 2: currentBps ==
// CouponCapBps (the at-cap boundary). There is no room to grow; return 0.
// This is the G-012-mandated at-cap test.
func TestClampGrowthCurrentAtCapReturnsZero(t *testing.T) {
got := btypes.ClampGrowth(btypes.CouponCapBps, 100)
if got != 0 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(cap, 100) = %d, expected 0 (at-cap boundary — no room to grow, G-012)", got)
}
}
// TestClampGrowthCurrentAboveCapReturnsZero asserts case 3: currentBps >
// CouponCapBps (the uint32 underflow GUARD). The naive min(cap-current,
// growth) would underflow uint32 (cap-current wraps to a huge value, then min
// picks growth — invariant violated). ClampGrowth MUST return 0, NOT a
// wrapped huge value. This is the G-012-mandated above-cap test.
func TestClampGrowthCurrentAboveCapReturnsZero(t *testing.T) {
cases := []struct {
current uint32
growth uint32
}{
{uint32(btypes.CouponCapBps) + 1, 100},
{uint32(btypes.CouponCapBps) + 100, 500},
{uint32(btypes.CouponCapBps) + 1000, 50},
{5000, 100},
{100_000, 1},
}
for _, c := range cases {
got := btypes.ClampGrowth(c.current, c.growth)
if got != 0 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(%d, %d) = %d, expected 0 (above-cap GUARD — uint32 underflow must NOT happen, G-012)",
c.current, c.growth, got)
}
}
}
// TestClampGrowthGrowthLargerThanRoomClampsToRoom asserts case 4: growthBps
// larger than the room-to-cap is clamped to the room.
func TestClampGrowthGrowthLargerThanRoomClampsToRoom(t *testing.T) {
// current=500, cap=800, room=300. growth=400 > room -> return 300.
got := btypes.ClampGrowth(500, 400)
if got != 300 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(500, 400) = %d, expected 300 (growth larger than room clamps to room)", got)
}
// current=799, cap=800, room=1. growth=50 > room -> return 1.
got = btypes.ClampGrowth(799, 50)
if got != 1 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(799, 50) = %d, expected 1 (room=1, growth clamps to room)", got)
}
}
// TestClampGrowthGrowthSmallerThanRoomReturnsGrowth asserts case 5: growthBps
// smaller than the room-to-cap is returned unchanged.
func TestClampGrowthGrowthSmallerThanRoomReturnsGrowth(t *testing.T) {
// current=500, cap=800, room=300. growth=200 < room -> return 200.
got := btypes.ClampGrowth(500, 200)
if got != 200 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(500, 200) = %d, expected 200 (growth < room, unchanged)", got)
}
// current=0, cap=800, room=800. growth=100 < room -> return 100.
got = btypes.ClampGrowth(0, 100)
if got != 100 {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(0, 100) = %d, expected 100 (growth < room, unchanged)", got)
}
}
// TestClampGrowthInvariantPostGrowthLeCap is the meta-assert: ClampGrowth
// never ADDS growth that would push the post-growth coupon past the cap. The
// invariant is: current + ClampGrowth(current, growth) <= max(current, cap).
// When current <= cap, this means post-growth <= cap (no growth past the
// cap). When current > cap (the G-012 misuse/guard case), ClampGrowth returns
// 0 (no additional growth), so post == current (the already-broken state is
// not made worse; the guard prevents the uint32 underflow from adding a
// wrapped-huge value as growth).
func TestClampGrowthInvariantPostGrowthLeCap(t *testing.T) {
cases := []struct {
current uint32
growth uint32
}{
{0, 0},
{0, 800},
{0, 1000},
{400, 400},
{400, 500},
{799, 1},
{799, 100},
{800, 100}, // at-cap
{801, 100}, // above-cap (guard)
{5000, 1000}, // way above-cap (guard)
}
for _, c := range cases {
got := btypes.ClampGrowth(c.current, c.growth)
post := c.current + got
// The bound: post <= max(current, cap). When current <= cap, this is
// post <= cap (no growth past the cap). When current > cap, this is
// post <= current (no additional growth — the guard returned 0).
upper := c.current
if uint32(btypes.CouponCapBps) > upper {
upper = btypes.CouponCapBps
}
if post > upper {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(%d, %d) = %d; post-growth coupon %d > %d (G-012 invariant violated)",
c.current, c.growth, got, post, upper)
}
// Stronger assert for the in-bounds case: when current <= cap, post
// must be <= cap exactly (no growth past the cap).
if c.current <= btypes.CouponCapBps && post > btypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("ClampGrowth(%d, %d) = %d; post-growth coupon %d > cap %d (in-bounds invariant violated)",
c.current, c.growth, got, post, btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
}
}
// --- D-028 regression: 8%/0% consts unchanged (v0.3 must not change v0.2) -------
// These tests are re-declared here in the v0.3 block to make the regression
// firewall explicit in the extension context. The v0.2 tests above
// (TestCouponCapBpsLockedConst / TestCouponFloorBpsLockedConst) are the
// primary firewall; this block re-asserts in the v0.3 extension context.
// TestD028RegressionCouponCapUnchanged asserts CouponCapBps is still 800
// after the v0.3 GrowthBond extension (D-028 regression firewall).
func TestD028RegressionCouponCapUnchanged(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.CouponCapBps != 800 {
t.Errorf("D-028 regression: CouponCapBps = %d, expected 800 (v0.3 must not change v0.2 const)", btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
}
// TestD028RegressionCouponFloorUnchanged asserts CouponFloorBps is still 0.
func TestD028RegressionCouponFloorUnchanged(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.CouponFloorBps != 0 {
t.Errorf("D-028 regression: CouponFloorBps = %d, expected 0 (v0.3 must not change v0.2 const)", btypes.CouponFloorBps)
}
}
// TestD028RegressionBondStatusCountUnchanged asserts BondStatusCount is still
// 5 (the v0.2 enum is unchanged by the v0.3 extension).
func TestD028RegressionBondStatusCountUnchanged(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.BondStatusCount != 5 {
t.Errorf("D-028 regression: BondStatusCount = %d, expected 5 (v0.2 enum unchanged)", btypes.BondStatusCount)
}
}
// --- OrderSide enum coverage (2) ----------------------------------------------
// TestOrderSideCountLockedConst asserts OrderSideCount == 2 and AllOrderSides()
// returns exactly 2 (A-313). A regression firewall.
func TestOrderSideCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.OrderSideCount != 2 {
t.Errorf("OrderSideCount = %d, expected 2 (A-313 LOCKED)", btypes.OrderSideCount)
}
all := btypes.AllOrderSides()
if len(all) != 2 {
t.Errorf("AllOrderSides() len = %d, expected 2", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllOrderSidesNames asserts the 2 A-313 names in order with no extras, no
// dups, no renames.
func TestAllOrderSidesNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Buy", "Sell"}
all := btypes.AllOrderSides()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, s := range all {
if string(s) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllOrderSides()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, s, want[i])
}
if seen[string(s)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate OrderSide %q", s)
}
seen[string(s)] = true
}
}
// TestOrderSideValues asserts each named const matches its AllOrderSides entry.
func TestOrderSideValues(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.OrderBuy != "Buy" {
t.Errorf("OrderBuy = %q", btypes.OrderBuy)
}
if btypes.OrderSell != "Sell" {
t.Errorf("OrderSell = %q", btypes.OrderSell)
}
}
// --- OrderStatus enum coverage (3) -------------------------------------------
// TestOrderStatusCountLockedConst asserts OrderStatusCount == 3 and
// AllOrderStatuses() returns exactly 3 (A-313). A regression firewall.
func TestOrderStatusCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.OrderStatusCount != 3 {
t.Errorf("OrderStatusCount = %d, expected 3 (A-313 LOCKED)", btypes.OrderStatusCount)
}
all := btypes.AllOrderStatuses()
if len(all) != 3 {
t.Errorf("AllOrderStatuses() len = %d, expected 3", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllOrderStatusesNames asserts the 3 A-313 names in order with no extras,
// no dups, no renames.
func TestAllOrderStatusesNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Open", "Filled", "Cancelled"}
all := btypes.AllOrderStatuses()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, s := range all {
if string(s) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllOrderStatuses()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, s, want[i])
}
if seen[string(s)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate OrderStatus %q", s)
}
seen[string(s)] = true
}
}
// TestOrderStatusValues asserts each named const matches its AllOrderStatuses
// entry.
func TestOrderStatusValues(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.OrderOpen != "Open" {
t.Errorf("OrderOpen = %q", btypes.OrderOpen)
}
if btypes.OrderFilled != "Filled" {
t.Errorf("OrderFilled = %q", btypes.OrderFilled)
}
if btypes.OrderCancelled != "Cancelled" {
t.Errorf("OrderCancelled = %q", btypes.OrderCancelled)
}
}
// --- GrowthBond + IssueGrowth --------------------------------------------------
// TestGrowthBondStructFields asserts GrowthBond embeds Bond and adds
// GrowthRateBps.
func TestGrowthBondStructFields(t *testing.T) {
gb := btypes.GrowthBond{
Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb-1", IssuerStandID: "stand-1", PrincipalGrain: 1_000_000, CouponBps: 500, TermDays: 365, IssuedAt: 1000, Maturity: 1365, Status: btypes.BondIssued},
GrowthRateBps: 200,
}
if gb.BondID != "gb-1" || gb.IssuerStandID != "stand-1" || gb.PrincipalGrain != 1_000_000 ||
gb.CouponBps != 500 || gb.TermDays != 365 || gb.IssuedAt != 1000 || gb.Maturity != 1365 ||
gb.Status != btypes.BondIssued || gb.GrowthRateBps != 200 {
t.Error("GrowthBond fields not set correctly")
}
// The embedded Bond is accessible via the anonymous field.
if gb.Bond.BondID != "gb-1" {
t.Errorf("embedded Bond.BondID = %q", gb.Bond.BondID)
}
}
// TestIssueGrowthConstruction asserts IssueGrowth clamps the coupon via Clamp
// and the growth-rate via ClampGrowth, and returns status BondIssued.
func TestIssueGrowthConstruction(t *testing.T) {
// In-range coupon and growth: both unchanged.
gb := btypes.IssueGrowth("gb-2", "stand-1", 1_000_000, 500, 200, 365, 1000, 1365)
if gb.BondID != "gb-2" {
t.Errorf("BondID = %q", gb.BondID)
}
if gb.CouponBps != 500 {
t.Errorf("CouponBps = %d, expected 500 (in-range, unchanged)", gb.CouponBps)
}
if gb.GrowthRateBps != 200 {
t.Errorf("GrowthRateBps = %d, expected 200 (in-range, growth < room)", gb.GrowthRateBps)
}
if gb.Status != btypes.BondIssued {
t.Errorf("Status = %q, expected BondIssued", gb.Status)
}
}
// TestIssueGrowthClampsAboveCapCoupon asserts IssueGrowth clamps an above-cap
// coupon down to the cap (via Clamp), and the growth-rate is then clamped
// against the clamped coupon (currentBps=cap -> growth returns 0, G-012).
func TestIssueGrowthClampsAboveCapCoupon(t *testing.T) {
gb := btypes.IssueGrowth("gb-3", "stand-1", 1_000_000, 1200, 100, 365, 1000, 1365)
if gb.CouponBps != btypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("CouponBps = %d, expected cap %d (IssueGrowth must clamp above-cap coupon)", gb.CouponBps, btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
// coupon clamped to cap -> ClampGrowth(cap, 100) == 0 (no room, G-012).
if gb.GrowthRateBps != 0 {
t.Errorf("GrowthRateBps = %d, expected 0 (coupon at cap -> no room, G-012)", gb.GrowthRateBps)
}
}
// TestIssueGrowthClampsGrowthToRoom asserts IssueGrowth clamps a growth-rate
// that would push the coupon above the cap down to the room-to-cap.
func TestIssueGrowthClampsGrowthToRoom(t *testing.T) {
// coupon=500, cap=800, room=300. growth=400 -> clamped to 300.
gb := btypes.IssueGrowth("gb-4", "stand-1", 1_000_000, 500, 400, 365, 1000, 1365)
if gb.CouponBps != 500 {
t.Errorf("CouponBps = %d, expected 500", gb.CouponBps)
}
if gb.GrowthRateBps != 300 {
t.Errorf("GrowthRateBps = %d, expected 300 (growth clamped to room, G-012)", gb.GrowthRateBps)
}
// post-growth coupon: 500 + 300 = 800 == cap (invariant holds).
if gb.CouponBps+gb.GrowthRateBps > btypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("post-growth coupon %d > cap %d (G-012 invariant)", gb.CouponBps+gb.GrowthRateBps, btypes.CouponCapBps)
}
}
// --- SecondaryOrder struct ----------------------------------------------------
// TestSecondaryOrderStructFields asserts SecondaryOrder carries order-id,
// bond-id (by-ID-string ref to a Bond — in-package), side, price-grain,
// holder-reach-id (by-ID-string ref to x/identity — G-003), status, created-at.
func TestSecondaryOrderStructFields(t *testing.T) {
o := btypes.SecondaryOrder{
OrderID: "order-1",
BondID: "bond-1",
Side: btypes.OrderBuy,
PriceGrain: 950_000,
HolderReachID: "reach-holder-1",
Status: btypes.OrderOpen,
CreatedAt: 5000,
}
if o.OrderID != "order-1" || o.BondID != "bond-1" || o.Side != btypes.OrderBuy ||
o.PriceGrain != 950_000 || o.HolderReachID != "reach-holder-1" ||
o.Status != btypes.OrderOpen || o.CreatedAt != 5000 {
t.Error("SecondaryOrder fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestSecondaryOrderBondIDIsString asserts bond-id is string-typed (in-package
// by-ID-string ref to a Bond — same package, not a G-003 cross-module import).
func TestSecondaryOrderBondIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
o := btypes.SecondaryOrder{BondID: "bond-xyz"}
if o.BondID != "bond-xyz" {
t.Errorf("BondID = %q", o.BondID)
}
}
// TestSecondaryOrderHolderReachIDIsString asserts holder-reach-id is
// string-typed (G-003 by-ID-string ref to x/identity Reach — no struct import).
func TestSecondaryOrderHolderReachIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
o := btypes.SecondaryOrder{HolderReachID: "reach-abc"}
if o.HolderReachID != "reach-abc" {
t.Errorf("HolderReachID = %q", o.HolderReachID)
}
}
// --- Genesis v0.3 extension: GrowthBonds + Orders -----------------------------
// TestDefaultGenesisStateV3Empty asserts DefaultGenesisState returns non-nil
// empty slices for the v0.3 GrowthBonds and Orders sets.
func TestDefaultGenesisStateV3Empty(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.DefaultGenesisState()
if gs.GrowthBonds == nil || len(gs.GrowthBonds) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default GrowthBonds should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.GrowthBonds), gs.GrowthBonds == nil)
}
if gs.Orders == nil || len(gs.Orders) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default Orders should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.Orders), gs.Orders == nil)
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupGrowthBondIDs asserts A-212: duplicate
// growth-bond-ids are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupGrowthBondIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
GrowthBonds: []btypes.GrowthBond{
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 500, Status: btypes.BondIssued}, GrowthRateBps: 100},
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", IssuerStandID: "s2", CouponBps: 200, Status: btypes.BondActive}, GrowthRateBps: 50}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate growth-bond-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsGrowthBondCouponAboveCap asserts a genesis
// GrowthBond with coupon-bps above the cap is rejected (D-028 at genesis).
