Jon Chery 437d9b2691 docs(P00): grill v0.13 — CONDITIONAL PROCEED (6 binding conditions C-44..C-49)
Red-team review of PLAN_v0.13 across 9 axes. Verdict: CONDITIONAL
PROCEED (confidence 0.82). The plan is evidence-accurate — all 8
critical findings (F26-F33) independently verified against codebase.
No axis FAILs; 4 PASS, 4 CONDITIONAL, 1 PASS.

Key findings:
- Governance: v0.12 marked COMPLETE but 19 REQs still pending (G-255).
  Resolved: P13 marks both v0.12+v0.13 REQs Complete; v0.12 stays
  COMPLETE retroactively; C-43 makes consistency enforceable.
- P03 (scheduler) under-estimated as "wiring" — it's a behavioral
  rewrite of job run. C-44: fail-closed on SSH failure, no silent
  local fallback.
- P04 (ACL) staged rollout missing from task list. C-45: log-only
  mode for first run, enforce after bootstrap ACL verified.
- P12 dependencies incomplete. C-46: declare P05+P06 deps.
- UAT signoff assertions not enumerated. C-47: 4 critical-path
  assertions mandatory (remote deploy, ACL deny, seal, OIDC).
- Proxmox host prerequisite undocumented. C-48: alternative UAT path.
- "Last round" narrative overclaims. C-49: "last round before UAT."

---ci---
project: orca
phase: 0
milestone: v0.13
status: grill
binding_decisions:
  - G-255: P13 marks REQ-130..148 AND REQ-149..163 Complete; v0.12 stays COMPLETE retroactively (conf 0.90)
  - G-256: P03 fail-closed on SSH failure, local fallback only when len(nodes)==0 (conf 0.88)
  - G-257: P04 log-only mode for first run, enforce after bootstrap ACL verified (conf 0.85)
  - G-258: P12 declares dependency on P05+P06 in addition to P03+P04 (conf 0.82)
  - G-259: P12 uat-signoff.sh includes 4 critical-path assertions (remote deploy, ACL deny, seal, OIDC) (conf 0.84)
  - G-260: P12 docs/uat.md documents Proxmox prerequisite + alternative UAT path (conf 0.78)
  - G-261: v0.13 is "last round before UAT" not "last round absolute" (conf 0.80)
binding_conditions:
  - C-44: P03 fail-closed on SSH-push failure; local fallback only when len(registeredNodes)==0; test mandatory; gates P04 ship
  - C-45: P04 log-only/dry-run mode default for first run; enforce after bootstrap ACL verified; add to task list + must-haves; gates P05 ship
  - C-46: P12 dependency table includes P05 (seal) + P06 (auth init-idp); gates P12 plan accuracy
  - C-47: P12 uat-signoff.sh asserts (a) remote deploy node_id!=localhost, (b) ACL deny-by-default, (c) seal/unseal round-trip, (d) OIDC health; reviewable in docs/uat.md; gates v1.0.0
  - C-48: P12 docs/uat.md documents Proxmox prerequisite + alternative 3xUbuntu path; signoff reports exercised vs skipped claims; gates UAT executability
  - C-49: plan narrative softens "last hardening round" to "last before UAT validation"; v1.0.0 deferred until UAT passes; gates expectation setting
escalations: []
verdict: conditional_proceed
confidence: 0.82
2026-08-07 18:49:18 +00:00

Orca

A minimalist, offline-first, CLI-first orchestration engine inspired by HashiCorp Nomad. Proxmox is one supported node type — not the project's identity.

Status

v0.11: Production Hardening — IN PROGRESS | v1.0: UAT-gated (cut separately after v0.11 completion per operator decision)

See .ciagent/ROADMAP.md for the full roadmap.

Pillars

  • Simplicity — single binary, minimal dependencies, no daemon on the critical path
  • Offline-first — no cloud dependencies; the cluster is the OS
  • CLI-first — the command line is the primary interface (humans and AI agents)
  • Security before features — mTLS by default; NFRs ship before new functionality
  • WASM-first — workloads target OS primitives (systemd units, journald), not a container runtime shim
  • Bug fixes before features — stability is paramount

Quickstart

Install (1-liner)

# User-level install (binary at ~/.local/bin/orca, state at ~/.orca)
curl -fsSL https://git.cloudinit.dev/coreci/orca/raw/main/scripts/install.sh | bash

# System-level install (binary at /usr/local/bin/orca, state at /root/.orca)
curl -fsSL https://git.cloudinit.dev/coreci/orca/raw/main/scripts/install.sh | sudo bash -s -- --system

