CIAgent
6.9 KiB
GRILL — v1.30 Single-shot Leadership Deck
Adversarial review of the v1.30 SPECIFY + CLARIFY + RESEARCH + PLAN. Griller: lead-developer (acting as ci-griller at full autonomy). All 9 axes reviewed; every claim verified against the live codebase.
Overall verdict: PROCEED · Confidence 0.88
The plan is sound — this is a low-complexity, single-shot presentation artifact milestone. The scope is narrow (1 execution phase, 4 waves, no runtime code), the render pipeline extension is minimal (D-242), the discrete-artifact discipline is clear (D-241), and the environment prerequisites are resolved (python-pptx installed). No critical conditions. 4 tracked conditions (all advisory, none block P1).
The lower confidence vs. a "clean 0.95" reflects two residual
risks: (1) the python-pptx user-site install is environment-fragile
(it works now but is not reproducible in a fresh CI runner without
the same --break-system-packages path); (2) the PPTX footer
textbox is a new renderer behavior that needs visual confirmation.
Both are mitigated — (1) by the smoke-test hard-fail gate (8f) which
forces render success before ship, and (2) by the verify stage's
visual review (REQ-372.7).
Axis verdicts
| Axis | Verdict | Confidence | Tracked condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| §1 Feasibility | PROCEED | 0.90 | T-1.1 footer textbox overlap |
| §2 Scope | PROCEED | 0.92 | T-2.1 single-shot discipline enforcement |
| §3 Cost | PROCEED | 0.95 | (none — smallest milestone in project history) |
| §4 Schedule | PROCEED | 0.93 | (none — 1 execution phase) |
| §5 Technical Depth | PROCEED | 0.86 | T-5.1 speaker notes word-band parsing; T-5.2 → bullet rendering |
| §6 Operational Readiness | PROCEED | 0.90 | T-6.1 render env reproducibility |
| §7 Security Posture | PROCEED | 0.95 | (none — static artifact, no runtime surface) |
| §8 Dependency Risk | PROCEED | 0.84 | T-8.1 python-pptx user-site install |
| §9 Re-mapping Integrity | PROCEED | 0.92 | T-9.1 STATE.md intake override applied |
Tracked conditions (advisory — none block P1)
T-1.1 — Footer textbox overlap with content
Claim: The footer textbox at SLIDE_H - 0.3" (7.2") won't
overlap content (content area tops out at ~6.5").
Verification: python-pptx test rendered a textbox at
Inches(7.2) on a 7.5" slide — succeeds, no overlap with content
ending at ~6.5". The render_content_slide accumulates cur_top
per body block; a 7-slide deck with the Slide Content Map's body
volume (titles + 3-5 body blocks per slide) tops out at ~5.5-6.0".
Verdict: Safe. The verify stage visual review (REQ-372.7) is the
backstop.
T-2.1 — Single-shot discipline enforcement
Claim: The deck is not wired as a CI gate, not integrated with
publish.yml, not auto-regenerated.
Verification: workflows-src/slides.yml triggers on
docs/presentations/** but render_slides.sh hardcodes
DECK="nova-autonomous-cloud-delivery" — the leadership deck is
NOT rendered by CI. No publish.yml reference to the leadership
deck. The smoke test is a standalone script (no workflow
integration). Verdict: Discipline enforced by absence — no CI
plumbing references the new artifact.
T-5.1 — Speaker notes word-band parsing in bash
Claim: The smoke test extracts <!-- ... --> per slide and
counts words with wc -w.
Verification: Bash awk/sed can extract HTML comment content
per slide (split on ---, then extract <!-- ... --> within each
slide block). Multi-line comments are supported by the spec
convention ("placed within the slide body, before the next ---").
Verdict: Feasible. The ci-cli-engineer implements + tests this in
W3.
T-5.2 — → bullet rendering
Claim: Use - → ... bullets so the renderer treats → lines as
bullet blocks.
Verification: The renderer's unordered-list regex
^(\s*)([-*+])\s+(.*) matches - → ... → bullet level 0, text
→ .... The → is preserved in the rendered text. Verdict:
Correct. The ci-doc-writer uses - → ... for the arrow lines.
T-6.1 / T-8.1 — Render environment reproducibility
Claim: python-pptx is installed via user-site
pip install --user --break-system-packages.
Verification: Confirmed in this session: python-pptx 1.0.2 +
pytest 9.1.1 installed. python3 -c "import pptx" succeeds. The
install path is environment-specific (Debian/Ubuntu without system
pip/venv). In a fresh CI runner, the slides.yml workflow uses
pip install -e ".[slides]" (system pip in the runner image) —
reproducible there. For local on-demand renders, the user-site
install is the documented path. Verdict: Acceptable. The
smoke-test hard-fail gate (8f) forces render success before ship;
if the environment can't render, ship blocks until resolved.
T-9.1 — STATE.md intake override applied
Claim: D-241 overrides the stale STATE.md intake assumption 3.
Verification: STATE.md line ~526 assumption 3 was edited in CLARIFY to read "OVERRIDDEN by D-241 (v1.30 CLARIFY): the leadership deck is a discrete, hand-authored artifact — NOT a compression." The override is recorded in CLARIFY.md (D-241) + this grill. Verdict: Applied + verified.
Binding decisions (grill-level, full autonomy)
| ID | Decision | Rationale | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| G-1 | All 7 slides use ## H2 titles (content slides, white bg) — slide 1 is NOT a title-class slide. |
The Slide Content Map's slide 1 is content-rich (3 friction patterns + closing). A black-bg title slide would hide the arrows in white-on-black, differing from the map's framing. White-bg content slides give visual consistency across all 7. The map doesn't specify background; visual review accepts either. | 0.82 |
| G-2 | The → arrow lines are authored as - → ... bullets (not bare → plain text). |
The renderer parses [-*+] as bullets (proper indentation + bullet glyphs). Bare → lines parse as plain paragraphs (no bullet formatting). The Slide Content Map shows → as distinct arrow lines — bullets with the arrow glyph preserve the visual intent in the PPTX. |
0.88 |
| G-3 | The style: block in the leadership deck frontmatter replaces #2E2E2E (blockquote color in the existing deck) with #1B1B1B. |
REQ-372.6 allows only 4 hex colors in the source. The existing deck's style: uses #2E2E2E for blockquote text — this must not appear in the leadership deck source. #1B1B1B is the closest S&P token (black). |
1.0 |
| G-4 | The render_pptx.py extension parses the Marp frontmatter to extract the footer: value (for the footer textbox), but does NOT parse paginate:, theme:, size:, or style:. |
Minimal extension scope per D-242. Only the footer is needed for REQ-372.5. The other directives are source-only (smoke test checks source; the python-pptx path ignores them). | 0.90 |
Escalations
None. All axes ≥ 0.84 confidence. No human escalation required at full autonomy.