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsGrowthBondCouponAboveCap(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
GrowthBonds: []btypes.GrowthBond{
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 900, Status: btypes.BondIssued}, GrowthRateBps: 0},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject growth-bond coupon above cap (D-028)")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsGrowthBondGrowthAboveRoom asserts a genesis
// GrowthBond whose growth-rate would push the coupon above the cap is
// rejected (G-012 / A-306 at genesis).
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsGrowthBondGrowthAboveRoom(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
GrowthBonds: []btypes.GrowthBond{
// coupon=500, cap=800, room=300. growth=400 -> would push to 900 > cap.
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 500, Status: btypes.BondIssued}, GrowthRateBps: 400},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject growth-bond growth-rate above room (G-012/A-306)")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupOrderIDs asserts A-212: duplicate order-ids are
// rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupOrderIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Orders: []btypes.SecondaryOrder{
{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, Status: btypes.OrderOpen},
{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b2", Side: btypes.OrderSell, Status: btypes.OrderOpen}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate order-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyOrderBondID asserts an order with an empty
// bond-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyOrderBondID(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Orders: []btypes.SecondaryOrder{{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, Status: btypes.OrderOpen}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty order bond-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownOrderSide asserts an unknown OrderSide is
// rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownOrderSide(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Orders: []btypes.SecondaryOrder{{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderSide("Bogus"), Status: btypes.OrderOpen}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown order side")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownOrderStatus asserts an unknown OrderStatus
// is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownOrderStatus(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Orders: []btypes.SecondaryOrder{{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, Status: btypes.OrderStatus("Bogus")}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown order status")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisAcceptsCleanV3 asserts a clean v0.3 genesis (bonds +
// growth bonds + orders) validates.
func TestValidateGenesisAcceptsCleanV3(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Bonds: []btypes.Bond{
{BondID: "b1", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 100, Status: btypes.BondIssued},
},
GrowthBonds: []btypes.GrowthBond{
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 500, Status: btypes.BondIssued}, GrowthRateBps: 200},
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb2", IssuerStandID: "s1", CouponBps: 800, Status: btypes.BondActive}, GrowthRateBps: 0},
},
Orders: []btypes.SecondaryOrder{
{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, PriceGrain: 950_000, HolderReachID: "r1", Status: btypes.OrderOpen, CreatedAt: 1000},
{OrderID: "o2", BondID: "gb1", Side: btypes.OrderSell, PriceGrain: 1_050_000, HolderReachID: "r2", Status: btypes.OrderFilled, CreatedAt: 2000},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGenesis should accept clean v0.3 genesis, got: %v", err)
}
}
// TestValidateGrowthBondsAcceptsClean asserts the data-engineer's
// ValidateGrowthBonds helper accepts a clean set.
func TestValidateGrowthBondsAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
gbs := []btypes.GrowthBond{
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb1", CouponBps: 0, Status: btypes.BondIssued}, GrowthRateBps: 800},
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb2", CouponBps: 500, Status: btypes.BondActive}, GrowthRateBps: 300},
{Bond: btypes.Bond{BondID: "gb3", CouponBps: 800, Status: btypes.BondMatured}, GrowthRateBps: 0},
}
if err := btypes.ValidateGrowthBonds(gbs); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGrowthBonds should accept clean set; got: %v", err)
}
}
// TestValidateOrdersAcceptsClean asserts ValidateOrders accepts a clean set.
func TestValidateOrdersAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
orders := []btypes.SecondaryOrder{
{OrderID: "o1", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, Status: btypes.OrderOpen},
{OrderID: "o2", BondID: "b1", Side: btypes.OrderSell, Status: btypes.OrderFilled},
{OrderID: "o3", BondID: "b2", Side: btypes.OrderBuy, Status: btypes.OrderCancelled},
}
if err := btypes.ValidateOrders(orders); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateOrders should accept clean set; got: %v", err)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by
// walking up from this test file (v0.2 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
package types
import "fmt"
// genesis.go holds the data-engineer's genesis schema helpers for the
// bridge module (G-008 split). ValidateGenesis in types.go composes these
// helpers; the security-engineer's test assertions live in types_test.go.
//
// The Bridge genesis schema has one top-level set: Routes (the bridge
// routes). The invariants enforced at genesis load are (1) bridge-id
// uniqueness, (2) bridge-id non-empty, and (3) status is a known
// BridgeStatus. The route's l2-chain and watcher-quorum-id are by-ID-string
// refs (G-003) and are NOT referentially checked at genesis (the referenced
// x/satellite and x/watcher state is in separate modules; cross-module
// referential integrity is a v0.4 keeper concern, not a v0.3 skeleton
// concern per A-304).
// ValidateRoutes asserts bridge-ids are present and unique, and that each
// route's status is a known BridgeStatus. ValidateRoutes is the
// data-engineer's schema validator, composed by ValidateGenesis in
// types.go.
func ValidateRoutes(routes []BridgeRoute) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(routes))
for i, r := range routes {
if r.BridgeID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("bridge [%d]: empty bridge-id", i)
}
if seen[r.BridgeID] {
return fmt.Errorf("bridge: duplicate bridge-id %q", r.BridgeID)
}
seen[r.BridgeID] = true
if !knownBridgeStatus(r.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("bridge %q: unknown bridge status %q", r.BridgeID, r.Status)
}
}
return nil
}
// knownBridgeStatus reports whether s is one of the four BridgeStatus
// values.
func knownBridgeStatus(s BridgeStatus) bool {
for _, ss := range AllBridgeStatuses() {
if s == ss {
return true
}
}
return false
}
+104
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,104 @@
package types
import (
"encoding/json"
"fmt"
)
const (
ModuleName = "bridge"
StoreKey = ModuleName
RouterKey = ModuleName
QuerierRoute = ModuleName
// BridgeStatusCount is the locked count of BridgeStatus enum values
// (vision §7, REQ-010, D-036). Four route-level lifecycle states:
// Pending, Attested, Active, Closed. A regression firewall:
// adding/removing/renaming a status breaks this const's test.
BridgeStatusCount = 4
)
// BridgeStatus enumerates the route-level lifecycle of an L2↔L1 bridge
// (vision §7, REQ-010, D-036). The four-state lifecycle sits above the
// ICS-20 channel handshake (x/satellite ChannelStatus): a bridge route is
// Pending until Watcher attestation confirms it (Attested), then it
// becomes Active for transfers, and is Closed when the route is retired.
// The Attested state references a Watcher quorum by ID-string (the
// attestation is a by-ID-string field, not a struct import — G-003).
type BridgeStatus string
const (
BridgePending BridgeStatus = "Pending" // route declared, awaiting attestation
BridgeAttested BridgeStatus = "Attested" // Watcher quorum confirmed the route
BridgeActive BridgeStatus = "Active" // route open for transfers
BridgeClosed BridgeStatus = "Closed" // route retired
)
// AllBridgeStatuses returns all four BridgeStatus values in vision §7
// route-lifecycle order. Locked-const test asserts exactly 4 entries.
func AllBridgeStatuses() []BridgeStatus {
return []BridgeStatus{
BridgePending,
BridgeAttested,
BridgeActive,
BridgeClosed,
}
}
// BridgeRoute is a single L2↔L1 bridge route (REQ-010, D-036). The route
// is the higher-level abstraction over the v0.2 satellite IBC transfer
// channel: it carries the route-level status lifecycle and the Watcher
// attestation ref, while the underlying channel handshake lives in
// x/satellite. All cross-module references are by-ID-string per G-003:
//
// - bridge-id is this route's unique identifier.
// - l2-chain references an x/satellite L2Chain by ID-string (the L2
// satellite chain this route bridges to/from). No struct import of
// x/satellite (G-003).
// - watcher-quorum-id references an x/watcher quorum by ID-string; it is
// set when status transitions to Attested (the Watcher 6-of-9 quorum
// attests the route per vision §7). No struct import of x/watcher.
//
// status is the route-level lifecycle (BridgeStatus), distinct from the
// channel-level handshake (x/satellite ChannelStatus).
type BridgeRoute struct {
BridgeID string `json:"bridge_id" yaml:"bridge_id"`
L2Chain string `json:"l2_chain" yaml:"l2_chain"`
WatcherQuorumID string `json:"watcher_quorum_id" yaml:"watcher_quorum_id"`
Status BridgeStatus `json:"status" yaml:"status"`
}
// Params for the bridge module (skeleton — no tunables in v0.3).
type Params struct{}
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
// GenesisState defines the bridge module genesis state (REQ-010). Routes
// is the set of bridge routes. ValidateGenesis enforces bridge-id
// uniqueness and status validity. The data-engineer's genesis.go holds
// the schema helpers (G-008 split).
type GenesisState struct {
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
Routes []BridgeRoute `json:"routes" yaml:"routes"`
}
func DefaultGenesisState() *GenesisState {
return &GenesisState{
Params: DefaultParams(),
Routes: []BridgeRoute{},
}
}
// ValidateGenesis performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1
// no-op): rejects duplicate bridge-ids and unknown statuses. Delegates to
// the data-engineer's genesis.go helpers (G-008).
func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
var gs GenesisState
if err := json.Unmarshal(bz, &gs); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("bridge: invalid genesis: %w", err)
}
if err := ValidateRoutes(gs.Routes); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("bridge: %w", err)
}
return nil
}
+278
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,278 @@
package types_test
import (
"encoding/json"
"os"
"path/filepath"
"runtime"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/oy/openyield/lexicon"
btypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/bridge/types"
)
// --- BridgeStatus enum (exactly 4) ---------------------------------------------
// TestBridgeStatusCountLockedConst asserts BridgeStatusCount == 4 and
// AllBridgeStatuses() returns exactly 4 (vision §7, REQ-010, D-036). A
// regression firewall: adding/removing/renaming a status breaks this test.
func TestBridgeStatusCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.BridgeStatusCount != 4 {
t.Errorf("BridgeStatusCount = %d, expected 4 (vision §7 LOCKED)", btypes.BridgeStatusCount)
}
all := btypes.AllBridgeStatuses()
if len(all) != 4 {
t.Errorf("AllBridgeStatuses() len = %d, expected 4", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllBridgeStatusesNames asserts the 4 vision §7 route-lifecycle names
// in order with no extras, no dups, no renames (Pending, Attested, Active,
// Closed).
func TestAllBridgeStatusesNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Pending", "Attested", "Active", "Closed"}
all := btypes.AllBridgeStatuses()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, s := range all {
if string(s) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllBridgeStatuses()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, s, want[i])
}
if seen[string(s)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate BridgeStatus %q", s)
}
seen[string(s)] = true
}
}
// TestBridgeStatusValues asserts each named const matches its AllBridgeStatuses
// entry.
func TestBridgeStatusValues(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.BridgePending != "Pending" {
t.Errorf("BridgePending = %q", btypes.BridgePending)
}
if btypes.BridgeAttested != "Attested" {
t.Errorf("BridgeAttested = %q", btypes.BridgeAttested)
}
if btypes.BridgeActive != "Active" {
t.Errorf("BridgeActive = %q", btypes.BridgeActive)
}
if btypes.BridgeClosed != "Closed" {
t.Errorf("BridgeClosed = %q", btypes.BridgeClosed)
}
}
// --- BridgeRoute struct (by-ID-string refs — G-003) -----------------------------
// TestBridgeRouteStructFields asserts BridgeRoute carries all required
// fields including the by-ID-string refs to x/satellite (l2-chain) and
// x/watcher (watcher-quorum-id) per G-003. No struct imports of either
// referenced module (the G-003 import-invariant test enforces this).
func TestBridgeRouteStructFields(t *testing.T) {
r := btypes.BridgeRoute{
BridgeID: "bridge-1",
L2Chain: "Polygon", // by-ID-string ref to x/satellite L2Chain (G-003)
WatcherQuorumID: "quorum-1",
Status: btypes.BridgeActive,
}
if r.BridgeID != "bridge-1" {
t.Errorf("BridgeID = %q", r.BridgeID)
}
if r.L2Chain != "Polygon" {
t.Errorf("L2Chain = %q", r.L2Chain)
}
if r.WatcherQuorumID != "quorum-1" {
t.Errorf("WatcherQuorumID = %q", r.WatcherQuorumID)
}
if r.Status != btypes.BridgeActive {
t.Errorf("Status = %q", r.Status)
}
}
// TestBridgeRouteL2ChainIsString asserts the L2Chain field is an opaque
// string (by-ID-string ref — G-003), NOT a typed enum import from
// x/satellite. This locks the by-ID-string invariant at the type level.
func TestBridgeRouteL2ChainIsString(t *testing.T) {
r := btypes.BridgeRoute{L2Chain: "Polygon"}
// The field must be assignable from a plain string (no satellite.L2Chain
// type needed).
r.L2Chain = "Base"
if r.L2Chain != "Base" {
t.Errorf("L2Chain = %q, want %q (must be plain string)", r.L2Chain, "Base")
}
}
// TestBridgeRouteWatcherQuorumIDIsString asserts the WatcherQuorumID field
// is an opaque string (by-ID-string ref to x/watcher — G-003).
func TestBridgeRouteWatcherQuorumIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
r := btypes.BridgeRoute{WatcherQuorumID: "quorum-9"}
if r.WatcherQuorumID != "quorum-9" {
t.Errorf("WatcherQuorumID = %q", r.WatcherQuorumID)
}
}
// --- Genesis tests (A-212) ------------------------------------------------------
// TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty asserts DefaultGenesisState returns a non-nil
// empty slice for Routes.
func TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.DefaultGenesisState()
if gs == nil {
t.Fatal("DefaultGenesisState returned nil")
}
if gs.Routes == nil || len(gs.Routes) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default Routes should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.Routes), gs.Routes == nil)
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupBridgeIDs asserts A-212: duplicate bridge-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupBridgeIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []btypes.BridgeRoute{
{BridgeID: "b1", L2Chain: "Polygon", Status: btypes.BridgePending},
{BridgeID: "b1", L2Chain: "Base", Status: btypes.BridgeActive}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate bridge-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyBridgeID asserts empty bridge-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyBridgeID(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []btypes.BridgeRoute{{BridgeID: "", L2Chain: "Polygon", Status: btypes.BridgePending}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty bridge-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownStatus asserts an unknown BridgeStatus
// is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownStatus(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []btypes.BridgeRoute{{BridgeID: "b1", L2Chain: "Polygon", Status: btypes.BridgeStatus("Bogus")}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown bridge status")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON asserts malformed JSON is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON(t *testing.T) {
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(json.RawMessage(`{not json`)); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject malformed JSON")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean asserts a clean genesis validates.
func TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
gs := btypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []btypes.BridgeRoute{
{BridgeID: "b1", L2Chain: "Polygon", WatcherQuorumID: "q1", Status: btypes.BridgeActive},
{BridgeID: "b2", L2Chain: "Base", Status: btypes.BridgePending},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := btypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGenesis should accept clean genesis, got: %v", err)
}
}
// --- Module consts -------------------------------------------------------------
// TestModuleConsts asserts the four Cosmos-convention module consts.
func TestModuleConsts(t *testing.T) {
if btypes.ModuleName != "bridge" {
t.Errorf("ModuleName = %q", btypes.ModuleName)
}
if btypes.StoreKey != "bridge" {
t.Errorf("StoreKey = %q", btypes.StoreKey)
}
if btypes.RouterKey != "bridge" {
t.Errorf("RouterKey = %q", btypes.RouterKey)
}
if btypes.QuerierRoute != "bridge" {
t.Errorf("QuerierRoute = %q", btypes.QuerierRoute)
}
}
// TestDefaultParams asserts DefaultParams returns a zero-value Params.
func TestDefaultParams(t *testing.T) {
_ = btypes.DefaultParams() // no panics
}
// --- Lexicon assertion (REQ-012) -------------------------------------------------
//
// The bridge module must avoid the banned financial holder terms (the
// lexicon firewall's banned list). Use "Holder"/"Reach" instead. The lexicon
// helpers are used here — no banned literals are inlined.
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBridgePackage scans every non-test .go file in
// the bridge/types package directory for the banned terms (case-insensitive).
// Production files only — the test file references banned terms via the
// lexicon package helpers (standard lexicon-test bootstrapping pattern).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBridgePackage(t *testing.T) {
pkgDir := packageDir(t, "github.com/oy/openyield/x/bridge/types")
files, err := filepath.Glob(filepath.Join(pkgDir, "*.go"))
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("glob: %v", err)
}
prodFiles := []string{}
for _, f := range files {
if strings.HasSuffix(f, "_test.go") {
continue
}
prodFiles = append(prodFiles, f)
}
if len(prodFiles) == 0 {
t.Fatal("no production .go files found in bridge/types")
}
for _, f := range prodFiles {
bz, err := os.ReadFile(f)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read %s: %v", f, err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Errorf("%s: banned term %q (REQ-012 lexicon firewall — use Holder/Reach, not banned financial terms)", filepath.Base(f), found)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBridgeTestFile asserts this test file itself
// does not contain any banned term as a literal.
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInBridgeTestFile(t *testing.T) {
_, thisFile, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
bz, err := os.ReadFile(thisFile)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read self: %v", err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Fatalf("bridge test file contains banned term %q — use lexicon helpers, not literals", found)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by
// walking up from this test file (v0.3 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
// file = .../oy/x/bridge/types/types_test.go -> repoRoot = .../oy (4 dirs up)
repoRoot := filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))))
rel := strings.TrimPrefix(importPath, "github.com/oy/openyield/")
return filepath.Join(repoRoot, rel)
}
+52
View File
@@ -109,6 +109,58 @@ func TestSignalKindCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
}
}
// TestSignalKindShapeIntentional (REQ-031, AUDIT §193 P1-2) is a regression
// GUARD that documents and locks the 4-source SignalKind shape. It is NOT a
// shape change — the existing TestSignalKindCountLockedConst already locks
// the count. This test adds the INTENT documentation so a future agent who
// changes SignalKindCount from 4 to 5 (e.g., to "restore" the spec's 5-source
// VoiceSource list) must also update this test, surfacing the AUDIT rationale
// for review.
//
// AUDIT §193 P1-2 rationale (why SignalKind is 4 sources, NOT the spec's 5):
//
// The v0.2 P3-01-01 deliverable specified VoiceSource with 5 sources
// (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Freeholder/Guild). The implementation uses
// SignalKind with 4 sources (Stash/Standing/Vouch/Capital). The 4-source
// shape is a defensible design refinement:
// - Freeholder is an ELIGIBILITY property (upstream in x/standing), not
// a voice signal. A Freeholder-eligible Reach is a precondition for
// voting, not a signal that feeds a vote's weight.
// - Guild is a COUNCIL TIER (one of the three councils is the Guild
// Council), not a voice signal. Including Guild as a signal kind
// would conflate the council tier with the signal source.
// - Capital is committed-capital (vision §9.1, one of the four
// Freeholder signals per REQ-005), which the spec's VoiceSource list
// omitted. Adding Capital corrects the spec to match vision §9.1's
// four-signal definition (REQ-005: "Four Freeholder signals locked").
//
// The 4-source shape matches REQ-005 exactly. The spec deliverable text
// was wrong, not the implementation. v0.4 (D-050) DOCUMENTS this and
// locks the 4-source shape; changing it to 5 is a locked-const change
// rejected by the D-001 refinement-only filter and deferred to a future
// milestone that re-litigates REQ-005's signal definition.
//
// See .ciagent/oy/ARCHITECTURE.md §"Council Voice/Council Interface —
// Lifecycle Type Divergence Decisions (v0.4, REQ-031)" for the full rationale.
func TestSignalKindShapeIntentional(t *testing.T) {
// LOCKED: 4 sources. Changing this to 5 requires updating this test's
// intent block AND re-litigating REQ-005's four-signal definition.
const expectedSignalCount = 4
if types.SignalKindCount != expectedSignalCount {
t.Fatalf("SignalKindCount = %d, want %d (REQ-031 intent guard: the 4-source shape is intentional per AUDIT §193 P1-2; see ARCHITECTURE.md v0.4 divergence section before changing this)", types.SignalKindCount, expectedSignalCount)
}
want := []types.SignalKind{types.SignalStash, types.SignalStanding, types.SignalVouch, types.SignalCapital}
all := types.AllSignalKinds()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("AllSignalKinds() len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
for i, s := range all {
if s != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllSignalKinds()[%d] = %q, want %q (REQ-031 intent guard: the 4-source shape {Stash, Standing, Vouch, Capital} is intentional per AUDIT §193 P1-2; Freeholder and Guild are NOT signal kinds)", i, s, want[i])
}
}
}
// TestAllSignalKindsNames asserts the 4 signal names (Stash, Standing,
// Vouch, Capital) cross-ref v0.1 x/standing FreeholderSignals (StashMaturity,
// MultiDomainStanding, CommunityEndorsement, CommittedCapital).
+66
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
package types
import "fmt"
// genesis.go holds the data-engineer's genesis schema helpers for the
// exit module (G-008 split). ValidateGenesis in types.go composes these
// helpers; the security-engineer's test assertions live in types_test.go.
//
// The Exit genesis schema has two top-level sets: Routes (exit routes) and
// Swaps (DEX swaps). The invariants enforced at genesis load are (1)
// route-id uniqueness, (2) swap-id uniqueness, and (3) status validity.
// The route's bridge-route-id is a by-ID-string ref (G-003) and is NOT
// referentially checked at genesis (the referenced x/bridge state is in a
// separate module; cross-module referential integrity is a v0.4 keeper
// concern, not a v0.3 skeleton concern per A-308).
// ValidateRoutes asserts route-ids are present and unique, and that each
// route's status is a known ExitStatus. ValidateRoutes is the
// data-engineer's schema validator, composed by ValidateGenesis in
// types.go.
func ValidateRoutes(routes []ExitRoute) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(routes))
for i, r := range routes {
if r.RouteID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("exit [%d]: empty route-id", i)
}
if seen[r.RouteID] {
return fmt.Errorf("exit: duplicate route-id %q", r.RouteID)
}
seen[r.RouteID] = true
if !knownExitStatus(r.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("exit %q: unknown exit status %q", r.RouteID, r.Status)
}
}
return nil
}
// ValidateSwaps asserts swap-ids are present and unique, and that each
// swap's status is a known ExitStatus. The venue is an opaque string
// (A-308) and is not validated against a locked enum.
func ValidateSwaps(swaps []DEXSwap) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(swaps))
for i, s := range swaps {
if s.SwapID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("exit [%d]: empty swap-id", i)
}
if seen[s.SwapID] {
return fmt.Errorf("exit: duplicate swap-id %q", s.SwapID)
}
seen[s.SwapID] = true
if !knownExitStatus(s.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("exit swap %q: unknown exit status %q", s.SwapID, s.Status)
}
}
return nil
}
// knownExitStatus reports whether s is one of the five ExitStatus values.
func knownExitStatus(s ExitStatus) bool {
for _, ss := range AllExitStatuses() {
if s == ss {
return true
}
}
return false
}
+122
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,122 @@
package types
import (
"encoding/json"
"fmt"
)
const (
ModuleName = "exit"
StoreKey = ModuleName
RouterKey = ModuleName
QuerierRoute = ModuleName
// ExitStatusCount is the locked count of ExitStatus enum values
// (vision §7, REQ-010, D-036). Five exit lifecycle states: Proposed,
// InProgress, Settled, Failed, Refunded. A regression firewall:
// adding/removing/renaming a status breaks this const's test.
ExitStatusCount = 5
)
// ExitStatus enumerates the lifecycle of a Layer-3 exit (vision §7,
// REQ-010, D-036). The five-state lifecycle covers both successful exits
// (Proposed → InProgress → Settled) and the failure/recovery paths
// (Failed → Refunded). Refunded is the terminal recovery state when an
// exit fails and the holder is made whole.
type ExitStatus string
const (
ExitProposed ExitStatus = "Proposed" // exit declared, not yet executing
ExitInProgress ExitStatus = "InProgress" // exit executing (swap/bridge hop)
ExitSettled ExitStatus = "Settled" // exit completed, holder paid out
ExitFailed ExitStatus = "Failed" // exit failed (slippage/timeout)
ExitRefunded ExitStatus = "Refunded" // failed exit refunded to holder
)
// AllExitStatuses returns all five ExitStatus values in vision §7 lifecycle
// order. Locked-const test asserts exactly 5 entries.
func AllExitStatuses() []ExitStatus {
return []ExitStatus{
ExitProposed,
ExitInProgress,
ExitSettled,
ExitFailed,
ExitRefunded,
}
}
// ExitRoute is a Holder-initiated exit route (REQ-010, D-036, A-308). The
// route describes a holder's intent to exit the mesh via a DEX swap and
// (optionally) a cross-chain bridge hop. All cross-module references are
// by-ID-string per G-003:
//
// - route-id is this route's unique identifier.
// - bridge-route-id references an x/bridge BridgeRoute by ID-string
// (A-308, G-003). It is optional (empty for same-chain exits) and
// present for cross-chain exits. No struct import of x/bridge.
// - status is the exit lifecycle (ExitStatus).
//
// The bridge-route-id is the P4 intra-phase dependency edge (x/bridge is
// authored first within P4; x/exit references it by ID-string only).
type ExitRoute struct {
RouteID string `json:"route_id" yaml:"route_id"`
BridgeRouteID string `json:"bridge_route_id" yaml:"bridge_route_id"`
Status ExitStatus `json:"status" yaml:"status"`
}
// DEXSwap is a single DEX swap executed as part of an exit route (REQ-010,
// D-036, A-308). The venue is an OPAQUE string (e.g. "uniswap-v3", "oy-dex")
// — NOT a locked enum. A-308: venues are operational, not protocol-locked;
// locking an enum now risks churn (uniswap-v3/v4, oy-dex, etc. change over
// time). The skeleton keeps the venue as a free-form string so the type
// shape is stable across venue additions. status reuses ExitStatus (a swap
// shares the exit lifecycle: Proposed → InProgress → Settled/Failed).
//
// - swap-id is this swap's unique identifier.
// - venue is the opaque DEX venue string (A-308 — not a locked enum).
