GRILL stage for v0.7. ci-griller red-teamed the plan across 9 axes + 7
specific probes. Overall verdict: CONDITIONAL PASS (confidence 0.72).
5 binding decisions applied to PLANS.md + ARCHITECTURE.md + oy-state + PROJECT.md:
- D-086: P1 Factory functional for Phase-2 categories ONLY (FactoryAllowedPhases
= [Phase2] in P1; P2 extends to [Phase2,Phase3,Phase4]); P1 simtest adds
out-of-phase rejection negative case
- D-087: PierCarriesVoice=false added as 12th locked const (was 11; now 12)
in x/guild/types (FR-VOICE-6 mission-locked invariant)
- D-088: lexicon_meta_cover uses new lexicon.CoverBannedTerms() helper
(insurance/premium/claim/policy scoped to Cover surface, NOT project-wide);
x/cover/firewall pinned to allow-list of routing destinations (string-
equality check); optional x/pact insurance-like -> Cover-like doc-fix
- D-089: StillKeeper satisfied by simtest-local stub (x/still NOT extended
this milestone; x/still/keeper/ verified empty); x/bond -> x/cover
CoverKeeper reverse edge added to dependency map (MsgDebitMABProceeds
queries CoverKeeper.GetPoolReserveAccount; no import cycle, interface only)
- D-090: Bill of Rights temporal-gap fix (RightID + 13 Waivable* consts +
RightIsWaivable() + ValidateBasic gate land in P2, NOT P5 — closes the
P2->P5 window where rights were waivable); Voucher cold-start fix
(bond = max(10x avg, MinimumVoucherBond) — no zero-bond bypass); Standing-
gate dual check (floor enforced at BOTH launch handler AND Params-amendment
ValidateBasic); D-085 escalation window tightened to before P2
3 escalations to PO: D-085 (13th right identity, confidence 0.55),
lexicon banned-term scope (griller recommends Cover-scoped helper),
pen-test third party (this grill IS the self-administered review per
oy-state §7 item 4).
This grill IS the self-administered adversarial review (pen-test) per
oy-state §7 remaining-open item 4. High/critical findings (D-090(1)
temporal gap, D-088 lexicon paper tiger, D-090(2) Voucher cold-start)
are remediated in P0 via binding decisions D-086..D-090.
---ci---
project: oy
phase: 0
milestone: v0.7
status: grill
---/ci---
cloudinit-bot
977d2a1d24