# Pin a specific version (latest tag: v0.10.19)
curl -fsSL https://git.cloudinit.dev/coreci/orca/raw/main/scripts/install.sh | bash -s -- --version v0.10.19

# Dry-run: check what would be installed without writing
curl -fsSL https://git.cloudinit.dev/coreci/orca/raw/main/scripts/install.sh | bash -s -- --check

Then initialize local state and verify:

orca init          # creates ~/.orca/ (or /root/.orca with --system)
orca version       # prints version info
orca --help        # show all subcommands

Build from source

make build         # Build binary to ./bin/orca
./bin/orca init    # Initialize local state
./bin/orca version # Verify

Update in place

Re-running the installer updates the binary while preserving your config, database, and certificates in the namespace dir:

curl -fsSL https://git.cloudinit.dev/coreci/orca/raw/main/scripts/install.sh | bash
# → "updated orca from v0.8.15 to v0.10.19"

Subcommands

Command Description
orca init Initialize local orca state with full bootstrap
orca status Show orca daemon status
orca version Print version information
orca daemon (deprecated) Run the orca daemon (HTTP API + health checks)
orca metrics Start metrics endpoint (Prometheus text exposition)
orca logs Aggregate journald logs across nodes (--all-nodes --since)
orca backup Create a signed tar.gz backup of ORCA_HOME
orca restore Restore ORCA_HOME from a verified signed backup
orca upgrade Upgrade orca to a new version (thin wrapper; R-017 cutover)
orca node Manage orca nodes: join, leave, list, key-reset, drain, capacity
orca job Manage orca jobs: run, list, stop, logs, lint, verify, migrate, restart
orca ns Manage orca namespaces: list, create, delete, inspect, validate, inherit, set-constraint
orca cert (deprecated) Manage orca certificates: ca-init, gen, show, renew, fingerprint
orca doctor Run self-checks: cert, network, db, os, proxmox, no-orca-on-server
orca audit View orca audit log (list)
orca cache CLI cache management: show, invalidate, invalidate-all
orca acl ACL management: grant, revoke, list, check
orca secrets Secrets management: set, get, list, rotate, delete
orca drift Drift detection: show, watch, acknowledge, remediate, config
orca txn Transaction management: apply, list, show, rollback
orca collector Collector/aggregator management: start, stop, status
orca cluster Cluster management: cutover, rotate-lead, compat-check

See docs/cli.md for the full CLI reference with all flags and examples.

Honest trade-offs

Orca is not a Kubernetes replacement for every workload. This table is the honest comparison — K8s wins in several dimensions, and that is acknowledged rather than papered over.

Dimension Kubernetes wins Orca wins
Ecosystem Mature CNCF ecosystem; vast operator, controller, plugin surface
Talent pool Large pool of K8s-experienced engineers
Multi-cloud Portable across all major clouds; control plane is cloud-agnostic
Stateful operators Rich operator pattern (CRD + controller) for stateful workloads
Service mesh First-class service mesh (Istio, Linkerd)
Auto-scaling Cluster autoscaler, HPA/VPA, deep integrations
Daemon footprint No daemon on the critical path; the cluster is the OS
OS-native Workloads are systemd units + journald; no container runtime shim
mTLS mTLS by default; no opt-in required
Offline-first No cloud dependencies; fully air-gapped operation
WASM-first Workloads target OS primitives, not a container runtime
Proxmox First-class Proxmox node type (--type proxmox) via SSH-push

Documentation

Document Description
docs/cli.md CLI reference — every command, flag, and example
docs/jobspec.md Jobspec reference — markdown frontmatter schema
docs/ingress.md Ingress guide — Traefik configuration
docs/namespace.md Namespace and path layout
docs/install.md Installation guide
docs/security-scanning.md Security scanning tools

Examples

Example Description
examples/full-stack/ Full-stack deployment with ingress (5 services + rendered artifacts)

Development

make build         # Build binary to ./bin/orca
make test          # Run tests
go vet ./...       # Vet all packages
make lint          # Run gofmt + go vet + shellcheck
make verify-reqs   # Assert ROADMAP ↔ REQUIREMENTS consistency

Architecture

See .ciagent/ARCHITECTURE.md for full architecture details.

License

MIT — see LICENSE.

S
Description
Orca — offline/CLI-first orchestration engine (Nomad-inspired, far simpler than Kubernetes)
Readme MIT 6.2 MiB
Languages
Go 94.7%
Shell 4.9%
Makefile 0.3%