// - status is the swap lifecycle (ExitStatus).
type DEXSwap struct {
SwapID string `json:"swap_id" yaml:"swap_id"`
Venue string `json:"venue" yaml:"venue"`
Status ExitStatus `json:"status" yaml:"status"`
}
// Params for the exit module (skeleton — no tunables in v0.3).
type Params struct{}
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
// GenesisState defines the exit module genesis state (REQ-010). Routes is
// the set of exit routes; Swaps is the set of DEX swaps. ValidateGenesis
// enforces route-id and swap-id uniqueness. The data-engineer's genesis.go
// holds the schema helpers (G-008 split).
type GenesisState struct {
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
Routes []ExitRoute `json:"routes" yaml:"routes"`
Swaps []DEXSwap `json:"swaps" yaml:"swaps"`
}
func DefaultGenesisState() *GenesisState {
return &GenesisState{
Params: DefaultParams(),
Routes: []ExitRoute{},
Swaps: []DEXSwap{},
}
}
// ValidateGenesis performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1
// no-op): rejects duplicate route-ids and swap-ids. Delegates to the
// data-engineer's genesis.go helpers (G-008).
func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
var gs GenesisState
if err := json.Unmarshal(bz, &gs); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("exit: invalid genesis: %w", err)
}
if err := ValidateRoutes(gs.Routes); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("exit: %w", err)
}
if err := ValidateSwaps(gs.Swaps); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("exit: %w", err)
}
return nil
}
+390
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,390 @@
package types_test
import (
"encoding/json"
"os"
"path/filepath"
"runtime"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/oy/openyield/lexicon"
etypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/exit/types"
)
// --- ExitStatus enum (exactly 5) -----------------------------------------------
// TestExitStatusCountLockedConst asserts ExitStatusCount == 5 and
// AllExitStatuses() returns exactly 5 (vision §7, REQ-010, D-036). A
// regression firewall: adding/removing/renaming a status breaks this test.
func TestExitStatusCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if etypes.ExitStatusCount != 5 {
t.Errorf("ExitStatusCount = %d, expected 5 (vision §7 LOCKED)", etypes.ExitStatusCount)
}
all := etypes.AllExitStatuses()
if len(all) != 5 {
t.Errorf("AllExitStatuses() len = %d, expected 5", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllExitStatusesNames asserts the 5 vision §7 exit-lifecycle names in
// order with no extras, no dups, no renames (Proposed, InProgress, Settled,
// Failed, Refunded).
func TestAllExitStatusesNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Proposed", "InProgress", "Settled", "Failed", "Refunded"}
all := etypes.AllExitStatuses()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, s := range all {
if string(s) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllExitStatuses()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, s, want[i])
}
if seen[string(s)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate ExitStatus %q", s)
}
seen[string(s)] = true
}
}
// TestExitStatusValues asserts each named const matches its AllExitStatuses
// entry.
func TestExitStatusValues(t *testing.T) {
if etypes.ExitProposed != "Proposed" {
t.Errorf("ExitProposed = %q", etypes.ExitProposed)
}
if etypes.ExitInProgress != "InProgress" {
t.Errorf("ExitInProgress = %q", etypes.ExitInProgress)
}
if etypes.ExitSettled != "Settled" {
t.Errorf("ExitSettled = %q", etypes.ExitSettled)
}
if etypes.ExitFailed != "Failed" {
t.Errorf("ExitFailed = %q", etypes.ExitFailed)
}
if etypes.ExitRefunded != "Refunded" {
t.Errorf("ExitRefunded = %q", etypes.ExitRefunded)
}
}
// --- ExitRoute struct (bridge-route-id by-ID-string — G-003/A-308) ----------------
// TestExitRouteStructFields asserts ExitRoute carries all required fields
// including the by-ID-string ref to x/bridge BridgeRoute (bridge-route-id)
// per A-308/G-003. No struct import of x/bridge (the G-003 import-invariant
// test enforces this).
func TestExitRouteStructFields(t *testing.T) {
r := etypes.ExitRoute{
RouteID: "route-1",
BridgeRouteID: "bridge-1", // by-ID-string ref to x/bridge (A-308/G-003)
Status: etypes.ExitProposed,
}
if r.RouteID != "route-1" {
t.Errorf("RouteID = %q", r.RouteID)
}
if r.BridgeRouteID != "bridge-1" {
t.Errorf("BridgeRouteID = %q", r.BridgeRouteID)
}
if r.Status != etypes.ExitProposed {
t.Errorf("Status = %q", r.Status)
}
}
// TestExitRouteBridgeRouteIDIsString asserts the BridgeRouteID field is an
// opaque string (by-ID-string ref — G-003), NOT a typed x/bridge.BridgeRoute
// import. This locks the by-ID-string invariant at the type level.
func TestExitRouteBridgeRouteIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
r := etypes.ExitRoute{BridgeRouteID: "bridge-9"}
// The field must be assignable from a plain string (no bridge.BridgeRoute
// type needed).
r.BridgeRouteID = "bridge-2"
if r.BridgeRouteID != "bridge-2" {
t.Errorf("BridgeRouteID = %q, want %q (must be plain string)", r.BridgeRouteID, "bridge-2")
}
}
// TestExitRouteBridgeRouteIDOptional asserts an empty bridge-route-id is
// valid (same-chain exits have no bridge hop).
func TestExitRouteBridgeRouteIDOptional(t *testing.T) {
r := etypes.ExitRoute{
RouteID: "same-chain-exit",
BridgeRouteID: "", // empty = same-chain exit (no bridge hop)
Status: etypes.ExitSettled,
}
if r.BridgeRouteID != "" {
t.Errorf("BridgeRouteID should be empty for same-chain exit; got %q", r.BridgeRouteID)
}
}
// --- DEXSwap struct (opaque venue — A-308) --------------------------------------
// TestDEXSwapStructFields asserts DEXSwap carries all required fields
// including the opaque venue string (A-308) and an ExitStatus.
func TestDEXSwapStructFields(t *testing.T) {
s := etypes.DEXSwap{
SwapID: "swap-1",
Venue: "uniswap-v3",
Status: etypes.ExitSettled,
}
if s.SwapID != "swap-1" {
t.Errorf("SwapID = %q", s.SwapID)
}
if s.Venue != "uniswap-v3" {
t.Errorf("Venue = %q", s.Venue)
}
if s.Status != etypes.ExitSettled {
t.Errorf("Status = %q", s.Status)
}
}
// TestDEXSwapVenueIsOpaqueString asserts the DEXSwap venue is an opaque
// string, NOT a locked enum (A-308 — venues are operational, locking now
// risks churn). The field must accept any free-form string.
func TestDEXSwapVenueIsOpaqueString(t *testing.T) {
// A-308: venue is an opaque string, not a locked enum. Various venue
// strings must be assignable without any enum type.
venues := []string{"uniswap-v3", "oy-dex", "1inch", "paraswap", "0x-api", "custom-venue-xyz"}
for _, v := range venues {
s := etypes.DEXSwap{SwapID: "s", Venue: v}
if s.Venue != v {
t.Errorf("Venue = %q, want %q (A-308: venue must be opaque string)", s.Venue, v)
}
}
}
// TestDEXSwapVenueTypeIsString asserts the Venue field's Go type is the
// built-in string (not a typed enum). This locks A-308 at the type level:
// the field is a plain string, so any venue string is assignable without
// conversion.
func TestDEXSwapVenueTypeIsString(t *testing.T) {
s := etypes.DEXSwap{}
// Assigning a plain string literal must compile and work — no enum
// conversion needed. If venue were a typed enum, assigning a plain
// string would require a type conversion (e.g. etypes.Venue("x")).
s.Venue = "any-string-works"
var want string = "any-string-works"
if s.Venue != want {
t.Errorf("Venue type is not plain string (A-308): got %q want %q", s.Venue, want)
}
}
// TestDEXSwapStatusReusesExitStatus asserts the DEXSwap status field reuses
// the ExitStatus enum (a swap shares the exit lifecycle).
func TestDEXSwapStatusReusesExitStatus(t *testing.T) {
statuses := etypes.AllExitStatuses()
for _, st := range statuses {
s := etypes.DEXSwap{SwapID: "s", Venue: "v", Status: st}
if s.Status != st {
t.Errorf("DEXSwap.Status = %q, want %q (must reuse ExitStatus)", s.Status, st)
}
}
}
// --- Genesis tests (A-212) ------------------------------------------------------
// TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty asserts DefaultGenesisState returns non-nil
// empty slices for Routes and Swaps.
func TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.DefaultGenesisState()
if gs == nil {
t.Fatal("DefaultGenesisState returned nil")
}
if gs.Routes == nil || len(gs.Routes) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default Routes should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.Routes), gs.Routes == nil)
}
if gs.Swaps == nil || len(gs.Swaps) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default Swaps should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.Swaps), gs.Swaps == nil)
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupRouteIDs asserts A-212: duplicate route-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupRouteIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []etypes.ExitRoute{
{RouteID: "r1", Status: etypes.ExitProposed},
{RouteID: "r1", Status: etypes.ExitSettled}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate route-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyRouteID asserts empty route-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyRouteID(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []etypes.ExitRoute{{RouteID: "", Status: etypes.ExitProposed}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty route-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownRouteStatus asserts an unknown ExitStatus
// on a route is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownRouteStatus(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []etypes.ExitRoute{{RouteID: "r1", Status: etypes.ExitStatus("Bogus")}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown exit status on route")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupSwapIDs asserts A-212: duplicate swap-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupSwapIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Swaps: []etypes.DEXSwap{
{SwapID: "s1", Venue: "uniswap-v3", Status: etypes.ExitSettled},
{SwapID: "s1", Venue: "oy-dex", Status: etypes.ExitProposed}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate swap-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptySwapID asserts empty swap-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptySwapID(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Swaps: []etypes.DEXSwap{{SwapID: "", Venue: "oy-dex", Status: etypes.ExitProposed}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty swap-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownSwapStatus asserts an unknown ExitStatus
// on a swap is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownSwapStatus(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Swaps: []etypes.DEXSwap{{SwapID: "s1", Venue: "oy-dex", Status: etypes.ExitStatus("Bogus")}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown exit status on swap")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON asserts malformed JSON is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON(t *testing.T) {
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(json.RawMessage(`{not json`)); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject malformed JSON")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean asserts a clean genesis validates.
func TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
gs := etypes.GenesisState{
Routes: []etypes.ExitRoute{
{RouteID: "r1", BridgeRouteID: "bridge-1", Status: etypes.ExitInProgress},
{RouteID: "r2", BridgeRouteID: "", Status: etypes.ExitSettled}, // same-chain exit
},
Swaps: []etypes.DEXSwap{
{SwapID: "s1", Venue: "uniswap-v3", Status: etypes.ExitSettled},
{SwapID: "s2", Venue: "oy-dex", Status: etypes.ExitProposed},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := etypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGenesis should accept clean genesis, got: %v", err)
}
}
// --- Module consts -------------------------------------------------------------
// TestModuleConsts asserts the four Cosmos-convention module consts.
func TestModuleConsts(t *testing.T) {
if etypes.ModuleName != "exit" {
t.Errorf("ModuleName = %q", etypes.ModuleName)
}
if etypes.StoreKey != "exit" {
t.Errorf("StoreKey = %q", etypes.StoreKey)
}
if etypes.RouterKey != "exit" {
t.Errorf("RouterKey = %q", etypes.RouterKey)
}
if etypes.QuerierRoute != "exit" {
t.Errorf("QuerierRoute = %q", etypes.QuerierRoute)
}
}
// TestDefaultParams asserts DefaultParams returns a zero-value Params.
func TestDefaultParams(t *testing.T) {
_ = etypes.DefaultParams() // no panics
}
// --- Lexicon assertion (REQ-012) -------------------------------------------------
//
// The exit module must avoid the banned financial holder terms (the
// lexicon firewall's banned list). Use "Holder"/"Reach" instead. The lexicon
// helpers are used here — no banned literals are inlined.
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInExitPackage scans every non-test .go file in
// the exit/types package directory for the banned terms (case-insensitive).
// Production files only — the test file references banned terms via the
// lexicon package helpers (standard lexicon-test bootstrapping pattern).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInExitPackage(t *testing.T) {
pkgDir := packageDir(t, "github.com/oy/openyield/x/exit/types")
files, err := filepath.Glob(filepath.Join(pkgDir, "*.go"))
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("glob: %v", err)
}
prodFiles := []string{}
for _, f := range files {
if strings.HasSuffix(f, "_test.go") {
continue
}
prodFiles = append(prodFiles, f)
}
if len(prodFiles) == 0 {
t.Fatal("no production .go files found in exit/types")
}
for _, f := range prodFiles {
bz, err := os.ReadFile(f)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read %s: %v", f, err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Errorf("%s: banned term %q (REQ-012 lexicon firewall — use Holder/Reach, not banned financial terms)", filepath.Base(f), found)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInExitTestFile asserts this test file itself
// does not contain any banned term as a literal.
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInExitTestFile(t *testing.T) {
_, thisFile, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
bz, err := os.ReadFile(thisFile)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read self: %v", err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Fatalf("exit test file contains banned term %q — use lexicon helpers, not literals", found)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by
// walking up from this test file (v0.3 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
// file = .../oy/x/exit/types/types_test.go -> repoRoot = .../oy (4 dirs up)
repoRoot := filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))))
rel := strings.TrimPrefix(importPath, "github.com/oy/openyield/")
return filepath.Join(repoRoot, rel)
}
+70
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,70 @@
package types
// cross_const_test.go (REQ-030, REVIEW.md P2 / A-304, GRILL G-015) is a
// cross-package const-equality test that catches silent drift between the
// x/hub LOCAL consts (LendingCouponCapBps / LendingCouponFloorBps) and the
// x/bond mission-locked consts (CouponCapBps / CouponFloorBps, D-028).
//
// Before REQ-030, the two const pairs were cross-documented only by a comment
// (x/hub/types/types.go:46-55) — no automated check existed. A future
// mission-locked change to x/bond.CouponCapBps without a matching x/hub change
// would silently drift. This test fails closed on either kind of drift:
//
// - single-sided drift: hub stays 800, bond changes to 900 → the equality
// test fails.
// - paired drift: BOTH change to the same wrong value (e.g., both 900) → the
// equality test passes BUT the absolute-value test (G-015) fails, because
// the mission-locked value is 800, not 900.
//
// G-003 (no production cross-module struct imports): this is a TEST-ONLY
// import of x/bond/types in a _test.go file. G-003's test-import exemption
// (documented in v0.2 GRILL G-003 and already exercised by
// x/bearers/types/types_test.go:7 importing x/processing/types) permits
// cross-package test imports. NO production .go file in x/hub/types/ imports
// x/bond/types (the P1-99-01 verification greps non-test .go files to confirm).
import (
"testing"
bondtypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/bond/types"
)
// TestLendingCouponCapMatchesBondCap asserts the x/hub LOCAL
// LendingCouponCapBps equals the x/bond mission-locked CouponCapBps (A-304).
// Fails on single-sided drift (one changes, the other does not).
func TestLendingCouponCapMatchesBondCap(t *testing.T) {
if LendingCouponCapBps != bondtypes.CouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("A-304 drift: x/hub LendingCouponCapBps = %d, x/bond CouponCapBps = %d (must match)", LendingCouponCapBps, bondtypes.CouponCapBps)
}
}
// TestLendingCouponFloorMatchesBondFloor asserts the x/hub LOCAL
// LendingCouponFloorBps equals the x/bond mission-locked CouponFloorBps
// (A-304). Fails on single-sided drift.
func TestLendingCouponFloorMatchesBondFloor(t *testing.T) {
if LendingCouponFloorBps != bondtypes.CouponFloorBps {
t.Errorf("A-304 drift: x/hub LendingCouponFloorBps = %d, x/bond CouponFloorBps = %d (must match)", LendingCouponFloorBps, bondtypes.CouponFloorBps)
}
}
// TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0 (GRILL G-015) asserts the ABSOLUTE
// mission-locked values: both caps are 800 (8pct, D-028) and both floors are 0
// (0pct, D-028). This catches PAIRED drift — if both consts change to the same
// wrong value (e.g., both 900), the equality tests above pass but this test
// fails, because the mission-locked value is 800, not 900. The 8pct cap /
// 0pct floor is the anti-greed covenant (vision §17, §18); defending the
// absolute value is the highest-priority regression guard in v0.4.
func TestConstsAreMissionLocked800And0(t *testing.T) {
if LendingCouponCapBps != 800 {
t.Errorf("G-015: x/hub LendingCouponCapBps = %d, want 800 (mission-locked 8pct, D-028)", LendingCouponCapBps)
}
if bondtypes.CouponCapBps != 800 {
t.Errorf("G-015: x/bond CouponCapBps = %d, want 800 (mission-locked 8pct, D-028)", bondtypes.CouponCapBps)
}
if LendingCouponFloorBps != 0 {
t.Errorf("G-015: x/hub LendingCouponFloorBps = %d, want 0 (mission-locked 0pct, D-028)", LendingCouponFloorBps)
}
if bondtypes.CouponFloorBps != 0 {
t.Errorf("G-015: x/bond CouponFloorBps = %d, want 0 (mission-locked 0pct, D-028)", bondtypes.CouponFloorBps)
}
}
+245
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,245 @@
// Package types defines the Hub API module types (vision §13, REQ-024, D-039).
//
// The Hub is the B2B backbone: a registry of Hub-brokered services an Anchor
// partner operates. v0.3 ships the skeleton (enum + per-service struct stubs
// + genesis); the live B2B runtime is deferred to v0.4 (D-039).
//
// Lexicon note (REQ-012, A-210): the Hub is HIGH lexicon-risk because the
// lending primitive is a natural fit for the banned financial terms. The
// coupon vocabulary is used EXCLUSIVELY here — "lending"/"coupon"/"custody"/
// "compliance"/"jurisdiction" are the safe vision-§13 phrasings; the banned
// synonyms for these concepts NEVER appear in this package. "lending" is NOT
// a banned term (the banned list has the compounding term and the storage
// terms, not "lending" or "loan"); "coupon" is the bond vocabulary (vision
// §17). The per-package lexicon assertion in types_test.go is the gate.
//
// Cross-module references are by-ID-string per G-003 (no struct imports):
// - operator-partner-id references an x/partner Anchor Partner by ID-string
// (A-304, G-003). The Anchor extension lands in P4; x/hub in P5. The
// reference is a string, validated by the keeper against the partner
// registry at runtime, not by the type system.
// - LendingCouponCapBps is a LOCAL const cross-documented to D-028 /
// x/bond CouponCapBps (A-304). x/hub does NOT import x/bond; the cap is
// redefined locally so the lending-primitive coupon clamp is enforced
// without a cross-module struct import (mirrors how x/guild cross-docs
// x/feecovenant WaiverHandPassGuild).
package types
import (
"encoding/json"
"fmt"
)
const (
ModuleName = "hub"
StoreKey = ModuleName
RouterKey = ModuleName
QuerierRoute = ModuleName
// HubServiceCount is the locked count of HubService enum values (vision
// §13, REQ-024, A-312). A regression firewall: adding/removing/renaming a
// Hub service breaks this const's test.
HubServiceCount = 3
// LendingCouponCapBps is the LOCAL upper bound on a lending-primitive
// coupon in basis points (A-304). It is cross-documented to D-028 and
// x/bond.CouponCapBps (also 800, the mission-locked 8pct bond coupon cap).
// This const is LOCAL to x/hub to avoid importing x/bond (G-003 — no
// cross-module struct imports). The two consts MUST stay in sync; a
// change to x/bond.CouponCapBps requires a matching change here. The
// ClampLendingCoupon helper uses this local const, NOT x/bond.Clamp.
LendingCouponCapBps = uint32(800) // 8pct (cross-doc D-028 / x/bond CouponCapBps — A-304)
// LendingCouponFloorBps is the LOCAL lower bound on a lending-primitive
// coupon (A-304, cross-doc to D-028 / x/bond.CouponFloorBps = 0). Local
// const for the same G-003 reason as LendingCouponCapBps.
LendingCouponFloorBps = uint32(0) // 0pct (cross-doc D-028 / x/bond CouponFloorBps — A-304)
)
// HubService enumerates the three Hub-brokered B2B service categories (vision
// §13, REQ-024, A-312): Custody (asset safekeeping), LendingPrimitive (the
// protocol-level lending primitive, NOT a live market), Compliance (on-chain
// compliance attestations). The full B2B suite is deferred to v0.4 (D-039).
type HubService string
const (
ServiceCustody HubService = "Custody" // asset safekeeping
ServiceLendingPrimitive HubService = "LendingPrimitive" // protocol-level lending primitive
ServiceCompliance HubService = "Compliance" // on-chain compliance attestations
)
// AllHubServices returns all three HubService values in vision §13 order.
// Locked-const test asserts exactly 3 entries with these names (REQ-024).
func AllHubServices() []HubService {
return []HubService{
ServiceCustody,
ServiceLendingPrimitive,
ServiceCompliance,
}
}
// CustodyService is the per-service struct stub for a Hub custody service
// (vision §13, REQ-024). custody-id is the service identifier. operator-
// partner-id references an x/partner Anchor Partner by ID-string (A-304,
// G-003 — no struct import of x/partner). asset-ref is an opaque reference to
// the custodied asset (the asset identifier is opaque so the Hub does not
// import any asset-denom module).
type CustodyService struct {
CustodyID string `json:"custody_id" yaml:"custody_id"`
OperatorPartnerID string `json:"operator_partner_id" yaml:"operator_partner_id"`
AssetRef string `json:"asset_ref" yaml:"asset_ref"`
}
// LendingPrimitive is the per-service struct stub for a Hub lending-primitive
// service (vision §13, REQ-024). loan-id is the primitive identifier.
// principal-grain is the principal in Grain (the OY internal unit, cross-ref
// x/bread by name only — no struct import). coupon-bps is the coupon rate in
// basis points, clamped to [LendingCouponFloorBps, LendingCouponCapBps] by
// ClampLendingCoupon at construction (NewLendingPrimitive). term-days is the
// primitive term length. The coupon vocabulary is used EXCLUSIVELY here
// (A-210); the banned compounding term and storage terms NEVER appear.
type LendingPrimitive struct {
LoanID string `json:"loan_id" yaml:"loan_id"`
PrincipalGrain int64 `json:"principal_grain" yaml:"principal_grain"`
CouponBps uint32 `json:"coupon_bps" yaml:"coupon_bps"`
TermDays uint32 `json:"term_days" yaml:"term_days"`
}
// ComplianceService is the per-service struct stub for a Hub compliance
// service (vision §13, REQ-024). compliance-id is the service identifier.
// jurisdiction is an opaque jurisdiction tag (e.g. "EU-MiCA"). attestation-
// uri is an opaque URI to the compliance attestation (kept opaque in the
// skeleton, like the v0.2 Pier CredentialRef).
type ComplianceService struct {
ComplianceID string `json:"compliance_id" yaml:"compliance_id"`
Jurisdiction string `json:"jurisdiction" yaml:"jurisdiction"`
AttestationURI string `json:"attestation_uri" yaml:"attestation_uri"`
}
// ClampLendingCoupon ensures a lending-primitive coupon is within the LOCKED
// LOCAL bounds (A-304: never above the local cap, never below the local floor).
// This mirrors x/bond.Clamp's shape (min(cap, max(floor, coupon))) but uses the
// LOCAL LendingCouponCapBps / LendingCouponFloorBps consts — it does NOT import
// x/bond.Clamp (G-003). The clamp is automatic and authoritative; the live
// keeper enforces it at construction and at genesis load.
func ClampLendingCoupon(couponBps uint32) uint32 {
if couponBps > LendingCouponCapBps {
return LendingCouponCapBps
}
if couponBps < LendingCouponFloorBps {
return LendingCouponFloorBps
}
return couponBps
}
// NewLendingPrimitive constructs a LendingPrimitive with the coupon clamped to
// the LOCAL [floor, cap] bounds via ClampLendingCoupon (A-304). The stub does
// not persist or enforce referential integrity of operator-partner-id; it only
// enforces the coupon clamp invariant at construction time.
func NewLendingPrimitive(loanID string, principalGrain int64, couponBps uint32, termDays uint32) LendingPrimitive {
return LendingPrimitive{
LoanID: loanID,
PrincipalGrain: principalGrain,
CouponBps: ClampLendingCoupon(couponBps),
TermDays: termDays,
}
}
// Params for the hub module (skeleton — no tunables in v0.3; the lending
// coupon cap/floor are LOCKED LOCAL consts, not Params fields).
type Params struct{}
// DefaultParams returns the zero-value Params (skeleton — no tunables).
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
// GenesisState defines the hub module genesis state (REQ-024). The three
// slices hold the per-service stubs. ValidateGenesis enforces per-set ID
// uniqueness (A-212) and the lending-primitive coupon clamp at genesis load
// (each LendingPrimitive's coupon-bps must be within the LOCAL bounds).
type GenesisState struct {
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
CustodyServices []CustodyService `json:"custody_services" yaml:"custody_services"`
LendingPrimitives []LendingPrimitive `json:"lending_primitives" yaml:"lending_primitives"`
ComplianceServices []ComplianceService `json:"compliance_services" yaml:"compliance_services"`
}
// DefaultGenesisState returns an empty genesis state with non-nil slices.
func DefaultGenesisState() *GenesisState {
return &GenesisState{
Params: DefaultParams(),
CustodyServices: []CustodyService{},
LendingPrimitives: []LendingPrimitive{},
ComplianceServices: []ComplianceService{},
}
}
// ValidateGenesis performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1
// no-op) and the lending-primitive coupon clamp at genesis load (A-304):
// rejects duplicate custody-ids, loan-ids, compliance-ids, and any
// LendingPrimitive whose coupon-bps is outside the LOCAL [floor, cap] bounds.
func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
var gs GenesisState
if err := json.Unmarshal(bz, &gs); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("hub: invalid genesis: %w", err)
}
if err := validateCustodyServices(gs.CustodyServices); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("hub: %w", err)
}
if err := validateLendingPrimitives(gs.LendingPrimitives); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("hub: %w", err)
}
if err := validateComplianceServices(gs.ComplianceServices); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("hub: %w", err)
}
return nil
}
// validateCustodyServices enforces custody-id presence and uniqueness.
func validateCustodyServices(svcs []CustodyService) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(svcs))
for i, c := range svcs {
if c.CustodyID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("custody service [%d]: empty custody-id", i)
}
if seen[c.CustodyID] {
return fmt.Errorf("custody service: duplicate custody-id %q", c.CustodyID)
}
seen[c.CustodyID] = true
}
return nil
}
// validateLendingPrimitives enforces loan-id presence/uniqueness and the
// LOCAL coupon clamp at genesis load (A-304).
func validateLendingPrimitives(svcs []LendingPrimitive) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(svcs))
for i, l := range svcs {
if l.LoanID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("lending primitive [%d]: empty loan-id", i)
}
if seen[l.LoanID] {
return fmt.Errorf("lending primitive: duplicate loan-id %q", l.LoanID)
}
seen[l.LoanID] = true
if l.CouponBps < LendingCouponFloorBps || l.CouponBps > LendingCouponCapBps {
return fmt.Errorf("lending primitive %q: coupon-bps %d outside [%d, %d] (A-304 clamp at genesis load)",
l.LoanID, l.CouponBps, LendingCouponFloorBps, LendingCouponCapBps)
}
}
return nil
}
// validateComplianceServices enforces compliance-id presence and uniqueness.
func validateComplianceServices(svcs []ComplianceService) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(svcs))
for i, c := range svcs {
if c.ComplianceID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("compliance service [%d]: empty compliance-id", i)
}
if seen[c.ComplianceID] {
return fmt.Errorf("compliance service: duplicate compliance-id %q", c.ComplianceID)
}
seen[c.ComplianceID] = true
}
return nil
}
+424
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,424 @@
package types_test
import (
"encoding/json"
"os"
"path/filepath"
"runtime"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/oy/openyield/lexicon"
htypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/hub/types"
)
// --- HubService enum coverage (3) ----------------------------------------------
// TestHubServiceCountLockedConst asserts HubServiceCount == 3 and
// AllHubServices() returns exactly 3 (REQ-024, A-312). A regression firewall.
func TestHubServiceCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.HubServiceCount != 3 {
t.Errorf("HubServiceCount = %d, expected 3 (REQ-024 LOCKED)", htypes.HubServiceCount)
}
all := htypes.AllHubServices()
if len(all) != 3 {
t.Errorf("AllHubServices() len = %d, expected 3", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllHubServicesNames asserts the 3 REQ-024 names in order with no
// extras, no dups, no renames.
func TestAllHubServicesNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Custody", "LendingPrimitive", "Compliance"}
all := htypes.AllHubServices()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, s := range all {
if string(s) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllHubServices()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, s, want[i])
}
if seen[string(s)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate HubService %q", s)
}
seen[string(s)] = true
}
}
// TestHubServiceValues asserts each named const matches its AllHubServices
// entry.
func TestHubServiceValues(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.ServiceCustody != "Custody" {
t.Errorf("ServiceCustody = %q", htypes.ServiceCustody)
}
if htypes.ServiceLendingPrimitive != "LendingPrimitive" {
t.Errorf("ServiceLendingPrimitive = %q", htypes.ServiceLendingPrimitive)
}
if htypes.ServiceCompliance != "Compliance" {
t.Errorf("ServiceCompliance = %q", htypes.ServiceCompliance)
}
}
// --- LendingCouponCapBps LOCAL const (A-304) -----------------------------------
// TestLendingCouponCapBpsLockedConst asserts the LOCAL LendingCouponCapBps ==
// 800 (A-304 cross-doc to D-028 / x/bond.CouponCapBps). The const is LOCAL to
// x/hub to avoid importing x/bond (G-003); the test asserts the value matches
// the bond cap so the two consts stay in sync.
func TestLendingCouponCapBpsLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.LendingCouponCapBps != 800 {
t.Errorf("LendingCouponCapBps = %d, expected 800 (A-304 cross-doc D-028)", htypes.LendingCouponCapBps)
}
}
// TestLendingCouponFloorBpsLockedConst asserts the LOCAL
// LendingCouponFloorBps == 0 (A-304 cross-doc to D-028 / x/bond.CouponFloorBps).
func TestLendingCouponFloorBpsLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.LendingCouponFloorBps != 0 {
t.Errorf("LendingCouponFloorBps = %d, expected 0 (A-304 cross-doc D-028)", htypes.LendingCouponFloorBps)
}
}
// --- ClampLendingCoupon invariants (A-304) -------------------------------------
// The ClampLendingCoupon invariant is the hub module's firewall (A-304): a
// lending-primitive coupon can never exceed the local cap (8pct) and can
// never fall below the local floor (0pct). These tests are the regression
// firewall — a change to LendingCouponCapBps or LendingCouponFloorBps breaks
// them.
// TestClampLendingCouponBelowFloorReturnsFloor asserts a coupon below the
// floor is clamped up to the floor. The floor is 0 and uint32 cannot be
// negative, so the below-floor case is type-prevented; the test asserts the
// floor boundary passes through.
func TestClampLendingCouponBelowFloorReturnsFloor(t *testing.T) {
got := htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(htypes.LendingCouponFloorBps)
if got != htypes.LendingCouponFloorBps {
t.Errorf("ClampLendingCoupon(floor) = %d, expected floor %d", got, htypes.LendingCouponFloorBps)
}
}
// TestClampLendingCouponAboveCapReturnsCap asserts a coupon above the cap is
// clamped down to the cap.
func TestClampLendingCouponAboveCapReturnsCap(t *testing.T) {
cases := []uint32{
uint32(htypes.LendingCouponCapBps) + 1,
uint32(htypes.LendingCouponCapBps) + 100,
uint32(htypes.LendingCouponCapBps) + 1000,
900,
1000,
5000,
}
for _, c := range cases {
got := htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(c)
if got != htypes.LendingCouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("ClampLendingCoupon(%d) = %d, expected cap %d (above-cap must clamp to cap)", c, got, htypes.LendingCouponCapBps)
}
}
}
// TestClampLendingCouponInRangeUnchanged asserts a coupon within [floor, cap]
// is unchanged.
func TestClampLendingCouponInRangeUnchanged(t *testing.T) {
cases := []uint32{
0,
1,
100,
400,
500,
799,
uint32(htypes.LendingCouponCapBps),
}
for _, c := range cases {
got := htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(c)
if got != c {
t.Errorf("ClampLendingCoupon(%d) = %d, expected %d (in-range must be unchanged)", c, got, c)
}
}
}
// TestClampLendingCouponShape asserts the min(cap, max(floor, coupon)) shape
// at the boundaries.
func TestClampLendingCouponShape(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(0) != 0 {
t.Error("ClampLendingCoupon(0) should be 0 (floor boundary)")
}
if htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(800) != 800 {
t.Error("ClampLendingCoupon(800) should be 800 (cap boundary)")
}
if htypes.ClampLendingCoupon(801) != 800 {
t.Error("ClampLendingCoupon(801) should be 800 (above-cap clamps to cap)")
}
}
// --- Per-service struct stubs --------------------------------------------------
// TestCustodyServiceStructFields asserts CustodyService carries custody-id,
// operator-partner-id (by-ID-string ref to x/partner Anchor — G-003), asset-ref.
func TestCustodyServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
c := htypes.CustodyService{
CustodyID: "cust-1",
OperatorPartnerID: "anchor-partner-1",
AssetRef: "bread-grain",
}
if c.CustodyID != "cust-1" || c.OperatorPartnerID != "anchor-partner-1" || c.AssetRef != "bread-grain" {
t.Error("CustodyService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestCustodyServiceOperatorPartnerIDIsString asserts operator-partner-id is
// string-typed (G-003 by-ID-string ref to x/partner Anchor; no struct import).
func TestCustodyServiceOperatorPartnerIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
c := htypes.CustodyService{OperatorPartnerID: "anchor-1"}
if c.OperatorPartnerID != "anchor-1" {
t.Errorf("OperatorPartnerID = %q", c.OperatorPartnerID)
}
}
// TestLendingPrimitiveStructFields asserts LendingPrimitive carries loan-id,
// principal-grain, coupon-bps, term-days.
func TestLendingPrimitiveStructFields(t *testing.T) {
l := htypes.LendingPrimitive{
LoanID: "loan-1",
PrincipalGrain: 1_000_000,
CouponBps: 500,
TermDays: 365,
}
if l.LoanID != "loan-1" || l.PrincipalGrain != 1_000_000 || l.CouponBps != 500 || l.TermDays != 365 {
t.Error("LendingPrimitive fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestNewLendingPrimitiveClampsCoupon asserts NewLendingPrimitive clamps an
// above-cap coupon down to the cap and leaves an in-range coupon unchanged.
func TestNewLendingPrimitiveClampsCoupon(t *testing.T) {
l := htypes.NewLendingPrimitive("loan-2", 500_000, 1200, 180)
if l.CouponBps != htypes.LendingCouponCapBps {
t.Errorf("CouponBps = %d, expected cap %d (NewLendingPrimitive must clamp above-cap coupon)", l.CouponBps, htypes.LendingCouponCapBps)
}
l2 := htypes.NewLendingPrimitive("loan-3", 500_000, 300, 180)
if l2.CouponBps != 300 {
t.Errorf("CouponBps = %d, expected 300 (in-range, unchanged)", l2.CouponBps)
}
}
// TestComplianceServiceStructFields asserts ComplianceService carries
// compliance-id, jurisdiction, attestation-uri.
func TestComplianceServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
c := htypes.ComplianceService{
ComplianceID: "comp-1",
Jurisdiction: "EU-MiCA",
AttestationURI: "ipfs://attestation/abc",
}
if c.ComplianceID != "comp-1" || c.Jurisdiction != "EU-MiCA" || c.AttestationURI != "ipfs://attestation/abc" {
t.Error("ComplianceService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// --- Module consts + Params ----------------------------------------------------
// TestModuleConsts asserts the four Cosmos-convention module consts.
func TestModuleConsts(t *testing.T) {
if htypes.ModuleName != "hub" {
t.Errorf("ModuleName = %q", htypes.ModuleName)
}
if htypes.StoreKey != "hub" {
t.Errorf("StoreKey = %q", htypes.StoreKey)
}
if htypes.RouterKey != "hub" {
t.Errorf("RouterKey = %q", htypes.RouterKey)
}
if htypes.QuerierRoute != "hub" {
t.Errorf("QuerierRoute = %q", htypes.QuerierRoute)
}
}
// TestDefaultParams asserts DefaultParams returns a zero-value Params.
func TestDefaultParams(t *testing.T) {
_ = htypes.DefaultParams() // no panics
}
// --- Genesis -------------------------------------------------------------------
// TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty asserts DefaultGenesisState returns non-nil
// empty slices for all three service sets.
func TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.DefaultGenesisState()
if gs == nil {
t.Fatal("DefaultGenesisState returned nil")
}
if gs.CustodyServices == nil || len(gs.CustodyServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default CustodyServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.CustodyServices), gs.CustodyServices == nil)
}
if gs.LendingPrimitives == nil || len(gs.LendingPrimitives) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default LendingPrimitives should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.LendingPrimitives), gs.LendingPrimitives == nil)
}
if gs.ComplianceServices == nil || len(gs.ComplianceServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default ComplianceServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.ComplianceServices), gs.ComplianceServices == nil)
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupCustodyIDs asserts A-212: duplicate custody-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupCustodyIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
CustodyServices: []htypes.CustodyService{
{CustodyID: "c1", OperatorPartnerID: "a1"},
{CustodyID: "c1", OperatorPartnerID: "a2"}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate custody-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyCustodyID asserts empty custody-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyCustodyID(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
CustodyServices: []htypes.CustodyService{{CustodyID: "", OperatorPartnerID: "a1"}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty custody-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupLoanIDs asserts duplicate loan-ids are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupLoanIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
LendingPrimitives: []htypes.LendingPrimitive{
{LoanID: "l1", CouponBps: 100},
{LoanID: "l1", CouponBps: 200}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate loan-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsCouponAboveCap asserts the genesis-side clamp: a
// LendingPrimitive with coupon-bps above the local cap is rejected (A-304).
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsCouponAboveCap(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
LendingPrimitives: []htypes.LendingPrimitive{
{LoanID: "l1", CouponBps: uint32(htypes.LendingCouponCapBps) + 1},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject lending-primitive coupon-bps above local cap (A-304)")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupComplianceIDs asserts duplicate compliance-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupComplianceIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
ComplianceServices: []htypes.ComplianceService{
{ComplianceID: "comp-1"},
{ComplianceID: "comp-1"}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate compliance-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON asserts malformed JSON is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON(t *testing.T) {
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(json.RawMessage(`{not json`)); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject malformed JSON")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean asserts a clean genesis validates.
func TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
gs := htypes.GenesisState{
CustodyServices: []htypes.CustodyService{
{CustodyID: "c1", OperatorPartnerID: "a1", AssetRef: "bread"},
},
LendingPrimitives: []htypes.LendingPrimitive{
{LoanID: "l1", PrincipalGrain: 1_000_000, CouponBps: 500, TermDays: 365},
{LoanID: "l2", PrincipalGrain: 500_000, CouponBps: 800, TermDays: 180},
},
ComplianceServices: []htypes.ComplianceService{
{ComplianceID: "comp-1", Jurisdiction: "EU-MiCA", AttestationURI: "ipfs://x"},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := htypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGenesis should accept clean genesis, got: %v", err)
}
}
// --- Lexicon assertion (REQ-012) -------------------------------------------------
// The hub module is HIGH lexicon-risk (lending primitive): the banned terms
// that are natural fit-words for a lending primitive (the compounding term,
// the storage terms, the tradable-unit terms) must NEVER appear. The coupon
// + lending vocabulary is used EXCLUSIVELY. The lexicon helpers are used
// here — no banned literals are inlined in this test file.
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInHubPackage scans every non-test .go file in the
// hub/types package directory for the banned terms (case-insensitive).
// Production files only — the test file references banned terms via the
// lexicon package helpers (standard lexicon-test bootstrapping pattern).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInHubPackage(t *testing.T) {
pkgDir := packageDir(t, "github.com/oy/openyield/x/hub/types")
files, err := filepath.Glob(filepath.Join(pkgDir, "*.go"))
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("glob: %v", err)
}
prodFiles := []string{}
for _, f := range files {
if strings.HasSuffix(f, "_test.go") {
continue
}
prodFiles = append(prodFiles, f)
}
if len(prodFiles) == 0 {
t.Fatal("no production .go files found in hub/types")
}
for _, f := range prodFiles {
bz, err := os.ReadFile(f)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read %s: %v", f, err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Errorf("%s: banned term %q (REQ-012 lexicon firewall — coupon+lending vocabulary only)", filepath.Base(f), found)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInHubTestFile asserts this test file itself does not
// contain any banned term as a literal (the firewall scans test files too;
// the lexicon helpers must be used rather than inlining banned terms).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInHubTestFile(t *testing.T) {
_, thisFile, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
bz, err := os.ReadFile(thisFile)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read self: %v", err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Fatalf("hub test file contains banned term %q — use lexicon helpers, not literals", found)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by walking
// up from this test file (v0.3 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
// file = .../oy/x/hub/types/types_test.go -> repoRoot = .../oy (4 dirs up)
repoRoot := filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))))
rel := strings.TrimPrefix(importPath, "github.com/oy/openyield/")
return filepath.Join(repoRoot, rel)
}
+47
View File
@@ -155,6 +155,53 @@ func (k *Keeper) ListByTier(tier PartnerTier) []Partner {
return out
}
// AnchorCredential is the institutional onboarding metadata for an Anchor
// tier Partner (REQ-023, D-038, A-305). The Anchor tier (the 4th of the
// 4-tier Partner Spectrum, REQ-018) gets institution-specific credential
// fields in v0.3. v0.2 defined the 4-tier enum + Partner struct +
// CredentialRef; v0.3 adds this AnchorCredential struct carrying the
// institutional onboarding metadata. No live institutional onboarding in
// v0.3 (the skeleton defines the type shape only).
//
// All cross-module references are by-ID-string per G-003:
//
// - anchor-id references a Partner with Tier=Anchor by ID-string
// (G-003). No struct import; the reference is validated against the
// Partner registry by the keeper, not the type system.
// - custody-provider-id references an x/hub custody service by ID-string
// (A-304/G-003). The hub is NOT live until P5/v0.4, so this field is
// EMPTY in the v0.3 skeleton (NewAnchorCredential sets it to "").
// The field exists so the shape is stable when the hub comes online.
// No struct import of x/hub.
// - credential-uri is an opaque URI to the institutional credential
// (regulatory jurisdiction, attestation refs, etc.) — like the v0.2
// Pier CredentialRef, kept opaque in the skeleton.
// - attestation-count is the number of Watcher/auditor attestations on
// the credential (starts at 0 in the skeleton).
type AnchorCredential struct {
AnchorID string `json:"anchor_id" yaml:"anchor_id"`
CustodyProviderID string `json:"custody_provider_id" yaml:"custody_provider_id"`
CredentialURI string `json:"credential_uri" yaml:"credential_uri"`
AttestationCount uint32 `json:"attestation_count" yaml:"attestation_count"`
}
// NewAnchorCredential constructs an AnchorCredential for an Anchor-tier
// Partner (D-038, A-305). The custody-provider-id is set to "" (empty)
// because the x/hub custody service is NOT live until P5/v0.4 (A-304:
// the field is typed-but-empty in the v0.3 skeleton; the hub is live in
// P5, so the field exists but is not validated against hub yet). The
// attestation-count is set to 0 (no attestations in the skeleton). The
// caller supplies the anchor-id (the Anchor Partner's ID) and the opaque
// credential-uri.
func NewAnchorCredential(anchorID, credentialURI string) AnchorCredential {
return AnchorCredential{
AnchorID: anchorID,
CustodyProviderID: "", // empty — hub not live until P5/v0.4 (A-304)
CredentialURI: credentialURI,
AttestationCount: 0, // no attestations in the skeleton
}
}
// Params for the partner module (skeleton — no tunables in v0.2).
type Params struct{}
+145
View File
@@ -411,6 +411,151 @@ func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInPartnerTestFile(t *testing.T) {
}
}
// --- v0.3 Partner extension (P4-04, D-038, A-305) — AnchorCredential -------------
//
// The following tests extend the v0.2 partner tests with the v0.3
// AnchorCredential struct (D-038). The existing v0.1/v0.2 tests above
// MUST remain green — no regression. The PartnerTier enum (4 tiers) is
// locked since v0.2; v0.3 adds the AnchorCredential STRUCT only (no new
// tier — A-305).
// TestAnchorCredentialStructFields asserts the AnchorCredential struct
// carries all required fields (anchor-id, custody-provider-id,
// credential-uri, attestation-count) per D-038/A-305.
func TestAnchorCredentialStructFields(t *testing.T) {
c := types.AnchorCredential{
AnchorID: "anchor-1",
CustodyProviderID: "hub-custody-1",
CredentialURI: "oy:cred:anchor-1/jurisdiction/EU-MiCA",
AttestationCount: 3,
}
if c.AnchorID != "anchor-1" {
t.Errorf("AnchorID = %q", c.AnchorID)
}
if c.CustodyProviderID != "hub-custody-1" {
t.Errorf("CustodyProviderID = %q", c.CustodyProviderID)
}
if c.CredentialURI != "oy:cred:anchor-1/jurisdiction/EU-MiCA" {
t.Errorf("CredentialURI = %q", c.CredentialURI)
}
if c.AttestationCount != 3 {
t.Errorf("AttestationCount = %d, want 3", c.AttestationCount)
}
}
// TestAnchorCredentialAnchorIDIsString asserts the AnchorID field is an
// opaque string (by-ID-string ref to a Partner with Tier=Anchor — G-003),
// NOT a typed Partner import. This locks the by-ID-string invariant at
// the type level.
func TestAnchorCredentialAnchorIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
c := types.AnchorCredential{AnchorID: "partner-9"}
c.AnchorID = "partner-2"
if c.AnchorID != "partner-2" {
t.Errorf("AnchorID = %q, want %q (must be plain string — G-003)", c.AnchorID, "partner-2")
}
}
// TestAnchorCredentialCustodyProviderIDIsString asserts the
// CustodyProviderID field is an opaque string (by-ID-string ref to an
// x/hub custody service — A-304/G-003), NOT a typed x/hub import.
func TestAnchorCredentialCustodyProviderIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
c := types.AnchorCredential{CustodyProviderID: "hub-custody-9"}
c.CustodyProviderID = "hub-custody-2"
if c.CustodyProviderID != "hub-custody-2" {
t.Errorf("CustodyProviderID = %q, want %q (must be plain string — A-304/G-003)", c.CustodyProviderID, "hub-custody-2")
}
}
// TestNewAnchorCredentialConstruction asserts NewAnchorCredential sets
// the anchor-id and credential-uri from the constructor args, AND sets
// custody-provider-id to "" (empty — hub not live until P5/v0.4 per
// A-304), AND attestation-count to 0 (no attestations in the skeleton).
func TestNewAnchorCredentialConstruction(t *testing.T) {
c := types.NewAnchorCredential("anchor-1", "oy:cred:anchor-1/EU-MiCA")
if c.AnchorID != "anchor-1" {
t.Errorf("AnchorID = %q, want %q", c.AnchorID, "anchor-1")
}
if c.CredentialURI != "oy:cred:anchor-1/EU-MiCA" {
t.Errorf("CredentialURI = %q, want %q", c.CredentialURI, "oy:cred:anchor-1/EU-MiCA")
}
// custody-provider-id must be EMPTY in the skeleton (A-304: hub not
// live until P5/v0.4).
if c.CustodyProviderID != "" {
t.Errorf("CustodyProviderID = %q, want empty (A-304: hub not live until P5)", c.CustodyProviderID)
}
// attestation-count must be 0 in the skeleton.
if c.AttestationCount != 0 {
t.Errorf("AttestationCount = %d, want 0 (skeleton)", c.AttestationCount)
}
}
// TestNewAnchorCredentialCustodyProviderIDEmptyInvariant asserts the
// A-304 invariant: NewAnchorCredential ALWAYS sets custody-provider-id to
// "" regardless of inputs (the hub is not live until P5/v0.4; the field
// is typed-but-empty in the v0.3 skeleton). This is the dependency edge
// that forces P4 before P5 (D-044): x/partner Anchor lands in P4, x/hub
// in P5.
func TestNewAnchorCredentialCustodyProviderIDEmptyInvariant(t *testing.T) {
cases := []struct {
anchorID string
credURI string
}{
{"anchor-1", "oy:cred:a/EU-MiCA"},
{"anchor-2", "oy:cred:a/US-SOC2"},
{"", ""},
{"anchor-3", ""},
}
for _, c := range cases {
got := types.NewAnchorCredential(c.anchorID, c.credURI)
if got.CustodyProviderID != "" {
t.Errorf("NewAnchorCredential(%q,%q): CustodyProviderID = %q, want empty (A-304 LOCKED)", c.anchorID, c.credURI, got.CustodyProviderID)
}
if got.AttestationCount != 0 {
t.Errorf("NewAnchorCredential(%q,%q): AttestationCount = %d, want 0 (skeleton)", c.anchorID, c.credURI, got.AttestationCount)
}
}
}
// TestNewAnchorCredentialAttestationCountZero asserts the constructor sets
// attestation-count to 0 (no attestations in the skeleton; attestations
// are a v0.4 keeper concern).
func TestNewAnchorCredentialAttestationCountZero(t *testing.T) {
c := types.NewAnchorCredential("anchor-1", "oy:cred:anchor-1/x")
if c.AttestationCount != 0 {
t.Errorf("AttestationCount = %d, want 0 (skeleton — attestations are v0.4)", c.AttestationCount)
}
}
// TestAnchorCredentialZeroValue asserts the zero-value AnchorCredential
// has empty strings and a 0 attestation-count.
func TestAnchorCredentialZeroValue(t *testing.T) {
var c types.AnchorCredential
if c.AnchorID != "" || c.CustodyProviderID != "" || c.CredentialURI != "" {
t.Error("zero-value AnchorCredential should have empty string fields")
}
if c.AttestationCount != 0 {
t.Errorf("zero-value AttestationCount = %d, want 0", c.AttestationCount)
}
}
// TestPartnerTierCountStillFour is the v0.3 REGRESSION test (A-305): the
// PartnerTier enum is LOCKED at 4 tiers since v0.2; v0.3 adds the
// AnchorCredential STRUCT, NOT a new tier. This test asserts the count
// is still 4 (no new tier added by the v0.3 extension).
func TestPartnerTierCountStillFour(t *testing.T) {
if types.PartnerTierCount != 4 {
t.Errorf("PartnerTierCount = %d, expected 4 (A-305: v0.3 adds AnchorCredential struct, not a tier)", types.PartnerTierCount)
}
all := types.AllPartnerTiers()
if len(all) != 4 {
t.Errorf("AllPartnerTiers() len = %d, expected 4 (A-305 regression)", len(all))
}
// Anchor must still be the 4th tier (no new tier added before/after it).
if all[3] != types.TierAnchor {
t.Errorf("AllPartnerTiers()[3] = %q, want %q (Anchor must remain 4th tier)", all[3], types.TierAnchor)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by
// walking up from this test file (v0.2 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
+225
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,225 @@
// Package types defines the Services module types (vision §13, REQ-025,
// D-040, A-307).
//
// OY-protocol services beyond the financial layer: Care (community care),
// SIM (connectivity), Vault (storage service), Mail (messaging). v0.3 ships
// the skeleton (enum + per-service struct stubs + genesis); no live services.
//
// Lexicon note (REQ-012): "Mail"/"SIM"/"Care"/"Vault" are not banned terms.
// Avoid the banned Holder-identity term (use "operator-reach-id" not the
// banned term). The per-package lexicon assertion in types_test.go is the gate.
//
// Cross-module references are by-ID-string per G-003 (no struct imports):
// - operator-reach-id references an x/identity Reach by ID-string (G-003).
// - window-id references an x/window Window by ID-string (A-307, G-003).
// A service-grant opens a Window on the holder's behalf (the Window
// Lifecycle interface hook, typed in v0.3, invoked at runtime in v0.4).
// - mailbox-id (MailService) and storage-quota-grain (VaultService) are
// opaque / in-package values; VaultService references x/vault by name only
// (the ServiceKind "Vault" is a service kind, NOT a struct import of
// x/vault — the naming collision is concept-level, not package-level).
package types
import (
"encoding/json"
"fmt"
)
const (
ModuleName = "services"
StoreKey = ModuleName
RouterKey = ModuleName
QuerierRoute = ModuleName
// ServiceKindCount is the locked count of ServiceKind enum values (vision
// §13, REQ-025, A-307). A regression firewall: adding/removing/renaming a
// service kind breaks this const's test.
ServiceKindCount = 4
)
// ServiceKind enumerates the four OY-protocol service kinds (vision §13,
// REQ-025, A-307): Care (community care), SIM (subscriber identity module /
// connectivity), Vault (storage service), Mail (messaging). The full services
// suite (the real-return token, Travel, +11 more) is Phase 4, out of v0.3
// scope (D-040). The real-return token's name in vision §13 uses a banned
// standalone term; this comment uses the lexicon-safe "real-return" phrasing.
type ServiceKind string
const (
KindCare ServiceKind = "Care" // community care
KindSIM ServiceKind = "SIM" // connectivity
KindVault ServiceKind = "Vault" // storage service
KindMail ServiceKind = "Mail" // messaging
)
// AllServiceKinds returns all four ServiceKind values in vision §13 order.
// Locked-const test asserts exactly 4 entries with these names (REQ-025).
func AllServiceKinds() []ServiceKind {
return []ServiceKind{
KindCare,
KindSIM,
KindVault,
KindMail,
}
}
// ServiceStatus enumerates the lifecycle states of a service (REQ-025). This
// is a LOCAL redefinition of the 4-state shape (mirrors the v0.2 PartnerStatus
// shape); no struct import of x/partner (G-003).
type ServiceStatus string
const (
ServicePending ServiceStatus = "Pending" // registered, not yet active
ServiceActive ServiceStatus = "Active" // live
ServiceSuspended ServiceStatus = "Suspended" // temporarily halted
ServiceRevoked ServiceStatus = "Revoked" // permanently revoked
)
// ServiceStatusCount is the locked count of ServiceStatus enum values.
const ServiceStatusCount = 4
// ServiceInfo is the registry record for a service (REQ-025, A-307).
// service-id is the unique identifier. kind picks the ServiceKind.
// operator-reach-id references an x/identity Reach by ID-string (G-003 — use
// "operator-reach-id" not the banned Holder-identity term). name is a human-
// readable label. status is the lifecycle state. window-id references an
// x/window Window by ID-string (A-307, G-003 — a service-grant opens a Window
// on the holder's behalf; the Window Lifecycle interface hook, typed in v0.3,
// invoked at runtime in v0.4). The window-id field is the by-ID-string ref
// that ties a service-grant to a Window scope.
type ServiceInfo struct {
ServiceID string `json:"service_id" yaml:"service_id"`
Kind ServiceKind `json:"kind" yaml:"kind"`
OperatorReachID string `json:"operator_reach_id" yaml:"operator_reach_id"`
Name string `json:"name" yaml:"name"`
Status ServiceStatus `json:"status" yaml:"status"`
WindowID string `json:"window_id" yaml:"window_id"`
}
// CareService is the per-service struct stub for a Care service (vision §13,
// REQ-025). care-id is the service identifier. care-kind is an opaque string
// (the kind of community care, e.g. "mutual-aid" — opaque so the enum is not
// locked in v0.3; care kinds are operational, not protocol-locked).
type CareService struct {
CareID string `json:"care_id" yaml:"care_id"`
CareKind string `json:"care_kind" yaml:"care_kind"`
}
// SIMService is the per-service struct stub for a SIM (connectivity) service
// (vision §13, REQ-025). sim-id is the service identifier. carrier is an
// opaque string (the connectivity carrier — opaque so the enum is not locked
// in v0.3 per A-308 venue pattern; carriers are operational).
type SIMService struct {
SIMID string `json:"sim_id" yaml:"sim_id"`
Carrier string `json:"carrier" yaml:"carrier"`
}
// VaultService is the per-service struct stub for a Vault (storage) service
// (vision §13, REQ-025). vault-id is the service identifier. holder-reach-id
// references an x/identity Reach by ID-string (G-003 — use "holder-reach-id"
// not the banned Holder-identity term). storage-quota-grain is the storage
// quota in Grain (the OY internal unit, by name only — no x/bread import).
// "Vault" here is a service kind, NOT a struct import of x/vault (the naming
// collision is concept-level; VaultService references x/vault by ID-string at
// runtime, not by Go import).
type VaultService struct {
VaultID string `json:"vault_id" yaml:"vault_id"`
HolderReachID string `json:"holder_reach_id" yaml:"holder_reach_id"`
StorageQuotaGrain int64 `json:"storage_quota_grain" yaml:"storage_quota_grain"`
}
// MailService is the per-service struct stub for a Mail (messaging) service
// (vision §13, REQ-025). mail-id is the service identifier. holder-reach-id
// references an x/identity Reach by ID-string (G-003). mailbox-id is the
// opaque mailbox identifier.
type MailService struct {
MailID string `json:"mail_id" yaml:"mail_id"`
HolderReachID string `json:"holder_reach_id" yaml:"holder_reach_id"`
MailboxID string `json:"mailbox_id" yaml:"mailbox_id"`
}
// Params for the services module (skeleton — no tunables in v0.3).
type Params struct{}
// DefaultParams returns the zero-value Params (skeleton — no tunables).
func DefaultParams() Params { return Params{} }
// GenesisState defines the services module genesis state (REQ-025). The
// ServiceInfos slice holds the registry records. The per-service stub slices
// hold the service-specific metadata. ValidateGenesis enforces service-id
// uniqueness across the registry (A-212).
type GenesisState struct {
Params Params `json:"params" yaml:"params"`
ServiceInfos []ServiceInfo `json:"service_infos" yaml:"service_infos"`
CareServices []CareService `json:"care_services" yaml:"care_services"`
SIMServices []SIMService `json:"sim_services" yaml:"sim_services"`
VaultServices []VaultService `json:"vault_services" yaml:"vault_services"`
MailServices []MailService `json:"mail_services" yaml:"mail_services"`
}
// DefaultGenesisState returns an empty genesis state with non-nil slices.
func DefaultGenesisState() *GenesisState {
return &GenesisState{
Params: DefaultParams(),
ServiceInfos: []ServiceInfo{},
CareServices: []CareService{},
SIMServices: []SIMService{},
VaultServices: []VaultService{},
MailServices: []MailService{},
}
}
// ValidateGenesis performs ID-uniqueness checks (A-212 upgrade from v0.1
// no-op): rejects duplicate or empty service-ids in the registry, and unknown
// ServiceKind / ServiceStatus values.
func ValidateGenesis(bz json.RawMessage) error {
var gs GenesisState
if err := json.Unmarshal(bz, &gs); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("services: invalid genesis: %w", err)
}
if err := validateServiceInfos(gs.ServiceInfos); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("services: %w", err)
}
return nil
}
// validateServiceInfos enforces service-id presence and uniqueness, and that
// each Kind/Status is a known enum value.
func validateServiceInfos(infos []ServiceInfo) error {
seen := make(map[string]bool, len(infos))
for i, s := range infos {
if s.ServiceID == "" {
return fmt.Errorf("service info [%d]: empty service-id", i)
}
if seen[s.ServiceID] {
return fmt.Errorf("service info: duplicate service-id %q", s.ServiceID)
}
seen[s.ServiceID] = true
if !knownServiceKind(s.Kind) {
return fmt.Errorf("service %q: unknown service kind %q", s.ServiceID, s.Kind)
}
if !knownServiceStatus(s.Status) {
return fmt.Errorf("service %q: unknown service status %q", s.ServiceID, s.Status)
}
}
return nil
}
// knownServiceKind reports whether k is one of the four ServiceKind values.
func knownServiceKind(k ServiceKind) bool {
for _, kk := range AllServiceKinds() {
if k == kk {
return true
}
}
return false
}
// knownServiceStatus reports whether s is one of the four ServiceStatus values.
func knownServiceStatus(s ServiceStatus) bool {
switch s {
case ServicePending, ServiceActive, ServiceSuspended, ServiceRevoked:
return true
}
return false
}
+369
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,369 @@
package types_test
import (
"encoding/json"
"os"
"path/filepath"
"runtime"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/oy/openyield/lexicon"
stypes "github.com/oy/openyield/x/services/types"
)
// --- ServiceKind enum coverage (4) --------------------------------------------
// TestServiceKindCountLockedConst asserts ServiceKindCount == 4 and
// AllServiceKinds() returns exactly 4 (REQ-025, A-307). A regression firewall.
func TestServiceKindCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if stypes.ServiceKindCount != 4 {
t.Errorf("ServiceKindCount = %d, expected 4 (REQ-025 LOCKED)", stypes.ServiceKindCount)
}
all := stypes.AllServiceKinds()
if len(all) != 4 {
t.Errorf("AllServiceKinds() len = %d, expected 4", len(all))
}
}
// TestAllServiceKindsNames asserts the 4 REQ-025 names in order with no extras,
// no dups, no renames.
func TestAllServiceKindsNames(t *testing.T) {
want := []string{"Care", "SIM", "Vault", "Mail"}
all := stypes.AllServiceKinds()
if len(all) != len(want) {
t.Fatalf("len = %d, want %d", len(all), len(want))
}
seen := map[string]bool{}
for i, k := range all {
if string(k) != want[i] {
t.Errorf("AllServiceKinds()[%d] = %q, want %q", i, k, want[i])
}
if seen[string(k)] {
t.Errorf("duplicate ServiceKind %q", k)
}
seen[string(k)] = true
}
}
// TestServiceKindValues asserts each named const matches its AllServiceKinds
// entry.
func TestServiceKindValues(t *testing.T) {
if stypes.KindCare != "Care" {
t.Errorf("KindCare = %q", stypes.KindCare)
}
if stypes.KindSIM != "SIM" {
t.Errorf("KindSIM = %q", stypes.KindSIM)
}
if stypes.KindVault != "Vault" {
t.Errorf("KindVault = %q", stypes.KindVault)
}
if stypes.KindMail != "Mail" {
t.Errorf("KindMail = %q", stypes.KindMail)
}
}
// --- ServiceStatus enum coverage (4) ------------------------------------------
// TestServiceStatusCountLockedConst asserts ServiceStatusCount == 4.
func TestServiceStatusCountLockedConst(t *testing.T) {
if stypes.ServiceStatusCount != 4 {
t.Errorf("ServiceStatusCount = %d, expected 4", stypes.ServiceStatusCount)
}
}
// TestServiceStatusValues asserts the four ServiceStatus named consts.
func TestServiceStatusValues(t *testing.T) {
if stypes.ServicePending != "Pending" {
t.Errorf("ServicePending = %q", stypes.ServicePending)
}
if stypes.ServiceActive != "Active" {
t.Errorf("ServiceActive = %q", stypes.ServiceActive)
}
if stypes.ServiceSuspended != "Suspended" {
t.Errorf("ServiceSuspended = %q", stypes.ServiceSuspended)
}
if stypes.ServiceRevoked != "Revoked" {
t.Errorf("ServiceRevoked = %q", stypes.ServiceRevoked)
}
}
// --- ServiceInfo struct + by-ID-string refs (G-003, A-307) --------------------
// TestServiceInfoStructFields asserts ServiceInfo carries service-id, kind,
// operator-reach-id, name, status, window-id.
func TestServiceInfoStructFields(t *testing.T) {
s := stypes.ServiceInfo{
ServiceID: "svc-1",
Kind: stypes.KindCare,
OperatorReachID: "reach-holder-1",
Name: "Care Service",
Status: stypes.ServiceActive,
WindowID: "window-1",
}
if s.ServiceID != "svc-1" || s.Kind != stypes.KindCare || s.OperatorReachID != "reach-holder-1" ||
s.Name != "Care Service" || s.Status != stypes.ServiceActive || s.WindowID != "window-1" {
t.Error("ServiceInfo fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestServiceInfoWindowIDIsString asserts window-id is string-typed (A-307
// by-ID-string ref to x/window — G-003, no struct import). This is the
// window-id by-ID-string ref presence test mandated by the P5 task spec.
func TestServiceInfoWindowIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
s := stypes.ServiceInfo{WindowID: "window-abc"}
if s.WindowID != "window-abc" {
t.Errorf("WindowID = %q", s.WindowID)
}
}
// TestServiceInfoOperatorReachIDIsString asserts operator-reach-id is
// string-typed (G-003 by-ID-string ref to x/identity Reach — no struct import).
func TestServiceInfoOperatorReachIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
s := stypes.ServiceInfo{OperatorReachID: "reach-xyz"}
if s.OperatorReachID != "reach-xyz" {
t.Errorf("OperatorReachID = %q", s.OperatorReachID)
}
}
// --- Per-service struct stubs --------------------------------------------------
// TestCareServiceStructFields asserts CareService carries care-id, care-kind.
func TestCareServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
c := stypes.CareService{CareID: "care-1", CareKind: "mutual-aid"}
if c.CareID != "care-1" || c.CareKind != "mutual-aid" {
t.Error("CareService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestSIMServiceStructFields asserts SIMService carries sim-id, carrier.
func TestSIMServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
s := stypes.SIMService{SIMID: "sim-1", Carrier: "oy-mobile"}
if s.SIMID != "sim-1" || s.Carrier != "oy-mobile" {
t.Error("SIMService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestVaultServiceStructFields asserts VaultService carries vault-id,
// holder-reach-id (by-ID-string ref to x/identity — G-003), storage-quota-grain.
func TestVaultServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
v := stypes.VaultService{
VaultID: "vault-1",
HolderReachID: "reach-holder-1",
StorageQuotaGrain: 1_000_000,
}
if v.VaultID != "vault-1" || v.HolderReachID != "reach-holder-1" || v.StorageQuotaGrain != 1_000_000 {
t.Error("VaultService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// TestVaultServiceHolderReachIDIsString asserts holder-reach-id is string-typed
// (G-003 by-ID-string ref to x/identity Reach — no struct import).
func TestVaultServiceHolderReachIDIsString(t *testing.T) {
v := stypes.VaultService{HolderReachID: "reach-abc"}
if v.HolderReachID != "reach-abc" {
t.Errorf("HolderReachID = %q", v.HolderReachID)
}
}
// TestMailServiceStructFields asserts MailService carries mail-id,
// holder-reach-id (by-ID-string ref to x/identity — G-003), mailbox-id.
func TestMailServiceStructFields(t *testing.T) {
m := stypes.MailService{
MailID: "mail-1",
HolderReachID: "reach-holder-1",
MailboxID: "mbox-1",
}
if m.MailID != "mail-1" || m.HolderReachID != "reach-holder-1" || m.MailboxID != "mbox-1" {
t.Error("MailService fields not set correctly")
}
}
// --- Module consts + Params ----------------------------------------------------
// TestModuleConsts asserts the four Cosmos-convention module consts.
func TestModuleConsts(t *testing.T) {
if stypes.ModuleName != "services" {
t.Errorf("ModuleName = %q", stypes.ModuleName)
}
if stypes.StoreKey != "services" {
t.Errorf("StoreKey = %q", stypes.StoreKey)
}
if stypes.RouterKey != "services" {
t.Errorf("RouterKey = %q", stypes.RouterKey)
}
if stypes.QuerierRoute != "services" {
t.Errorf("QuerierRoute = %q", stypes.QuerierRoute)
}
}
// TestDefaultParams asserts DefaultParams returns a zero-value Params.
func TestDefaultParams(t *testing.T) {
_ = stypes.DefaultParams() // no panics
}
// --- Genesis -------------------------------------------------------------------
// TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty asserts DefaultGenesisState returns non-nil
// empty slices for all five sets.
func TestDefaultGenesisStateEmpty(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.DefaultGenesisState()
if gs == nil {
t.Fatal("DefaultGenesisState returned nil")
}
if gs.ServiceInfos == nil || len(gs.ServiceInfos) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default ServiceInfos should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.ServiceInfos), gs.ServiceInfos == nil)
}
if gs.CareServices == nil || len(gs.CareServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default CareServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.CareServices), gs.CareServices == nil)
}
if gs.SIMServices == nil || len(gs.SIMServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default SIMServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.SIMServices), gs.SIMServices == nil)
}
if gs.VaultServices == nil || len(gs.VaultServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default VaultServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.VaultServices), gs.VaultServices == nil)
}
if gs.MailServices == nil || len(gs.MailServices) != 0 {
t.Errorf("Default MailServices should be non-nil empty slice; got len=%d nil=%v", len(gs.MailServices), gs.MailServices == nil)
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupServiceIDs asserts A-212: duplicate service-ids
// are rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsDupServiceIDs(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.GenesisState{
ServiceInfos: []stypes.ServiceInfo{
{ServiceID: "s1", Kind: stypes.KindCare, Status: stypes.ServiceActive},
{ServiceID: "s1", Kind: stypes.KindSIM, Status: stypes.ServiceActive}, // dup
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject duplicate service-ids")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyServiceID asserts empty service-id is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsEmptyServiceID(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.GenesisState{
ServiceInfos: []stypes.ServiceInfo{{ServiceID: "", Kind: stypes.KindCare, Status: stypes.ServiceActive}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject empty service-id")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownServiceKind asserts an unknown ServiceKind
// is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownServiceKind(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.GenesisState{
ServiceInfos: []stypes.ServiceInfo{{ServiceID: "s1", Kind: stypes.ServiceKind("Bogus"), Status: stypes.ServiceActive}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown service kind")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownServiceStatus asserts an unknown
// ServiceStatus is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsUnknownServiceStatus(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.GenesisState{
ServiceInfos: []stypes.ServiceInfo{{ServiceID: "s1", Kind: stypes.KindCare, Status: stypes.ServiceStatus("Bogus")}},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject unknown service status")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON asserts malformed JSON is rejected.
func TestValidateGenesisRejectsBadJSON(t *testing.T) {
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(json.RawMessage(`{not json`)); err == nil {
t.Error("ValidateGenesis should reject malformed JSON")
}
}
// TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean asserts a clean genesis validates.
func TestValidateGenesisAcceptsClean(t *testing.T) {
gs := stypes.GenesisState{
ServiceInfos: []stypes.ServiceInfo{
{ServiceID: "s1", Kind: stypes.KindCare, OperatorReachID: "r1", Name: "Care", Status: stypes.ServiceActive, WindowID: "w1"},
{ServiceID: "s2", Kind: stypes.KindMail, OperatorReachID: "r2", Name: "Mail", Status: stypes.ServicePending, WindowID: "w2"},
},
}
bz, _ := json.Marshal(gs)
if err := stypes.ValidateGenesis(bz); err != nil {
t.Errorf("ValidateGenesis should accept clean genesis, got: %v", err)
}
}
// --- Lexicon assertion (REQ-012) -------------------------------------------------
// The services module must avoid the banned Holder-identity term (use
// "operator-reach-id"/"holder-reach-id" not the banned term). "Mail"/"SIM"/
// "Care"/"Vault" are not banned. The lexicon helpers are used here — no
// banned literals are inlined in this test file.
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInServicesPackage scans every non-test .go file in
// the services/types package directory for the banned terms
// (case-insensitive). Production files only — the test file references banned
// terms via the lexicon package helpers (standard lexicon-test bootstrapping
// pattern).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInServicesPackage(t *testing.T) {
pkgDir := packageDir(t, "github.com/oy/openyield/x/services/types")
files, err := filepath.Glob(filepath.Join(pkgDir, "*.go"))
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("glob: %v", err)
}
prodFiles := []string{}
for _, f := range files {
if strings.HasSuffix(f, "_test.go") {
continue
}
prodFiles = append(prodFiles, f)
}
if len(prodFiles) == 0 {
t.Fatal("no production .go files found in services/types")
}
for _, f := range prodFiles {
bz, err := os.ReadFile(f)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read %s: %v", f, err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Errorf("%s: banned term %q (REQ-012 lexicon firewall — use operator-reach-id not the banned Holder-identity term)", filepath.Base(f), found)
}
}
}
// TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInServicesTestFile asserts this test file itself does
// not contain any banned term as a literal (the firewall scans test files too;
// the lexicon helpers must be used rather than inlining banned terms).
func TestLexiconNoBannedTermsInServicesTestFile(t *testing.T) {
_, thisFile, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
bz, err := os.ReadFile(thisFile)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("read self: %v", err)
}
if found, ok := lexicon.FindBannedTerm(string(bz)); ok {
t.Fatalf("services test file contains banned term %q — use lexicon helpers, not literals", found)
}
}
// packageDir resolves a Go import path to its filesystem directory by walking
// up from this test file (v0.3 skeleton has zero external deps).
func packageDir(t *testing.T, importPath string) string {
t.Helper()
_, file, _, ok := runtime.Caller(0)
if !ok {
t.Fatal("runtime.Caller failed")
}
// file = .../oy/x/services/types/types_test.go -> repoRoot = .../oy (4 dirs up)
repoRoot := filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(filepath.Dir(file))))
rel := strings.TrimPrefix(importPath, "github.com/oy/openyield/")
return filepath.Join(repoRoot, rel)
}